Trophy Talk

Toronto International Film Festival Takeaways: The Future is Female

Standout documentaries and female filmmakers led the way at the fest, signalling the start of an unusual, uncertain awards season.

by | September 22, 2020 | Comments

The Toronto International Film Festival wrapped its mostly virtual festivities on Sunday, September 20, and despite a downsized slate of digital screenings and drive-in events, it remains the premier curtain riser of the awards season — even a strange one playing out amid a global pandemic. The organizers behind the Telluride Film Festival opted to sit this year out, and the folks behind the Venice Film Festival instead put on a socially distant event with limited attendees, but TIFF and its sister September festivals were in agreement on one thing: Chloe Zhao’s Nomadland is an awards contender. Telluride, though canceled, did partner with Fox Searchlight for an A-list drive-in screening at the Pasadena Rose Bowl, and for the first time, both Venice and TIFF chose the same film for their top prize. Never before has the Venice Golden Lion matched the TIFF Audience Award winner; with both seen as a strong indication of a films’ Best Picture chances, Nomadland now heads into the season sitting comfortably in the frontrunner seat.

Last year at TIFF, Taika Waititi’s Nazi satire Jojo Rabbit rebounded from a mixed initial critical reception to win the Grolsch People’s Choice Award on its way to a Best Picture nomination alongside 2019’s Golden Lion winner and Best Picture nominee, Todd Phillips’ Joker. This year, however, with limited options and only a handful of contenders with calendar dates, Nomadland and the TIFF Audience Award runner-up, Regina King’s One Night in Miami, will likely ride a wave of momentum into 2021. No matter how many titles are currently in contention, the season has begun, so here are our key awards takeaways from this year’s Toronto International Film Festival.



Despite a skinnier slate, TIFF remained committed to diversity and inclusion in their selections, with 33% of the feature film Gala presentations directed by women, two of which emerged as the big winners of the weekend. Neither Nomadland nor Oscar-winner Regina King’s feature directorial debut One Night in Miami were short on buzz prior to their Toronto premieres. After stunning receptions, Audience Award accolades, and a pair of 98% Tomatometer scores, they are now the films to beat heading into the heart of the season. Critics were effusive with praise for both, with Robert Daniels of 812FilmReviews calling One Night in Miami “a blistering feature debut replete with visceral performances,” while Anne Brodie of What She Said dubbed Nomadland “indescribably enveloping.” King and Zhao would be considered underdogs in a season expected to include previous Oscar nominees Wes Anderson and David Fincher and prior winners Aaron Sorkin and Stephen Speilberg, but the chances of one or both making it to Oscar night are high.

Elsewhere, Halle Berry’s directorial debut was picked up by Netflix, and Pieces of a Woman generated a lot of conversation, both for Vanessa Kirby’s (The Crown) turn in it and for its harrowing, heart-stopping 20-minute opening scene. Dianne West and Rosamund Pike also enjoyed positive reviews for their biting comedy I Care A Lot, and indigenous filmmaker Tracey Deer’s second runner up Audience Award for Beans made it a clean sweep of female filmmakers for TIFF’s most coveted prize. Considering the results, it appears a helpful bi-product of this unconventional season is providing discovery films from female filmmakers the chance to capture the attention of audiences and voters.


While many narrative productions were paused or pushed due to restrictions from COVID-19, documentary filmmaking carried on mostly unaffected by the “pandemic pause.” By the very nature of their productions, documentary films seem the medium most equipped to navigate our new normal. Talking head interviews, archival footage, and post-production editing can all continue largely uninterrupted, which is why this fall sees a crop of exceptional documentaries with Oscar shortlist aspirations. Nathan Grossman’s doc on Greta Thunberg’s crusade to combat climate change, I Am Greta, was well-received, with Rubin Safaya of Cinemalogue calling it “a profile in courage.” Martin Luther King Jr.’s harassment and surveillance by J. Edgar Hoover and the FBI is chronicled with disturbing detail for MLK/FBI, a timely documentary about activism and government that strikes an all too familiar chord. However, the most timely bit of non-fiction storytelling from the TIFF slate was 76 Days, which dives behind the COVID-19 lockdown headlines in Wuhan, China to examine the staff of one hospital for isolated patients. A moving piece with moments of quiet heroism, 76 days looks good for a deep run in 2021 alongside Spike Lee’s (if deemed eligible) David Byrne concert doc Utopia, which David Ehrlich of Indiewire wrote was “one of the best since Stop Making Sense.”


This time of year, the close of every festival typically provides some clarification about the awards season, and while we have new glimmers of hope courtesy of One Night in Miami and Nomadland, TIFF still leaves a lot of niggling questions unanswered. Wes Anderson’s The French Dispatch, a likely Oscar favorite, has been pulled from the release schedule, and films like Stephen Spielberg’s West Side Story and the Tom Hanks-led News of the World are still in jeopardy of vacating their December dates if theaters are not widely open and operating by then. The disastrous North American release of Christopher Nolan’s Tenet over Labor Day weekend quickly humbled studios, with several marquee names like Wonder Woman 1984 fleeing to later dates, presumably with Black Widow and Soul to follow. A24’s Zola, The Green Knight, and Minari are not expected to pull in hundreds of millions at the box office, but with no end to the pandemic in sight and audiences clearly not ready to head back to theaters, it is unclear which films will actually commit to 2020/2021 Oscar eligibility.

Suppose we readjust the schedule to take into account the Academy’s extended season; the end of September lines up perfectly with the end of June for a normal year. This time last year leaving Cannes, The LighthouseOnce Upon a Time in Hollylwood, and Bong Joon-ho’s Palme D’or- and eventual Best Picture-winning Parasite were the buzziest titles. In contrast, eventual Oscar nominees like The Irishman, JokerMarriage Story, and 1917 had yet to be screened. Therefore, perhaps we should reserve judgment until we get closer to the new Academy deadline of February 2021 before we raise alarms. It is true that we typically know more around this time, but as with so many other things, the 20/21 season is anything but typical.


For a season of digital premieres and modest box office totals, the streaming giant Netflix’s absence at TIFF and the other fall festivals further muddied an already murky season. If the festival calendar strives to pull the contenders into sharper focus, Netflix’s decision to skip the festival circuit places significant pieces of the awards landscape out of frame. Netflix picked up Pieces of A Woman during TIFF, as well as Euphoria creator Sam Levinson’s quarantine-filmed Malcolm & Marie just prior to the festival start, adding the pair to their already crowded roster of nearly 20 films set to compete in 2021.

Previously released films like Spike Lee’s Da 5 Bloods and I’m Thinking of Ending Things are very much in the thick of contention for several categories, and Aaron Sorkin’s The Trial of the Chicago 7 and Sundance winner Radha Blank’s The 40-Year-Old Version are scheduled to hit the platform soon. However, Ron Howard’s Hillbilly Elegy, David Fincher’s Mank, and George Clooney’s Midnight Sky are still in post-production and remain undated. A-list casts acting in “awards-friendly” source material is precisely what Oscar voters flock to, but a sizable anti-Netflix contingent is still very prominent within AMPAS, and until those movies screen, it is unclear if one or more of them will be able to overcome that bias to take home the Best Picture prize.

However, with a handful of strong candidates unbeholden to box office receipts, Netflix can carefully plot out their release schedule to drum up timely buzz as often as possible. The recent tragic death of Chadwick Boseman will likely have a significant impact on the release of Viola Davis’ Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom, but the August Wilson adaptation is still expected to join the titles mentioned above in what could be a Netflix vs. Netflix race for several categories. Until the rest of the heavy hitters from Netflix’s slate debut and other studios’ Oscar hopefuls commit to a release date, this season is less like educated guesswork and more like blindly groping for statues in a darkened room.

Tag Cloud

name the review 2016 dogs politics BBC America The CW YA Food Network Amazon Prime TruTV spider-man Marvel Television Sundance TV ratings Biopics Rocketman FX VOD screen actors guild japanese sequels Spike harry potter Drama Watching Series TNT spain Ovation Emmy Nominations Summer Toys stand-up comedy Mindy Kaling DGA Animation Rocky crime drama YouTube Premium italian mockumentary Television Academy Polls and Games game of thrones cooking Pixar cats Brie Larson SundanceTV E! mutant australia Ghostbusters 2015 spinoff Cartoon Network CNN USA USA Network TBS Country Set visit cancelled TV shows comic Calendar See It Skip It ITV Martial Arts technology Creative Arts Emmys Showtime classics television romance Hallmark cancelled TV series Disney streaming service Tomatazos dark police drama OneApp adaptation crime Amazon Tarantino LGBT Walt Disney Pictures singing competition Red Carpet movies Comedy X-Men AMC golden globes PlayStation Vudu worst Best and Worst El Rey Baby Yoda sag awards Paramount Network space die hard science fiction Amazon Prime Video Music Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Rock biography SXSW obituary deadpool 2018 Tumblr Disney Plus BBC One MTV ABC versus directors comiccon Horror child's play PBS cartoon Extras blockbuster Black Mirror Musical Nickelodeon CBS transformers 20th Century Fox Paramount theme song Kids & Family comic books disaster reboot E3 docudrama series criterion Certified Fresh Black History Month GoT films Stephen King Fox Searchlight quibi Podcast finale cancelled television National Geographic IFC Films book SDCC game show 45 Star Trek worst movies WGN cars foreign Apple TV Plus Lionsgate Classic Film Musicals nbcuniversal PaleyFest fresh Awards Tour Travel Channel Netflix Christmas movies Marathons hist psycho indie 24 frames ghosts slashers nfl period drama Emmys Pop TV comedies TCA travel FOX Rom-Com crossover Trivia Acorn TV MCU GLAAD The Academy critics Opinion The Arrangement toy story rotten VICE Awards First Look natural history animated anime free movies parents Pet Sematary boxoffice Teen TV renewals Ellie Kemper award winner Pride Month NBC adventure a nightmare on elm street Mudbound christmas movies Captain marvel Academy Awards TCA Winter 2020 Holiday indiana jones all-time anthology documentaries Starz reviews movie Epix venice Netflix medical drama A24 richard e. Grant rotten movies we love documentary revenge festival dramedy Super Bowl Photos YouTube scorecard Disney Channel vampires Pirates news CBS All Access DC Comics mission: impossible Lifetime History 007 Adult Swim ID historical drama Turner Grammys halloween tv aliens 72 Emmy Awards Shondaland kids justice league Cosplay dceu Western dc comics Endgame Reality Competition batman spy thriller Lucasfilm New York Comic Con Warner Bros. Nat Geo remakes archives psychological thriller laika TCM Sci-Fi BET Awards Disney+ Disney Plus Fall TV NYCC Quiz dragons Television Critics Association emmy awards teaser Hallmark Christmas movies superhero Esquire blaxploitation Bravo Sneak Peek joker Disney Britbox Film Festival war Mary Tyler Moore FXX supernatural RT21 Dark Horse Comics concert unscripted 71st Emmy Awards Holidays 4/20 Heroines cancelled TCA Awards Sony Pictures tv talk hispanic Film boxing Reality WarnerMedia Hear Us Out diversity First Reviews Shudder Superheroe Premiere Dates children's TV based on movie werewolf Pop Action Crackle Election BAFTA Mary poppins Tubi Spectrum Originals robots CMT 99% Peacock Columbia Pictures BET romantic comedy HBO Go jamie lee curtis sequel Masterpiece LGBTQ Character Guide Interview rt archives CW Seed IFC french south america The Purge 2019 Binge Guide Arrowverse Logo toronto Elton John video on demand witnail cinemax A&E best zombie breaking bad Lifetime Christmas movies Writers Guild of America what to watch GIFs Winners screenings stoner scary movies halloween APB asian-american Mary Poppins Returns TIFF political drama The Walking Dead strong female leads doctor who fast and furious Anna Paquin Schedule Alien TCA 2017 Video Games DirecTV TV zero dark thirty streaming San Diego Comic-Con Marvel casting BBC Funimation canceled TV shows Valentine's Day TLC james bond Trophy Talk VH1 satire Discovery Channel football latino stop motion twilight American Society of Cinematographers franchise FX on Hulu Women's History Month 2020 Marvel Studios Thanksgiving Year in Review The Witch Apple TV+ Mystery video Nominations Avengers Comic Book Apple true crime Trailer Fantasy Universal ESPN Hulu DC streaming service discovery Box Office Oscars zombies green book Chernobyl Family cults sports President Star Wars Crunchyroll Spring TV MSNBC black thriller 2017 social media cops Cannes Sundance Now Christmas chucky ABC Family DC Universe miniseries Superheroes facebook elevated horror hollywood crime thriller Syfy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Comics on TV Turner Classic Movies renewed TV shows serial killer sitcom spanish language nature canceled YouTube Red Song of Ice and Fire Freeform TV Land composers Amazon Studios universal monsters Infographic independent Fox News spanish binge 21st Century Fox RT History Comedy Central Winter TV HBO talk show festivals Sundance Countdown OWN HBO Max