Showdowns

Supernatural vs. Scooby-Doo

They're some of entertainment's most long-running monster hunters, but which team is greatest? We're breaking it down by Tomatometer, popularity, and more.

by | April 27, 2020 | Comments

Got a ghost problem? A rogue vampire keeping you up at night? A spawn of Satan disturbing your peace? If so, there are two teams you can rely on to crack the case: The Winchester Brothers of TV’s Supernatural or the “Scooby Gang” and its hilarious namesake, Scooby-Doo. But which is better suited to solve your supernatural issues? In our latest episode of Vs., we’re pitting the long-running series Supernatural against everything Scooby-Doo – the original cartoon, its spin-offs, and the live-action movies. Which mystery-solvers are more popular with the people and the critics? Which franchise features the richest characters? And which team has faced off against the most dastardly villains? Find out as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks it down to decide whether you should hop in the Mystery Van or the Winchesters’ Chevy when the ghouls come a-calling.

As ever, if you don’t agree with our choice of winner, let us have it in the comments.


Scoob! will be released digitally May 15, 2020. Supernatural airs on the CW, next air dates are unknown. 

#1

Scoob! (2020)
47%

#1
Adjusted Score: 53.401%
Critics Consensus: Scoob! is fun enough for youthful viewers and some hardcore fans, but never quite solves the mystery of why audiences shouldn't watch old episodes instead.
Synopsis: "SCOOB!" reveals how lifelong friends Scooby and Shaggy first met and how they joined with young detectives Fred, Velma and... [More]
Directed By: Tony Cervone

Thumbnail: CW / © Warner Bros.

Tag Cloud

reboot Travel Channel cops TIFF children's TV Apple TV+ Creative Arts Emmys remakes Rom-Com YA Premiere Dates toronto Character Guide miniseries Freeform Black History Month TCM ITV psycho a nightmare on elm street Logo archives cartoon Opinion Countdown medical drama fresh crime thriller italian BBC halloween tv 20th Century Fox romantic comedy unscripted jamie lee curtis emmy awards 2018 Showtime james bond stop motion Cosplay Cartoon Network Sony Pictures documentaries Captain marvel sag awards latino spider-man 45 TV renewals National Geographic revenge period drama twilight political drama nbcuniversal reviews casting Spike hist Columbia Pictures classics Esquire Amazon Nat Geo Hulu Animation fast and furious deadpool dceu The Walking Dead award winner Sci-Fi FX The Academy Martial Arts Kids & Family RT21 Disney Channel ABC Family sequels Alien Peacock Star Wars Trophy Talk game of thrones nfl Black Mirror satire robots DC streaming service Action space SXSW Thanksgiving Video Games stoner criterion Crunchyroll Western video on demand Discovery Channel Endgame Amazon Prime Video Avengers Television Critics Association Marvel NYCC Netflix Christmas movies rotten movies we love best superhero PaleyFest doctor who USA Network VICE franchise Election Comics on TV CBS Comedy batman boxoffice biography Pop Classic Film spy thriller X-Men Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Starz GoT Heroines comic books aliens Amazon Prime Sundance ESPN GIFs witnail Certified Fresh dramedy Set visit The CW stand-up comedy Christmas animated golden globes quibi Pride Month police drama cinemax canceled TV shows Lifetime DirecTV 2020 scorecard venice blockbuster Turner Trivia free movies natural history Comedy Central 71st Emmy Awards Photos series Marvel Studios obituary A24 Mary poppins The Arrangement parents spanish nature richard e. Grant TCA foreign RT History Stephen King Tomatazos chucky Lifetime Christmas movies movie Walt Disney Pictures comiccon zero dark thirty 2019 Elton John historical drama Disney Plus anime Family discovery sequel E! FX on Hulu joker MTV San Diego Comic-Con Horror Infographic TLC YouTube green book MSNBC Baby Yoda south america CBS All Access based on movie Emmys Disney streaming service crossover Ovation DC Universe Dark Horse Comics Writers Guild of America Mystery Marathons 007 black Pet Sematary cats HBO Max E3 independent DC Comics boxing politics television rt archives psychological thriller cooking Marvel Television Brie Larson Pop TV Mary Tyler Moore toy story Red Carpet Spring TV 4/20 2016 Musicals Reality Arrowverse Podcast japanese Calendar canceled Universal BET Awards disaster LGBT Tarantino Winners worst movies NBC travel Winter TV Best and Worst diversity football TruTV APB versus hispanic Fox Searchlight news Mary Poppins Returns MCU Hallmark Schedule Netflix game show Syfy halloween CMT Cannes Awards Tour universal monsters Film comics Sundance Now sports FOX hollywood true crime book harry potter Adult Swim laika PBS strong female leads streaming GLAAD composers scary movies Chernobyl Lucasfilm documentary renewed TV shows Rocky TNT elevated horror Hear Us Out dc finale AMC The Purge Paramount Network zombie Shondaland child's play SundanceTV TV Land USA teaser Disney+ Disney Plus slashers Tumblr See It Skip It die hard Mindy Kaling ratings History DGA Superheroes cars Women's History Month YouTube Red what to watch BET IFC Films Sundance TV 24 frames vampires Emmy Nominations TCA Awards Hallmark Christmas movies Turner Classic Movies Disney talk show Funimation Academy Awards CW Seed blaxploitation Toys Interview First Look LGBTQ Acorn TV Musical Nominations binge Nickelodeon french video festivals Grammys comic Oscars SDCC kids VOD rotten YouTube Premium Ellie Kemper Watching Series Lionsgate HBO Extras directors ABC screen actors guild cancelled television transformers Mudbound Trailer VH1 films Apple TV Plus spanish language American Society of Cinematographers Fall TV singing competition concert zombies 72 Emmy Awards A&E technology adaptation Box Office supernatural Superheroe romance australia serial killer PlayStation dragons Country dogs CNN Vudu Masterpiece tv talk BBC One WGN 2015 Quiz Britbox indie mutant BBC America facebook screenings Anna Paquin Paramount Fantasy justice league thriller theme song Bravo cancelled Teen Valentine's Day Apple crime drama cancelled TV shows ghosts Holidays IFC Shudder President TV Rocketman name the review Drama Biopics dark comedies Rock werewolf Film Festival FXX festival mockumentary Awards Spectrum Originals Summer Pirates war crime mission: impossible The Witch Crackle critics all-time ID spinoff OWN Ghostbusters TBS cults Food Network 99% cancelled TV series Television Academy First Reviews BAFTA science fiction Polls and Games HBO Go Music TCA 2017 2017 Tubi WarnerMedia Holiday Warner Bros. Song of Ice and Fire Pixar Binge Guide Epix breaking bad El Rey Reality Competition social media indiana jones Star Trek christmas movies docudrama Year in Review OneApp Fox News spain New York Comic Con worst movies Sneak Peek adventure 21st Century Fox asian-american anthology sitcom TCA Winter 2020 Comic Book Amazon Studios Super Bowl Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt