Total Recall

Total Recall: Big-Screen Fairy Tales

With Snow White and the Huntsman hitting theaters, we run down some memorable films based on folkloric fantasy.

by | May 31, 2012 | Comments

Fairy Tale Movies

Snow White and the Huntsman opens this weekend, following closely behind Mirror Mirror and marking the second trip to theaters for the Fairest of Them All in 2012. With plenty of other folkloric fantasy adaptations in our recent past (Red Riding Hood, Beastly) and plenty more on the horizon (including Jack the Giant Killer and Hansel and Gretel: Witch Hunters), fairy tales are having something of a moment right now — but as any film fan could tell you, and as this week’s list demonstrates, this is nothing new in Hollywood. There are countless examples of filmmakers turning to fairy tales for inspiration, but we couldn’t possibly fit all those once upon a times and happily ever afters into a single feature. Which of your favorites made the cut? Find out in the latest Total Recall!

Beauty and the Beast

94%

We could have filled this list with Disney pictures, but that wouldn’t have been nearly as much fun — and still, when the time came to pick a Beauty and the Beast for our feature, it was no contest. A huge, Best Picture-nominated hit during its original run — and a big success all over again during its repeated reissues — Disney’s version of this timeless tale is the one that comes to mind for multiple generations when they think of Beauty and the Beast. And while it may have taken a few storyline liberties with the original text (and while the IMAX and 3D additions don’t really improve the story), the most important part remains: As Jay Boyar wrote for the Orlando Sentinel, it “Moves us because we know that true love can sometimes seem like a mismatch. And also because, in love, we can all feel like captives or beasts.”

The Brothers Grimm

38%

Their stories have inspired plenty of films, so it’s only fitting that Wilhelm and Jakob Grimm got to topline their own movie in 2005 — albeit one that starred Matt Damon and Heath Ledger as wildly fictionalized versions of the brothers. With a pair of matinee idols in the leads, Terry Gilliam behind the cameras, and an effects-heavy storyline that pitted the Grimms against a fairy tale curse and a wicked queen, The Brothers Grimm could have been a smash hit; unfortunately, its strife-plagued production only led to indifferent reviews and a mildly disappointing $105 million gross. Still, some critics thought Gilliam’s flair was enough to transcend the film’s flaws; as Bob Strauss of the Los Angeles Daily News argued, “You won’t want to pass this version of The Brothers Grimm on to your children. But you may find yourself coming back to marvel at parts of it for the rest of your life.”

Ever After: A Cinderella Story

91%

Starring an utterly winsome Drew Barrymore as the young woman who catches a prince’s eye — but has to overcome her stepmother’s cruel mistreatment to find true love — 1998’s Ever After drew on historical details for its background while offering a postmodern twist to the Cinderella story, positioning its heroine as a woman capable of saving herself from peril (and her royal beau, if need be). Sure, the audience knew the whole story by heart, but with Andy Tennant’s sumptuous direction, a supporting cast that included Anjelica Huston and Dougray Scott, and Barrymore in those glass slippers, they didn’t mind watching it unfold one more time — and neither did Roger Ebert, who proclaimed, “The old tale still has life and passion in it.”

Freeway

77%

When she made her debut in 1991’s The Man in the Moon, Reese Witherspoon looked like a luminous, innocent kid. Fast-forward five years later to Freeway, and goodness gracious, how things changed: A miniskirt-rocking Witherspoon starred opposite Kiefer Sutherland in this grimy, violent loose update on the story of Red Riding Hood, following a prostitute’s daughter on her dangerous journey up southern California’s I-5 freeway to find her grandmother. (Sutherland, naturally, was the leering serial killer standing in for the wolf.) While not a particularly pleasant film, Freeway earned its young star some career-boosting rave reviews, including Margaret A. McGurk’s writeup for the Cincinnati Enquirer: “I didn’t particularly want to like Freeway,” admitted McGurk, “but I couldn’t help myself. Reese Witherspoon made me.”

Hans Christian Andersen

83%

It’s named after the famous storyteller, but don’t watch 1952’s Hans Christian Andersen looking for a biopic; instead, producer Samuel Goldwyn opted to create a typically lavish musical extravaganza, starring Danny Kaye as Andersen in a sort of fairytale revue that includes nods to “The Little Mermaid,” “Thumbelina,” “The Ugly Duckling,” and “The Emperor’s New Clothes.” As a result, it’s sort of all over the place, but it has a certain gregarious charm that wasn’t lost on audiences, the Academy (who nominated it for six Oscars), or critics; as Variety put it, “No attempt at biography is made, so the imaginative production has full rein in bringing in songs and ballet numbers to round out the Andersen fairy tales told by Kaye.”

The Pied Piper

44%

Take a heaping helping of 1960s psychedelic strangeness, stir it into the timeless legend of the Pied Piper, and you’ve got this 1972 drama starring folk troubadour Donovan as the piper, who’s tricked by the unscrupulous Donald Pleasance into exterminating a village’s worth of rats and is then shortchanged on the fee. You know what happens next — the Piper gets even by stealing the village’s children, Donovan performs a few musical numbers, and Dylan humiliates him at a party. (Oh, wait — wrong movie.) Generally speaking, critics weren’t as entranced by The Pied Piper as the kids in the movie, but it earned nods of approval from a few scribes — including J. Hoberman of the Village Voice, who called it “A dark and smoky affair that, although set in Germany during the Black Death summer of 1349, suggests something brainstormed in a St. Marks Place head shop.”

Pinocchio

0%

Like plenty of other Oscar-winning actors, Roberto Benigni used the clout he earned with his awards (Best Actor and Best Foreign Film for Life Is Beautiful) to help get his passion project made. And it had plenty of potential, too — Carlo Callodi’s The Adventures of Pinocchio is a classic book, but the character has become more closely identified with its somewhat bowdlerized Disney counterpart, and Benigni could have channeled his love for the book into a more faithful film. Alas, he chose instead to create one of the strangest (and vaguely creepiest) family movies of the 21st century, starring Benigni himself (who also directed and co-wrote the script) as the impish wooden boy. In fairness, it should be pointed out that the international version of Pinocchio did fairly well, but in the States, the English overdubs only compounded the overall weirdness of what unfolded on the screen. As an incredulous Edward Guthmann asked for the San Francisco Chronicle: “What can one say about a balding 50-year-old actor playing an innocent boy carved from a log?”

Shrek

88%

Strictly speaking, the Shrek franchise was inspired by the classic William Stieg children’s book from which it takes its name — but along the way, the four Shrek films (plus their Puss in Boots spinoff) have gotten a lot of mileage out of lampooning fairy tales. From the first film, which featured a heroic ogre and a princess who knew kung fu — not to mention comedic cameos from Pinocchio, the Gingerbread Man, the Three Little Pigs, and many others — the Shrek series has offered critically approved (and wildly commercially successful) proof that there’s still plenty of creative life left in the stories we all know by heart. They are, as CNN’s Paul Tatara wrote of the first film, “A heck of a lot of fun — even if you don’t believe in fairy tales.”

Sydney White

35%

Put Snow White on a modern college campus and substitute a gaggle of social outcasts for the seven dwarves, and you’ve got 2007’s Sydney White, an Amanda Bynes rom-com about an adorably perky freshman who runs afoul of a popular girl on campus and ends up befriending seven unpopular kids. Along the way, she unwittingly infuriates her nemesis with her widely acknowledged beauty, suffering the effects of an infected Apple (computer) for her transgression before being kissed by…well, you know the story. In spite of Bynes’ charms and the aforementioned clever modern parallels, Sydney struck out with audiences as well as most critics — although it proved a pleasant diversion for Laura Kern of the New York Times, who argued, “Ms. Bynes, with her cherubic face, expressive eyes and comic timing, helps create a positive, pleasing diversion that caters to the geek in all of us.”

tom thumb

67%

Starring Russ Tamblyn in the title role, this 1958 production put a whimsical (and appropriately special effects-heavy) spin on the tale of a diminutive lad who always seems to be getting himself out of one horrible jam after another. With a stellar supporting cast that included Alan Young and Peter Sellers, soundtrack assistance from Peggy Lee, and direction from FX wiz George Pal, tom thumb turned a handsome profit at the box office, earned an Academy Award for Special Effects, and earned praise from a number of critics — including the folks at Film4, who called it “one of the most memorable and beloved films directed by special-effects pioneer Pal, with Tamblyn looking bright and fresh-faced as the diminutive fairytale hero.”


Take a look through the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out the reviews for Snow White and the Huntsman.

 

Tag Cloud

heist movie History rom-coms Photos Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt black comedy Turner Classic Movies 2018 stand-up comedy Reality Spring TV aliens Exclusive Video mockumentary wonder woman Binge Guide 2021 Esquire Holidays Amazon Prime Video canceled TV shows Election Country Paramount black CBS All Access franchise Hallmark royal family 1990s El Rey National Geographic elevated horror cancelled television king arthur ITV WarnerMedia video on demand Awards Tour olympics what to watch award winner Nickelodeon Rock Freeform BBC America movies zombie Shudder foreign San Diego Comic-Con halloween Super Bowl MSNBC ViacomCBS RT21 Amazon Prime crime thriller Universal doctor who sequels Tarantino police drama disaster 72 Emmy Awards high school fast and furious Baby Yoda cancelled Cartoon Network indie mutant Musicals IMDb TV kong Neflix cults Brie Larson Rocky Pirates binge animated Apple TV Plus GoT cartoon ratings marvel cinematic universe Television Academy golden globe awards debate Fox News TV One Vudu feel good scary movies Reality Competition President monster movies nature serial killer Disney streaming service Turner science fiction The Walt Disney Company Sony Pictures political drama Endgame Food Network godzilla Syfy game show Women's History Month Britbox Sundance TV YouTube kaiju Mystery festival obituary Fox Searchlight ESPN NYCC Sundance Grammys best Marathons DC streaming service The Witch crime Lucasfilm boxing trophy X-Men 73rd Emmy Awards Film Festival MTV comic books 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Comic-Con@Home 2021 Comics on TV legend stoner prank finale children's TV Thanksgiving VOD sopranos TV movies Walt Disney Pictures Columbia Pictures composers WGN Fall TV social media The Purge Hulu joker toy story 4/20 aapi Mary poppins Amazon Studios blockbusters 2016 psycho adventure Mary Poppins Returns video Arrowverse scary Podcast Awards Winners stop motion Ellie Kemper TNT FOX The Academy Discovery Channel unscripted based on movie cars DGA emmy awards Christmas sitcom golden globes talk show dragons Trivia Alien OneApp spinoff YouTube Premium king kong critics streaming saw Character Guide Extras BET Awards Heroines spanish rotten archives docuseries comic book movie 2017 superhero Warner Bros. Showtime 2015 south america japanese Quiz Music 99% Ovation new zealand teaser Funimation Lifetime 24 frames Crunchyroll blockbuster 20th Century Fox reviews HFPA DC Comics Musical Superheroe CMT name the review SDCC Film Netflix Shondaland Mudbound LGBTQ scorecard criterion Pop TV Peacock Infographic Tokyo Olympics IFC Films USA strong female leads GLAAD sag awards Emmy Nominations mcc TCA Winter 2020 scene in color Comic Book TCA facebook Academy Awards ghosts cats fresh dark PaleyFest venice hist Marvel PBS Hollywood Foreign Press Association Instagram Live Pride Month Cosplay Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Video Games dreamworks Apple Travel Channel documentary art house 2019 E! AMC cancelled TV shows true crime kids rotten movies we love romance documentaries Hear Us Out suspense dramedy cooking remakes mission: impossible natural history Crackle comic book movies Sneak Peek Year in Review game of thrones romantic comedy anime Sci-Fi christmas movies miniseries TV universal monsters television Box Office E3 Apple TV+ 21st Century Fox Winter TV Premiere Dates Family live event blaxploitation robots Disney+ Disney Plus Cannes Universal Pictures Mindy Kaling 45 a nightmare on elm street Interview Legendary adaptation rt labs critics edition Biopics Western Nominations jurassic park satire Trophy Talk Tags: Comedy American Society of Cinematographers deadpool classics HBO boxoffice parents nbcuniversal hispanic heritage month FXX spider-man die hard latino marvel comics canceled Avengers critic resources space 90s dc vampires Bravo Calendar child's play Hallmark Christmas movies period drama new york APB live action BAFTA cancelled TV series TCA 2017 basketball superman AMC Plus PlayStation diversity transformers Song of Ice and Fire USA Network Disney YA streaming movies biopic rt archives french TV renewals book adaptation comic green book cops worst historical drama TIFF VH1 Rocketman Countdown TLC 007 TruTV Spectrum Originals mob Chernobyl biography Creative Arts Emmys RT History politics Certified Fresh DC Universe Emmys Fantasy The Arrangement Adult Swim Drama Pop batman Paramount Network Star Trek Watching Series 79th Golden Globes Awards Image Comics ID Broadway A&E new star wars movies leaderboard reboot OWN Tumblr nfl cinemax Summer sports action-comedy technology Polls and Games Star Wars target revenge Elton John Acorn TV gangster book Valentine's Day Holiday festivals Tomatazos Disney Plus pirates of the caribbean Marvel Television Best and Worst know your critic Kids & Family Pacific Islander thriller Masterpiece razzies Trailer theme song movie Prime Video IFC 71st Emmy Awards Oscars Disney Channel Captain marvel hollywood GIFs Pixar Netflix Christmas movies adenture telelvision CW Seed LGBT SXSW YouTube Red spanish language dogs BET international screen actors guild jamie lee curtis halloween tv crossover witnail Logo BBC One Marvel Studios tv talk casting See It Skip It independent ABC Family Pet Sematary Martial Arts free movies Action First Look posters HBO Max HBO Go quibi Tubi The Walking Dead werewolf genre Dark Horse Comics trailers TCA Awards Red Carpet New York Comic Con Writers Guild of America spy thriller TBS Comedy comedies asian-american Wes Anderson 93rd Oscars richard e. Grant Fargo Animation medical drama all-time laika The CW CBS A24 Horror italian worst movies popular toronto sequel ABC Signature concert Lionsgate young adult Mary Tyler Moore harry potter screenings Toys slashers Epix spain Nat Geo NBA FX Opinion Classic Film war justice league chucky Anna Paquin Teen Paramount Plus TCM MCU women vs. DirecTV football zero dark thirty 2020 lord of the rings Black Mirror dceu Amazon series renewed TV shows comiccon Rom-Com anthology hispanic news BBC comics spider-verse VICE Lifetime Christmas movies Black History Month TV Land slasher discovery singing competition Superheroes CNN Schedule dexter hidden camera supernatural crime drama Stephen King twilight travel psychological thriller Ghostbusters Starz ABC docudrama Comedy Central films versus Television Critics Association james bond directors SundanceTV zombies Spike Set visit First Reviews breaking bad australia indiana jones rt labs japan FX on Hulu NBC Sundance Now