News

The Prom First Reviews: We're All Just Living in Meryl Streep's World

Critics say Ryan Murphy's adaptation of the Broadway hit is a feel-good treat for musical fans with a scene-stealing Meryl Streep and a bright young newcomer in Jo Ellen Pellman.

by | December 1, 2020 | Comments

It’s time for a new hit movie musical, and Netflix hopes The Prom will rise to the occasion. Fortunately for them, if the first reviews are any indication, Ryan Murphy’s adaptation of the Broadway show will fit the bill and delight subscribers of all ages with its mix of old-school razzle-dazzle and progressive subject matter.

The Prom, which arrives on the streaming service December 11, stars Meryl Streep, James Corden, Nicole Kidman, and Andrew Rannells as egocentric showbiz types from NYC who descend upon a conservative Midwest American town to help a teen (Jo Ellen Pellman) whose sexual orientation has caused her school to cancel the titular dance. For both its message of tolerance and its lively spectacle, it seems like it might just be the movie of the year.

Here’s what critics are saying about The Prom:


Should Ryan Murphy fans flock to the movie?

It’s a perfect combination of filmmaker and material.
– Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

This film is well inside Ryan Murphy’s Glee wheelhouse.
– Fionnuala Halligan, Screen International

Murphy is back in Glee territory here, for better or worse.
– David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

Ryan Murphy again finds the underdog vibe of Glee that captured pop culture’s imagination.
– Brian Truitt, USA Today

The Prom demonstrates that Murphy has matured as a filmmaker since his Glee days.
– Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

The Prom is the best of what Murphy can offer Hollywood — a taste of the past with its eyes on the future.
– Jude Dry, IndieWire


Ryan Murphy and the cast of The Prom

(Photo by Melinda Sue Gordon/Netflix)

Is it a worthy adaptation of the musical?

[Murphy’s] real achievement is making The Prom feel like a film rather than a captured-on-camera stage production, one that still retains the let’s-put-on-a-show energy of live theater.
Thom Geier, The Wrap

[The] stage vision translates surprisingly well to the screen thanks to the movie’s visual flair.
Jude Dry, IndieWire


But what if you don’t care for musicals?

It probably goes without saying, but anybody with an aversion to musicals or Murphy’s previous work, such as Glee, should stay well clear of The Prom.
Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

Regrettably, much of the film’s humor comes in the form of musical theater in-jokes.
Mary Sollosi, Entertainment Weekly

In recent years, there’s been a spate of musicals that you’ll “enjoy even if you don’t like musicals”… The Prom is no such musical.
Ben Travis, Empire Magazine

Ryan Murphy offers a fun and lightweight musical that will certainly not win over the sort of people who detest the genre but will likely entertain those who do.
Lewis Knight, Daily Mirror

The Prom isn’t quite as ubiquitous as, say, Cats or Les Miserables, and thus Murphy’s film will feel refreshing for a streaming audience often itching to watch Netflix’s next big thing.
Brian Truitt, USA Today


Meryl Streep and James Corden in The Prom

(Photo by Melinda Sue Gordon/Netflix)

And what about fans of old-school musicals?

Aside from its impassioned overtures for LGBTQ+ rights, The Prom has all the makings of a classic Hollywood musical.
Jude Dry, IndieWire

If The Prom is a proudly liberated musical, it’s also one that’s so defiantly square, with a vibe that reaches back to the incandescently wholesome musicals of the studio system.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety

It will frustrate audiences who prefer their musicals with subtlety and nuance.
Doug Jamieson, The Jam Report


How are the songs?

The heartrending songs Pellman and [Ariana] DeBose deliver are sweet and, more importantly, powerfully poignant.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Catchy in the moment, even if they seldom linger long in the head.
David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

The songs truly are terrible.
Jesse Hassenger, AV Club


The Prom

Ryan Fujitani

How is Meryl Streep?

Streep is transcendent… a genuine campy hoot.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Streep is consistently hilarious.
David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

Streep absolutely shines in her most endearing role in years.
Doug Jamieson, The Jam Report

Meryl Streep is having the most fun in years as she revels in her character’s awfulness.
Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

As fantastic as every cast member is — and there isn’t a dud in the bunch — it’s still Streep’s show.
Jude Dry, IndieWire


And James Corden?

I don’t think he has ever been better.
Scott Menzel, We Live Entertainment

He burrows so deeply into the character’s quibbling insouciance that he gives him a three-dimensional essence. He’s soulfully funny and touching.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety

Corden’s performance feels the most like a caricature and comes across as especially calculated, with some moments landing with comedic heft but most of them not.
Lewis Knight, Daily Mirror

It’s a flat performance without much heart… This is a role that cries out for Nathan Lane.
David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

Murphy made a major error in the casting of James Corden as the musical’s gay male lead character… a flaw that undoes a lot of the good work elsewhere. Corden camp[s] it up to the point of being regressive and offensive… His performance comes across as dated and strikes a sour note.
Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy


Jo Ellen Pellman and Ariana Debose in The Prom

(Photo by Melinda Sue Gordon/Netflix)

And what about their young castmates?

I would certainly be remiss if I did not mention newcomer Jo Ellen Pellman who absolutely steals every scene that she is in.
Scott Menzel, We Live Entertainment

[Pelllman is] “one of the discoveries of the year.
Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

Pellman makes an assured debut. Yet it’s DeBose who turns in a star-making performance.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Pellman holds her own throughout, plus she and DeBose… form a dynamic pairing essential to the film’s aspirational themes.
Brian Truitt, USA Today


Does Pellman’s Emma get enough screen time?

The film really sparkles when [Pellman and DeBose] are in the spotlight. If only the focus was on them more often.
Emily Maskell, Little White Lies

Where’s Emma in all of this?… The Prom doesn’t seem especially interested in accepting Emma as an individual person.
Jesse Hassenger, AV Club

This, though, is Emma’s story, and she gets lost in the mix…the character feels thin.
Ben Travis, Empire Magazine

It’s a shame the film doesn’t spend more time with Emma as a character as this is truly her story, even if sometimes the Broadway divas are more fun.
Lewis Knight, Daily Mirror

The movie belongs not to the people with the painful problem, who actually overcome something difficult, but the quartet of invaders… The film has way too much in common with the egomaniacs at its center.
Mary Sollosi, Entertainment Weekly


The Prom

(Photo by Melinda Sue Gordon/Netflix)

Does it convey its message convincingly?

The Prom is very much a movie about “the two Americas,” and part of its luster is that it portrays the conservative Midwestern one with dignity, even as it attacks the impulses of bigotry.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety

Bob Martin and Chad Beguelin’s script goes as soft as cafeteria Jell-O when it comes to the Indiana crowd.
Thom Geier, The Wrap

Its core message of inclusivity and tolerance is more than welcome, even if it’s more fun to watch the self-absorbed Broadway stars learn their lessons than the PTA come to heel.
Fionnuala Halligan, Screen International

The Prom is better at satirically skewering Broadway than it is at seriously skewering homophobia, which feels like a missed opportunity.
Ben Travis, Empire Magazine


Should you keep the tissues handy?

There won’t be a dry eye in the house come the finale.
Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

I’ve watched the film twice already, and I teared up both times.
Scott Menzel, We Live Entertainment

The tear-jerking climax is worth the wait, despite the choppy waters along the way.
Lewis Knight, Daily Mirror


The Prom

(Photo by Melinda Sue Gordon/Netflix)

Is The Prom the perfect way to end 2020?

After the year we’ve all had, Netflix’s glorious musical comedy The Prom couldn’t have come at a better time.
Brian Truitt, USA Today

This is a feel great musical extravaganza that is exactly what the world needs in 2020.
Scott Menzel, We Live Entertainment

The Prom is everything you need right now.
Jude Dry, IndieWire

[It’s] an eye-poppingly vibrant finale to a grim year.
Ben Travis, Empire Magazine


The Prom premieres on Netflix on Friday, December 11, 2020.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Dark Horse Comics natural history batman Infographic 2020 all-time festival south america screen actors guild Film ghosts Disney Plus Film Festival nature Family Disney streaming service Mary Poppins Returns toy story facebook dc Food Network Anna Paquin harry potter The Academy cooking golden globes Reality Competition MTV films SDCC Captain marvel pirates of the caribbean psycho science fiction Comics on TV cancelled TV series talk show jurassic park sag awards comic deadpool slashers The Purge twilight Lucasfilm History TV Amazon Prime fast and furious American Society of Cinematographers Awards Tour cops green book FXX 2018 Polls and Games child's play revenge venice scary movies documentary Shondaland Star Wars miniseries MSNBC Country archives movie Starz Trailer vampires Funimation Tarantino Grammys anthology TCM Lifetime Christmas movies 71st Emmy Awards documentaries Holidays Emmys ID rotten movies we love HBO Go Paramount Plus sequel finale FX on Hulu Toys chucky Columbia Pictures President Logo Elton John Pride Month Horror reviews spider-man Vudu crime thriller technology Pop TV Quiz ABC Signature supernatural Nat Geo video Chernobyl Best and Worst TCA Chilling Adventures of Sabrina italian Netflix Christmas movies OWN TBS Spike TruTV BBC America unscripted YouTube VH1 binge Musical women hispanic USA Turner Classic Movies Tomatazos fresh zombie game show Creative Arts Emmys LGBT A&E comedies social media Freeform thriller transformers 2016 cancelled Bravo Comedy HBO Max AMC nbcuniversal spain Alien animated Kids & Family Extras biography japanese doctor who directors ABC DirecTV Superheroes elevated horror kids SXSW 4/20 rom-coms space A24 Television Academy CNN HBO The Walt Disney Company travel singing competition mockumentary Schedule NYCC canceled TV shows cartoon Song of Ice and Fire Sci-Fi Arrowverse boxoffice OneApp Nominations composers free movies Fox News Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt CBS best series The CW justice league criterion Crackle Apple Biopics Showtime stoner james bond sequels halloween Election festivals YouTube Red renewed TV shows Pirates Lionsgate Sundance TV Walt Disney Pictures franchise politics Photos dragons parents dogs El Rey Sundance Now concert Cosplay rotten DC streaming service ViacomCBS Thanksgiving Premiere Dates Crunchyroll hist strong female leads USA Network SundanceTV Trivia Fantasy classics Epix Martial Arts universal monsters Mary Tyler Moore Ellie Kemper ratings E3 Awards black war Red Carpet Cannes Countdown Warner Bros. hollywood christmas movies Esquire RT History Masterpiece Winter TV Drama spanish Animation game of thrones Academy Awards Spring TV dceu Music jamie lee curtis Apple TV Plus spinoff Oscars Netflix Mindy Kaling Year in Review medical drama cinemax Cartoon Network laika comics theme song TIFF Stephen King comic books ITV Rocky television DC Universe what to watch Avengers indiana jones Amazon superhero Women's History Month stop motion stand-up comedy critics ABC Family MCU serial killer Star Trek Turner 99% VOD Hear Us Out blaxploitation rt archives First Look 45 Watching Series Acorn TV TCA Winter 2020 2019 robots name the review Hulu breaking bad PBS streaming Classic Film LGBTQ cancelled television versus Set visit First Reviews RT21 CMT discovery Rom-Com New York Comic Con Valentine's Day FOX Western Christmas crime dark Endgame Discovery Channel golden globe awards quibi obituary casting Rock Rocketman 2017 2015 FX Superheroe worst movies indie BBC One TNT richard e. Grant toronto trailers Musicals GLAAD Winners TV renewals historical drama Fall TV zero dark thirty Teen Holiday adaptation NBC 007 Pet Sematary BET comiccon joker Character Guide Lifetime Video Games crime drama Podcast Sony Pictures emmy awards IFC Films football teaser Spectrum Originals The Walking Dead TCA Awards cars romance Pop cancelled TV shows crossover Ghostbusters dramedy E! GoT spy thriller a nightmare on elm street Opinion boxing canceled based on movie nfl tv talk Universal foreign asian-american Tumblr worst mutant Binge Guide scorecard political drama Hallmark Christmas movies CBS All Access Super Bowl Heroines mission: impossible 20th Century Fox Pixar YouTube Premium movies WarnerMedia anime Disney Channel police drama Sneak Peek Marvel werewolf Apple TV+ 72 Emmy Awards Marvel Television Brie Larson Nickelodeon disaster Disney VICE witnail Amazon Prime Video See It Skip It independent 21st Century Fox Travel Channel Adult Swim Comedy Central Television Critics Association remakes zombies CW Seed TCA 2017 Emmy Nominations Fox Searchlight Hallmark APB Britbox National Geographic GIFs australia docudrama cats period drama Black Mirror video on demand satire award winner 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards TV One Disney+ Disney Plus Reality BET Awards halloween tv PlayStation Mystery die hard X-Men Baby Yoda Comic Book sports aliens BAFTA Action PaleyFest WGN Interview Box Office Mudbound children's TV french Shudder BBC cults romantic comedy psychological thriller Certified Fresh Trophy Talk YA adventure Amazon Studios San Diego Comic-Con Ovation 24 frames Tubi DC Comics true crime screenings diversity Paramount Network Syfy The Witch book Mary poppins TLC Paramount Summer Peacock IFC spanish language DGA Calendar Sundance Marathons blockbuster news Black History Month Writers Guild of America ESPN reboot Marvel Studios sitcom TV Land latino The Arrangement