Showdowns

Star Wars Prequels vs. Star Wars Sequels: Which Trilogy Is Better?

Fandoms, unite: We're finally settling the Prequels vs. Sequels debate with a deep dive into box office results, Tomatometer scores, and the characters and moments that make us love Star Wars so damn much.

by | February 26, 2020 | Comments

OK, commenters: Fire up your engines because we’re tackling a big one in our latest edition of Vs., pitting the Star Wars Prequels against the Star Wars Sequels and declaring definitively which galactic triptych is the superior set of films. We’re looking at box office data and Tomatometer scores for Episodes 1-3 and 7-9, as well as which trilogy delivered the best moments and gave us the most memorable characters. Are you a Darth Maul vs. Qui-Gon vs. Obi-Wan person? Or do you prefer your lightsaber battles more of the Throne Room variety? Does a Jar Jar Binks outweigh the awesomeness of Ewan McGregor’s young Obi-Wan? And how do they compare to Babu Frik? Watch above as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis lays out the case for both trilogies and – bravely – declares a winner.


Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is available digitally on March 17, 2020. 

#1
Adjusted Score: 73.559%
Critics Consensus: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker suffers from a frustrating lack of imagination, but concludes this beloved saga with fan-focused devotion.
Synopsis: The battle between the Jedi and the Sith comes to a thrilling conclusion in this final chapter of the Skywalker... [More]
Directed By: J.J. Abrams

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

witnail stop motion Marvel Television Musical zombies asian-american crossover best Apple TV Plus Nat Geo Ovation El Rey politics GoT cartoon Film Festival TIFF talk show Pop 007 dceu FX science fiction Walt Disney Pictures series Awards Tour Film 72 Emmy Awards reviews TruTV binge BBC One Comedy Central IFC Films TV Land Netflix Christmas movies Stephen King Marathons Rock FXX space historical drama USA Network cancelled television Interview Binge Guide ghosts canceled TV shows TCA Winter 2020 diversity CNN MSNBC game of thrones crime thriller 2019 sag awards E3 psychological thriller Hulu TCA Awards ABC 20th Century Fox vampires Set visit Netflix 2020 Year in Review Paramount Network X-Men LGBTQ cancelled TV shows See It Skip It casting Baby Yoda Adult Swim theme song news Universal National Geographic dramedy boxoffice Holiday Rom-Com Fantasy HBO Go halloween Reality Competition Infographic History First Reviews BBC America psycho The CW comics Lifetime Trailer Academy Awards BET Awards Biopics Tubi comedies sequel facebook Hallmark Christmas movies Mystery aliens cops Women's History Month Sneak Peek Mary Tyler Moore Country twilight anime child's play batman discovery sequels TCM Star Wars Pirates justice league based on movie Comic Book E! franchise HBO children's TV New York Comic Con Ellie Kemper 2018 Turner travel Song of Ice and Fire romantic comedy Classic Film Sundance biography medical drama versus First Look war technology classics ESPN fast and furious crime Vudu kids Logo Trivia FX on Hulu Oscars CBS mission: impossible Fox News cinemax cancelled indie indiana jones spanish language all-time DC streaming service MTV free movies San Diego Comic-Con satire festivals obituary PBS DC Universe Acorn TV Music harry potter Nickelodeon universal monsters Family nbcuniversal supernatural Disney Channel tv talk thriller Podcast Dark Horse Comics Valentine's Day singing competition TCA Mary Poppins Returns green book police drama sitcom 2017 parents AMC teaser elevated horror Action Comedy joker Certified Fresh adventure natural history Superheroe 71st Emmy Awards The Walking Dead Crackle DGA foreign 2016 Lifetime Christmas movies Britbox SXSW Grammys video on demand Elton John Video Games Anna Paquin reboot game show Pixar Disney+ Disney Plus Toys docudrama Hear Us Out award winner Tarantino zombie Showtime Emmy Nominations Schedule zero dark thirty dogs Photos Thanksgiving TV renewals 21st Century Fox TNT Chilling Adventures of Sabrina WarnerMedia Reality VH1 Paramount robots Polls and Games Quiz south america video true crime Musicals Black Mirror cancelled TV series nature Creative Arts Emmys ABC Family Mindy Kaling Election Arrowverse scary movies Shondaland Amazon Studios Countdown Shudder Star Trek book Best and Worst quibi cars ratings Discovery Channel stoner rotten unscripted Western BET Summer CBS All Access period drama renewed TV shows revenge a nightmare on elm street laika 2015 Teen Red Carpet Sci-Fi Writers Guild of America Cosplay Lionsgate APB MCU cats Spring TV Bravo Sundance Now NYCC CW Seed VICE animated FOX Ghostbusters Trophy Talk TCA 2017 Apple independent Christmas Box Office PaleyFest Martial Arts sports miniseries Turner Classic Movies YouTube Red Extras Rocketman Rocky screenings superhero LGBT spain Pet Sematary DirecTV RT History Opinion Premiere Dates emmy awards worst Endgame SDCC Marvel Studios Winter TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt BAFTA dc President Disney Syfy Food Network HBO Max films cults Avengers CMT Comics on TV werewolf screen actors guild documentaries Awards Cannes Horror spider-man TLC Nominations NBC mutant Watching Series Freeform composers The Witch political drama serial killer jamie lee curtis TV Crunchyroll 24 frames Amazon 4/20 stand-up comedy Spectrum Originals dark Calendar criterion dragons Television Critics Association Cartoon Network Epix richard e. Grant Brie Larson 45 A&E Captain marvel spy thriller romance critics RT21 comic IFC what to watch Amazon Prime Video Travel Channel social media Drama The Arrangement The Purge Television Academy golden globes YA die hard Tumblr GLAAD American Society of Cinematographers Character Guide YouTube Premium Hallmark Spike comiccon VOD Sundance TV movies Superheroes Pride Month DC Comics Super Bowl Holidays name the review documentary Heroines YouTube slashers crime drama OWN Columbia Pictures TBS adaptation Tomatazos hist disaster latino Animation blaxploitation Chernobyl Starz GIFs USA Amazon Prime Mary poppins movie ITV Marvel Mudbound christmas movies rotten movies we love BBC Apple TV+ hispanic blockbuster toy story strong female leads PlayStation doctor who mockumentary canceled Emmys Masterpiece Sony Pictures spinoff Black History Month Disney Plus streaming television cooking Esquire hollywood Fall TV concert transformers finale Disney streaming service Pop TV Peacock breaking bad WGN Kids & Family chucky SundanceTV A24 Lucasfilm OneApp Funimation Warner Bros. anthology directors Winners