The King of Staten Island First Reviews: A Little Long, but Judd Apatow's Best Film in a Decade

Critics say the comedy starring and co-written by SNL's Pete Davidson is a natural fit for its star and sparks great work from its cast, even if it's a tad long.

by | June 8, 2020 | Comments

The King of Staten Island, the latest directorial effort from Judd Apatow (The 40-Year-Old Virgin, Knocked Up) arrives exclusively on VOD on June 12th. The movie was co-written by and stars Saturday Night Live cast member Pete Davidson, whose life story serves loosely as the basis for the film. Initial reviews are calling it one of the filmmaker’s best in years for its dramatic maturity — apparently this isn’t exactly another laugh-out-loud comedy — and for the winning supporting cast more than for its central star. Of course, this is an Apatow movie, so criticisms about its length are to be expected.

Here’s what critics are saying about The King of State Island:

How does it compare to Judd Apatow’s other films?

His best film since 2009’s Funny People.
– David Ehrlich, IndieWire

It’s surely the best Apatow movie since Funny People, and maybe even since Knocked Up.
– Kyle Pinion, The Beat

Never has Apatow been so on point collaborating with another creative to make a fully-formed vision that isn’t just a hilarious experience. The King of Staten Island is the most technically proficient work of his entire career.
– James Clay, Fresh Fiction

The movie deserves credit for skewing a little darker than the usual Apatow conclusion.
– Brett Arnold, Consequence of Sound

It’s the director’s most emotionally attuned and narrowly focused work.
– Jordan Raup, The Film Stage

If The King of Staten Island is the director’s least overtly comedic effort, it’s also probably his least sentimental.
– Jon Frosch, Hollywood Reporter

It’s an arrested development story, but it also shows that Apatow is growing up.
– Matt Goldberg, Collider

Pete Davidson and Judd Apatow on the set of The King of Staten Island

(Photo by Kevin Mazur/©Universal Pictures)

How is Pete Davidson’s Performance?

Davidson is a triumph in The King of Staten Island.
Molly Freeman, ScreenRant

On the basis of The King of Staten Island, I couldn’t tell you if he could carry a whole movie that wasn’t about his own life – but he definitely carries this one.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

He certainly has comic timing and screen presence, and yet I don’t know if he has the range to play characters that don’t mirror his own life and experiences.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

His range as an actor may not turn out to be as wide as his wingspan, but the numb vulnerability he shares here makes for a performance that might as well be seeping out of his skin.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

While no one will confuse him for Laurence Olivier anytime soon, Davidson does have a breezy charm that affixes his personal connection to the material and engages throughout.
Kyle Pinion, The Beat

Davidson, it turns out, is a fine leading man. Loose and expressive, he strikes a balance of droll loutishness and sensitivity that never tips over into Sandler-esque clowning or cloying.
Jon Frosch, Hollywood Reporter

The ensemble allows Davidson to play off of other actors in different ways to ideally give the young comic a chance to shine.
Aaron Neuwirth, We Live Entertainment

While he sparks with an irreverent punch line here or there, there’s not enough liveliness in this maudlin role for Davidson to dazzle in.
Kristy Puchko, IGN

Pete Davidson and Bill Burr in The King of Staten Island

(Photo by Mary Cybulski/©Universal Pictures)

And the rest of the cast?

Even though this is supposed to be Davidson’s big coming-out party, it’s the cast around him who gets to truly shine. [Marisa] Tomei, an always-welcomed presence, is phenomenal.
Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

One of the best things about The King of Staten Island is the supporting cast and their performances apart from Davidson, especially Bill Burr.
Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews

Bill Burr steals the movie.
Roger Moore, Movie Nation

A better [movie] whenever Burr is on screen, especially when he’s with Tomei.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

While it’s too early to imagine what this year’s awards season is going to be like, [Burr] deserves some serious recognition for his performance.
Chris Bumbray, JoBlo

Moises Arias puts in a brilliant turn as Scott’s eternally bewildered friend.
Linda Marric, HeyUGuys

One wishes [Bel Powley’s] character was more fully-formed, particularly considering how heavily she figures into the film’s final moments.
Jordan Raup, The Film Stage

Is the movie funny?

It goes without saying that the movie is pretty funny.
Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews

There are a handful of laugh-out-loud moments throughout Staten Island and one screamingly-funny extended sequence that winds up influencing a great deal of the plot.
Brett Arnold, Consequence of Sound

There are few out-and-out comedic set pieces; the humor appears out of honest and sometimes intense conversations.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

The King of Staten Island is more of an indie drama that happens to have some really sharp jokes.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

There’s nothing here that’s going to stick with you – the next great quotable comedy this is not.
Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

If you go in expecting Apatow’s usual comedic flair you may be disappointed as the laughs aren’t as numerous as his previous films. However…it is nonetheless entertaining.
Allison Rose, FlickDirect

Pete Davidson in The King of Staten Island

(Photo by Mary Cybulski/©Universal Pictures)

Is the running time a problem?

The King of Staten Island is inexcusably overlong.
Brett Arnold, Consequence of Sound

There is no reason for this movie to be this long, especially when it’s telling a story that has been told ample times before.
Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews

The movie, juggling too many narrative priorities over an overlong 137 minutes, seems to succumb to Scott’s own sense of aimlessness as much as it depicts it.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

The real issue is not the running time, but that you feel it.
Kristy Puchko, IGN

I never got bored or wanted Apatow to wrap things up. If anything I wanted to spend more time with some of the supporting characters.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

The editing by Jay Cassidy keeps the plotting from going off the skids while staying true to Apatow’s signature improvisational style.
James Clay, Fresh Fiction

Does it get better as it goes?

The movie’s second half is more compelling than it’s first.
Chris Bumbray, JoBlo

While certainly Apatow hoped the overlong first half would match the fecklessness of Scott’s life, it’s a hard slog… Without a sense of direction in the dark comedy’s first half, the heartfelt second half nearly arrives unnoticed.
Robert Daniels, 812 Film Reviews

Moises Arias, Ricky Velez, and Pete Davidson in The King of Staten Island

(Photo by Mary Cybulski/©Universal Pictures)

Will it make for a good rental at home?

It’s the kind of soul-bearing filmmaking that’s at least worthy of a weekend view in your own home.
Kyle Pinion, The Beat

Having this story exist on streaming exclusively seems oddly appropriate. Davidson is the comedian for this generation, and most of his die-hard fans would rather catch up with him at home anyways.
James Clay, Fresh Fiction

A pretty apt film for home viewing; something to dip in and out of, perhaps, while you’re gaming, ordering pizza to your mother’s basement, or having a lazy lockdown.
Fionnuala Halligan, Screen International

Viewers stuck at home won’t go wrong with The King of Staten Island – a dramedy that delivers both laugh-out-loud comedy and entertaining drama.
Molly Freeman, ScreenRant

The King of Staten Island premieres on VOD on Friday, June 12.

Adjusted Score: 86.641%
Critics Consensus: The King of Staten Island's uncertain tone and indulgent length blunt this coming-of-age dramedy's ability to find itself, but Pete Davidson's soulful performance holds it together.
Synopsis: Scott (Pete Davidson) has been a case of arrested development ever since his firefighter father died when he was seven.... [More]
Directed By: Judd Apatow

Tag Cloud

Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt singing competition Sundance dc Food Network Quiz VICE hispanic Starz Sundance Now USA Network scary movies ratings name the review christmas movies dragons Year in Review 21st Century Fox Fox Searchlight See It Skip It 2018 video on demand spider-man versus WarnerMedia reboot Comic Book docudrama Britbox 71st Emmy Awards Mary Tyler Moore unscripted Kids & Family American Society of Cinematographers 2017 Paramount Network Interview adventure TCA Awards GoT Crunchyroll Hallmark Christmas movies Academy Awards DGA PBS japanese concert stop motion Universal Pride Month directors BBC America comics Binge Guide fresh Sneak Peek teaser El Rey Masterpiece stoner ID Creative Arts Emmys Peacock Fantasy Tarantino psycho chucky The Purge Stephen King Schedule movie Valentine's Day rotten Summer zombie Pet Sematary Martial Arts Election Captain marvel FOX Disney Channel OWN video elevated horror Video Games TLC Grammys ABC Family DC Comics A&E venice dceu Podcast 99% crime thriller A24 Awards FX on Hulu festivals asian-american Dark Horse Comics PaleyFest mission: impossible dogs YouTube comedies ABC what to watch TCA Winter 2020 travel 2015 Brie Larson french quibi free movies indie miniseries screen actors guild Family classics serial killer laika Warner Bros. reviews DC streaming service Reality Competition Epix DC Universe deadpool Certified Fresh children's TV hollywood 72 Emmy Awards franchise Set visit Amazon Prime Marvel Television transformers screenings Hallmark Mindy Kaling Black Mirror films TCM YA Spectrum Originals Elton John crime drama Vudu archives boxoffice BBC sitcom Heroines VH1 strong female leads Super Bowl spy thriller Superheroe X-Men SXSW Rocketman Spring TV Columbia Pictures documentary SundanceTV cats 20th Century Fox MTV crossover MCU cancelled Mudbound Calendar stand-up comedy best Holiday crime dramedy Biopics ghosts revenge composers Marvel Studios Women's History Month aliens Red Carpet criterion Television Academy USA batman a nightmare on elm street Toys Bravo First Reviews superhero Emmys cinemax comiccon 2016 Lionsgate CNN First Look medical drama CBS Alien scorecard Film Best and Worst parents Pixar series Funimation Pop TV spanish language Nominations Adult Swim anthology HBO Go political drama Baby Yoda MSNBC spinoff Walt Disney Pictures The Academy Sci-Fi BET Awards TruTV BAFTA tv talk FX AMC Anna Paquin slashers The Walking Dead Premiere Dates Acorn TV The Arrangement Rocky Apple streaming toy story cooking TV Infographic WGN comic supernatural Mystery Thanksgiving NBC Marvel RT21 YouTube Premium cops emmy awards Lifetime Christmas movies diversity BET Travel Channel Mary poppins Writers Guild of America period drama Extras satire Nickelodeon Film Festival blockbuster Horror Arrowverse comic books Superheroes Syfy witnail Photos Apple TV Plus Song of Ice and Fire New York Comic Con Chernobyl mutant Cartoon Network The Witch CW Seed PlayStation book LGBT Endgame finale politics natural history APB justice league discovery GLAAD Netflix Lucasfilm award winner Amazon Studios space south america anime Turner Classic Movies Spike 2020 Reality cancelled TV series police drama VOD National Geographic Disney Plus Sony Pictures History Discovery Channel italian Comics on TV TV renewals Fox News Lifetime San Diego Comic-Con Esquire theme song Christmas halloween SDCC universal monsters cancelled TV shows NYCC Shudder science fiction Freeform mockumentary canceled Turner Musicals sag awards Ovation TBS IFC Films Ellie Kemper based on movie news hist renewed TV shows FXX Tubi spanish TCA 2017 YouTube Red cancelled television Logo child's play adaptation australia Watching Series Rock IFC game show independent breaking bad black ESPN harry potter all-time CBS All Access HBO Drama blaxploitation festival thriller TCA Teen LGBTQ critics die hard President Opinion The CW latino nbcuniversal E! Sundance TV Netflix Christmas movies cults Winter TV halloween tv football Marathons movies Tomatazos historical drama Black History Month joker Nat Geo Apple TV+ toronto Polls and Games BBC One Awards Tour Countdown canceled TV shows cars foreign Country Action jamie lee curtis remakes psychological thriller Trivia spain 007 Classic Film RT History Cosplay indiana jones Ghostbusters Animation animated Disney Trailer zombies E3 Western technology romance TIFF social media werewolf Chilling Adventures of Sabrina rt archives documentaries Mary Poppins Returns Tumblr Cannes binge romantic comedy Holidays Showtime Emmy Nominations richard e. Grant HBO Max CMT worst green book kids cartoon rotten movies we love television nfl Pop sequel vampires TV Land war 24 frames Trophy Talk DirecTV Box Office Amazon Prime Video TNT casting Musical nature Comedy robots Winners fast and furious sequels zero dark thirty Hear Us Out 45 Star Trek Music james bond Star Wars Pirates biography Character Guide ITV talk show doctor who facebook Rom-Com Comedy Central Hulu Oscars Disney streaming service Crackle worst movies dark true crime golden globes disaster Avengers sports obituary Fall TV boxing Paramount 2019 Television Critics Association game of thrones OneApp GIFs Disney+ Disney Plus Shondaland 4/20 Amazon twilight