Total Recall

Total Recall: Steve Buscemi's Best Movies

We count down the best-reviewed work of the Incredible Burt Wonderstone star.

by | March 14, 2013 | Comments

Steve Buscemi

He hasn’t always played the nicest characters, but both onscreen and off, Steve Buscemi has always come across as a pretty interesting person — a gifted thespian, talented director, and former firefighter who helped clear rubble from the World Trade Center after 9/11, he’s one ubiquitous character actor whose Hollywood success doesn’t seem to have turned him into anything other than a regular guy from Brooklyn. Of course, in this weekend’s The Incredible Burt Wonderstone, he’s anything but regular… which is why we decided we couldn’t miss the opportunity to dedicate a list to some of Buscemi’s best-reviewed roles. It’s time for Total Recall!


10. Living in Oblivion

Allegedly inspired by writer/director Tom DiCillo’s less-than-wonderful experiences on the set of the early Brad Pitt picture Johnny Suede, 1995’s Living in Oblivion starred Buscemi as a put-upon director whose struggles with his emotionally distraught crew (including Dermot Mulroney as the director of photography) and exasperating cast (including Catherine Keener as his difficult leading lady and James LeGros as the buffoonish, possibly Pitt-derived leading man) make it difficult for him — and the audience — to keep track of what’s illusory and what’s real. “So you wanna make a movie?” asked the Washington Post’s Hal Hinson. “Well, first, you should see Living in Oblivion, Tom DiCillo’s savagely funny satire of the world of independent filmmaking.”


9. Mystery Train

Buscemi picked up his first Independent Spirit Award nomination for his supporting work in this Jim Jarmusch anthology film consisting of three loosely connected stories — one of which found Buscemi sharing screen time with Joe Strummer, Screamin’ Jay Hawkins, and the decade’s most in-depth discussion of Lost in Space not involving Matt LeBlanc. “The three-part structure of Mystery Train is still a bit shambling and slight,” admitted Entertainment Weekly’s Chris Nashawaty, “but there’s an undeniable air of deadpan cool that permeates the film and gives it a haunting sense of place.”


8. The Messenger

One on a growing list of 21st century films about American war that American audiences have largely ignored, 2009’s The Messenger takes the mounting costs of our conflicts and gives them unforgettably human faces — including Will Montgomery and Tony Stone (played by Ben Foster and Woody Harrelson, who received a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination) as soldiers tasked with delivering casualty notifications to survivors, and Steve Buscemi as a father whose awful grief helps lend the film its gut-punching power before giving it an unexpected twist. “This is a wholly different look at the fallout of the Iraq War and its effect on soldiers and civilians,” offered USA Today’s Claudia Puig. “It is also a gentle portrait of grief, friendship and solace.”


7. Barton Fink

Generally speaking, we tend to avoid including cameos and smallish roles in these lists, but those rules are bent when it comes to actors like Buscemi, who can steal an entire movie with little more than a few moments on the screen. One of his more memorable minor parts: Chet the bellhop in Barton Fink, a barely-seen character whose friendliness to Fink (John Turturro) adds a bit of light to an oft-gloomy Coen brothers picture that uses the uneasy partnership between art and commerce as a backdrop for a surreal drama about sex, lies, and a shotgun-toting John Goodman. Calling the end result “Gnomic, claustrophobic, hallucinatory, just plain weird,” Time’s Richard Schickel lauded it as “the kind of movie critics can soak up thousands of words analyzing and cinephiles can soak up at least three espressos arguing their way through.”


6. Miller’s Crossing

The gangster drama whose stubborn script eventually prompted the desperate break that birthed Barton Fink, Miller’s Crossing blended well-worn genre formula with the Coen brothers’ signature style — and gave Steve Buscemi an early break with the brief but pivotal role of Mink Larouie, a bookie whose illicit affairs draw him into a gang war that proves deadly (giving the Coens the first of many opportunities to cause Buscemi’s on-screen death). “While Miller’s Crossing is not as messy or inspired as Martin Scorsese’s GoodFellas, or as richly suggestive as The Godfather, it accomplishes exactly what it sets out to do,” mused John Hartl for


5. In the Soup

1992 was really Buscemi’s year at Sundance — not only did he make a big splash as part of Quentin Tarantino’s Reservoir Dogs, but he was also an integral part of Alexandre Rockwell’s highly regarded In the Soup, an offbeat low-budget dramedy about a struggling screenwriter (Buscemi) who desperately teams up with a con man (Seymour Cassel) in order to find financial backing for his meandering 500-page script. Unfortunately overshadowed by some of the higher-profile festival favorites of the year, Soup remained a critical favorite for writers like Combustible Celluloid’s Jeffrey M. Anderson, who admitted, “Yes, it’s an old story that has been told a thousand times before and since, but Alexandre Rockwell’s little film has a home movie charm and a streetwise wit that make it a must-see sleeper.”


4. Ghost World

Buscemi’s ability to imbue even the most unlikable characters with some shred of humanity (think Garland Green in Con Air) has made him a favorite for directors who need someone to play a multi-dimensional cretin. A notable exception: Terry Zwigoff’s Ghost World, a bleakly funny adaptation of the Daniel Clowes comic book about a pair of teenage misfits (Scarlett Johansson and Thora Birch) whose casually mean-spirited prank on a lonely middle-aged man (Buscemi) has unforeseen consequences on their friendship. A cult and critical favorite, Ghost World resonated with scribes like Angie Errigo of Empire, who wrote, “This is ‘teen comedy’ of startling sophistication — with horribly funny bits as well. A true original, with sharp humour, subtle detail and painfully realistic characters.”


3. Fargo

After filming small-but-pivotal parts in the Coen brothers’ Miller’s Crossing and Barton Fink, Buscemi was rewarded with a role written specifically for him in their 1996 breakthrough, Fargo. A seven-time Academy Award nominee (and two-time winner) that now resides in the National Film Registry, it tells the increasingly unpleasant tale of a car dealership manager (William H. Macy) who tries to get out from under his financial woes by hiring a pair of small-time crooks (Buscemi and Peter Stormare) to kidnap his wife so he can fool his wealthy father-in-law into paying the ransom. A grisly comedy of errors ensues, with the kidnappers leaving a trail of death in their wake and a tenacious cop (Frances McDormand) in hot pursuit. “To watch it is to experience steadily mounting delight,” smiled Roger Ebert, “as you realize the filmmakers have taken enormous risks, gotten away with them and made a movie that is completely original, and as familiar as an old shoe.”


2. Reservoir Dogs

A heist movie without the heist — but with a far sharper (as well as gorier and more profane) script than most movies of its kind, Quentin Tarantino’s Reservoir Dogs helped kick off the indie film boom of the 1990s with a tightly wound, beautifully cast look at what happens when a group of really bad guys try to pull off a big score and it all goes wrong. Working with a scarily talented group of character actors, Tarantino — who was making his feature debut — made it count by giving Harvey Keitel, Tim Roth, Michael Madsen, Chris Penn, and Buscemi (as the weaselly Mr. Pink, a role Tarantino originally planned to take for himself) some of the most memorable scenes of their careers. “It’s unclear whether this macho thriller does anything to improve the state of the world or our understanding of it,” admitted the Chicago Reader’s Jonathan Rosenbaum, “but it certainly sets off enough rockets to hold and shake us for every one of its 99 minutes.”


1. Monsters, Inc.

It’s always a bit of a disappointment when an animated film ends up at the top of an actor’s Total Recall list — and we know more than a few of you think voice roles shouldn’t count at all — but if it has to happen, then it might as well be a movie as wonderful as Monsters, Inc. Starting from a rich premise (what if the monsters in your kid’s closet are real…and they’re scared too?), Pixar’s fourth feature used its universal concept as the framework for a thoughtful, ecologically conscious rumination on the journey from childhood to adulthood. Plus, it was exciting and really funny, thanks to a stellar voice cast that included Billy Crystal and John Goodman (as monster pals Mike and Sulley), James Coburn, Jennifer Tilly, and (of course) Steve Buscemi as the nasty monster Randall Boggs. It all added up to a massive box office hit — and a movie that, in the words of Melanie McFarland of the Seattle Times, acts as “A marvelous combination of lollipop visuals, brilliant screenwriting, sharp comedic timing and, above all, overflowing amounts of heart.”

In case you were wondering, here are Buscemi’s top 10 movies according to RT users’ scores:

1. Reservoir Dogs — 93%
2. The Big Lebowski — 93%
3. Fargo — 91%
4. Miller’s Crossing — 88%
5. Barton Fink — 87%
6. Mystery Train — 86%
7. Monsters, Inc. — 84%
8. Living in Oblivion — 84%
9. Ghost World — 80%
10. Desperado — 79%

Take a look through Buscemi’s complete filmography, as well as the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out the reviews for The Incredible Burt Wonderstone.


Tag Cloud

TNT Prime Video spanish language new star wars movies name the review Exclusive Video ABC Comics on TV directors 2020 critics Pop A24 superhero comics independent YA travel comic books SXSW japanese psychological thriller Television Academy Spectrum Originals indiana jones DGA Fox Searchlight Cartoon Network E3 TV Land Quiz genre a nightmare on elm street halloween romantic comedy lord of the rings legend mcc ghosts period drama President true crime reviews Grammys what to watch WGN Polls and Games thriller cars dragons natural history PaleyFest 2016 Arrowverse Discovery Channel leaderboard aapi El Rey hollywood comic book movie rt labs critics edition Fantasy game show National Geographic spider-verse Trophy Talk Mary Tyler Moore historical drama binge Esquire italian cancelled TV series Acorn TV Hallmark Funimation franchise mission: impossible See It Skip It Chernobyl cults Podcast Stephen King Turner Superheroe CBS All Access Tomatazos vs. USA reboot Paramount Network popular critic resources Spring TV The Witch Family book ID TBS CNN TruTV blaxploitation Spike Drama PlayStation werewolf adenture Hollywood Foreign Press Association APB composers Captain marvel Interview IMDb TV Trailer Rocky Elton John crossover 45 mob scene in color basketball Thanksgiving batman anime Opinion Comic-Con@Home 2021 Comedy Central nfl Mystery adaptation Character Guide rotten television Red Carpet Universal comiccon Music green book boxing MCU TLC HBO Go halloween tv ESPN Broadway 4/20 007 Set visit TV One sag awards strong female leads Paramount Neflix Columbia Pictures 79th Golden Globes Awards blockbusters venice YouTube Premium deadpool game of thrones Sneak Peek Mary Poppins Returns Tarantino crime marvel cinematic universe TCA Awards gangster child's play Legendary spinoff X-Men children's TV Marvel dceu Freeform emmy awards comic 99% rt labs IFC Comic Book christmas movies Teen Winners biography Cosplay facebook foreign 73rd Emmy Awards RT21 black hispanic cats trailers boxoffice biopic VOD Paramount Plus posters cops DC Comics FXX ABC Signature crime drama documentaries First Reviews know your critic 2015 CMT dark Disney+ Disney Plus Valentine's Day versus Sony Pictures universal monsters Trivia FX Epix Lifetime dc Nat Geo Biopics 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Pride Month Rocketman Warner Bros. hidden camera kids The Purge justice league Apple TV+ CW Seed best stand-up comedy Action E! worst TV movies sequel The Walking Dead black comedy crime thriller Anna Paquin scary movies TCA 2017 OneApp spider-man psycho YouTube Syfy indie space Animation FX on Hulu series kaiju women feel good satire godzilla Creative Arts Emmys science fiction Universal Pictures australia Extras 71st Emmy Awards debate RT History Watching Series Crackle docuseries SDCC Brie Larson First Look cooking harry potter 2017 Marathons fresh stop motion BET Awards hist Adult Swim mutant young adult Kids & Family HBO Sundance docudrama french marvel comics Best and Worst USA Network trophy GLAAD 20th Century Fox A&E Disney Channel Ghostbusters 2021 Toys teaser Disney Plus Summer movies American Society of Cinematographers Marvel Studios cancelled television NBC renewed TV shows art house superman golden globes scorecard Shondaland blockbuster Amazon Prime Video Image Comics Women's History Month action-comedy Netflix HBO Max festivals LGBT Ovation finale slasher Box Office joker cancelled Amazon Prime Super Bowl prank dramedy Martial Arts YouTube Red Peacock DC streaming service Alien rt archives 2018 ViacomCBS rotten movies we love TV renewals Heroines Mudbound New York Comic Con Rock Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt canceled TV shows films Song of Ice and Fire dogs Pacific Islander screen actors guild kong olympics San Diego Comic-Con Disney stoner Infographic cartoon Fox News japan Film TIFF Marvel Television richard e. Grant Walt Disney Pictures Lucasfilm Musicals zombies asian-american WarnerMedia casting SundanceTV revenge VICE cancelled TV shows wonder woman The Arrangement theme song Dark Horse Comics king arthur Star Trek ratings fast and furious 72 Emmy Awards heist movie Countdown technology Instagram Live Wes Anderson Food Network Holiday Western BAFTA GIFs Pop TV The Academy Mary poppins LGBTQ Avengers Awards Photos sports Schedule obituary cinemax Showtime remakes jamie lee curtis serial killer History Logo Classic Film Hulu BBC One award winner Country FOX Christmas politics sopranos Sci-Fi social media high school Comedy new zealand elevated horror golden globe awards medical drama diversity video Britbox Mindy Kaling concert TV AMC Plus breaking bad Pirates Starz Crunchyroll mockumentary Hear Us Out zombie Superheroes comedies Certified Fresh Election Amazon Studios classics spy thriller war Black Mirror Ellie Kemper AMC TCA Holidays witnail festival sitcom worst movies Sundance Now CBS disaster BET pirates of the caribbean james bond Film Festival robots Awards Tour PBS Masterpiece toy story rom-coms Apple TV Plus comic book movies police drama jurassic park singing competition Winter TV Black History Month BBC America Lionsgate Bravo Netflix Christmas movies ITV talk show live action screenings Binge Guide latino news suspense dexter Tubi royal family international Vudu Sundance TV supernatural Writers Guild of America OWN Disney streaming service anthology Tags: Comedy twilight archives chucky Reality Competition Reality Lifetime Christmas movies streaming dreamworks Nominations Tokyo Olympics criterion miniseries monster movies Baby Yoda zero dark thirty 1990s saw DirecTV MSNBC movie doctor who transformers sequels 93rd Oscars 24 frames Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Endgame target Shudder Hallmark Christmas movies razzies die hard documentary free movies 21st Century Fox Pixar DC Universe Academy Awards telelvision ABC Family football quibi animated toronto nature Fall TV Oscars new york Rom-Com Horror BBC adventure discovery Star Wars parents scary Emmy Nominations spain 2019 south america Turner Classic Movies spanish HFPA laika Video Games video on demand live event VH1 Emmys nbcuniversal TCM tv talk all-time vampires The CW The Walt Disney Company Year in Review TCA Winter 2020 MTV king kong NBA Television Critics Association Calendar NYCC slashers hispanic heritage month Tumblr Premiere Dates IFC Films GoT Apple Amazon book adaptation canceled Pet Sematary Travel Channel Musical streaming movies romance 90s political drama Fargo based on movie aliens unscripted Nickelodeon Cannes