Showdowns

Supernatural vs. Scooby-Doo

They're some of entertainment's most long-running monster hunters, but which team is greatest? We're breaking it down by Tomatometer, popularity, and more.

by | April 27, 2020 | Comments

Got a ghost problem? A rogue vampire keeping you up at night? A spawn of Satan disturbing your peace? If so, there are two teams you can rely on to crack the case: The Winchester Brothers of TV’s Supernatural or the “Scooby Gang” and its hilarious namesake, Scooby-Doo. But which is better suited to solve your supernatural issues? In our latest episode of Vs., we’re pitting the long-running series Supernatural against everything Scooby-Doo – the original cartoon, its spin-offs, and the live-action movies. Which mystery-solvers are more popular with the people and the critics? Which franchise features the richest characters? And which team has faced off against the most dastardly villains? Find out as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks it down to decide whether you should hop in the Mystery Van or the Winchesters’ Chevy when the ghouls come a-calling.

As ever, if you don’t agree with our choice of winner, let us have it in the comments.


Scoob! will be released digitally May 15, 2020. Supernatural airs on the CW, next air dates are unknown. 

#1

SCOOB! (2020)
48%

#1
Adjusted Score: 56948%
Critics Consensus: Scoob! is fun enough for youthful viewers and some hardcore fans, but never quite solves the mystery of why audiences shouldn't watch old episodes instead.
Synopsis: With hundreds of cases solved and adventures shared, Scooby and the gang face their biggest, most challenging mystery ever --... [More]
Directed By: Tony Cervone

Thumbnail: CW / © Warner Bros.

Tag Cloud

dramedy award winner 4/20 reboot New York Comic Con Logo asian-american ABC Signature hispanic razzies hispanic heritage month book adaptation Anna Paquin Lifetime YA rom-coms Academy Awards Holidays Grammys christmas movies APB 2020 Podcast doctor who Premiere Dates Mindy Kaling action-comedy live action medical drama 73rd Emmy Awards Tumblr streaming witnail Certified Fresh Star Trek CNN spain joker Disney streaming service new zealand video Rock Best and Worst Sundance Box Office harry potter football E3 PlayStation scary TV renewals casting dexter Apple Valentine's Day TV Land boxing toronto Broadway rotten movies we love kaiju Marvel Studios Sci-Fi Masterpiece movies vs. Crackle biography mission: impossible rt archives reviews Paramount Music Countdown archives PBS anime ITV El Rey Mary Poppins Returns Pop TV Writers Guild of America Schedule A24 Spectrum Originals 1990s versus indiana jones Pet Sematary chucky movie ABC Family comic Vudu Horror Action police drama Disney+ Disney Plus sequels FXX docudrama parents critic resources Star Wars BET cancelled TV series robots Character Guide Amazon Prime spinoff renewed TV shows lord of the rings Disney Channel Paramount Plus documentaries screen actors guild dc diversity cults directors nature child's play young adult Walt Disney Pictures USA tv talk godzilla high school halloween tv Columbia Pictures dogs Shondaland Thanksgiving Wes Anderson Ovation latino BBC America dceu Calendar video on demand Freeform festival GLAAD TNT Legendary TCA Winter 2020 finale comiccon children's TV Summer Winter TV Disney Plus HBO PaleyFest Showtime Captain marvel 007 Drama jamie lee curtis Exclusive Video ESPN game of thrones See It Skip It Creative Arts Emmys NYCC SXSW zero dark thirty stoner popular HBO Max green book pirates of the caribbean italian Netflix criterion The Academy Arrowverse telelvision stop motion boxoffice Neflix WarnerMedia Trailer IFC Films Emmys mutant BAFTA Lionsgate Infographic 20th Century Fox jurassic park DGA Dark Horse Comics crossover blockbusters Cannes First Reviews Toys Holiday comic books nbcuniversal CW Seed indie dark Ghostbusters scorecard Comic Book based on movie golden globes Brie Larson Television Critics Association FX scary movies japanese Tokyo Olympics Fox Searchlight fast and furious Universal debate AMC Hallmark Christmas movies Marvel Kids & Family Black Mirror Apple TV+ king kong prank war VH1 2018 American Society of Cinematographers Mary Tyler Moore Photos Paramount Network Nat Geo biopic TV movies The Walt Disney Company talk show facebook true crime politics deadpool singing competition The CW Endgame marvel comics theme song Sundance TV festivals anthology ID 93rd Oscars psychological thriller Quiz nfl independent WGN zombie Starz quibi Avengers target james bond 24 frames black comedy hollywood TIFF Mystery classics Lucasfilm historical drama Christmas news Travel Channel CMT twilight Epix FX on Hulu Interview werewolf miniseries NBA universal monsters 45 21st Century Fox king arthur Amazon Prime Video series vampires Teen Musical political drama Tomatazos The Arrangement Heroines Cosplay TCA Awards CBS All Access Shudder Extras Britbox VOD Trivia dreamworks richard e. Grant Musicals space President BBC Mary poppins sitcom Film Festival crime drama Instagram Live blaxploitation heist movie Comedy Set visit TruTV Year in Review elevated horror Image Comics adenture SundanceTV Oscars Fox News screenings Watching Series The Witch cats 2017 worst The Walking Dead Family National Geographic Sundance Now TV Pacific Islander MCU TCA 2017 films Chilling Adventures of Sabrina mob Election Amazon sopranos Spring TV justice league comedies crime Sony Pictures Alien DC Universe comic book movie technology TBS south america San Diego Comic-Con Pirates concert thriller Black History Month best Adult Swim 2015 stand-up comedy cops royal family Rocketman cancelled TV shows breaking bad Reality E! Rom-Com Animation GoT 90s LGBTQ worst movies cooking feel good Emmy Nominations Biopics Rocky trailers what to watch venice Pride Month Classic Film Winners monster movies Nickelodeon hidden camera science fiction franchise Hulu comics Country live event animated teaser cartoon strong female leads obituary new star wars movies 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Turner Classic Movies First Look foreign TLC know your critic discovery cancelled television disaster emmy awards superman NBC television Trophy Talk VICE Chernobyl rt labs Fall TV Video Games Fargo CBS cancelled ratings Superheroe Funimation Ellie Kemper USA Network golden globe awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt black marvel cinematic universe game show FOX Women's History Month YouTube canceled period drama Crunchyroll Apple TV Plus History 71st Emmy Awards Mudbound Reality Competition Discovery Channel Hear Us Out spy thriller sag awards BBC One Acorn TV Super Bowl Netflix Christmas movies slasher gangster Sneak Peek DC Comics Marvel Television Western ABC mockumentary Marathons Stephen King RT21 posters Comedy Central HBO Go LGBT SDCC Syfy dragons Warner Bros. documentary Comic-Con@Home 2021 cinemax toy story australia satire Opinion Esquire DC streaming service scene in color serial killer Television Academy TCA Food Network Martial Arts 99% spider-verse YouTube Red romantic comedy all-time Spike rt labs critics edition superhero MTV Turner AMC Plus Universal Pictures genre romance ghosts Comics on TV RT History batman Binge Guide mcc supernatural halloween Awards Tour rotten kong The Purge saw OneApp zombies Tarantino name the review Pixar free movies Pop olympics GIFs remakes women new york revenge streaming movies Hallmark japan X-Men basketball unscripted 2019 BET Awards hist adaptation international Peacock Baby Yoda IFC 72 Emmy Awards adventure travel Disney social media Nominations french Bravo Polls and Games sequel TCM art house spanish book psycho aapi aliens laika Elton John slashers legend Amazon Studios YouTube Premium sports Tubi IMDb TV OWN Superheroes Fantasy DirecTV blockbuster MSNBC critics wonder woman 2016 composers suspense Song of Ice and Fire spanish language die hard A&E Film fresh comic book movies spider-man binge transformers TV One kids ViacomCBS Lifetime Christmas movies 2021 Red Carpet Cartoon Network natural history a nightmare on elm street docuseries Awards canceled TV shows crime thriller cars