Who Is the Best Joker?

The iconic villain has been portrayed on the big screen by several actors for over half a century, but who played him best?

by | October 4, 2019 | Comments

Joaquin Phoenix is making all the headlines with his magnetic performance in Todd Phillips’ Joker, but before he came along to give us all the creeps, who played the character best? We decided to look back at the history of the singularly iconic villain as portrayed on screen and take on the impossible task of figuring out the answer to that question. So how did we do it? Watch as Mark Ellis takes every big-screen version of the Joker and pits them against each other in four categories: Box Office/Tomatometer, Most Memorable, Most Dastardly Plan, and, of course, the Wild Card round. Check out the video to see who gets crowned the ultimate Clown Prince of Crime, and let us know in the comments who your favorite is!

Joker opens everywhere on October 4.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

ITV Pet Sematary 2020 toy story tv talk 2015 DC streaming service Trophy Talk DGA all-time Women's History Month Logo Nickelodeon franchise Country Tubi Sneak Peek The Witch mission: impossible sag awards films Captain marvel sequel Drama best political drama cancelled Paramount Network mutant Comedy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt police drama Comic Book zombies Apple TV+ Crackle true crime series Marvel RT History GLAAD cartoon festivals reviews disaster crime thriller green book GIFs dc Box Office TruTV TCA 2017 twilight 24 frames laika Elton John BBC One Writers Guild of America cancelled TV shows BBC America politics composers YouTube Red romance IFC Films National Geographic Quiz PBS NBC Walt Disney Pictures Summer book Sundance Now Premiere Dates Musical ratings Star Wars CW Seed binge Mindy Kaling Travel Channel SundanceTV documentaries Winter TV 20th Century Fox Peacock stoner cinemax video unscripted social media golden globes Reality Competition zero dark thirty 2018 Black Mirror 007 Character Guide Comedy Central Disney streaming service E! Spectrum Originals Trivia Horror strong female leads blaxploitation Columbia Pictures canceled movie child's play Pop TV Fox News Amazon Studios dogs sitcom Arrowverse anime Thanksgiving Discovery Channel supernatural Baby Yoda OWN Rock witnail Cosplay Sundance TV BET First Look TCM American Society of Cinematographers anthology Toys Animation TNT space Lifetime Christmas movies richard e. Grant Valentine's Day stand-up comedy AMC boxoffice Calendar elevated horror TLC FOX Britbox Film doctor who romantic comedy Tumblr Cannes criterion Podcast docudrama Awards Tour 45 Ovation USA Network A&E spy thriller Song of Ice and Fire biography TV Land Winners hollywood rotten movies we love Television Academy Tarantino quibi Ghostbusters Amazon Prime diversity transformers chucky HBO See It Skip It History LGBT teaser Starz dark Pixar WGN Heroines Certified Fresh CMT universal monsters Sony Pictures Video Games ghosts spinoff serial killer Year in Review Black History Month finale Star Trek Tomatazos Avengers jamie lee curtis kids Shondaland name the review vampires Red Carpet comic Nominations MSNBC Photos Television Critics Association nbcuniversal VICE Apple Binge Guide crime 21st Century Fox Fantasy spain foreign MTV historical drama Universal Holidays Rom-Com Watching Series Brie Larson south america asian-american television ABC Family Showtime satire animated Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pirates PaleyFest ABC news cars Reality Schedule movies comics CBS VH1 versus YouTube Premium cooking BBC 2019 TV Grammys comiccon GoT 2016 psycho indie concert Hallmark Christmas movies Kids & Family Rocketman Spring TV adventure nature Extras hispanic Warner Bros. Teen Paramount Marvel Television Martial Arts Lifetime worst YouTube sports adaptation Marathons Mystery award winner Marvel Studios TCA Winter 2020 cops Shudder game of thrones The Walking Dead Mudbound Comics on TV fast and furious indiana jones Infographic Interview Disney directors Oscars crime drama Mary Tyler Moore Turner Classic Movies screenings VOD free movies Superheroe Chernobyl Netflix Christmas movies blockbuster Pop Creative Arts Emmys Syfy Set visit science fiction cats psychological thriller game show joker singing competition President HBO Go cancelled television thriller Spike Best and Worst The Arrangement reboot classics theme song miniseries Biopics breaking bad Lucasfilm Trailer rotten TV renewals talk show Ellie Kemper renewed TV shows superhero Amazon medical drama sequels casting critics Disney Channel Holiday Cartoon Network werewolf FX on Hulu period drama WarnerMedia cancelled TV series OneApp 72 Emmy Awards TBS Superheroes what to watch zombie USA TCA Awards Opinion latino independent Apple TV Plus die hard Awards MCU canceled TV shows parents Acorn TV Crunchyroll Classic Film based on movie Esquire Fall TV mockumentary A24 Anna Paquin Film Festival obituary The Purge 4/20 New York Comic Con X-Men Stephen King Hulu Mary Poppins Returns SDCC Emmy Nominations Sci-Fi Freeform PlayStation TCA Vudu Adult Swim DC Comics E3 robots revenge cults discovery Dark Horse Comics Musicals FX dceu Emmys Funimation APB Rocky BET Awards Disney Plus screen actors guild Family slashers halloween children's TV spanish language Mary poppins Countdown spider-man Pride Month San Diego Comic-Con Netflix Action facebook SXSW technology Hear Us Out CBS All Access DirecTV comedies Academy Awards First Reviews FXX HBO Max LGBTQ 2017 dragons stop motion El Rey The CW Lionsgate TIFF emmy awards Epix CNN ESPN Hallmark Turner natural history documentary justice league Nat Geo Sundance IFC christmas movies dramedy NYCC Bravo Endgame video on demand Christmas YA Amazon Prime Video streaming Election Disney+ Disney Plus BAFTA Masterpiece batman Food Network scary movies war hist a nightmare on elm street Polls and Games RT21 crossover travel DC Universe harry potter Music aliens 71st Emmy Awards Super Bowl Western