The Walking Dead Season 8 Midseason Finale: What Critics Thought About That Major Cliffhanger

Critics' have mixed thoughts about the midseason finale of AMC's zombie series and its possible impact on the rest of season 8.

by | December 11, 2017 | Comments

(Photo by AMC)

The first seven episodes of The Walking Dead‘s season 8 were a critical mixed bag, but the midseason finale, titled “How It’s Gotta Be,” concluded with a major (and heartbreaking) character development that will undoubtedly affect the series moving forward.


Rick (Andrew Lincoln) and the rest of the AHK crew were once again on the defensive when Negan (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) and the Saviors escaped the Sanctuary and sought revenge, but the real twist occurred at the very end of the episode. As Rick and Michonne (Danai Gurira) saw that most of the Alexandrians were safe in the sewers underneath the town, they came across a weakened Carl (Chandler Riggs), who revealed a nasty zombie bite to the torso (which he probably got when he was saving new recruit Saddiq in the woods).

Although people are devastated by the Carl twist, he isn’t actually dead yet, as star Riggs and showrunner Scott M. Gimple (on the post-finale episode of Talking Dead) were quick to remind us in post-show interviews. The writing is on the wall, though — meaning there probably isn’t going to be a bait-and-switch à la Glenn and the dumpster.

With a Tomatometer score of 64 percent (updated), season 8’s mid-season finale isn’t quite as Fresh as season 7 (78 percent), but a whole lot better than season 6 (35 percent). Here’s what the critics had to say.


The finale delivered the requisite dropped-jaw response.

“It turns out, as usual, that a big heart is a relatively fast track to death in this post-apocalyptic, rotting world.” – Laura Bradley, Vanity Fair

“Subtlety is a long forgotten and extinct practice on TWD. That means eight seasons in, it’s hard for the writers to find ways to surprise us. They did with this fall finale.” – Jeffrey Lyles, Lyles’ Movie Files

The Walking Dead always tries to hold a big reveal for the end of their mid-season finale, and I think it’s safe to say that this one delivered fairly well.” – Jim Vorel, Paste Magazine

“Director Michael E. Satrazemis’ use of close-ups is visually striking, and shifts the emphasis to individual reactions to a crisis, which has always been the show’s strong suit.” – Noel Murray, Rolling Stone


This turn of events with Carl should finally shake things up.

“The mid-season finale is as long and tedious as so much of season 8, but a game-changing cliffhanger is a terrifying reminder that no one is ever safe.” – Sarah Moran, Screenrant

“While this has been one the more energetic episodes this year, it’s the small preview of the back half of season 8 that looks far more exciting and enticing than what we’ve seen so far this season.” – Nick Romano, Entertainment Weekly

“It was a pretty shocking twist to an otherwise-frustrating episode… Without Carl, anything might be possible. That might just be exactly what The Walking Dead needs.”  – Kelly Lawler, USA Today


“Whoo-hoo-hoo, look who knows so much. It just so happens that your friend here is only MOSTLY dead. There’s a big difference between mostly dead and all dead. Mostly dead is slightly alive.” – Miracle Max, The Princess Bride

Stupid Is as Stupid Does

Andrew Lincoln as Rick Grimes, Chandler Riggs as Carl Grimes, Danai Gurira as Michonne - The Walking Dead _ Season 8, Episode 8 (Gene Page/AMC)

Plenty of critics thought the slow burn and nonsensical action were still too tedious.

“This is all just characters acting dumb for no reason, and it’s all too much for this episode to bear, especially when it plays out so slowly over 90 minutes.” – Jeff Stone, IndieWire

“Man, does this feel empty. Despite all the big events, so much of ‘How It’s Gotta Be’ is boring, and so little of it makes sense.” – Zack Handlen, AV Club

“The stakes in the finale didn’t feel nearly as high as they needed to (sorry Carl). It’s hard to invest emotionally in characters when they seem to be running around toting assault rifles / bin lorries etc. to no clear purpose.” – Ed Power, The Daily Telegraph

“By the end of the episode’s ‘shocking’ reveal, I could only shake my head in disgust. What a joke this show has become. A bad joke.” – Erik Kain, Forbes

The Walking Dead returns Sunday, Feb. 25 at 9 p.m. on AMC.

Tag Cloud

First Reviews witnail social media FX comiccon richard e. Grant Pirates Apple TV+ biography Syfy 2020 south america SundanceTV Ghostbusters singing competition video on demand BET Awards Family movies Rock CMT spy thriller American Society of Cinematographers tv talk 2018 Crackle E! ghosts Music DGA Pride Month Premiere Dates scary movies Interview reboot Election hollywood indie concert Academy Awards foreign Awards documentaries Red Carpet rotten supernatural The Arrangement Superheroe ratings serial killer casting Tubi Netflix Christmas movies Pop TV Amazon Fox News Box Office game of thrones MTV Binge Guide GoT laika sitcom Starz TCM anthology Esquire Winter TV science fiction Baby Yoda sag awards Best and Worst DC streaming service TBS BAFTA OneApp Schedule 71st Emmy Awards diversity GIFs Masterpiece FXX Tumblr unscripted critics Awards Tour Winners comedies FOX Sneak Peek Food Network Photos Lucasfilm stand-up comedy Captain marvel game show joker TCA Winter 2020 dragons franchise Animation ESPN nature Pixar justice league Nominations sports Biopics Reality Competition Western Disney Plus Nat Geo child's play book Ovation Martial Arts YouTube Red dc Rom-Com Sundance Now Musical Spectrum Originals Star Trek Nickelodeon Dark Horse Comics Warner Bros. Podcast HBO Go Polls and Games cults Comics on TV The CW strong female leads Travel Channel Adult Swim docudrama Apple TV Plus nbcuniversal TLC Film Shudder Emmys Mary Tyler Moore Super Bowl police drama parents Hulu series Spike Britbox robots HBO Max crime drama Extras IFC Films doctor who Classic Film Hallmark Christmas movies Infographic thriller aliens A24 The Purge werewolf adaptation Set visit Character Guide Marvel Television Walt Disney Pictures YouTube 2016 The Walking Dead Calendar cats PBS E3 Trivia reviews historical drama RT History composers zombies WGN PaleyFest ABC Family DC Comics asian-american zombie revenge Holiday Country finale cooking television streaming 4/20 Certified Fresh Acorn TV blaxploitation Action 2015 24 frames obituary Heroines kids teaser Universal zero dark thirty what to watch hispanic all-time TV YA OWN Disney The Witch quibi Television Academy Mudbound screenings Shondaland latino Writers Guild of America space 21st Century Fox Oscars Musicals Year in Review AMC free movies dramedy satire transformers IFC animated Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt blockbuster BBC APB VOD political drama Spring TV Trophy Talk Mystery Hear Us Out vampires RT21 SDCC Mindy Kaling Pop Fantasy halloween Women's History Month Lionsgate 45 Vudu Tarantino jamie lee curtis Anna Paquin Marathons fast and furious Endgame cops Christmas golden globes true crime NYCC TNT screen actors guild cancelled FX on Hulu indiana jones HBO technology Summer TruTV Cartoon Network universal monsters ITV anime renewed TV shows MCU Lifetime Christmas movies slashers New York Comic Con talk show war Discovery Channel green book cartoon Avengers cars worst Peacock criterion TCA comics Thanksgiving Disney streaming service President Disney+ Disney Plus Kids & Family Teen video best Funimation Watching Series versus Disney Channel romance canceled Hallmark dceu cancelled TV series Ellie Kemper Paramount Black Mirror Horror Valentine's Day Song of Ice and Fire mockumentary emmy awards Video Games Reality Chernobyl Toys Emmy Nominations Turner Classic Movies Marvel Studios directors politics Turner CNN spinoff CW Seed Creative Arts Emmys psychological thriller dark San Diego Comic-Con rotten movies we love Comic Book Netflix LGBTQ BBC America festivals Lifetime 72 Emmy Awards Stephen King twilight boxoffice facebook children's TV stoner name the review harry potter binge Logo toy story Drama Sundance TV CBS romantic comedy crime thriller adventure X-Men Chilling Adventures of Sabrina SXSW news WarnerMedia Paramount Network Cosplay TCA Awards TCA 2017 007 El Rey natural history Holidays History Bravo period drama independent USA disaster Quiz Television Critics Association films 2017 canceled TV shows Black History Month medical drama travel Crunchyroll CBS All Access movie Opinion TIFF spanish language spain LGBT VICE 2019 Pet Sematary psycho theme song crossover Epix elevated horror Rocketman batman crime sequel BBC One USA Network Arrowverse See It Skip It Star Wars Mary Poppins Returns Cannes Amazon Prime cinemax TV Land based on movie christmas movies Tomatazos die hard DC Universe Amazon Studios miniseries BET ABC VH1 Comedy award winner spider-man dogs GLAAD Mary poppins chucky a nightmare on elm street documentary Comedy Central MSNBC DirecTV Freeform cancelled television Showtime stop motion breaking bad Marvel Elton John PlayStation hist National Geographic Fall TV Columbia Pictures First Look Grammys mutant Sundance superhero Sony Pictures Rocky classics Apple cancelled TV shows 20th Century Fox Superheroes YouTube Premium Brie Larson Film Festival comic NBC mission: impossible discovery A&E Sci-Fi Trailer Amazon Prime Video TV renewals Countdown