Total Recall

Reese Witherspoon's 10 Best Movies

We look at the ten best-reviewed films of the Hot Pursuit star.

by | May 6, 2015 | Comments

She’s one of the highest-paid stars in Hollywood, with dozens of films to her credit and a lifetime box office gross total topping a billion dollars — and this weekend, Reese Witherspoon will add to that impressive sum with Hot Pursuit, an action comedy pairing her with Sofia Vergara. To celebrate Reese’s return to the big screen, as well as a terrific 2014 that included her Oscar-nominated work in Wild as well as a small supporting appearance in Inherent Vice, we decided to dedicate this week’s Total Recall to an appreciative look back at some of her best-reviewed releases.

10. LEGALLY BLONDE (2001) 68%

Critics tend to vilify the romantic comedy, but it’s an undeniable rite of passage for twentysomething actresses in Hollywood, and with 2001’s Legally Blonde, Witherspoon managed to enjoy the perks of the genre (such as the pay raise that comes with toplining a $141 million smash hit) without succumbing to its worst pitfalls (including dreadful scripts and scathing reviews). While Legally Blonde is far from groundbreaking, and its plot hinges on any number of silly contrivances, it’s never less than likable — largely thanks to a magnetic performance from its talented leading lady. In the words of Entertainment Weekly’s Lisa Schwarzbaum, “As an actor of distinction who’s all of 25, Reese Witherspoon reveals interesting dark roots even as she plays golden girls.”


9. MONSTERS VS. ALIENS (2009) 72%

In real life, Reese Witherspoon is a hair under five feet, two inches tall, which might be why the idea of playing a freakishly tall woman nicknamed “Ginormica” appealed to her — or maybe it was just the chance to score one of those cushy voice acting gigs that all the major celebrities seem to get these days. Either way, the result was Monsters vs. Aliens, Witherspoon’s only film of 2009 and a $381 million 3D hit for DreamWorks Animation. Alongside the famous voices of Seth Rogen, Kiefer Sutherland, Steven Colbert, Rainn Wilson, Will Arnett, and others, Witherspoon helped wreak family-friendly cartoon havoc — and helped earn praise from critics like the Houston Chronicle’s Amy Biancolli, who wrote, “True, the story doesn’t amount to much, but the plot tends to take a back seat when you’ve got a not-quite-50-foot version of Reese Witherspoon duking it out with a mighty alien robot alongside the Golden Gate Bridge.”


8. FREEWAY (1996) 76%

She’d made a few movies by the mid-’90s, but it was Reese Witherspoon’s work in 1996’s Freeway that really made critics sit up and take notice. At the center of this modern take on Red Riding Hood, playing a juvenile delinquent whose trip to her grandmother’s house is impeded by a wolfish sexual predator (Kiefer Sutherland), she essentially used her smoldering performance as a challenge, daring viewers to look away. It was a challenge unmet by many critics, including the Cincinnati Enquirer’s Margaret A. McGurk, who wrote, “I didn’t particularly want to like Freeway, but I couldn’t help myself. Reese Witherspoon made me.”


7. WALK THE LINE (2005) 82%

Witherspoon joined the ranks of Oscar-winning leading ladies for her sensitive portrayal of June Carter Cash in this Johnny Cash biopic, which follows the early years of the Man in Black (played by Joaquin Phoenix), including the beginning of his career and the romance that would endure through more than four decades of his life. One of the year’s biggest hits and a five-time Academy Award nominee, Walk the Line wasn’t without its concessions to Hollywood formula — or without its critics, including Cash’s daughter Rosanne — but most scribes had plenty of praise for the film, including Andrew Sarris of the New York Observer, who wrote, “I advise you catch up with Walk the Line, if only for Ms. Witherspoon’s transcendent joyousness as a still-growing legend within a legend.”


6. PLEASANTVILLE (1998) 85%

Gary Ross’ Pleasantville could easily have been nothing more than a gentle, simple satire about the way nostalgia changes our memories, but beneath the surface of the story — which sends a pair of squabbling modern teens (played by Witherspoon and Tobey Maguire) into the world of a 1950s sitcom — there’s some thoughtful commentary on civil rights and the cruelly arbitrary ways society can oppress those who don’t fit in. Pleasantville wasn’t a blockbuster hit, but it earned some of the best reviews of the year from critics like Louis B. Hobson of Jam! Movies, who wrote, “This wondrous little fable is a cross between The Truman Show and Back to the Future — and it’s better than both.”


5. THE GOOD LIE (2014) 88%

Befitting its title, The Good Lie practiced a bit of well-meaning subterfuge with its marketing materials, selling this fact-based drama about the American lives of Sudanese refugees once known as “lost boys” by putting Witherspoon’s face front and center on the poster. But if her character — a Kansas City settlement worker given the life-altering task of helping her charges adjust to their new environment — isn’t truly central to the story, her performance remains a solid anchor in a film whose ingredients run the gamut from Hollywood gloss to real-life horror. “This is very much a mainstream movie meant to shine a light on the plight of people who were ignored for too long,” wrote the Arizona Republic’s Bill Goodykoontz. “For that reason alone, it’s well worth seeing.”


4. THE MAN IN THE MOON (1991) 89%

For her first film, Witherspoon found herself in good company, including director Robert Mulligan (concluding a career that included To Kill a Mockingbird and Summer of ’42) and co-stars Sam Waterston and Tess Harper. But in this sweet coming-of-age drama, it’s Witherspoon’s character that largely drives the story, and she carried the film with an assured performance that belied her youth and lack of experience. Man in the Moon “gets an outstandingly natural performance out of Miss Witherspoon, who has no trouble carrying a lot of the film single-handedly,” wrote Janet Maslin for the New York Times. “It falls to her to remind the audience that this story is at heart about a family, and she does.”


3. WILD (2014) 90%

The sort of physically and dramatically demanding role that an actor can spend an entire career waiting to score, Wild gave Witherspoon the opportunity to shoulder an entire film pretty much on her own — and she more than delivered, bringing Cheryl Strayed’s unflinching memoir to the screen with a suitably fierce drama (directed by Jean-Marc Vallée from a screenplay by Nick Hornby) that takes viewers on a harrowing hike along the Pacific Crest Trail while reliving key moments from its protagonist’s bumpy past. At the forefront of it all are solid performances from Witherspoon and Laura Dern, both of whom picked up Oscar nominations for their efforts. As Mick LaSalle wrote for the San Francisco Chronicle, “This pensive, reflective, complicated Witherspoon feels more real than the one she left behind — and more in keeping with how she started, in hard-hitting independent movies 20 years ago.”


2. ELECTION (1999) 92%

It takes a special type of young actress to embody a character who is both seductive enough to destroy one high school teacher’s career and irritating enough to turn another teacher into an election-fixing madman — and that’s exactly what Witherspoon did as Election‘s Tracy Flick, the overachieving senior whose steamrolling campaign for student body president inspires one of her teachers (Matthew Broderick) to take desperate measures to keep her out of office. Critics expected great things from writer/director Alexander Payne after 1996’s Citizen Ruth, and Election delivered — and it also helped cement Witherspoon’s burgeoning reputation, thanks to reviews from critics like CNN’s Paul Clinton, who wrote, “Reese Witherspoon is proving to be one of the most versatile actresses of her generation.”


1. MUD (2013) 98%

Just when it seemed like she might be forever doomed to a lifetime of romantic comedies like Four Christmases and This Means War, Witherspoon turned up next to her fellow rom-com refugee Matthew McConaughey in 2013’s Mud — and although he received much of the movie’s accolades for one of the roles that helped spark his so-called “McConaissance,” there really are no false notes or out-of-place performances in writer-director Jeff Nichols’ tale of a mysterious man who claims to be on the run from bounty hunters and desperate to flee with the love of his life. Calling it “More than a mere tribute to Twain and Dickens,” the Vine’s Alice Tynan wrote, “This has all the makings of a modern classic.”

Tag Cloud

franchise Classic Film Box Office directors justice league USA Network robots fast and furious hispanic Comic Book screenings 4/20 ABC Family animated parents independent The Witch The Purge Film Festival Food Network Ellie Kemper Cosplay Esquire documentary documentaries cancelled television boxoffice Podcast Video Games transformers Teen Marvel Studios HBO chucky werewolf 72 Emmy Awards 21st Century Fox crossover 2015 cartoon golden globes social media Black History Month mission: impossible Captain marvel Summer Arrowverse witnail CW Seed MCU obituary Election superhero Television Academy Certified Fresh video on demand FX The CW elevated horror Martial Arts Turner Classic Movies scary movies WarnerMedia Lifetime Vudu Emmy Nominations Disney+ Disney Plus comiccon Spring TV Tarantino Action Kids & Family The Arrangement child's play DGA TV Land Comics on TV spanish language Spectrum Originals south america 24 frames halloween tv talk YouTube BBC Set visit casting 2019 cancelled TV series Hallmark spy thriller cars best reviews VH1 Lionsgate comics MTV RT History TCM IFC Films finale supernatural war Bravo Winners Reality Competition Pixar Rock medical drama Mary Tyler Moore CNN ITV Winter TV game show game of thrones Spike Star Trek television Funimation Apple TV Plus 2017 DC streaming service WGN Premiere Dates Extras Musicals Marvel Television Logo classics book FXX rotten Anna Paquin A24 miniseries Character Guide 007 Pirates Dark Horse Comics Peacock christmas movies mockumentary AMC cancelled TCA Winter 2020 Trophy Talk Crunchyroll series worst video Nat Geo criterion YouTube Premium stand-up comedy adaptation Superheroe discovery Holiday DirecTV Nominations sag awards crime Pride Month true crime travel vampires universal monsters jamie lee curtis teaser VICE harry potter Song of Ice and Fire psycho HBO Go Thanksgiving Superheroes sports comic critics TV Rom-Com cults Horror what to watch Quiz based on movie CBS All Access composers joker toy story biography Red Carpet TV renewals Women's History Month FOX Drama Creative Arts Emmys laika Calendar APB SundanceTV Holidays serial killer space dragons Showtime Warner Bros. sitcom Year in Review Brie Larson BET Awards Pet Sematary reboot stop motion Columbia Pictures thriller Mindy Kaling CBS GIFs Oscars canceled TV shows dogs Star Wars nature Cartoon Network Avengers anthology talk show Countdown Chernobyl satire ratings disaster Lucasfilm richard e. Grant zombie Universal President name the review LGBTQ Mary poppins Discovery Channel A&E TCA 2017 kids dceu Marathons Interview SDCC BBC One Television Critics Association Fox News spider-man Awards Tour CMT Paramount historical drama First Look concert ABC Netflix RT21 PaleyFest revenge indiana jones cooking mutant science fiction LGBT streaming Animation OWN 20th Century Fox MSNBC Hallmark Christmas movies Christmas TLC psychological thriller cancelled TV shows foreign Paramount Network Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Lifetime Christmas movies Masterpiece YouTube Red 45 2016 El Rey Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt canceled Amazon police drama movies DC Universe Pop TV History Baby Yoda romantic comedy facebook dc HBO Max technology diversity Ovation Amazon Prime latino romance NYCC cops stoner Turner NBC Best and Worst natural history Binge Guide OneApp Tomatazos Opinion Photos asian-american Mystery aliens Epix strong female leads Country die hard Netflix Christmas movies rotten movies we love twilight Super Bowl BET news Mudbound hollywood Sony Pictures dark binge SXSW PBS Ghostbusters Musical Black Mirror blockbuster nbcuniversal singing competition ghosts Mary Poppins Returns Fall TV Rocketman Writers Guild of America slashers See It Skip It Comedy Fantasy green book TCA Awards political drama Sundance TV Amazon Prime Video GoT spinoff movie Disney Plus PlayStation IFC E3 Schedule Pop TruTV Marvel Crackle indie Cannes dramedy renewed TV shows Toys breaking bad Family batman Valentine's Day TIFF comedies Disney Syfy BAFTA E! Travel Channel docudrama Apple Hear Us Out zombies TCA BBC America Sundance Stephen King Endgame Music period drama Tubi Hulu San Diego Comic-Con award winner Western Freeform Sci-Fi Film GLAAD crime thriller Apple TV+ hist festivals Academy Awards adventure The Walking Dead versus free movies Infographic American Society of Cinematographers cinemax National Geographic theme song zero dark thirty Britbox Adult Swim Awards crime drama Amazon Studios Polls and Games 2020 Sundance Now Disney streaming service X-Men Nickelodeon Shudder Elton John Trivia Starz cats TNT Rocky 2018 Biopics films anime Watching Series 71st Emmy Awards screen actors guild TBS USA Walt Disney Pictures Sneak Peek Acorn TV Heroines unscripted Reality all-time Disney Channel First Reviews a nightmare on elm street Shondaland Emmys children's TV Trailer blaxploitation quibi DC Comics Grammys Comedy Central ESPN doctor who sequel spain Tumblr FX on Hulu VOD YA politics emmy awards New York Comic Con