Hear Us Out

Wolfwalkers Demonstrates Why Cartoon Saloon is Studio Ghibli's True Successor

The Irish studio's unique style, mature storytelling, and emphasis on folklore and myth make it a spiritual cousin to the iconic Japanese animation house.

by | December 22, 2020 | Comments

Studio Ghibli is arguably the most recognizable and beloved animated studio outside of Disney/Pixar, one that has proven time and time again that animation is more than just entertainment aimed at kids thanks to critically acclaimed movies that challenge what you can do in the medium. So it’s easy to understand, then, that the moment one of the studio’s main directors, Hayao Miyazaki decided to retire (the first time), fans around the world began searching for a successor. Rather than a studio, could it be an auteur like Mamoru Hosoda (Summer Wars, Mirai) or Makoto Shinkai (Your Name, Weathering with You)? Would it be a studio founded by former Ghibli employees like Studio Ponoc, makers of 2018’s Mary and the Witch’s Flower?

It might, in fact, be none of the above. In truth, the animation studio that best captures the magic of Studio Ghibli and the themes they explore, all while carving out an identity and space in the industry of its own, is Cartoon Saloon. The Irish studio founded in 1999 has earned Academy Awards nominations for every single feature film it’s produced, and all of them are Certified Fresh at 90% or above on the Tomatometer. Its latest offering, Wolfwalkers, is being called the best animated film of the year by several critics, and it demonstrates why Cartoon Saloon’s unique blend of traditional animation and folklore make it the true successor to Studio Ghibli.

Their Films Deal with Folklore and Myth


(Photo by ©Apple TV+)

You don’t need to be familiar with yōkai or kodama to appreciate Princess Mononoke, and you certainly don’t need to know what a tanuki is in order to enjoy Pom Poko, but with both, you certainly do get the feeling that you’re watching a movie that’s deeply rooted in Japanese culture. Hayao Miyazaki and the people at Studio Ghibli don’t really adapt specific folktales the way Disney does, but they add creatures and beliefs as flavor to deepen the story and the cultural context. My Neighbor Totoro’s titular character may not be based on any specific creature of lore, but he is still instantly recognizable as an uniquely Japanese being.

The movies of Cartoon Saloon aren’t direct adaptations of any particular tales either, but they incorporate folkloric creatures and beliefs. Wolfwalkers takes its central concept from old myths about natives of the Kilkenny region in Ireland being able to transform into wolves while their bodies lie in a sort of trance, while Song of the Sea is about selkies, or humans that could transform into seals. These two movies, as well as the studio’s feature debut The Secret of Kells, make up an unofficial trilogy about Irish folklore, using legends and myths to tell fantastical stories about the conflict that arises when belief and tradition are threatened or abandoned.

Even if The Secret of Kells and Wolfwalkers are period pieces steeped in important moments of Irish history, there is a universality to their stories. You don’t need to know about Oliver Cromwell’s conquest of Ireland to understand Wolfwalkers’ central conflict and how it affects its main character’s relationship with her father — who works for Cromwell himself. But it does add some context that grounds the film in a real place and a real moment in time.

They Explore Humanity’s Relationship with Nature


(Photo by Cartoon Saloon)

As evident even in their earliest films, a big part of Ghibli movies is the focus on humanity’s fragile relationship with the environment and the struggle between nature and industrial progress. Miyazaki’s films in particular often explore how technology causes people to drift away from their cultural traditions while factories damage the land they live on. Perhaps the most obvious example of this is Princess Mononoke, a movie all about nature fighting back when humans start burning down forests to expand their towns and their industry.

Song of the Sea is partially about a Celtic goddess who threatens to destroy the world, but director Tomm Moore uses that as a starting point to tell a story about what happens when people begin to lose their cultural identity. Like many a Miyazaki film, Song of the Sea depicts the city as an oppressive, dirty place that drowns the freedom of the country and its children as the ones who are best suited carry on the country’s cultural heritage while the city’s inhabitants forget about it.

Wolfwalkers definitely takes some pointers from Princess Mononoke in its central conflict — a group of humans who set out to kill every wolf in the nearby woods — except the “nature vs. industry” conflict is used as an allegory for the Cromwellian ideal of taming the wild Irish lands and burning down traditions to replace them with English principles. As with Song of the Sea, the distinction between the city and the country informs the visual style as well. Kilkenny and its walls are drawn with geometric rigidity, and it almost resembles a prison as it looms in the background — just like the city cars in Song of the Sea, which only serve to spew black smoke and narrowly avoid hitting innocent children. Meanwhile, the art style of the woods, trees, and wolf of the forest are more sketched-out, with traditional Celtic spiral pattens to show the wolves haven’t been tamed, for they represent the “real” cultural Ireland.

Their Visual Styles are Exquisite and Unique


(Photo by ©Apple TV+)

As a studio grows and its films become more popular, a visual style is bound to emerge. Anyone can recognize Disney’s particular trademarks, just as all of Pixar films take on a similar visual language. Studio Ghibli’s films are instantly recognizable too, and yet they all feel and look incredibly different from each other. This balance between versatility and recognizability is the key to Cartoon Saloon.

The Irish studio’s unique visual style appears in every one of their movies, which feel like they belong in a strange sort of multiverse. At a time when CG animation is everywhere, Cartoon Saloon’s style feels defiant and stunning, but each of their films feels distinct from one another, as they try to capture the aesthetic of their subject matter. The Secret of Kells feels like an illustrated picture book to mimic the illuminated Christian tome that gives it its name, whereas The Breadwinner looks and feels distinctly like Afghan art, and Wolfwalkers pays homage to the wood-cut illustrations of the 1600s. By now, you know how to recognize a Cartoon Saloon film, but they always manage to offer some surprises, too.

They Aren’t Afraid of the Dark


(Photo by ©Apple TV+)

Though animation has a bit of a reputation for being kids’ entertainment in the West, Studio Ghibli is a perfect example of why this is entirely untrue. Not only do their more kid-friendly movies like Kiki’s Delivery Service tackle deeper and darker subjects like depression, but no one would dare call Grave of the Fireflies — a movie about two kids trying to survive in Japan during WWII — a kids movie.

Similarly, Cartoon Saloon’s movies are certainly entertainment made for broader audiences, but they also often go to darker places. The studio’s debut film, The Secret of Kells deals with an incoming Viking invasion, and Song of the Sea‘s main theme is grief and loss, but they are still stories being told through the eyes of kids. The protagonist of Wolfwalkers is literally hunted by her father at one point, but it’s The Breadwinner, the studio’s third feature, that best exemplifies their diversity in storytelling. The film follows a young Afghan girl posing as a boy to help her family survive after her father is imprisoned as a dissident by the ruling Taliban. This film is clearly aimed at a slightly older audience — hence its PG-13 rating — as it explores a more mature subject matter in its war-torn world, and even the colors are more naturalistic compared to the rest of the studio’s filmography.

They Entrust the Future to Children


(Photo by ©Apple TV+)

It’s not only that Cartoon Saloon’s movies can get dark, it’s that the worlds of the films feel like they’re approaching a cataclysmic ending, even as they somehow remain optimistic about the future.

A village is threatened by Vikings coming to destroy it; a little girl is engulfed in a war; a sea deity wants to turn the world to stone; the new people in charge want to burn the forest down. There’s a sense of urgency and doom looming large over each of Cartoon Saloon’s feature films, brought upon by the hubris of man — a theme the studio shares with Ghibli. Hayao Miyazaki’s movies in particular often deal with the error of trusting mankind to treat the world with respect. And yet, both studios seem to deeply trust their young protagonists and believe that children are the ones who will save the Earth. Parvana faces horrible, horrible things in The Breadwinner, but in her own small way, she wins in the end. War and evil will continue and people will still reject wolves and nature, but at least the children will be all right and grow up to do incredible things, hopefully with the lessons they’ve learned throughout their journeys in both Studio Ghibli’s and Cartoon Saloon’s films firmly rooted in their hearts.

Wolfwalkers debuted on November 13, 2020 and is currently available to stream on Apple TV+.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

VICE Crackle BAFTA Super Bowl Spike Marvel Television razzies Trailer Election TV Land Mystery crime drama Disney cartoon game show Best and Worst medical drama Rock Wes Anderson Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Musicals festivals foreign spanish Netflix Christmas movies Acorn TV politics Song of Ice and Fire fast and furious transformers anime Awards Tour NBC halloween Ghostbusters Masterpiece TV movies Broadway TV renewals singing competition 73rd Emmy Awards Binge Guide crime FX teaser Spectrum Originals die hard comiccon fresh remakes Apple TV+ what to watch cooking Pirates Mary Poppins Returns game of thrones Tomatazos obituary vampires toronto rotten movies we love Quiz prank Emmy Nominations hist comic book movies Thanksgiving Watching Series TCA 2017 E3 Lifetime Christmas movies Columbia Pictures Anna Paquin Pixar stoner cars romance CNN marvel cinematic universe scorecard dramedy cinemax Sony Pictures award winner Baby Yoda theme song all-time X-Men Food Network Valentine's Day Hallmark Christmas movies ESPN comic books suspense witnail DC streaming service TCA Mudbound discovery legend marvel comics biography new zealand Vudu popular independent NYCC Creative Arts Emmys Academy Awards gangster Turner romantic comedy Superheroe sitcom anthology Freeform TV DirecTV The Walt Disney Company LGBTQ wonder woman miniseries Endgame kids cats italian video Paramount Plus The Academy universal monsters ITV Year in Review Red Carpet rt archives Winners Amazon science fiction USA screen actors guild dexter hispanic directors historical drama Emmys boxing Awards Ellie Kemper Fox Searchlight Western American Society of Cinematographers reviews new york DGA Hear Us Out Horror movie aapi Showtime YA classics PaleyFest heist movie Marvel SXSW lord of the rings sports child's play Cannes free movies natural history japan RT History black book Pacific Islander documentary Comics on TV Sundance Now Film Festival Comic Book National Geographic high school golden globes saw breaking bad MSNBC spain CMT Teen Exclusive Video olympics streaming movies cancelled Oscars feel good adaptation comics Sneak Peek 90s Pop TV Drama zombies nfl A&E Holiday comedies criterion tv talk composers CBS All Access period drama Set visit name the review SundanceTV VOD Avengers football indiana jones video on demand YouTube Premium 93rd Oscars Musical Hallmark 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Reality BBC One indie The CW Nat Geo biopic christmas movies Apple TV Plus Kids & Family 2019 Cartoon Network Opinion batman Dark Horse Comics critic resources PBS Winter TV Amazon Studios TCA Winter 2020 Netflix asian-american 2015 spanish language Sci-Fi joker Warner Bros. cancelled TV shows unscripted First Look zero dark thirty Premiere Dates Family revenge quibi canceled Martial Arts sag awards Mary Tyler Moore festival technology docudrama diversity WGN TCA Awards Reality Competition Television Critics Association Tokyo Olympics 1990s aliens hollywood cops Crunchyroll Britbox Action spider-man Video Games Trophy Talk japanese live action Brie Larson renewed TV shows canceled TV shows blaxploitation superhero Alien ghosts El Rey international Paramount ID OWN concert know your critic Marathons Image Comics jamie lee curtis Grammys Women's History Month superman political drama IFC Films green book rotten werewolf Christmas movies stand-up comedy Epix The Arrangement best 4/20 Sundance TV Mindy Kaling slashers chucky venice australia women YouTube Red Esquire Star Trek ABC Family richard e. Grant A24 rom-coms 007 Animation 21st Century Fox HBO spinoff Turner Classic Movies Disney Channel Ovation ABC 2017 Amazon Prime Sundance satire Captain marvel a nightmare on elm street Funimation Paramount Network comic Amazon Prime Video psychological thriller Television Academy Comedy Polls and Games scene in color police drama Certified Fresh Travel Channel Toys Podcast Photos disaster telelvision Disney+ Disney Plus kong blockbuster news Nominations psycho 99% toy story Interview Hulu crime thriller Music Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt sequel HBO Go Character Guide 2020 Star Wars strong female leads Tubi BBC America Peacock mission: impossible OneApp Fox News television CBS worst movies based on movie mutant sequels DC Comics 72 Emmy Awards Film Black History Month Rom-Com dogs SDCC Holidays Pet Sematary Biopics PlayStation new star wars movies nature zombie target FX on Hulu halloween tv doctor who FXX Fantasy franchise LGBT cancelled television Legendary twilight scary movies E! Lifetime San Diego Comic-Con Country TCM robots IFC Rocky FOX TNT TBS Superheroes parents royal family travel ABC Signature Fall TV Discovery Channel New York Comic Con godzilla MCU First Reviews dc Infographic History Tarantino documentaries Classic Film CW Seed Lucasfilm 24 frames Marvel Studios war TLC king arthur cancelled TV series Tumblr Starz crossover AMC Shondaland President USA Network south america hidden camera Pop latino Bravo GoT Summer harry potter TIFF casting worst animated reboot 20th Century Fox posters Comedy Central basketball Chernobyl YouTube rt labs social media golden globe awards Logo Adult Swim versus spy thriller space hispanic heritage month mockumentary Heroines cults APB Rocketman justice league See It Skip It deadpool streaming GIFs NBA dceu laika 45 VH1 2018 Mary poppins Pride Month debate 71st Emmy Awards nbcuniversal The Walking Dead Calendar true crime young adult monster movies Cosplay boxoffice slasher docuseries Comic-Con@Home 2021 book adaptation films stop motion series Apple ViacomCBS children's TV supernatural finale emmy awards adenture Writers Guild of America facebook thriller WarnerMedia rt labs critics edition blockbusters 2016 Extras Schedule binge BET dark screenings serial killer GLAAD Shudder mcc action-comedy kaiju RT21 TruTV archives Walt Disney Pictures The Purge Elton John Syfy Stephen King BBC comic book movie Arrowverse pirates of the caribbean elevated horror critics ratings king kong Countdown HBO Max dragons jurassic park Nickelodeon MTV 2021 Black Mirror BET Awards french Disney streaming service talk show Box Office Spring TV Lionsgate Trivia TV One adventure Disney Plus Universal The Witch DC Universe james bond trailers