Showdowns

Wes Craven Vs. John Carpenter: Who Is the Ultimate Master of Horror?

Who has the Fresher movies, bigger box office, and more terrifying moments? It's our bloodiest battle yet.

by | October 14, 2020 | Comments

One gave us Michael Myers and the Thing, the other Freddy Krueger and Ghostface – and both gave us many, many sleepless nights. But who is the king of making us quake? In our latest episode of Vs., we’re slicing and dicing the numbers to find out who is the true master of horror: John Carpenter or Wes Craven. Will it be the famed director – and killer composer – who essentially defined the slasher genre with Halloween? Or will it be Craven, who let us know that danger lurked under the stairs, in the last house on the left, and in our dreams? Our favorite Final Boy and Rotten Tomatoes contributing editor Mark Ellis is examining Tomatometer and Audience Score data, box office performance, iconic moments and characters from their films, to make a call. And if you don’t agree, have at him: He’s just putting on some Jiffy Pop right now and his phone number is… we mean, let us know in the comments!


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.


Thumbnail image: © New Line, © First Run Features

Tag Cloud

Awards obituary spinoff animated Peacock Trophy Talk Paramount Network australia die hard free movies Red Carpet reviews The Academy Funimation blaxploitation VH1 First Reviews A24 Cartoon Network rt archives DirecTV aapi chucky 2015 ABC Signature aliens sag awards TNT Disney scorecard dc Acorn TV south america Marathons Martial Arts Emmys Trailer 20th Century Fox Comic-Con@Home 2021 93rd Oscars Turner Classic Movies Tubi black documentary Mary Tyler Moore cartoon wonder woman crime remakes golden globes HBO Tomatazos TCA 2017 Tokyo Olympics sequels Fox News Pacific Islander movie Rom-Com nfl renewed TV shows thriller james bond Mary Poppins Returns video on demand Best and Worst japanese NBA VOD scary movies MCU witnail screen actors guild scene in color natural history Marvel Animation Amazon Prime Video Reality Competition Hallmark Christmas movies festival werewolf Black History Month Pop godzilla all-time Nominations Toys supernatural period drama Biopics political drama Mystery Valentine's Day Pixar Apple TV+ adenture Watching Series Freeform DC Universe Marvel Television elevated horror Photos Hulu king arthur Sneak Peek critics Rock HBO Go justice league football Pride Month BBC One monster movies Brie Larson Esquire AMC disaster The Walking Dead jamie lee curtis Premiere Dates breaking bad GLAAD USA Masterpiece space OneApp SDCC MTV superman FOX Set visit 007 90s PlayStation Amazon Prime ID asian-american Reality WarnerMedia Film Trivia Amazon Studios FX twilight series anthology know your critic Spring TV Musical 2020 dogs DC Comics cats 2019 new star wars movies Lionsgate Turner concert stop motion Pop TV laika 4/20 American Society of Cinematographers Mudbound dragons italian rotten ghosts psycho HBO Max christmas movies El Rey venice historical drama sitcom psychological thriller CNN saw finale screenings Teen Comics on TV mockumentary Shondaland spanish language latino Creative Arts Emmys Sci-Fi Polls and Games Action Columbia Pictures hist Box Office The Witch GoT telelvision Alien Horror vampires casting Broadway E3 See It Skip It marvel cinematic universe cancelled television crime drama LGBTQ slashers festivals Elton John Marvel Studios children's TV The Walt Disney Company anime RT History archives Calendar X-Men 45 Super Bowl Arrowverse Infographic robots YouTube kids Shudder San Diego Comic-Con Walt Disney Pictures indiana jones golden globe awards crime thriller Video Games Starz comics cancelled TV shows Awards Tour Apple science fiction sports Disney Channel adventure Countdown FXX women Cosplay game show target BET A&E films ITV blockbuster trailers 2021 teaser Christmas Image Comics Certified Fresh Thanksgiving Chernobyl Netflix Christmas movies boxoffice heist movie YouTube Red lord of the rings BAFTA spain 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Vudu Comedy olympics Music Film Festival Schedule Syfy streaming Crackle Television Critics Association TruTV DGA Cannes Holiday reboot ViacomCBS strong female leads revenge Character Guide History Baby Yoda TV movies tv talk YouTube Premium deadpool halloween prank worst fresh cancelled TV series richard e. Grant TBS discovery Fall TV sequel independent TV Land Mary poppins Winners quibi biography 2018 Ghostbusters travel technology book adaptation ABC Family NBC hollywood Pet Sematary streaming movies green book GIFs award winner Sony Pictures LGBT USA Network canceled TV shows TLC satire Oscars serial killer Disney Plus social media binge documentaries Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Holidays live action 2016 miniseries television BBC America singing competition Netflix popular PBS boxing new york 2017 nature Black Mirror cooking Apple TV Plus romance spider-man new zealand Heroines emmy awards cinemax BET Awards superhero movies Comedy Central what to watch Quiz Summer Fox Searchlight fast and furious hidden camera Comic Book Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TV based on movie TCA Awards NYCC king kong Dark Horse Comics Family joker Television Academy Nat Geo Exclusive Video Showtime IFC TCM japan Lifetime Christmas movies PaleyFest TCA Winter 2020 Hear Us Out Tumblr rom-coms Drama game of thrones Lifetime toronto MSNBC Musicals Wes Anderson Discovery Channel directors international Podcast stoner true crime war basketball romantic comedy talk show Crunchyroll BBC 1990s Interview Academy Awards National Geographic suspense Extras Paramount ratings halloween tv dceu Pirates DC streaming service classics 24 frames dark book comiccon President Anna Paquin FX on Hulu toy story child's play docudrama Election TCA jurassic park comic a nightmare on elm street Women's History Month 71st Emmy Awards french RT21 Adult Swim name the review doctor who Paramount Plus universal monsters Tarantino Endgame Epix Hallmark batman transformers CMT The Arrangement Classic Film facebook crossover Logo Food Network nbcuniversal legend Superheroe VICE TV renewals 99% Warner Bros. best police drama Spectrum Originals Universal Ovation The CW Lucasfilm ABC Emmy Nominations Spike criterion Rocky comedies ESPN worst movies diversity OWN unscripted composers Opinion news spy thriller Superheroes high school razzies docuseries franchise medical drama versus Year in Review IFC Films cults parents Sundance Now CW Seed Kids & Family cars Writers Guild of America zero dark thirty cancelled Disney streaming service APB Song of Ice and Fire Amazon politics WGN SXSW canceled YA hispanic Bravo Sundance Sundance TV kaiju Star Trek CBS All Access dramedy Star Wars Ellie Kemper SundanceTV foreign TIFF comic books stand-up comedy mutant Legendary mission: impossible Captain marvel cops Grammys TV One Winter TV adaptation The Purge First Look Travel Channel rotten movies we love Disney+ Disney Plus Rocketman blockbusters Country 21st Century Fox spanish Britbox Binge Guide zombies Stephen King 72 Emmy Awards Western video Fantasy theme song harry potter Nickelodeon pirates of the caribbean zombie indie Avengers kong New York Comic Con CBS E! Mindy Kaling