Showdowns

Star Wars Prequels vs. Star Wars Sequels: Which Trilogy Is Better?

Fandoms, unite: We're finally settling the Prequels vs. Sequels debate with a deep dive into box office results, Tomatometer scores, and the characters and moments that make us love Star Wars so damn much.

by | February 26, 2020 | Comments

OK, commenters: Fire up your engines because we’re tackling a big one in our latest edition of Vs., pitting the Star Wars Prequels against the Star Wars Sequels and declaring definitively which galactic triptych is the superior set of films. We’re looking at box office data and Tomatometer scores for Episodes 1-3 and 7-9, as well as which trilogy delivered the best moments and gave us the most memorable characters. Are you a Darth Maul vs. Qui-Gon vs. Obi-Wan person? Or do you prefer your lightsaber battles more of the Throne Room variety? Does a Jar Jar Binks outweigh the awesomeness of Ewan McGregor’s young Obi-Wan? And how do they compare to Babu Frik? Watch above as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis lays out the case for both trilogies and – bravely – declares a winner.


Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is available digitally on March 17, 2020. 

#1
Adjusted Score: 73.399%
Critics Consensus: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker suffers from a frustrating lack of imagination, but concludes this beloved saga with fan-focused devotion.
Synopsis: The battle between the Jedi and the Sith comes to a thrilling conclusion in this final chapter of the Skywalker... [More]
Directed By: J.J. Abrams

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Academy Awards Disney Plus Alien dc golden globes A&E harry potter political drama TCA Awards dramedy renewed TV shows cars indiana jones game of thrones anime TCA Freeform NYCC based on movie Amazon Studios Photos 2016 Lifetime Christmas movies quibi The Walking Dead spanish language GIFs Infographic adventure CNN Biopics franchise FOX children's TV Disney Channel zombie romance dogs Paramount BBC mockumentary PlayStation Shudder Family vampires HBO Go 007 television Arrowverse 2018 video on demand BBC One Trivia Horror Comic Book unscripted IFC Films nfl HBO period drama Lifetime Mindy Kaling Quiz Tubi psycho hist Reality Summer science fiction satire scorecard Fox News festival diversity Stephen King fresh Oscars sequel Music 4/20 historical drama Hallmark Walt Disney Pictures Turner Classic Movies comics reviews PaleyFest E3 stoner Fox Searchlight Pixar TCM Action Film Festival SXSW natural history dceu Grammys fast and furious 2015 twilight romantic comedy Television Academy GoT deadpool DC streaming service Anna Paquin a nightmare on elm street Discovery Channel Apple sitcom parents Kids & Family Tomatazos movie Rom-Com Pop TV WGN spain CBS First Look toy story Amazon Marvel Television football BAFTA Set visit technology Emmys kids USA Network YouTube Red james bond scary movies dark revenge mutant TCA Winter 2020 comic documentary Baby Yoda SundanceTV LGBTQ Red Carpet BET Awards 2017 Television Critics Association Polls and Games series space Hallmark Christmas movies VH1 discovery serial killer Logo cancelled television Superheroe asian-american Marvel Studios RT History MCU mission: impossible toronto Travel Channel Comedy New York Comic Con boxoffice Pride Month canceled TV shows joker Binge Guide aliens The Purge universal monsters cats CBS All Access SDCC Best and Worst San Diego Comic-Con Sneak Peek Funimation 72 Emmy Awards YA Sci-Fi Spring TV remakes DirecTV theme song obituary Women's History Month Vudu Character Guide binge National Geographic free movies Lucasfilm werewolf Black History Month cops independent Creative Arts Emmys strong female leads superhero worst The Witch Mary Poppins Returns rt archives Watching Series Apple TV Plus Adult Swim E! OneApp hispanic finale PBS First Reviews Marathons zombies DC Universe Hulu Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ITV screenings Nat Geo Netflix Classic Film WarnerMedia The CW YouTube Premium spider-man festivals stand-up comedy NBC blockbuster History Toys Turner APB award winner Fantasy classics thriller archives Film TBS Lionsgate ratings richard e. Grant animated christmas movies Chernobyl stop motion Pop 24 frames Schedule video 21st Century Fox disaster Holiday witnail war Dark Horse Comics name the review OWN Superheroes social media comic books GLAAD IFC black criterion El Rey Spike zero dark thirty crime thriller cooking Britbox blaxploitation halloween Awards Tour sequels japanese TV Land Premiere Dates YouTube Hear Us Out Crackle robots Trophy Talk Ellie Kemper Amazon Prime Peacock what to watch reboot hollywood cancelled Endgame worst movies justice league comedies Universal casting ABC Family X-Men ABC Election Showtime Winter TV screen actors guild documentaries Sundance medical drama TruTV Mary poppins Winners rotten movies we love Warner Bros. Disney streaming service spanish miniseries elevated horror Awards biography Countdown Martial Arts Black Mirror Animation Shondaland A24 Mudbound Esquire cinemax rotten Interview Epix TCA 2017 Western Elton John CW Seed MSNBC spinoff teaser 20th Century Fox Certified Fresh Rock 71st Emmy Awards Holidays Heroines Rocky Disney+ Disney Plus sag awards crossover Pirates talk show MTV transformers films crime ghosts Masterpiece Spectrum Originals nbcuniversal TV Nickelodeon Cartoon Network Bravo boxing Fall TV Sundance TV breaking bad Star Wars police drama President FX The Academy Food Network Thanksgiving anthology Box Office nature cancelled TV shows 2020 psychological thriller venice supernatural Super Bowl Country doctor who Musicals facebook DGA Ovation south america Extras Netflix Christmas movies docudrama Crunchyroll green book streaming USA Opinion AMC composers versus comiccon movies The Arrangement australia cults Trailer Drama jamie lee curtis chucky Nominations crime drama 45 slashers Avengers batman true crime Teen HBO Max TNT singing competition travel Cosplay Amazon Prime Video cartoon Cannes game show latino Apple TV+ canceled Writers Guild of America BET Tumblr Starz TV renewals Brie Larson Marvel Rocketman french cancelled TV series BBC America critics dragons Comics on TV VOD sports Musical spy thriller 99% indie best FX on Hulu DC Comics die hard FXX foreign Calendar Video Games Reality Competition laika TLC Mary Tyler Moore 2019 Sundance Now Disney Valentine's Day child's play Star Trek LGBT Paramount Network TIFF Tarantino ESPN tv talk concert Sony Pictures Mystery Captain marvel RT21 CMT news Ghostbusters Christmas Acorn TV directors Pet Sematary Comedy Central Song of Ice and Fire Columbia Pictures emmy awards Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ID American Society of Cinematographers adaptation Emmy Nominations halloween tv italian See It Skip It Year in Review politics all-time Podcast Syfy book VICE