News

Star Trek: Picard First Reviews: Patrick Stewart Shines in New Series That Does the Franchise Proud

The Star Trek universe and this beloved lead character have matured in the CBS All Access series. And, like fine wine, the flavor is complex (and perhaps not to every taste).

by | January 23, 2020 | Comments


Bringing back Patrick Stewart to his iconic role as former captain and now retired admiral Jean-Luc Picard was no easy feat, Star Trek: Picard producers Alex Kurtzman, Akiva Goldsman, Michael Chabon, and Heather Kadin told Rotten Tomatoes recently. The classically-trained actor adamantly and very publicly had no interest in rehashing the beloved Star Trek: The Next Generation character.

“It was wildly public that he was not interested in ever coming back ever, ever, ever,” Goldman related. “But we felt that if we went and sat with him, he would come back. And we went and sat with him, and he said, ‘No.'”

But they sent him a 35-page script by Chabon anyway.

“None of which is in the show,” Goldsman revealed.

Series showrunner Chabon added: “None of that. It was a completely different story. But what it shared with what we ended up making was a perspective on the character of Jean-Luc Picard that was serious, and mature, and about a man who is at a later stage of his life, reckoning with his past, and the things that he’s done and things he hasn’t done, and trying to decide what’s next for him. We were just trying to show Patrick: ‘You can trust us. We get it. We get that you don’t want to come back and be on the bridge of the Enterprise and have the crew and all that. You want to do something different. Here’s something different.'”

Evidently, the work of the Chabon — author of Wonder Boys, The Yiddish Policemen’s Union, Moonglow, and Pulitzer Prize-winning The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay — held sway.


Pictured (l-r): Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard; Isa Briones as Dahj of the CBS All Access series STAR TREK: PICARD. Photo Cr: Matt Kennedy/CBS

Star Trek newcomers joining Stewart include Isa Briones as the mysterious Dahj, Michelle Hurd as former Starfleet Officer Raffi Musiker, Alison Pill as Dr. Agnes Jurati, Harry Treadaway as Narek, Evan Evagora as Elnor,  and Santiago Cabrera as pilot Chris Rios. Star Trek vets returning: Star Trek: The Next Generation’s Brent Spiner reprises his role as Data, Marina Sirtis returns as Deanna Troi, Jonathan Frakes is William Riker and again steps behind the camera to direct, and Jonathan Del Arco returns as Hugh, while Star Trek: Voyager’s Jeri Ryan appears as Seven of Nine.

Season 1 has just taken flight on CBS All Access and quickly scored a Certified Fresh designation based on reviews. Critics have been given a look at three episodes of the series. Here’s what they’re saying about Star Trek: Picard.


DOES IT HONOR THE FRANCHISE?

STAR TREK: PICARD -- Key Art Photo Cr: James Dimmock/CBS ©2019 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

(Photo by Netflix)

So unlike any other Trek property and deeply ensconced in the mythology of Gene Roddenberry’s creation which makes it one of the most distinct Star Trek stories ever to be told on screen. —Alex Maidy, JoBlo’s Movie Emporium

Extending a fiercely loved chapter in the “Star Trek” mythology means a director, practically speaking, cannot win with everyone…These first three episodes have been shrewdly tailored to fit Picard’s elder-statesman status, now that he’s a forcibly retired lion in winter, forced by his conscience and sense of duty to take on an authorized, this-time-it’s-personal mission. —Michael Phillips, Chicago Tribune

Despite the cameos and Easter eggs, Picard never feels like nostalgia for its own sake. The creative team… have clearly given a lot of thought to the idea of an elderly Picard. —Alan Sepinwall, Rolling Stone

Thankfully for “Trek” devotees, casual fans and curious subscribers alike, “Picard” is a delight. —Kelly Lawler, USA Today

Regret is a powerful motivator, and Jean-Luc’s list of regrets is nearly as long as his list of accomplishments, but Picard is more opening salvo than it is a requiem for a starship captain. —Danette Chavez, AV Club

Picard isn’t above moments of nostalgia (one scene in particular is packed with Easter eggs) but it also features a firm commitment to moving the franchise forward not just in time, but in what kind of stories Trek is capable of telling. —Liz Shannon Miller, Paste Magazine

“A bold and exciting addition to the franchise, featuring a compelling central mystery that will undoubtedly keep you gripped each week.” —Nicola Austin, We Have a Hulk


DOES PATRICK STEWART DELIVER?

Pictured: Sir Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard of the CBS All Access series STAR TREK: PICARD. Photo Cr: James Dimmock/CBS ©2019 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

(Photo by Netflix)

It’s a freight train performance from one of our great Shakespearean actors… There are moments you’re not quite sure if it’s Star Trek you’re watching or a high concept take on King Lear. —Ed Power, Daily Telegraph (UK)

It gives me no joy to say this, but: Stewart gave a more interesting performance in 2019’s Charlie’s Angels. —Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly

Stewart is as charming and naturally charismatic as ever, but the general level of the performances around him is significantly higher. —Mike Hale, New York Times

[Stewart] has a unique ability to dial into his roles without completely disappearing, carrying the audience’s earned investment from role to role, whether he’s suffering through an awkward trip to the toilet or sipping tea among the stars. —Ben Travers, indieWire

The cast is marvelous, starting with Stewart, the finest actor ever to wear a Starfleet uniform. His aging and conflicted Picard is an endlessly intriguing revival of the character. He not only keeps you involved but also engaged. —Mark Dawidziak, Cleveland Plain Dealer


READ ALSO: Patrick Stewart and the Star Trek: Picard Crew on Why the World Needs Jean-Luc Now More Than Ever


HOW’S THE PRODUCTION OVERALL?

(Photo by Netflix)

Smart, well-crafted, layered – verging on over-layered. —Verne Gay, Newsday

It’s pretty shallow as a dramatic and thematic construct, but it is recognizably contemporary in its preoccupation with diversity and the mistake of excluding those whose traits and faiths are not fully understood. —John Doyle, Globe and Mail

One hopes that this fits-and-starts opener will give way to smoother storytelling to come, now that twenty years of narrative Band-Aids have been yanked off. —Andrew Todd, Birth.Movies.Death.

For their part, the writing team have found the perfect reason for Picard to get back to saving the galaxy. —Richard Edwards, SFX Magazine

Right now, Star Trek: Picard feels like a cadet pretending to be a captain, and only time will tell whether the series can … transform itself into something more exciting. —Andrew Bloom, The Spool

It takes a while to fully gel, and some fans might start to get impatient, but I’m happy to report that Picard does eventually set up an intriguing mission that’s worthy of its lead character. —Dave Nemetz, TV Line


WHAT ABOUT THE PACING?

Pictured: Sir Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard of the CBS All Access series STAR TREK: PICARD. Photo Cr: Matt Kennedy/CBS ©2019 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

(Photo by Netflix)

If there’s a problem with this gripping first episode it’s that it has to squeeze a lot of exposition into an hour in ways that sometimes threaten to crowd into space that could be devoted to exploring what the events it recounts mean to Picard. —Keith Phipps, New York Magazine/Vulture

But it moves within three hours to a place that promises as much excitement and movement as there already has been insight into its beaten-down protagonist, a show that suggests it’ll be worth sticking around for. —Daniel D’Addario, Variety

The viewers most likely to get impatient are also those most likely to be so happy simply to have Jean-Luc back on their screen that they’re willing to allow the show some indulgence. —Dan Fienberg, Hollywood Reporter

It’s clear right away though that Picard is also about so much more. It’s a TV series with the narrative mindset of a movie, and a Star Trek story that’s committed to shining a light into dark places that we haven’t explored before. —Adam Rosenberg, Mashable

While I wish it didn’t take three full episodes of heavy exposition to get the fabled Next Generation captain, later admiral, into space, the crew of rogue fellow travelers he assembles over the first few weeks is promising. —Matt Roush, TV Insider


FINAL VERDICT?

Pictured: Sir Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard of the CBS All Access series STAR TREK: PICARD. Photo Cr: Trae Patton/CBS ©2019 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

(Photo by Netflix)

Does anyone want a bitter and brutal Star Trek, full of murder-sorrow flashbacks, swoopy-kinetic fights, and all-encompassing paranoia? So much of Trek since 2009 strains to resemble the dumbest version of cool. You always sense the hand of some savvy-pitchman producer trying hard to make everything that was once endearingly nerdy look swole as hell. Picard has flashes of eccentricity, and any science-fiction show with a Miguel de Unamuno shoutout demands a quantum of hope. But for now, this is another disappointing Star Trek. Should we give it a chance? My advice: Disengage. —Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly

Anyone with an ounce of romance in them should feel that thrill. —Robert Lloyd, Los Angeles Times

Against all odds Star Trek: Picard has started strong as both a loving tribute to something we once loved, and an artful exploration of something completely new. —Joshua Tyler, Giant Freakin Robot

One of the most highly anticipated new shows of the year… is simultaneously exciting and calmly beautiful, tantalizing and satisfying. —Diana Keng, TV Fanatic

Picard dares audiences to avoid wallowing in despair or nostalgia, and asks them to take action to build a world that’s even better than anyone could have imagined. —Samantha Nelson, Polygon

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Anchored by the incomparable Patrick Stewart, Picard departs from standard Starfleet protocol with a slower, serialized story, but like all great Star Trek it tackles timely themes with grace and makes for an exciting push further into the final frontier.

Tag Cloud

Reality Superheroe Amazon Prime Year in Review Lionsgate anthology Oscars Western Lifetime Christmas movies live event VOD boxing chucky serial killer suspense movie christmas movies true crime spanish language The Witch animated The Walking Dead debate Apple spy thriller superman spain 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards worst movies Red Carpet Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 21st Century Fox MCU Hallmark award winner BBC One Shudder Marvel Television Image Comics Grammys new zealand Family art house hollywood FX DC streaming service popular mission: impossible mob TCM Reality Competition TIFF 2016 Travel Channel psychological thriller thriller Acorn TV 2017 cancelled slashers strong female leads social media Winter TV news sequel game of thrones high school Hallmark Christmas movies Schedule canceled book adaptation kids LGBTQ comedies Watching Series Captain marvel Binge Guide Film Emmys CBS lord of the rings cancelled TV series miniseries E3 Paramount Plus 007 dceu cats stand-up comedy spanish witnail ABC Signature Exclusive Video natural history Comic Book kaiju A&E Best and Worst classics LGBT CBS All Access HBO Go sag awards PBS Amazon Prime Video psycho new york biopic romance medical drama Columbia Pictures period drama Fox News TV discovery franchise AMC History directors ViacomCBS TruTV Disney Plus Video Games YA game show First Reviews vs. Shondaland Sundance Mystery Elton John boxoffice hispanic screen actors guild BET Calendar Legendary critics video Music razzies ratings rt labs critics edition cops jurassic park Comedy Drama Broadway Marathons YouTube Premium ABC Family Fox Searchlight doctor who disaster Television Academy Pacific Islander war japan Marvel Studios VH1 Summer WGN Disney know your critic marvel cinematic universe historical drama black revenge mutant docuseries Teen First Look king arthur transformers Interview Universal Pictures saw Biopics Action nfl zero dark thirty APB book football video on demand reviews Arrowverse ghosts spinoff supernatural Premiere Dates Cannes The CW women Pride Month crime thriller facebook TBS theme song monster movies hidden camera rt archives Pirates HBO Comic-Con@Home 2021 comic Vudu rom-coms comic book movies Awards travel concert 2015 all-time Hear Us Out DC Universe dc james bond Mary Tyler Moore NBA PaleyFest Pop sopranos Apple TV+ 2018 Nominations french Horror rt labs RT21 free movies children's TV adventure BBC italian El Rey Fantasy FXX slasher Rock laika Netflix Christmas movies posters TCA Winter 2020 X-Men stop motion Star Wars MTV zombies Black Mirror trailers archives dexter aliens child's play AMC Plus sports Kids & Family Heroines GIFs cults TV One Song of Ice and Fire quibi heist movie prank Wes Anderson justice league The Academy Mary Poppins Returns political drama Academy Awards Logo docudrama elevated horror Superheroes Warner Bros. Holiday Trivia BAFTA comics Spectrum Originals name the review Rom-Com GoT worst Hulu The Arrangement Crunchyroll cancelled television Spring TV The Purge streaming Sundance TV rotten movies we love TV renewals ABC based on movie Black History Month Photos Polls and Games Disney+ Disney Plus black comedy crossover mcc golden globe awards DC Comics action-comedy Epix TCA 2017 Election BET Awards Opinion romantic comedy batman die hard finale FX on Hulu Food Network TV movies technology The Walt Disney Company Showtime cooking Mudbound Amazon Studios Universal Country TCA versus Walt Disney Pictures PlayStation Tumblr CW Seed National Geographic Podcast Emmy Nominations Infographic streaming movies obituary deadpool Animation Film Festival Certified Fresh OneApp Amazon basketball Ellie Kemper dogs scene in color casting composers dramedy Women's History Month SXSW 93rd Oscars Christmas science fiction talk show Star Trek 1990s genre Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt USA Network zombie Starz a nightmare on elm street cinemax fast and furious reboot Alien hist screenings Funimation teaser Pet Sematary blockbuster Brie Larson crime drama diversity australia toy story Awards Tour Comedy Central tv talk comic book movie young adult breaking bad adenture harry potter superhero canceled TV shows BBC America Comics on TV Tokyo Olympics Ghostbusters Toys YouTube Red Disney streaming service Anna Paquin Rocky Paramount USA GLAAD President satire south america olympics blaxploitation festivals DirecTV VICE latino YouTube Endgame OWN Ovation Cartoon Network CMT robots American Society of Cinematographers indiana jones legend Freeform aapi Martial Arts Lucasfilm IMDb TV CNN asian-american adaptation Creative Arts Emmys criterion TCA Awards sitcom Musicals toronto Pixar halloween Tarantino Sundance Now golden globes scorecard Instagram Live 90s Adult Swim critic resources Crackle cancelled TV shows green book stoner live action dragons what to watch Disney Channel japanese Character Guide Sci-Fi Writers Guild of America WarnerMedia movies scary movies New York Comic Con Masterpiece vampires Tubi telelvision comic books spider-verse Box Office royal family HBO Max 2021 rotten Trophy Talk binge SundanceTV TV Land documentaries ESPN godzilla Extras twilight documentary richard e. Grant emmy awards Mary poppins fresh FOX RT History Syfy venice Marvel Bravo gangster Lifetime series ID marvel comics Sony Pictures Valentine's Day IFC Films films cars target singing competition See It Skip It Britbox Fall TV 24 frames jamie lee curtis Holidays MSNBC crime best Neflix Nickelodeon indie Mindy Kaling Thanksgiving NYCC kong Turner Television Critics Association TNT Dark Horse Comics Super Bowl Sneak Peek 73rd Emmy Awards mockumentary universal monsters hispanic heritage month foreign police drama Chernobyl Tomatazos Paramount Network biography scary remakes festival 71st Emmy Awards renewed TV shows Esquire television parents dark pirates of the caribbean halloween tv independent joker DGA Cosplay Countdown Classic Film TLC Musical sequels Set visit wonder woman Discovery Channel 99% 2020 space E! Avengers dreamworks A24 Netflix comiccon IFC 4/20 20th Century Fox nature Baby Yoda Apple TV Plus werewolf unscripted spider-man Turner Classic Movies 45 Stephen King cartoon Trailer Winners nbcuniversal Peacock politics 72 Emmy Awards blockbusters Rocketman Pop TV international Nat Geo ITV new star wars movies king kong feel good San Diego Comic-Con anime 2019 Spike Quiz SDCC NBC