Total Recall

Total Recall: Liars, Hoaxers, and Frauds

With The Words hitting theaters this week, we run down some noteworthy films featuring imposters and fabulists.

by | September 6, 2012 | Comments


Liars and Hoaxers

In this weekend’s The Words, Bradley Cooper plays a struggling young writer who stumbles across a terrific unpublished manuscript and makes the fateful decision to pass it off as his own — an impulsively dishonest act that brings him the career success he’s dreamed of, but triggers major consequences along the way. Of course, Cooper’s character isn’t the first to pretend to be something he isn’t — and with that in mind, we decided to dedicate this week’s list to some of the many noteworthy plagiarists, imposters, liars, and frauds from films of the past. Lock up your valuables and don’t believe everything you’re told, because it’s time for Total Recall!

Catch Me if You Can


In his long and incredible career as a master fraud and forger, Frank W. Abagnale Jr. managed to pass himself off as a teacher, doctor, lawyer, and airplane pilot — and pass millions of dollars in phony checks while he was at it. It’s the kind of story that could play as a horribly sad drama, but with Catch Me if You Can, Steven Spielberg used it as the basis for a light (and thoroughly entertaining) caper in which Abagnale (played by Leonardo DiCaprio) dashes from con to con while striking up a bizarre long-distance friendship with the FBI agent who’s doggedly pursuing him (Tom Hanks). The end result, wrote John Anderson for Newsday, is “A very adult, very funny, very well-acted daydream that should delight just about anyone who’s ever been asked for picture ID.”

The Hoax


A sort of spiritual cousin to this week’s big movie, The Hoax dramatizes the real-life adventures of struggling author Clifford Irving, who cooked up an audacious million-dollar scheme to pass off his own forgeries as the authorized memoirs of reclusive billionaire Howard Hughes. It sounds like a ridiculous way to get yourself sent to prison rather than the basis for a Richard Gere movie, but Irving almost pulled it off — and that’s what makes The Hoax such gripping stuff. Saying it “never wanders too far from its pitiful but somehow joyously deceitful center,” Tom Long of the Detroit News applauded Gere for capturing “the sheer electricity of a man who, even for only a few moments, seems to have made reality play by his rules.”

The Imposter


Some of the best documentaries are the ones that persuasively demonstrate that truth really can be stranger than fiction. Case in point: The Imposter, which details the unsettling tale of Frédéric Bourdin, the French con man who impersonated a missing 13-year-old boy and went to live with his family, despite a number of telling differences between them. Bourdin was eventually forced to confess, thanks to the dogged efforts of a private investigator, but that’s only one dark chapter in a terribly disturbing — and still unsolved — true story. “The Imposter emerges as a brilliantly slippery film that demands brain-stretching consideration. Astonishing, indeed,” wrote the Irish Times’ admiring Donald Clarke.

Just One of the Guys


Good journalists stop at nothing to get their big scoop — even if they happen to be high school students, and researching the story means illicitly transferring to a new campus and pretending to be a boy. Witness Just One of the Guys, the mid-1980s teen cross-dressing comedy starring Joyce Hyser and an eclectic supporting cast that included Ayre Gross, Sherilyn Fenn, and — as was required by law in 1985 — Billy Zabka. While many critics thought Guys was too shallow and unbelievable to prove its own point, others were too busy yukking it up to care — like Nikki Tranter of PopMatters, who wrote, “Just One of the Guys is worth repeated viewing, especially for Hyser’s hilarious and charismatic performance.”

Mata Hari


Whether she was truly a German spy who caused the death of more than 50,000 soldiers or simply an exotic dancer who attracted the wrong kind of attention is still up for scholarly debate — but either way, Mata Hari’s story is a fascinating one, and it proved solid grist for this loose biopic, which made a million dollars in 1931 and ultimately proved to be Greta Garbo’s signature film. “Miss Garbo may not be any more like Mata Hari, whose real name was Margaret Zelle MacLeod, than the film narrative is like an authentic account of the spy’s career,” admitted Mordaunt Hall of the New York Times. “There is, however, in the skillfully arranged series of incidents enough truth to make a most compelling melodrama.”


The Music Man


The film world has certainly seen more daring cons than the one attempted by “Professor” Harold Hill (Robert Preston) in The Music Man, but we’d argue that none of them were as persuasively soundtracked — which is only fitting, given this Broadway adaptation’s storyline about a flimflam artist who strolls into a small Iowa town with the intention of tricking the residents into bankrolling a junior marching band. Of course, Hill has a change of heart by the third act, due to the feminine wiles of the town’s comely librarian (Shirley Jones), but even if his schemes were all for naught, the movie stole the hearts of critics like Time Out’s Geoff Andrew, who lauded its soundtrack “full of standards” and called the film “endowed with a warming nostalgia for old-fashioned ways.”

The Secret of My Success


With Michael J. Fox on the poster and Night Ranger on the soundtrack, The Secret of My Success was a quintessentially 1980s film even before the first frame was screened; the fact that its plot happened to revolve around a young mailroom employee (Fox) who impersonates his way up the corporate ladder just in time to save the company and find true love (with Helen “Supergirl” Slater) was just a bonus. Like a lot of the decade’s business-themed comedies, Success was burdened with mixed messages — it tried to lampoon corporate skullduggery while suggesting that overweening career ambition justifies pretty much any amount of fraud — but under all those synths and snappy blazers, it was really just another good old-fashioned comedy from director Herbert Ross. “The movie builds up a lot of good will early on, which is needed when the time comes to resolve its farcical complications,” admitted a begrudging Vincent Canby for the New York Times.

Shattered Glass


He may not have earned many raves for his performance as the petulant Anakin Skywalker of the Star Wars prequels, but Hayden Christensen proved his acting mettle with Shattered Glass, a biopic about Stephen Glass, the disgraced former New Republic writer whose journalism career came to an ignominious end after he was caught fabricating chunks of his articles. It registered barely a ripple at the box office, but this Billy Ray drama was a favorite with critics like Kenneth Turan of the Los Angeles Times, who observed, “More than being a smart and accurate look at magazine journalism — no small matter — Shattered Glass is also a compelling portrait of a psychosis at work.”



On the big screen, imposters tend to be nefarious, and for good reason — nine times out of 10, if you’re going to go to the trouble of stealing another person’s life, you’re probably up to no good. Sommersby, however, reminds us that there’s still that 10th guy. Starring Richard Gere as the returning Civil War vet (or is he?) who comes home from the war a noticeably better man, stirring confusing emotions in his puzzled wife (Jodie Foster) and setting in motion a painful chain of events, Sommersby tried to say a number of things about love and redemption — and while a number of critics found the end result too diffuse to recommend, others swooned at its old-fashioned romance. Argued James Berardinelli of ReelViews, “From start to finish, it is a well-crafted film: part love story, part mystery, and all drama.”



Dudes in dresses are usually played for laughs in Hollywood, and to an extent, Tootsie is no exception; it is, underneath all that makeup and hosiery, a romantic comedy about an actor (Dustin Hoffman) who masquerades as a woman in order to take what he initially views as a demeaning gig on a soap opera. But rather than the sort of broad-as-a-barn-door farce we’ve grown accustomed to via movies like White Girls and Big Momma’s House, it uses its gags to sweeten what’s actually a rather thoughtful drama about dishonesty and the struggle to earn a living in modern America — with a Stephen Bishop ballad on the soundtrack for good measure. Critics, grateful to be spared a film that had nothing more to offer than the sight of Dustin Hoffman in a dress, showered Tootsie with praise: “It turns out to be a touching love story, after all,” observed Roger Ebert. “So touching that you may be surprised how moved you are at the conclusion of this comedy.”

Take a look through the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out the reviews for The Words.


Tag Cloud

SXSW 2022 hispanic war spanish scene in color series Britbox Horror festival rt labs CMT jurassic park Sundance TV women A24 king arthur Disney+ Disney Plus cartoon italian Black History Month emmy awards streaming movies stand-up comedy psycho scene in color DC Comics Best and Worst japan Tarantino critics Star Trek Thanksgiving venice Oscars series X-Men disaster Epix Action book FX Heroines Box Office DirecTV Amazon hidden camera stoner halloween First Look marvel comics Star Wars Celebration spy thriller serial killer Legendary Best Actress jamie lee curtis Year in Review batman razzies facebook sopranos mcc Sundance Now elevated horror Opinion Kids & Family Binge Guide cooking GoT spanish language Classic Film action-comedy Lucasfilm latino Alien Marvel Studios a nightmare on elm street satire scary USA ratings hollywood The Walt Disney Company Hulu RT History trailers comic book movies debate Marvel Television obituary comics slashers toronto Disney Channel cancelled television docuseries Disney streaming service all-time Pet Sematary Comedy Central HFPA king kong basketball Extras comiccon cinemax First Reviews Hallmark Christmas movies Awards Tour toy story sports mob Mary Poppins Returns TCA Awards crime thriller halloween tv Mystery IFC Superheroes Women's History Month medical drama Quiz stop motion Polls and Games golden globes History NBC Broadway 90s casting Film Festival critic resources australia Western Sony tv talk spinoff Freeform indie Native streaming A&E worst movies Grammys Reality Competition 93rd Oscars 45 Oscar worst ABC Stephen King LGBTQ cancelled TV shows green book Shondaland Musicals CBS All Access feel good CBS 94th Oscars Video Games dramedy Christmas universal monsters crime marvel cinematic universe Pop TV E3 TIFF Elton John international documentary screen actors guild Television Academy Hear Us Out black screenings Warner Bros. VICE dogs zero dark thirty comic book movie ESPN know your critic Set visit unscripted game of thrones summer TV preview PBS scene in color film series Mary poppins deadpool rt archives Fargo Wes Anderson composers target broadcast true crime book adaptation Apple TV+ romance The Arrangement Walt Disney Pictures Pixar Drama Schedule MSNBC free movies Spring TV french gangster Ellie Kemper BBC America National Geographic Lifetime adaptation child's play President miniseries popular Pacific Islander VOD festivals See It Skip It 71st Emmy Awards SXSW boxoffice Interview 20th Century Fox adventure biography classics Apple vs. TLC japanese Reality Spike Disney Disney Plus YA DGA Turner werewolf GIFs OneApp Ghostbusters Netflix strong female leads 24 frames high school ID remakes prank Bravo Photos Winter TV reboot Country Amazon Prime Video aapi Nat Geo Biopics Holiday Mudbound die hard 2015 Sony Pictures Avengers politics rotten Chernobyl monster movies Tumblr MGM south america Cartoon Network 21st Century Fox cancelled Pride Month laika directors blockbuster docudrama TV One young adult kids IMDb TV Mary Tyler Moore trophy criterion OWN AMC Plus Valentine's Day theme song sitcom Martial Arts BAFTA Lionsgate joker witnail Baby Yoda Pirates Fox Searchlight talk show telelvision Comic-Con@Home 2021 TruTV Podcast Fantasy Rock name the review boxing 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards comic books Mindy Kaling video on demand CNN Emmys 1990s Sundance 2018 2016 dreamworks Countdown DC streaming service Comic Book AMC Cosplay independent blockbusters 2020 suspense rt labs critics edition Rom-Com psychological thriller ITV Showtime Song of Ice and Fire YouTube Red Toys ABC Signature The Walking Dead dexter Spectrum Originals live action Starz political drama Tokyo Olympics Crackle IFC Films Vudu Watching Series animated Musical lord of the rings indiana jones APB ABC Family crime drama dceu streamig comic Funimation Nominations TBS Best Director Creative Arts Emmys based on movie versus Paramount posters summer TV breaking bad reviews football The Witch transformers fast and furious TCA Winter 2020 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt art house FXX anthology Teen chucky YouTube movies The CW vampires sag awards biopic justice league Television Critics Association harry potter mockumentary 99% MCU james bond Sneak Peek romantic comedy best mission: impossible HBO richard e. Grant travel Neflix movie Amazon Prime cats natural history thriller rom-coms El Rey Peacock Trophy Talk dark Rocky robots RT21 Tags: Comedy Superheroe Film new york Captain marvel golden globe awards 2019 Star Wars Hallmark historical drama kong CW Seed 2017 72 Emmy Awards period drama SDCC discovery parents Crunchyroll Music New York Comic Con anime TCM sequel leaderboard Tubi Exclusive Video godzilla GLAAD Universal Pictures Prime Video Pop olympics spain San Diego Comic-Con twilight 2021 Paramount Pictures adenture Fall TV heist movie archives BBC One canceled TV shows teaser Comedy royal family Ovation BBC hist zombies Summer Endgame 73rd Emmy Awards diversity Chilling Adventures of Sabrina documentaries black comedy canceled E! Best Picture interviews Food Network rotten movies we love HBO Go Masterpiece Character Guide foreign The Academy 79th Golden Globes Awards DC Universe HBO Max what to watch Certified Fresh binge PlayStation renewed TV shows Amazon Studios nature Turner Classic Movies space sequels Black Mirror Writers Guild of America wonder woman dragons Paramount Plus Brie Larson TNT films Hollywood Foreign Press Association doctor who children's TV Emmy Nominations Animation spider-man PaleyFest franchise TV renewals Paramount Network Focus Features Winners BET Awards Esquire 007 nfl supernatural SundanceTV obi wan pirates of the caribbean Adult Swim slasher TV Land Cannes zombie cars Calendar Trailer game show Family Apple TV Plus YouTube Premium USA Network Trivia hispanic heritage month Image Comics Academy Awards Fox News live event Marathons Anna Paquin Comics on TV ViacomCBS Geeked Week Election scorecard mutant 4/20 saw dc Nickelodeon South by Southwest Film Festival Rocketman comedies Logo finale Universal VH1 TV Discovery Channel fresh Holidays NYCC social media Sci-Fi legend Acorn TV asian-american revenge Super Bowl new star wars movies cults Arrowverse crossover video FOX cops new zealand spider-verse WarnerMedia ghosts Marvel Infographic American Society of Cinematographers news TCA 2017 TV movies genre kaiju singing competition Syfy Awards quibi BET FX on Hulu scary movies WGN MTV cancelled TV series Lifetime Christmas movies Tomatazos christmas movies NBA Netflix Christmas movies Shudder television Instagram Live superhero target scene in color LGBT concert Best Actor science fiction police drama award winner The Purge aliens Travel Channel nbcuniversal superman Columbia Pictures Dark Horse Comics blaxploitation technology Premiere Dates TCA summer preview Red Carpet Indigenous