Showdowns

RT Fans Crown Halloween the Ultimate Horror Movie

The John Carpenter classic surged from behind on the last day of voting to eke out a victory over The Shining by a mere 20 votes!

by | October 29, 2021 | Comments

(Click to enlarge.)

After six intense rounds of voting on some of the most beloved, most iconic horror films ever, we can finally announce that the winner of the Ultimate Horror Movie Showdown is John Carpenter’s original Halloween! And, appropriately enough, the win came by the narrowest of margins, making it the closest battle of the entire tournament. Stanley Kubrick’s adaptation of Stephen King’s The Shining held a tenuous lead of just under 100 votes as the last day of voting began, but as afternoon came, the tide began to turn. When all was said and done, almost 14,000 votes were cast, and Halloween received a last-minute surge that helped it eke out the victory over The Shining by a mere 20 votes (6917 to 6897, to be exact)!

As always, thanks to everyone who participated and followed along, leaving comments and discussing the results. If nothing else, we hope we’ve reminded you of a few forgotten favorites or a few gems you’ve been meaning to check out that you can place on your Halloween watch list for the weekend. With that said, stay tuned for our next showdown, and have a safe and Happy Halloween!

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results


Final Round Result

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next

Tag Cloud

documentary Film die hard cancelled television japanese American Society of Cinematographers fresh Acorn TV comic book movies binge Video Games Grammys movie Sci-Fi Stephen King spanish zombies Creative Arts Emmys Syfy Starz Awards Tour Nominations Captain marvel parents spinoff transformers award winner TV Land YouTube Premium Opinion Crackle YA animated Discovery Channel First Reviews Chernobyl children's TV Freeform Paramount Network breaking bad Rocketman dramedy Comic-Con@Home 2021 technology 90s reviews sitcom new york Indigenous GoT razzies emmy awards The Academy IFC worst BET Awards thriller Cosplay know your critic marvel comics interviews 2017 Superheroes ViacomCBS crime canceled films posters ID Mary Tyler Moore jamie lee curtis Quiz Image Comics trailers VICE renewed TV shows batman talk show satire scene in color series Television Critics Association RT History justice league DGA Paramount Pictures boxing Pop TV boxoffice romance Paramount APB romantic comedy streaming movies mob book politics space stop motion toronto Black Mirror obi wan 21st Century Fox NBA Song of Ice and Fire movies Exclusive Video E3 IMDb TV BBC Dark Horse Comics IFC Films mockumentary Star Wars game show El Rey Instagram Live Focus Features Year in Review Sundance Lifetime TCA Awards Sony MGM Music Ovation Binge Guide spain ABC Signature ESPN blaxploitation diversity best debate Oscar 93rd Oscars indie YouTube Red TruTV Arrowverse DirecTV sports Netflix Tokyo Olympics Showtime Sundance TV Country hispanic Teen Martial Arts nfl Wes Anderson Pet Sematary halloween Comics on TV psychological thriller dragons composers comic books Mystery scene in color film series black FX on Hulu First Look Rocky 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards live event 73rd Emmy Awards new zealand comiccon Interview Baby Yoda hidden camera strong female leads gangster Action spider-man franchise adaptation Nat Geo 007 2021 Awards Bravo hollywood Universal deadpool 24 frames superhero 2019 Comedy USA Network worst movies target Pirates Hollywood Foreign Press Association Best and Worst documentaries Columbia Pictures reboot doctor who Marvel Studios Musical Amazon Studios revenge italian History Food Network news NYCC summer TV preview crime drama theme song A24 Trophy Talk Emmy Nominations PaleyFest TCM Crunchyroll adenture fast and furious spider-verse Apple teaser DC Universe Peacock supernatural singing competition criterion book adaptation science fiction 71st Emmy Awards cults ABC Family live action lord of the rings Academy Awards cats Mary poppins latino Marathons superman Western HBO Max concert VH1 Marvel Writers Guild of America Heroines dogs X-Men Animation witnail CMT SDCC Disney+ Disney Plus a nightmare on elm street Best Director sequels Pop child's play Mudbound Travel Channel ITV docudrama jurassic park Toys Fox Searchlight kong President quibi HBO Go dark Drama rt labs critics edition Pacific Islander psycho Elton John 99% Paramount Plus The Arrangement stoner Watching Series football blockbuster Anna Paquin WGN Family biography kids political drama heist movie rt labs Musicals Lifetime Christmas movies free movies Disney PlayStation South by Southwest Film Festival adventure sequel Fox News broadcast FXX robots discovery cinemax Sneak Peek 94th Oscars New York Comic Con HBO cartoon rotten movies we love Tags: Comedy halloween tv television Apple TV Plus TV renewals Best Actor social media green book vs. festival VOD CBS scary TBS Oscars DC streaming service cops scene in color Prime Video Disney Channel BAFTA scorecard Pixar Fall TV comic HFPA Funimation See It Skip It anthology rom-coms BET king kong Television Academy Turner National Geographic Classic Film travel Countdown Fargo CNN Rom-Com christmas movies Cartoon Network 79th Golden Globes Awards facebook TNT stand-up comedy FOX canceled TV shows Star Trek monster movies Tumblr genre game of thrones 2016 new star wars movies zombie chucky festivals LGBTQ leaderboard telelvision hispanic heritage month biopic RT21 Disney streaming service art house Amazon Prime Video suspense Horror Walt Disney Pictures medical drama all-time MSNBC critic resources Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Ellie Kemper vampires casting Tubi women Red Carpet NBC spy thriller 20th Century Fox Calendar PBS foreign Superheroe disaster Tomatazos elevated horror Kids & Family TLC pirates of the caribbean independent AMC Plus universal monsters mcc Warner Bros. Winter TV mutant police drama joker Valentine's Day ABC comic book movie 4/20 The Walking Dead summer TV Best Actress Mary Poppins Returns Ghostbusters Thanksgiving olympics Star Wars Celebration screen actors guild Best Picture SXSW 2022 Spike Marvel Television docuseries SXSW The CW Apple TV+ ratings high school critics 1990s CBS All Access richard e. Grant Film Festival Extras nbcuniversal harry potter cooking dexter BBC America FX Neflix Esquire Hulu cancelled Adult Swim Hallmark royal family comedies Schedule mission: impossible remakes war Holiday zero dark thirty black comedy international venice Shudder San Diego Comic-Con Brie Larson YouTube 2018 godzilla classics serial killer archives E! screenings french Turner Classic Movies Mindy Kaling TCA Winter 2020 australia cancelled TV shows CW Seed Epix crossover asian-american young adult werewolf OWN Fantasy Photos japan saw golden globes Black History Month slashers Set visit aapi Sony Pictures Amazon Prime james bond popular laika Tarantino twilight Election slasher 2020 sag awards Endgame sopranos golden globe awards A&E Trivia Masterpiece historical drama Reality Women's History Month Spectrum Originals unscripted Britbox The Witch blockbusters Avengers directors Lionsgate Winners BBC One obituary 45 GLAAD Polls and Games name the review dceu Comedy Central Disney Plus period drama Logo scary movies basketball Certified Fresh Broadway GIFs trophy Netflix Christmas movies feel good legend spanish language target scene in color Box Office aliens natural history based on movie Sundance Now kaiju dc action-comedy Universal Pictures MCU indiana jones dreamworks hist king arthur TIFF Character Guide comics true crime Spring TV 2015 Cannes wonder woman Alien anime AMC TCA 2017 ghosts Emmys Hear Us Out video on demand DC Comics Trailer Reality Competition streamig versus The Walt Disney Company Rock Nickelodeon streaming TV One TCA Shondaland SundanceTV Holidays south america video rotten Comic Book Legendary Super Bowl MTV crime thriller Vudu LGBT nature toy story Pride Month Geeked Week prank Native Christmas tv talk WarnerMedia 72 Emmy Awards marvel cinematic universe summer preview rt archives USA TV movies TV cars cancelled TV series The Purge Chilling Adventures of Sabrina series Biopics Premiere Dates finale Hallmark Christmas movies OneApp Amazon Summer what to watch Infographic Lucasfilm miniseries Podcast