Who Is the Best Joker?

The iconic villain has been portrayed on the big screen by several actors for over half a century, but who played him best?

by | October 4, 2019 | Comments

Joaquin Phoenix is making all the headlines with his magnetic performance in Todd Phillips’ Joker, but before he came along to give us all the creeps, who played the character best? We decided to look back at the history of the singularly iconic villain as portrayed on screen and take on the impossible task of figuring out the answer to that question. So how did we do it? Watch as Mark Ellis takes every big-screen version of the Joker and pits them against each other in four categories: Box Office/Tomatometer, Most Memorable, Most Dastardly Plan, and, of course, the Wild Card round. Check out the video to see who gets crowned the ultimate Clown Prince of Crime, and let us know in the comments who your favorite is!

Joker opens everywhere on October 4.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

revenge MCU Comic Book Kids & Family latino Rock New York Comic Con El Rey zombie golden globes hist green book FOX The Walking Dead Horror Hallmark Christmas movies Apple TV+ Mary Poppins Returns Disney+ Disney Plus dragons justice league Song of Ice and Fire Watching Series comics NBC ESPN cartoon FX Sundance Comedy Central Ghostbusters Spectrum Originals Winter TV CW Seed Rocky Tubi Tumblr Opinion Netflix mockumentary versus Star Wars Podcast children's TV Countdown Lifetime Christmas movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The Purge comic Logo teaser Election series Disney Plus E3 strong female leads MSNBC Nat Geo facebook WGN Reality Competition Classic Film Red Carpet TruTV BBC historical drama Music DC Universe Rom-Com spider-man Trailer game of thrones BBC America VICE Lifetime Oscars MTV Action LGBTQ cancelled Character Guide 007 Black Mirror YouTube Premium Adult Swim cars renewed TV shows television Holiday Disney Channel zero dark thirty Superheroe LGBT Polls and Games Chernobyl sports breaking bad anime Shondaland independent Quiz Pirates Turner Classic Movies free movies book biography anthology Country blaxploitation Fox News Christmas spinoff USA Network Extras Food Network Academy Awards Mary poppins Pop ghosts Western OneApp cancelled TV shows Premiere Dates Vudu singing competition hispanic Star Trek Schedule Spring TV directors richard e. Grant politics adventure Starz docudrama Marvel GoT Valentine's Day TV Trivia Apple Lionsgate war Hulu diversity Cosplay blockbuster IFC Films USA what to watch science fiction NYCC thriller mutant Arrowverse E! Best and Worst Discovery Channel DC Comics FXX social media First Reviews cats canceled TV shows TCA romance Pride Month reboot discovery TNT crime thriller SXSW GIFs AMC Syfy TV Land crossover PaleyFest Martial Arts name the review Marathons Set visit unscripted TV renewals police drama 2017 Ovation Hallmark cooking south america Grammys Turner travel Tarantino Netflix Christmas movies award winner sag awards Family quibi robots 2020 spy thriller Marvel Studios Peacock cops CBS YA Showtime Tomatazos Holidays psycho werewolf Heroines American Society of Cinematographers dramedy San Diego Comic-Con 2016 Writers Guild of America based on movie See It Skip It Mudbound aliens Stephen King screen actors guild Esquire IFC Creative Arts Emmys Television Academy Fantasy video finale WarnerMedia elevated horror spain DC streaming service Winners Comics on TV witnail dceu Teen serial killer game show Sneak Peek Shudder Musicals CNN Baby Yoda Bravo Sundance TV streaming talk show animated OWN TBS Columbia Pictures YouTube Red Freeform joker Sci-Fi Toys Summer VH1 Biopics TLC HBO Max doctor who harry potter Photos Box Office Mary Tyler Moore Captain marvel Women's History Month Cannes romantic comedy festivals natural history Marvel Television sequel 45 A&E disaster Paramount Network Emmy Nominations theme song Amazon political drama crime Sundance Now Mystery 2018 Brie Larson kids Comedy true crime Elton John CMT Superheroes Film indie CBS All Access transformers Emmys vampires cancelled TV series Avengers History canceled Pet Sematary Spike Endgame X-Men DirecTV SDCC TCA Winter 2020 tv talk TIFF Rocketman Ellie Kemper miniseries foreign boxoffice Cartoon Network cults zombies toy story Apple TV Plus movies 2019 batman Trophy Talk psychological thriller ABC Family sitcom Pixar Amazon Prime Crunchyroll Amazon Prime Video YouTube National Geographic supernatural The Arrangement jamie lee curtis Disney Nominations Film Festival Masterpiece Paramount SundanceTV comiccon GLAAD 20th Century Fox Disney streaming service medical drama screenings spanish language Binge Guide Dark Horse Comics Lucasfilm Reality PBS Certified Fresh dc 2015 Acorn TV HBO Infographic binge DGA Super Bowl A24 casting rotten movies we love First Look space adaptation Animation Interview Thanksgiving RT21 ITV Awards technology Awards Tour ratings stand-up comedy Sony Pictures 71st Emmy Awards Universal BET ABC Britbox halloween period drama Mindy Kaling Musical Drama cancelled television composers Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt The CW Walt Disney Pictures slashers Crackle Warner Bros. TCM RT History Nickelodeon Video Games Year in Review nature Anna Paquin crime drama christmas movies TCA 2017 Epix Calendar Fall TV 21st Century Fox President cinemax APB The Witch 24 frames