Video Interviews

Will The Irishman Earn Martin Scorsese His Next Best Picture Oscar?: The Ultimate Debate

Mark Ellis, Angie Han, and Scott Mantz are tackling the big one: How does The Irishman stack up against Scorsese's other films? Who's the movie's MVP? And is Scorsese bound for Oscar glory... again?

by | November 3, 2019 | Comments

Netflix released Martin Scorsese’s long-anticipated The Irishman into very select theaters this weekend ahead of the film’s digital release on the streaming platform November 27. And so the world is finally getting its first look at the epic three-and-a-half–hour gangster flick that reunites Scorsese favorites Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci and also features Al Pacino, starring in a Scorsese picture for the very first time. Critics are loving it so far: The movie is Certified Fresh at 97% on the Tomatometer, and the director and lead cast are all considered sure-things for nominations this awards season. But is this adaptation of I Heard You Paint Houses, the story of gangster Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran and his relationship with union leader Jimmy Hoffa, everything the buzz says it is? That’s the question Mark Ellis is asking critics Scott Mantz and Angie Han (Mashable) in this Irishman deep dive. The panel tackles all the big questions about Netflix’s big Oscar play: Is it Scorsese’s best movie? Who stands out in the cast? Does the movie completely sideline its female cast? And, of course, we ask if this movie will land the legendary director his second Best Picture statuette?

The Irishman is in select theaters now and available on Netflix November 27, 2019. 

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.


The Irishman (2019)

Adjusted Score: 114.759%
Critics Consensus: An epic gangster drama that earns its extended runtime, The Irishman finds Martin Scorsese revisiting familiar themes to poignant, funny, and profound effect.
Synopsis: This biographical crime thriller follows Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro) as he recalls his past years working for the Bufalino... [More]
Directed By: Martin Scorsese

Tag Cloud

Nickelodeon Comedy Central docudrama spinoff 71st Emmy Awards political drama robots Lifetime Christmas movies HBO Go cults Holidays book Hallmark Christmas movies Ellie Kemper strong female leads ratings mission: impossible Showtime Music Holiday twilight universal monsters Fall TV The Purge video on demand Endgame CBS All Access talk show 007 doctor who Cannes screenings Trailer best BET Awards OWN Hulu parents TCM streaming ABC Christmas Fox News ESPN dark critics boxing First Look Box Office Lucasfilm comiccon Walt Disney Pictures boxoffice SXSW Interview zombies series Summer worst movies PlayStation Elton John Musical A24 Anna Paquin joker natural history Horror Rock TNT MSNBC 2016 rotten TV renewals ITV Women's History Month TIFF romantic comedy Teen dogs Valentine's Day Video Games Polls and Games Tarantino comedies Emmy Nominations hollywood Extras 21st Century Fox concert singing competition FX on Hulu Pet Sematary Song of Ice and Fire YA dceu films casting cancelled TV series Apple TV Plus dragons Certified Fresh Mary poppins Classic Film japanese Pop CW Seed Marvel Television hispanic American Society of Cinematographers VH1 BET TCA Awards Thanksgiving binge Grammys NBC dramedy SDCC Acorn TV theme song USA Network unscripted social media Winners movies Sneak Peek Amazon Film versus Disney+ Disney Plus HBO Max richard e. Grant FOX Mary Tyler Moore christmas movies Hallmark The Arrangement Disney Channel comic festival Rocky Opinion comic books San Diego Comic-Con animated Brie Larson anime Netflix ID VICE Amazon Prime Video Schedule toronto scorecard Awards Tomatazos superhero Infographic cooking Mary Poppins Returns Character Guide Travel Channel Martial Arts Toys ABC Family TCA 2017 Trophy Talk YouTube Premium Nominations PBS Set visit TCA Winter 2020 Comics on TV Family festivals Peacock Epix television cancelled Cartoon Network Calendar Spike Pride Month cats Oscars game show Pixar TV Land tv talk what to watch Television Academy PaleyFest BAFTA teaser USA Ovation MTV indiana jones TBS Creative Arts Emmys 20th Century Fox Tubi BBC One biography DGA Crunchyroll harry potter documentary obituary 24 frames National Geographic Western Paramount Premiere Dates Apple TV+ Starz Reality Competition 2015 Freeform werewolf breaking bad Podcast spain Columbia Pictures Chernobyl BBC America jamie lee curtis Mudbound Disney screen actors guild The CW DC Universe video movie war E! football TLC Captain marvel Sci-Fi Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Lifetime psychological thriller Fantasy AMC romance Superheroe Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Bravo Sundance Now crossover spanish language Stephen King aliens police drama based on movie Writers Guild of America vampires witnail criterion Binge Guide 2020 The Witch space See It Skip It toy story zero dark thirty Black History Month BBC a nightmare on elm street VOD scary movies fast and furious 2017 finale Star Trek Black Mirror Apple DC streaming service Lionsgate zombie venice discovery Superheroes miniseries Shudder sequels TCA cinemax Discovery Channel Spectrum Originals cancelled television Mystery Vudu Crackle LGBTQ batman nbcuniversal CBS justice league Warner Bros. Awards Tour news Arrowverse 2019 halloween tv Dark Horse Comics free movies emmy awards independent remakes south america crime drama First Reviews Universal children's TV DirecTV NYCC classics President stoner Marathons thriller Animation 2018 TruTV historical drama medical drama Fox Searchlight ghosts FX all-time italian 4/20 french Hear Us Out worst Funimation Musicals supernatural technology archives Turner Netflix Christmas movies APB Amazon Studios Super Bowl Avengers composers game of thrones halloween Trivia LGBT Esquire RT History stand-up comedy Masterpiece Film Festival sag awards Disney streaming service Marvel Studios Shondaland The Walking Dead adaptation transformers TV directors WGN Paramount Network Pop TV cartoon serial killer YouTube Red Marvel laika OneApp anthology Spring TV mockumentary australia franchise nature MCU Kids & Family HBO Reality Baby Yoda FXX science fiction blaxploitation 72 Emmy Awards travel Winter TV Quiz Comic Book SundanceTV Year in Review Best and Worst Heroines james bond The Academy CMT black Academy Awards period drama Pirates GLAAD rotten movies we love spy thriller WarnerMedia Food Network crime thriller Ghostbusters Rocketman adventure Photos YouTube A&E sequel elevated horror renewed TV shows reviews chucky IFC Films Countdown GIFs documentaries Logo child's play Election Sundance TV rt archives Cosplay psycho CNN comics Star Wars Amazon Prime die hard reboot Television Critics Association diversity Red Carpet asian-american Britbox Disney Plus X-Men Mindy Kaling stop motion Country Sony Pictures Turner Classic Movies foreign canceled TV shows Drama true crime hist 99% Action Biopics GoT golden globes Syfy Emmys green book politics kids History El Rey spanish Alien latino sitcom DC Comics E3 fresh name the review quibi Adult Swim blockbuster slashers revenge mutant cars facebook Comedy spider-man Tumblr deadpool 45 nfl Sundance disaster cops RT21 Rom-Com Watching Series award winner sports indie canceled satire IFC New York Comic Con Nat Geo crime cancelled TV shows dc