Best-Reviewed Superhero Series 2020

Among the many, many superhero shows on TV, the seasons of only four managed to be Certified Fresh in 2020, flexing their critical supremacy over the rest. Season 2 of satirical superhero drama The Boys emerged victorious in a year that saw its vigilante heroes in hiding from the law and the increasingly corrupt corporate “supes” trying to corner the market on world-saving. Also impressing in its second season, The Umbrella Academy took the No. 2 spot in the category, while newcomers I Am Not Okay with This – which was unfortunately canceled by Netflix – and The CW’s sunny Stargirl completed the category.

The order of the rank below reflects the Adjusted Score as of December 31, 2020. Scores might change over time.

The Boys: Season 2 (2020)

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: The Boys comes out swinging in a superb second season that digs deeper into its complicated characters and ups the action ante without pulling any punches.

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Proof that time can heal almost all wounds, The Umbrella Academy's exhilarating second season lightens its tonal load without losing its emotional core, giving the super siblings room to grow while doubling down on the time traveling fun.

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: As awkward and charming as adolescence, but with twice the supernatural twists, I Am Not Okay With This' first season at times veers into shallow territory, but Sophia Lillis' strong performance keeps it afloat.

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: A stellar series perfect for anyone looking for a little hope, Stargirl is delightful fun the whole family can enjoy.

Tag Cloud

true crime Broadway CMT LGBTQ cooking Drama Set visit Reality cinemax obi wan directors Mindy Kaling green book 71st Emmy Awards italian diversity Nat Geo Grammys thriller young adult CBS All Access FOX Best Picture children's TV heist movie Hulu dceu witnail video streaming movies Disney streaming service concert Showtime Image Comics Election ITV batman Mary poppins Universal Pictures 4/20 comic book movies Mary Poppins Returns E3 prank TNT documentaries Schedule twilight king kong book adaptation PaleyFest universal monsters marvel cinematic universe Paramount Plus Horror dramedy Starz Disney worst 99% natural history Best Actor Amazon Studios genre art house Apple The Walt Disney Company DC Universe lord of the rings Interview 24 frames royal family DGA sequel free movies Red Carpet olympics NYCC Best and Worst travel TLC cartoon Pixar dc WarnerMedia Animation comics TCA romance HBO Max Peacock San Diego Comic-Con comic book movie Extras sopranos legend IFC suspense Awards Tour GoT chucky Alien Spectrum Originals scene in color Nickelodeon Ellie Kemper YouTube Premium rt labs critics edition Family elevated horror scorecard ghosts Funimation 007 nature 2018 Adult Swim History biopic zombie Wes Anderson christmas movies Thanksgiving laika Country remakes screen actors guild hispanic Epix BBC America TV One interviews See It Skip It Superheroe strong female leads GIFs live action social media Turner french OWN VH1 2017 romantic comedy Countdown worst movies 2019 versus Shondaland Sony Pictures renewed TV shows Elton John medical drama casting CBS Hallmark Holidays Tags: Comedy cars Pop Box Office BAFTA Pirates Podcast Anna Paquin black American Society of Cinematographers 90s south america Amazon rt archives South by Southwest Film Festival Ovation 2020 a nightmare on elm street Cosplay docudrama Disney Channel sports black comedy HBO Marathons NBA Shudder vampires BET Awards VOD BET Esquire WGN teaser Quiz Tumblr MGM vs. Marvel Arrowverse mutant TV renewals Warner Bros. SXSW First Reviews Song of Ice and Fire IFC Films SXSW 2022 hollywood Music Lifetime Christmas movies USA Network reboot Pet Sematary Comic-Con@Home 2021 Emmy Nominations TruTV BBC new york action-comedy Film DC Comics The Walking Dead anime wonder woman Certified Fresh Sneak Peek Fall TV cancelled news Black Mirror 93rd Oscars slashers crime drama posters Trophy Talk Universal adventure 1990s serial killer video on demand First Look Tomatazos TIFF Sundance razzies archives ratings indiana jones comic books Logo Watching Series sequels Exclusive Video cops Legendary Rock Turner Classic Movies Pride Month Mudbound Endgame Character Guide CNN FX on Hulu Paramount Network films comiccon Action Bravo Sundance Now marvel comics HBO Go Comic Book binge spain justice league Marvel Television basketball psycho award winner Vudu kaiju Winners Acorn TV DirecTV Tarantino Heroines 94th Oscars robots international Crunchyroll animated Kids & Family President Tokyo Olympics feel good Toys Captain marvel jamie lee curtis 2021 biography rt labs movies venice Teen book DC streaming service Fox News technology LGBT Hear Us Out Holiday parents broadcast Awards Calendar Walt Disney Pictures women RT History Paramount theme song obituary foreign fresh blaxploitation Disney Plus halloween tv Black History Month target Comics on TV child's play richard e. Grant disaster Netflix Christmas movies mob festival Lionsgate screenings hist Marvel Studios OneApp Cartoon Network psychological thriller A&E summer preview MCU golden globe awards mission: impossible kong FX Masterpiece singing competition summer TV preview HFPA spinoff Apple TV+ werewolf MTV The CW space Star Wars new zealand Fox Searchlight Hollywood Foreign Press Association Mary Tyler Moore Comedy Central Oscar Travel Channel franchise Rocketman IMDb TV best game of thrones hidden camera new star wars movies science fiction PlayStation Tubi what to watch Super Bowl high school zombies spy thriller independent X-Men anthology 21st Century Fox superhero Infographic harry potter Television Critics Association television Focus Features Instagram Live movie Photos dragons National Geographic Chernobyl satire period drama Apple TV Plus 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards SundanceTV Opinion A24 The Arrangement 79th Golden Globes Awards Crackle talk show leaderboard Best Director fast and furious quibi El Rey 45 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Oscars trophy breaking bad joker spider-verse blockbuster series aapi godzilla cancelled TV series FXX toronto classics dogs scary summer TV Neflix BBC One Ghostbusters nfl game show football NBC toy story TV crossover Paramount Pictures Television Academy gangster aliens die hard Premiere Dates cancelled TV shows australia E! japan adenture adaptation composers halloween stoner AMC CW Seed dexter Columbia Pictures TCA Awards USA Spike revenge Academy Awards tv talk Rocky TV movies crime thriller Year in Review stop motion saw zero dark thirty 2016 73rd Emmy Awards james bond Lucasfilm YA PBS jurassic park Brie Larson criterion superman Prime Video MSNBC Hallmark Christmas movies Britbox Discovery Channel japanese canceled unscripted canceled TV shows YouTube Western TV Land Polls and Games ESPN Pop TV trailers Biopics dark Pacific Islander monster movies Creative Arts Emmys streaming emmy awards historical drama TBS debate festivals mcc Christmas facebook pirates of the caribbean popular Classic Film asian-american ID Dark Horse Comics police drama cults Nominations live event Martial Arts The Witch Superheroes spanish Avengers Best Actress politics critics YouTube Red Binge Guide Netflix Disney+ Disney Plus Baby Yoda doctor who SDCC political drama war APB discovery all-time Star Trek kids comic critic resources rotten movies we love ABC Family New York Comic Con reviews RT21 Rom-Com 2015 TCM crime blockbusters spanish language boxoffice deadpool name the review dreamworks know your critic latino Sundance TV VICE Amazon Prime Spring TV GLAAD telelvision AMC Plus sag awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Stephen King ViacomCBS sitcom ABC Fantasy transformers Women's History Month ABC Signature Fargo Syfy Valentine's Day TCA Winter 2020 rom-coms scary movies slasher Freeform cats supernatural cancelled television streamig Reality Competition Mystery finale golden globes Emmys docuseries Winter TV documentary Musicals 20th Century Fox Amazon Prime Video The Purge miniseries hispanic heritage month TCA 2017 Video Games king arthur rotten based on movie Comedy Cannes Trailer 72 Emmy Awards Trivia spider-man Food Network stand-up comedy nbcuniversal Summer Musical Sci-Fi mockumentary Film Festival The Academy indie Lifetime boxing Writers Guild of America comedies