Best-Reviewed Superhero TV Shows 2018

The Marvel-versus-DC debate is as heated as ever thanks to the dozens of comic book–inspired series on television, but looking at the best-reviewed superhero shows of the year — a year that lost Marvel legend and comics industry titan Stan Lee — Marvel emerges victorious. Excelsior!

The order of the rank below reflects the Adjusted Score as of December 31, 2018. Scores might change over time.

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: The Man with No Fear returns to top form with a third season that begins tediously slow but gradually generates comic book thrills, immeasurably helped by the welcome return of Vincent D'Onofrio's menacing Kingpin.

The Flash: Season 5 (2018)
94%

#2
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: The Flash's fifth season maintains the show's high standard for compelling visuals, chilling villains, and well-scripted moments of humor, but also turns a more focused gaze on the role of family dynamics amongst the increasingly complex characters.

Legion: Season 2 (2018)
91%

#3
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Legion returns with a smart, strange second season that settles into a straighter narrative without sacrificing its unique sensibilities.

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Cloak & Dagger blends soapy drama with superhero grit to create an exciting, surprisingly thoughtful addition to the genre -- even if it falls prey to a certain amount of narrative bloat.

Titans: Season 1 (2018)
78%

#5
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Despite a few tonal growing pains, Titans does justice to its source material and truly shines when its titular ensemble finally assembles.

Tag Cloud

Instagram Live doctor who broadcast Tags: Comedy MSNBC Trivia popular Oscars children's TV Anna Paquin Showtime festival cops Cartoon Network genre Best Director crime drama richard e. Grant talk show Marvel Musical Focus Features sopranos medical drama South by Southwest Film Festival Captain marvel Election reboot Netflix Christmas movies golden globes Reality Competition YouTube Premium Black History Month south america Awards Tour screenings Crackle Crunchyroll Marvel Studios political drama 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards biography Hulu Acorn TV new star wars movies rt archives Disney Plus Pixar summer TV ViacomCBS leaderboard Columbia Pictures Comedy game show Fall TV Mindy Kaling police drama rt labs critics edition Film streamig cinemax ABC Signature anime NBA Masterpiece critics The Arrangement art house HBO Go universal monsters movies Mary Poppins Returns Lionsgate deadpool gangster Netflix Lifetime SundanceTV joker french Action 2020 based on movie die hard DGA DirecTV IFC Films Awards films Legendary 4/20 Spike WGN olympics Esquire spy thriller Martial Arts cats series japanese sequels Ellie Kemper Alien 20th Century Fox Universal Pictures Ghostbusters AMC Plus Academy Awards Mudbound cars sequel dexter crossover Musicals Britbox Quiz live action ID what to watch vampires action-comedy Arrowverse halloween crime thriller Year in Review trophy MGM Baby Yoda christmas movies CMT Travel Channel CNN worst The Academy TCA 2017 romance composers Rom-Com Star Trek Apple TV+ Polls and Games target Ovation award winner Writers Guild of America free movies strong female leads Lifetime Christmas movies Sundance Now werewolf suspense screen actors guild Family best BET Awards comic book movie name the review Disney NYCC psychological thriller TCM WarnerMedia Starz Summer TV MTV Amazon Epix scary franchise Pirates Cosplay Christmas rotten Kids & Family MCU boxing Trophy Talk Elton John 24 frames dogs Country dragons Fantasy Premiere Dates hist blockbuster Sony superhero 007 cults TV movies Teen elevated horror X-Men 93rd Oscars FOX spain OneApp Tarantino BBC One hidden camera Binge Guide Western justice league Disney streaming service unscripted fast and furious AMC video FXX FX canceled CBS All Access Trailer OWN streaming movies Podcast golden globe awards Certified Fresh TV renewals telelvision king arthur spider-man archives zero dark thirty 79th Golden Globes Awards breaking bad Avengers reviews Tubi Winter TV book adaptation SXSW posters zombie cartoon TLC TIFF indie Pacific Islander independent football Opinion Comics on TV NBC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Best Picture Funimation TV One Box Office History spanish language canceled TV shows new zealand ratings National Geographic rom-coms black comedy Peacock American Society of Cinematographers Neflix Food Network PaleyFest 94th Oscars San Diego Comic-Con toronto HBO Max Freeform Horror Bravo batman royal family The Walking Dead adventure twilight Mary Tyler Moore Turner Hallmark Christmas movies dark docudrama PBS 2016 FX on Hulu pirates of the caribbean Set visit stoner indiana jones Black Mirror A24 obi wan Women's History Month interviews toy story dramedy 21st Century Fox nbcuniversal vs. Super Bowl Reality Mystery 2017 Character Guide travel comedies Superheroe basketball Television Academy classics First Reviews marvel cinematic universe Classic Film Drama Countdown binge 99% miniseries Pride Month blaxploitation Best and Worst foreign james bond HFPA BBC America a nightmare on elm street IMDb TV Shondaland dreamworks SXSW 2022 nfl hispanic heritage month laika prank transformers Mary poppins Best Actor Shudder space Animation facebook aapi mutant Tokyo Olympics Amazon Prime ABC Family game of thrones Schedule blockbusters 72 Emmy Awards The Witch Disney+ Disney Plus PlayStation thriller mcc DC streaming service disaster Tumblr Pop Fargo ITV sag awards Prime Video CW Seed Toys lord of the rings animated Logo Superheroes Amazon Prime Video Music young adult Image Comics psycho rt labs Pop TV concert Fox Searchlight Comic Book scorecard The CW slashers worst movies jamie lee curtis Extras festivals streaming documentary hispanic war Disney Channel renewed TV shows romantic comedy Stephen King theme song spider-verse comics GIFs Sony Pictures docuseries kids high school summer preview GLAAD remakes hollywood all-time obituary mob slasher aliens trailers Video Games cancelled 45 casting E3 Film Festival Dark Horse Comics Exclusive Video Spectrum Originals VOD diversity witnail summer TV preview quibi anthology women TruTV Grammys TNT Emmy Nominations BBC black tv talk VH1 CBS kong dc japan latino 2021 zombies mission: impossible BET Song of Ice and Fire revenge Broadway Universal ABC Paramount Hollywood Foreign Press Association Apple TV Plus Endgame Pet Sematary versus monster movies singing competition Oscar asian-american satire E! Paramount Network HBO Turner Classic Movies comiccon venice Hear Us Out saw Paramount Plus RT21 YA Walt Disney Pictures Emmys LGBTQ Watching Series 90s Sundance VICE Sci-Fi Tomatazos Winners YouTube Red DC Universe international cancelled TV series adenture australia robots Rocky Rock Comic-Con@Home 2021 Adult Swim Vudu Discovery Channel razzies TV Land period drama social media Photos historical drama GoT stop motion video on demand cooking Nat Geo Star Wars Wes Anderson 2019 directors New York Comic Con TBS Red Carpet crime Brie Larson comic scary movies Spring TV live event documentaries kaiju supernatural movie emmy awards spinoff boxoffice harry potter parents Creative Arts Emmys king kong President ghosts godzilla dceu ESPN BAFTA stand-up comedy Sundance TV Lucasfilm Marvel Television Amazon Studios 2018 Nominations 2015 true crime cancelled television nature RT History halloween tv Hallmark Warner Bros. Syfy feel good italian 71st Emmy Awards Valentine's Day Chilling Adventures of Sabrina technology The Purge fresh Holidays DC Comics serial killer debate scene in color YouTube television new york First Look critic resources TCA Winter 2020 green book spanish 73rd Emmy Awards TCA book mockumentary El Rey superman child's play SDCC Sneak Peek sitcom Fox News USA Network biopic chucky jurassic park LGBT Television Critics Association adaptation natural history rotten movies we love wonder woman heist movie Biopics discovery See It Skip It Calendar Infographic sports teaser Cannes Chernobyl science fiction marvel comics Comedy Central A&E news 1990s legend comic books Best Actress Holiday Interview Thanksgiving criterion TCA Awards Rocketman Nickelodeon finale Heroines know your critic USA comic book movies Marathons APB IFC politics The Walt Disney Company cancelled TV shows Paramount Pictures Apple