Total Recall

Total Recall: RT Celebrates the Bill of Rights

This Independence Day, we count down your 10 favorite amendments -- with a cinematic twist.

by and | July 2, 2008 | Comments

We the people of Rotten Tomatoes, in order to make this Independence Day more perfect, do ordain and establish this Total Recall as a cinematic tribute to the Bill of Rights.

Independence Day is a time to reflect on the history of our country, and what makes our nation unique. A good place to start is the Bill of Rights, the original 10 amendments to the Constitution, which provide Americans such essential freedoms as self-expression, the right to a fair trial, and the limits of governmental powers against U.S. citizens. However, since we don’t want to dish out a bone-dry history lesson in this festive season, we’ve compiled a list that puts each amendment in a cinematic context, with plenty of car chases, titillation, and shootouts. In other words, just what you expect on the Fourth of July: fireworks.

more info…
The First Amendment: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

The People Vs. Larry Flynt (1996, 87 percent)
One of the most profoundly important aspects of the First Amendment is that it protects unpopular — and offensive — speech. Fans of good taste found much to dislike in the oeuvre of Hustler publisher Larry Flynt. However, when Evangelist Jerry Falwell saw a fake liquor ad in Flynt’s skin mag that claimed the reverend had had a romantic entanglement with his mother in an outhouse, he sued for emotional distress. The Supreme Court ultimately ruled that, being a public figure, Falwell could not claim to be distressed by what was an obvious parody. As Flynt (played by Woody Harrelson) succinctly puts it, “If the First Amendment will protect a scumbag like me, it will protect all of you.”


more info…
The Second Amendment: A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the People to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

Death Wish (1974, 74 percent)
Second Amendment proponents feel that guns in the hands of private citizens can prevent crime. Perhaps if Paul Kersey’s (Charles Bronson) wife and daughter had a sidearm in the house when it was invaded by three street punks, they’d be alive and/or well. The ruthless attack takes its toll on Kersey, who becomes a well-regulated militia of one — perhaps not what the framers had in mind, but an effective crime-fighting force nonetheless. However, legal scholars could successfully argue that one-man vigilante campaigns at very least violate the Sixth and Ninth Amendments.



more info…
The Third Amendment: No Soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any house, without the consent of the Owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law.Cops and Robbersons (1994, 17 percent)
Smarting from the failure of his quickly-canceled Fox talk show, Chevy Chase reunited with his Fletch director, Michael Ritchie, for Cops and Robbersons, a comedy about a tough-as-nails cop (Jack Palance, natch) who moves in with a suburban family in order to nab the crook living next door (Robert Davi). That the movie’s premise could be accused of playing fast and loose with our friendly Third Amendment was of little importance to critics — they had their hands full pointing out flaws in the direction, screenplay, and performances from the cast. Cops and Robbersons made more than one viewer wish we had an amendment forcing Chevy Chase to choose better scripts.

more info…

The Fourth Amendment: The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.

Training Day (2001, 71 percent)

Alonzo Harris (Denzel Washington) is certainly no card-carrying member of the ACLU. If he was, he wouldn’t be acting in such blatant violation of the Fourth Amendment, which prevents illegal search and seizure without a warrant. During the course of a particularly wild 24 hours on the beat, Harris steals money from not one, but two drug dealers. Washington picked up a Best Actor Oscar for his terrific performance, but if this was the real world, he’d be heaped with scorn from civil libertarians.

more info…

The Fifth Amendment: No person shall be held to answer for any capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.

The Godfather, Part 2 (1974, 98 percent)

In The Godfather Part 2, a senate subcommittee conducts an open hearing into the alleged illegal activities of the Corleone family. It would seem like the perfect time for Michael (Al Pacino) to invoke the Fifth Amendment and preserve his right to not incriminate himself. However, Michael didn’t get to the top of the criminal world by being a dummy, and his knowledge of the Constitution is particularly astute. “I have not taken refuge behind the Fifth Amendment although it is my right to do so,” he tells the Senate, before evoking the Sixth Amendment. “I challenge this committee to produce any witness or evidence against me.” The government’s case falls apart, and Michael eventually violates his brother Fredo’s Sixth Amendment rights by exercising his Second Amendment rights.

more info…

The Sixth Amendment: In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district where in the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defense.

12 Angry Men (1957, 100 percent)

Sidney Lumet‘s terrific debut is more than a compelling drama — it’s also a terrific civics lesson. Featuring an all-star cast, this Oscar-nominated classic follows the deliberations of a jury in a capital murder trial; one of the jurors (Henry Fonda) tries to convince the rest to overcome their prejudices against the defendant — a teenage boy from the wrong side of the tracks — and deliver a fair verdict. As 12 Angry Men proves, a trial by jury can be pretty messy — but it sure beats the Star Chamber.

more info…
The Seventh Amendment: In Suits at common law, where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved, and no fact tried by a jury, shall be otherwise reexamined in any Court of the United States, than according to the rules of the common law.The Verdict (1982, 96 percent)

Kind of a mouthful, isn’t it? Don’t worry — all that founding fathers-speak in the Seventh Amendment just boils down to one simple thing: The right to a civil trial by jury. The Verdict provides what is widely regarded as cinema’s most elegant defense of this right, and for good reason — it was scripted by David Mamet, directed by Sidney Lumet, and starred Paul Newman in one of his most finely nuanced (and most riveting) performances as a washed-up, alcoholic lawyer who finds redemption through his pursuit of a medical malpractice lawsuit that bore a strong similarity to the Karen Ann Quinlan case. Law scholars have been quick to point out that The Verdict hinges on developments that strain credulity, but the critics didn’t care — it’s one of Newman’s best-reviewed films.

more info…
The Eighth Amendment: Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted. The Shawshank Redemption (1994, 88 percent)
It routinely pops up on “Best Movies” lists and is widely regarded as a classic – in fact, Frank Darabont‘s career-launching adaptation of Stephen King‘s The Shawshank Redemption is so beloved, it’s easy to forget that during its theatrical release, the film barely earned enough to cover its $25 million budget. No one could argue that Andy Dufresne, the unjustly imprisoned banker played by Tim Robbins, isn’t subjected to “cruel and unusual punishment” — but that’s a big part of what makes him a hero we can’t help but root for. Of course, not every member of the prison population is as pure of heart as Andy or his friends — and yes, this is only fiction — but The Shawshank Redemption still provides a glimpse of life without the Bill of Rights that’s as sobering as it is entertaining.

more info…
The Ninth Amendment: The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.Enemy of the State (1998, 71 percent)

The framers of the Constitution weren’t dummies — they knew that by spelling out the citizens’ rights upheld in these amendments, they might be encouraging the idea that any rights not specifically mentioned didn’t exist, so they gave themselves the Ninth Amendment as a loophole — basically saying that just because you don’t read something here, it doesn’t mean the government has carte blanche to do whatever it wants. This amendment comes in handy for Chris Gardner, the labor lawyer played by Will Smith in Enemy of the State, when he discovers he’s being framed by government agents for a crime he didn’t commit. To accomplish their nefarious goals, these agents resort to all sorts of dirty tricks — planting bugs, having Gardner’s credit cards canceled, even tricking his wife into thinking he’s been having an affair. A beautifully shot ode to the paranoid, Enemy made oodles of cash at the box office.

more info…
The Tenth Amendment: The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
Smokey and the Bandit (1977, 76 percent)

Yes, it’s the ever-popular “states’ rights” amendment — and in this case, those rights meant that, in the late 1970s, transporting liquor past the east Texas border was considered bootlegging, which is why the wealthy Big Enos Burdette (played by Pat McCormick) had to offer an $80,000 reward to infamous trucker Bo “Bandit” Darville (Burt Reynolds) in order to get him to bring 400 cases of Coors to Georgia. Considering that Smokey and the Bandit went on to become the second highest-grossing film of 1977 (outdone only by Star Wars) and spawn a pair of sequels, not to mention inspiring The Dukes of Hazzard, it’s interesting to note that director Hal Needham had to fight tooth and nail to get Bandit made — it wasn’t until his pal Reynolds stepped in that the studios came knocking. The results were unquestionably lowbrow, but the critics didn’t mind.


And finally, for those of you who need a primer on the Bill of Rights, we present you with this:

Check out past editions of Total Recall in our column archives.

Tag Cloud

crime thriller 45 dark worst Video Games The CW razzies Mystery Nominations 2020 BBC America Country Nickelodeon Academy Awards action-comedy trailers Prime Video chucky ghosts Warner Bros. cancelled TV shows Reality women Apple TV Plus DC streaming service revenge vs. Super Bowl VOD scary movies Musicals ABC Family BET stand-up comedy docudrama Bravo Amazon Studios medical drama USA Network Grammys based on movie FOX Toys 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards dogs ViacomCBS Certified Fresh aapi Alien Pop TV TV One spain Opinion olympics Stephen King Turner Classic Movies black SundanceTV Oscars best sopranos Epix sequel politics Comic-Con@Home 2021 Fall TV space robots Paramount Network french cults adaptation OWN Tarantino Rom-Com Sneak Peek Christmas Holiday Star Trek casting science fiction biopic ITV Trophy Talk See It Skip It spinoff anthology legend Film Festival Columbia Pictures BAFTA Mary poppins Netflix reviews 2021 Fargo Mary Tyler Moore talk show Dark Horse Comics Paramount Plus rt labs critics edition 007 TCM comedies indie superman Lionsgate children's TV YouTube Comedy Central Holidays CNN Emmy Nominations binge Black Mirror romantic comedy debate zombie HFPA halloween tv MTV Box Office TCA Winter 2020 Fantasy south america IFC Films SDCC Disney PlayStation sag awards critic resources know your critic festivals die hard comic travel Universal FX on Hulu boxing singing competition police drama LGBT CMT kong leaderboard Comics on TV TV Land social media streaming Adult Swim serial killer Apple TV+ HBO Max Cannes streaming movies fresh discovery theme song richard e. Grant versus dramedy Sundance Now Spike Martial Arts Marvel Studios game show RT21 miniseries canceled NBA dreamworks 2016 Pacific Islander genre Showtime joker cancelled television Tags: Comedy Western WarnerMedia SXSW GoT Brie Larson Freeform series Disney Channel Shudder witnail ESPN Creative Arts Emmys Exclusive Video trophy DirecTV mutant political drama Fox Searchlight 2015 vampires romance stop motion Elton John Spring TV suspense Instagram Live Music Black History Month sequels zero dark thirty hist classics art house video on demand American Society of Cinematographers biography Women's History Month true crime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Turner Baby Yoda Amazon Crackle facebook Disney streaming service Awards Tour Star Wars Wes Anderson ratings pirates of the caribbean Tokyo Olympics 79th Golden Globes Awards Peacock HBO marvel comics godzilla mockumentary scorecard latino San Diego Comic-Con ABC Signature Ellie Kemper The Witch black comedy Captain marvel Travel Channel teaser psychological thriller AMC Hear Us Out GIFs sports target Mindy Kaling 90s Summer Action quibi jamie lee curtis what to watch new york Writers Guild of America Ghostbusters jurassic park Tubi comic book movie OneApp Apple 20th Century Fox sitcom ID dragons video GLAAD adenture Family aliens venice golden globe awards TruTV kaiju nfl USA composers Sci-Fi 24 frames Cartoon Network documentaries universal monsters parents anime Image Comics Rocky FXX archives Rocketman Hulu Paramount Shondaland Countdown hispanic heritage month comic book movies werewolf Britbox twilight italian Rock CW Seed Disney Plus TV E! foreign The Walking Dead Marvel cinemax Tomatazos natural history blockbusters Teen superhero screen actors guild transformers free movies The Walt Disney Company high school Premiere Dates finale new zealand Syfy asian-american football The Purge Food Network Hollywood Foreign Press Association TCA Awards popular Lifetime Christmas movies TV renewals Amazon Prime Video Hallmark Christmas movies justice league Red Carpet Sundance posters hispanic RT History feel good award winner 4/20 Hallmark Sony Pictures Election telelvision slasher breaking bad PaleyFest psycho independent Marathons a nightmare on elm street james bond Biopics Mudbound Legendary A24 BBC CBS All Access Cosplay dc docuseries The Academy new star wars movies Trivia supernatural HBO Go Watching Series war Arrowverse Awards royal family prank Acorn TV Emmys History rom-coms comic books MSNBC news BBC One Schedule 1990s japan heist movie LGBTQ Quiz movies technology marvel cinematic universe Tumblr NBC Photos Animation Song of Ice and Fire reboot Starz YA king kong Best and Worst films disaster Neflix Television Academy Lucasfilm live event IMDb TV diversity Drama Lifetime blockbuster Calendar historical drama YouTube Premium laika The Arrangement FX japanese christmas movies Esquire Mary Poppins Returns cops E3 stoner zombies blaxploitation mcc monster movies comiccon 2019 Television Critics Association gangster TIFF Musical VH1 basketball ABC canceled TV shows Kids & Family name the review Horror book adaptation Heroines 2017 cars rotten child's play slashers young adult Pixar crime drama spy thriller unscripted book 93rd Oscars Funimation critics elevated horror Endgame Reality Competition Trailer nbcuniversal TBS Binge Guide australia satire Anna Paquin movie 72 Emmy Awards Walt Disney Pictures scary Pet Sematary mob National Geographic TNT Classic Film rt labs Broadway mission: impossible NYCC Ovation hidden camera golden globes crime APB scene in color tv talk fast and furious Winter TV directors DGA Chilling Adventures of Sabrina DC Comics Podcast PBS emmy awards TCA 2017 Comic Book indiana jones cooking WGN strong female leads Winners Universal Pictures television First Reviews Polls and Games CBS DC Universe batman Discovery Channel screenings doctor who cats Avengers toronto spanish Disney+ Disney Plus green book festival Infographic remakes cancelled Masterpiece period drama spider-man spanish language A&E cartoon live action Character Guide thriller lord of the rings Spectrum Originals documentary TCA deadpool Film Pride Month halloween animated X-Men franchise President IFC Fox News all-time adventure toy story New York Comic Con Valentine's Day Comedy saw Pirates kids rt archives spider-verse king arthur cancelled TV series criterion Netflix Christmas movies game of thrones rotten movies we love nature Superheroe obituary TLC hollywood renewed TV shows Marvel Television BET Awards Vudu Interview YouTube Red AMC Plus boxoffice Amazon Prime Pop harry potter Nat Geo 73rd Emmy Awards VICE Logo MCU crossover international dexter Extras 2018 Set visit Crunchyroll 71st Emmy Awards Chernobyl Sundance TV concert TV movies Superheroes worst movies comics El Rey Thanksgiving Year in Review wonder woman 21st Century Fox 99% First Look dceu