Critics Consensus

The Hunt Isn't as Wild as It Thinks

Plus, Bloodshot is a (franchise) non-starter, I Still Believe is earnest but sanitized, and Never Rarely Somtimes Always is Certified Fresh.

by | March 12, 2020 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got evil elites (The Hunt, starring Betty Gilpin and Hilary Swank), a super soldier (Bloodshot, starring Vin Diesel and Guy Pearce), and a Christian courtship (I Still Believe, starring K.J. Apa and Britt Robertson). What are the critics saying?


The Hunt (2020) 57%

Author Richard Connell’s 1924 short story The Most Dangerous Game, in which a big-game hunter is hunted by a Russian aristocrat on a remote island, has been adapted for the screen several times since its publication, and more than a few of those films have taken creative liberties with the source material. In 1972’s The Woman Hunt, there were multiple victims, and they were all women; 1987’s Slave Girls from Beyond Infinity set the action in space; and 1993’s Hard Target gave us Jean-Claude Van Damme in a mullet. The latest alternate take on the story comes to us via The Hunt, which casts a gaggle of insufferable “liberal elites” as the hunters and a dozen “deplorables” as their prey. Originally slated for release in September of 2019, the film was delayed in the wake of mass shootings in Dayton, OH and El Paso, TX, as well as some high-profile backlash from none other than Donald Trump himself. Presumably, the dust has settled enough that Universal feels comfortable releasing the film, and critics say it’s kind of a mixed bag. Taken on its own merits as an action thriller infused with pitch-black comedy, it’s not bad, but its efforts to skewer the political divide largely miss the mark, resulting in clumsy attempts at social satire and exaggerated caricatures that are difficult for anyone to relate to. GLOW star Betty Gilpin handles herself admirably in the central heroic role, and there’s plenty of blood and guts to go around on all sides, but if there’s anything to get riled up about here, it’s that the end result wasn’t a smarter movie.


Bloodshot (2020) 30%

Marvel and DC obviously aren’t the only two purveyors of comic book fare around, but they are the most popular, so it’s easy to forget there are others out there trying to get a piece of the superhero franchise pie. Enter Valiant Comics’ Bloodshot, a marine who is brutally murdered but brought back to life by scientists hoping to create a super-soldier with the help of nanotechnology. Vin Diesel stars in the big-screen adaptation as Ray Garrison, the marine in question, who at first struggles to recall anything from his past life, but once he does, he embarks on a bloody mission of vengeance. Diesel already has a few action franchises under his belt, including the Chronicles of Riddick movies, the xXx movies, and, of course, the hugely popular Fast and Furious series, and Bloodshot is ostensibly an attempt to jump-start another. Unfortunately, while critics say Diesel is fairly compelling as the anti-hero here and Guy Pearce plays his role as the mad scientist with relish, neither is quiet capable of compensating for the film’s over-reliance on shopworn action cliches and bland CGI spectacle. That said, it may appeal to undemanding audiences in search of little more than a few cheap thrills.


I Still Believe (2020) 51%

It’s no secret that faith-based films have a fairly spotty track record when it comes to critical reception, but they frequently rely on ham-fisted narratives built upon performances of varying quality. At the very least, this week’s I Still Believe benefits from the presence of stars like Britt Robertson, Riverdale‘s K.J. Apa, and Gary Sinise, and instead of swinging wildly at rhetorical straw men, the film takes its cues from a true story, namely that of Christian music megastar Jeremy Camp. Based on his memoir of the same name, the film follows the singer-songwriter as he moves from Indiana to California for college and falls in love with his first wife, Melissa Lynn Henning. Not long after, Melissa is diagnosed with terminal cancer, and the couple decide to face the grim diagnosis together. While critics aren’t calling I Still Believe a triumph in filmmaking, they aren’t saying it’s a complete disaster either. It has its moments of affecting drama, and the more hopeful elements of the story can be inspiring. At the same time, the film is so sanitized that it’s somewhat robbed of its humanity, and like many faith-based films before it, it caters so specifically to a niche audience that few outside that circle are likely to find it a worthwhile watch.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Never Rarely Sometimes Always (2020) , a drama about two girls in rural Pennsylvania who travel to New York to end an unwanted pregnancy, is Certified Fresh at 100%.
  • Human Nature (2019) , a documentary about the gene-altering capabilities of CRISPR technology, is at 100%.
  • Heimat is a Space in Time (2019) , German documentarian Thomas Heise’s exploration of his own family’s history dating back over a century, is at 100%.
  • Inside the Rain (2019) , a comedy drama about a college student attempting to recreate on film an incident that might result in his expulsion, is at 100%.
  • Tokyo Godfathers (2003) , Satoshi Kon’s animated 2003 drama about a trio of homeless people in Tokyo who discover an abandoned baby on Christmas Eve, is Certified Fresh at 90% and remastered for a limited re-release.
  • The Dog Doc (2019) , a documentary about a New York veterinarian who practices holistic care alongside traditional medicine, is at 90%.
  • Big Time Adolescence (2019) , starring Pete Davidson in a coming-of-age comedy about a high schooler who falls under the questionable influence of his sister’s college dropout ex-boyfriend, is at 89%.
  • Lost Transmissions (2019) , starring Juno Temple and Simon Pegg in a drama about a young songwriter trying to track down her schizophrenic producer so he can get some help for his condition, is at 80%.
  • Lost Girls (2020) , starring Amy Ryan and Thomasin McKenzie in a drama about a desperate mother who reveals the truth behind a string of unsolved murders when her daughter goes missing, is at 62%.
  • Miss Fisher and the Crypt of Tears (2020) , starring Essie Davis as the titular early 20th century detective in a big screen continuation of the popular Australian TV drama, is at 36%.
  • The Roads Not Taken (2020) , starring Javier Bardem and Elle Fanning in a drama about a father-daughter duo dealing with the father’s advanced dementia, is at 33%.
  • The Postcard Killings (2020) , starring Jeffrey Dean Morgan in an adaptation of the James Patterson novel about a detective looking into the murder of his daughter and son-in-law in London, is at 0%.

Thumbnail image by Universal Pictures

Tag Cloud

game show theme song versus Women's History Month rt labs critics edition TCA Winter 2020 Disney Channel teaser directors NBA aliens dceu Sundance Shudder Marathons heist movie Tubi Sony Pictures popular rom-coms Awards christmas movies french TV One historical drama comic book movies TIFF talk show kids spanish language adaptation Comedy Central 45 Ghostbusters 007 movie ViacomCBS Western prank TV rotten movies we love Fall TV Elton John Ovation Country legend Valentine's Day YouTube Red concert rt labs japan based on movie cooking Quiz CBS All Access TNT Nickelodeon zombies Lionsgate deadpool mockumentary die hard news posters elevated horror Premiere Dates GLAAD telelvision Musical war sequels 1990s jurassic park Podcast spinoff Action Sundance TV Esquire book adaptation Chernobyl Britbox finale National Geographic ABC Signature IFC new york werewolf razzies scary movies pirates of the caribbean Super Bowl Netflix monster movies sag awards 2015 dexter Rocky politics DGA witnail Avengers 99% new zealand venice Columbia Pictures Turner Classic Movies Lifetime Christmas movies indie Tumblr Certified Fresh transformers Holidays psycho TLC nfl The Walking Dead nature Paramount Hulu BET Awards Binge Guide psychological thriller award winner gangster ID Marvel suspense crime thriller video GoT comic books stand-up comedy obituary festival vampires Disney A&E reviews sequel young adult hispanic heritage month adventure know your critic Nominations Pet Sematary BAFTA Pop TV animated The CW archives breaking bad screenings CMT cults police drama cancelled television Legendary cancelled TV shows Polls and Games halloween tv Arrowverse History docudrama Toys HBO Go Trophy Talk See It Skip It Tarantino Fox News HBO Infographic saw OneApp Musicals YA superhero Exclusive Video Masterpiece Netflix Christmas movies classics spanish FXX lord of the rings Apple TV Plus Disney Plus 2021 Drama casting CBS video on demand Cannes USA Network Spectrum Originals Tokyo Olympics streaming hidden camera Universal PBS nbcuniversal documentary rotten comedies Syfy foreign streaming movies PaleyFest Funimation aapi screen actors guild renewed TV shows action-comedy indiana jones Mary poppins asian-american 4/20 strong female leads Hear Us Out chucky ratings Summer justice league singing competition kaiju Television Critics Association Family VICE Character Guide tv talk Thanksgiving NYCC royal family toy story spider-man El Rey USA RT History discovery Fox Searchlight 2017 Lifetime marvel cinematic universe harry potter Sci-Fi American Society of Cinematographers stop motion reboot Election robots Oscars FOX comic book movie Comedy Photos Kids & Family Amazon Prime Video marvel comics critics 71st Emmy Awards olympics A24 72 Emmy Awards Sundance Now basketball composers Rocketman ghosts sports scorecard golden globe awards BBC One Comics on TV APB Television Academy Academy Awards women Apple TV+ jamie lee curtis Emmys Bravo Fantasy Extras cops rt archives comic technology Classic Film biopic satire Discovery Channel quibi facebook cars TCM universal monsters comics hispanic new star wars movies Endgame Superheroes Christmas toronto all-time Grammys BBC RT21 Broadway hist President San Diego Comic-Con criterion Interview The Witch CNN king arthur Holiday cinemax worst diversity Teen Shondaland Spike Set visit Anna Paquin Red Carpet HBO Max Turner fresh MTV Crackle Wes Anderson disaster canceled mutant SDCC period drama Trailer cartoon VH1 Peacock ABC 2020 blaxploitation Sneak Peek cancelled TV series batman Biopics 93rd Oscars Animation spain Freeform dc Paramount Network Walt Disney Pictures Marvel Studios Warner Bros. TV Land VOD emmy awards Dark Horse Comics Comic-Con@Home 2021 Mary Poppins Returns slasher BET dark Apple docuseries social media Hallmark SundanceTV comiccon zero dark thirty Creative Arts Emmys Amazon Studios Martial Arts MSNBC live action Star Trek Superheroe Pride Month debate ITV cancelled Star Wars Rom-Com OWN Rock unscripted crime dragons Awards Tour cats biography child's play Mudbound Reality Film parents YouTube Premium australia AMC anthology Lucasfilm Marvel Television crime drama Writers Guild of America FX on Hulu blockbusters New York Comic Con anime Travel Channel DC streaming service Cosplay medical drama E! kong joker E3 Song of Ice and Fire trailers 24 frames thriller CW Seed halloween doctor who romance 73rd Emmy Awards what to watch series 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards book First Look ABC Family Crunchyroll Winter TV Trivia YouTube Hallmark Christmas movies LGBT zombie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Music Cartoon Network TV movies NBC Stephen King serial killer remakes Alien Baby Yoda green book Vudu golden globes TCA 2017 wonder woman Opinion superman Pixar scene in color PlayStation japanese high school blockbuster Food Network documentaries target slashers FX twilight football 90s mcc Video Games Logo Reality Competition BBC America 21st Century Fox TCA revenge Mary Tyler Moore Calendar Amazon Prime independent Black Mirror latino Adult Swim hollywood crossover laika Spring TV The Academy Amazon 20th Century Fox Mindy Kaling Nat Geo king kong name the review X-Men MCU feel good Image Comics Showtime boxoffice Best and Worst Pop Epix south america stoner dogs movies WarnerMedia The Purge Countdown Disney+ Disney Plus SXSW Captain marvel TCA Awards canceled TV shows true crime sitcom children's TV space dramedy DC Universe Watching Series Disney streaming service Pirates boxing supernatural Comic Book LGBTQ natural history Ellie Kemper Black History Month Winners travel The Walt Disney Company television films Starz The Arrangement miniseries Box Office Year in Review Heroines james bond godzilla black game of thrones IFC Films Tomatazos franchise Paramount Plus best TV renewals Mystery mission: impossible fast and furious Acorn TV critic resources WGN GIFs adenture festivals DC Comics science fiction ESPN DirecTV romantic comedy Pacific Islander Horror First Reviews 2016 binge italian Chilling Adventures of Sabrina a nightmare on elm street 2019 Brie Larson Emmy Nominations Film Festival international richard e. Grant Schedule TruTV spy thriller free movies political drama TBS worst movies 2018