News

Spencer First Reviews: Kristen Stewart is “Mesmerizing” in Princess Diana Biopic That’s More Shining than The Crown

Critics out of the Venice Film Festival say Pablo Larraín’s latest is a poetic, eerie “masterpiece” – or a potential camp classic, perhaps – that makes a perfect companion piece to his Jackie.

by | September 3, 2021 | Comments

Spencer

(Photo by NEON)

One of the most intriguing biopics in years, Spencer stars American actress Kristen Stewart as Princess Diana, a world-famous figure who has already been portrayed many times before (including recently in the acclaimed fourth season of The Crown). This time, Chilean filmmaker Pablo Larraín is at the helm and the first reviews out of the Venice Film Festival are praising Spencer as a fitting companion to his Jackie Kennedy film starring Natalie Portman, Jackie. Could this be another major Oscar contender? That’s a good possibility. But this is also another artsy portrait that may not hold a broad enough appeal to enthrall all fans of Stewart, Diana, or stories involving the British throne in general.

Here’s what critics are saying about Spencer:


How is Kristen Stewart’s portrayal of Diana?

“I can’t say enough about Stewart’s performance…it is a bracing, bitter, moving, and altogether stunning turn, taking Diana down roads we have not seen played out quite like in this mesmerizing portrayal.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline Hollywood Daily

“Kristen Stewart doesn’t just do an impersonation (though on the level of impersonation she’s superb). She transforms; she changes her aspect, her rhythm, her karma.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“This is no impression — it’s more an interpretation of a classic role, bringing layers of real human complexity.” – Jason Solomons, The Wrap

“She gives an awkward and mannered performance as Diana, and this is entirely as it should be when one considers that Diana gave an awkward and mannered performance herself.” – Xan Brooks, Guardian

“Casting Stewart, another reserved celebrity who knows the obsessive, overbearing glare of fandom better than most, is inspired… it’s a wry, empathetic evocation of a woman somehow locked out of both her inner and outer lives, frozen in the corridor.” – Guy Lodge, Film of the Week

“Her most riveting performance since Personal Shopper.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter


Are there any standouts in the supporting roles?

“Sally Hawkins is very fine and hits just the right notes in [her] role…[Jack] Farthing manages to nail the tightly controlled Charles, but does show flashes of a human being eventually.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline Hollywood Daily

“Hawkins brings great warmth as Maggie, Diana’s sole ally in this twitchily mistrustful place.” – Robbie Collin, Daily Telegraph (UK)



How does the movie compare to Jackie?

“Like Larraín’s earlier film Jackie, in which Natalie Portman starred as JFK’s grieving wife, this is a self-consciously poetic and elegiac affair.” – Geoffrey Macnab, Independent (UK)

“Spencer is a movie made very much in the spirit of Larraín’s Jackie…every bit as good; it may be even better.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“As in Larraín’s equally brilliant, surprising Jackie, to which Spencer is an intricately attuned companion piece, the director thrills in presenting a public icon freed of her public, unsure how to act around herself.” – Guy Lodge, Film of the Week

Spencer is something else indeed…a more accessible approach in some ways, but also more ambitious.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline Hollywood Daily

“Unlike the maelstrom of emotions in Larain’s previous, and similarly-calibrated celebrity portrait pic, Jackie, this one is slower, linear and more austere, better to fit the genteel and regimented-to-death context of a Yuletide with Her Majesty.” – David Jenkins, Little White Lies


Is Spencer better than past Princess Diana biopics?

“A considerable upgrade on the ill-fated 2014 biopic in which Naomi Watts played Diana.” – Geoffrey Macnab, Independent (UK)

“Far from the laughable disaster of Oliver Hirshbiegel’s 2013 Diana starring Naomi Watts, Larrain’s Spencer will cause a sensation…it’s certainly a royal biopic like no other.” – Jason Solomons, The Wrap

“We have seen many takes on Diana…but Larrain has something very different, very intimate, and very revealing in mind here.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline Hollywood Daily


 Will it please fans of The Crown?

“This is a long way from the more decorous treatment of Netflix’s The Crown.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“This isn’t The Crown, it is far more insular, an intimate portrait of a woman trying to save herself.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline Hollywood Daily

“A more daring alternative to Netflix’s popular show The CrownSpencer tries, and largely succeeds, to get under Diana’s skin.” – James Mottram, South China Morning Post

“Larrain, working from Steven Knight’s script, is clearly going for something more classical here than can be found in an episode of the giant Netflix series The Crown.” – Jason Solomons, The Wrap

Spencer, the eerie, witty and quite extraordinary film that has resulted from their persistence, isn’t necessarily for fans of The Crown, or fetishists of royal ritual and ceremony.” – Guy Lodge, Film of the Week

“Unlike The Crown, there is no risk whatsoever of Pablo Larraín’s resplendently mad, sad and beautiful Spencer…being mistaken for historical fact.” – Robbie Collin, Daily Telegraph (UK)

Spencer

(Photo by NEON)


Is there a particular classic film it will remind us of?

“Larrain’s overhead shot of Diana’s approach turns Sandringham into a haunted house, or the Overlook Hotel from The Shining, rather than a royal residence.” – Jason Solomons, The Wrap

“Larraín makes the place look as spooky as Kubrick’s hotel in The Shining.” – Xan Brooks, Guardian

“Larraín places Di in this luxe getaway palace as if he were making a royal version of The Shining.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“Not for nothing do the long, depopulated hallways of Sandringham occasionally call the Overlook Hotel to mind.” – Guy Lodge, Film of the Week

“The film recalls both Sofia Coppola’s Marie Antoinette, in its elegantly decked-out dissection of cloistered entitlement, and Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining.” – David Jenkins, Little White Lies


 How is the screenplay?

“The script, by Steven Knight, creates its own alluring cleverness. It’s there in Diana’s dialogue, which consists of her spewing out observations, to others but almost to herself, with a kind of rueful mockery.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“The dialogue is rather on-the-nose, and practically every sentence feels aware of itself as a pronouncement of era-defining depth and acuity.” – Jason Solomons, The Wrap

“Occasionally Knight’s dialogue is on the nose…but Stewart sells even those awkward missteps.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“The script by Steven Knight is problematic from the get-go, packed with lots of winking pop psychology and on-the-nose portent, and clearly written with future tragedy in mind.” – David Jenkins, Little White Lies


Is it funny?

“There’s even time for a little humor, from a line about masturbation to an airing of a classic Mike and the Mechanics track.” – James Mottram, South China Morning Post

“There are some scenes that risk teetering into unintentional comedy…it could well grow into a gothic, almost camp classic.” – Jason Solomons, The Wrap

“Veers wildly from moments of dreamy intrigue to risible scenes of camp.” – Kevin Maher, Times (UK)


Spencer

(Photo by NEON)

How does the movie look?

“Mathon’s camerawork is ravishing, constantly in motion, gliding behind and circling a subject who bristles at being under constant surveillance.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“The remarkable production design, by Guy Hendrix Dyas, turns the interiors of Sandringham into a profusion of textures that dance before our eyes.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“Jacqueline Durran’s costumes are particularly exquisite.” – James Mottram, South China Morning Post


How is the score?

“Composer Jonny Greenwood [twists] the traditional sounds of heraldry into something creepy and unsettling.” – Jason Solomons, The Wrap

“The music by Jonny Greenwood is as bracing and risky as anything else in Larraín’s film, shifting from melodic piano and string themes early on into discordant free-form jazz or oppressive pipe organ passages as Diana’s self-possession unravels.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“Jonny Greenwood’s ominous jazzy score seems to have a direct pipeline to Diana’s emotions.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“Jonny Greenwood’s brilliant but sometimes heavy-handed score which deftly combines prim, dinnertime minuettes with clanging atonal dirges.” – David Jenkins, Little White Lies

“Absolutely-should-be-Oscar-winning.” – Jessica Kiang, The Playlist


Does the Royal Family come off looking badly?

“Larraín largely holds back on characterizing the other royals…” – James Mottram, South China Morning Post

“There is no question the film firmly lands on the side of Diana… [it’s] a humorless, stiff, and dreary picture of Royal life that seems about as lifeless as possible.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline Hollywood Daily

“While some will no doubt reject Spencer as lurid psychodrama, the presentation of the royal family as a sinister body corporate, ready to inflict wounds and ice out any interloper who tarnishes their brand is chillingly compelling.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“It is an understatement to say that many living royals – including the current regent – do not come off well in this film.” – David Jenkins, Little White Lies

“No doubt it took an outsider to make a film that’s as un-reverential as Spencer, which dares to examine the royals as if they were specimens under glass.” – Xan Brooks, Guardian

“All the right people are going to hate Spencer. That’s just how good it is.” – Jessica Kiang, The Playlist


Spencer

(Photo by NEON)

Will anyone have an issue with its historical or physical accuracy?

“This is a film in which the essence of the characters is given more weight than the actors’ resemblance to them.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“The film is bound to infuriate traditionalists. Larraín and Knight have taken huge liberties with their subject matter.” – Geoffrey Macnab, Independent (UK)

“Entirely to its credit, Spencer is nothing like real history, and its Diana can certainly not be proven to be anything like the real Diana, whoever that poor woman was.” – Jessica Kiang, The Playlist


What one or two words are best to describe the movie?

“Masterpiece.” – Jessica Kiang, The Playlist

“Magnificent.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“Extraordinary.” – Xan Brooks, Guardian

“Audaciously original.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“Brilliantly imagined.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline Hollywood Daily

“Infuriating.” – Kevin Maher, Times (UK)

“Sad and hopeless.” – David Jenkins, Little White Lies


Spencer is in theaters from Friday November 5, 2021.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

posters 2017 television renewed TV shows Apple TV Plus The Academy Image Comics international Paramount Plus serial killer Oscar Peacock A&E Rom-Com comics psycho Hallmark Christmas movies New York Comic Con Comic-Con@Home 2021 WarnerMedia Crackle italian NYCC scorecard Western blockbusters APB BBC America TV know your critic MSNBC laika ABC Family Women's History Month critic resources Stephen King Shondaland Interview scary suspense Schedule child's play Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Nat Geo Martial Arts Reality Competition indiana jones royal family Video Games werewolf HBO Go Summer Starz Awards Alien video Pride Month Mary Tyler Moore summer TV preview Pet Sematary Discovery Channel Adult Swim singing competition police drama Pirates Disney streaming service Universal Fall TV godzilla Countdown Travel Channel TBS dc natural history casting movie BET Tubi witnail SXSW 2022 miniseries Cartoon Network name the review GoT DC Comics Masterpiece romance RT History VOD Black History Month Extras boxoffice 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Fox News Shudder Exclusive Video The Witch toronto new zealand Broadway kong South by Southwest Film Festival ghosts black Apple TV+ biopic Dark Horse Comics disaster Red Carpet MCU video on demand Certified Fresh broadcast AMC Plus Superheroes documentary Awards Tour Trailer halloween robots target nature streaming Thanksgiving Song of Ice and Fire australia Best Picture medical drama discovery Britbox versus lord of the rings crime thriller CBS franchise Musicals Film Festival latino romantic comedy Comic Book ID saw Walt Disney Pictures Apple FXX deadpool war spain legend Musical quibi venice National Geographic pirates of the caribbean Mary Poppins Returns trophy Pixar Film Tumblr 71st Emmy Awards TV Land Food Network IFC Films concert Christmas rom-coms BBC One superman green book toy story batman Lionsgate Arrowverse Best Actress Pop TV Cannes sitcom Holiday science fiction SXSW rotten movies we love popular OWN award winner summer preview supernatural mission: impossible based on movie Hulu Best and Worst marvel comics dogs Tomatazos Music Marvel USA leaderboard blockbuster Pacific Islander festivals TCM technology dexter comiccon game show Hear Us Out LGBT Pop Black Mirror Lucasfilm 007 Vudu Ghostbusters TLC space Nominations sequels obi wan CNN Amazon Prime Video screenings fresh gangster Tokyo Olympics Paramount Network Star Trek NBC cars Acorn TV justice league Winter TV Year in Review comic books Netflix Best Actor talk show marvel cinematic universe 94th Oscars french Ellie Kemper Hollywood Foreign Press Association revenge 90s theme song mcc PBS political drama Cosplay black comedy live event ITV superhero slasher cooking The Walking Dead parents HBO Max animated Comedy docuseries Valentine's Day biography ABC Signature historical drama TV One Trophy Talk nfl south america teaser anime Elton John OneApp Nickelodeon ratings what to watch cancelled Bravo Television Academy Epix kids DirecTV Binge Guide Spring TV Legendary japan GIFs tv talk heist movie critics spanish language Focus Features Star Wars FOX mob docudrama a nightmare on elm street rt labs critics edition Universal Pictures basketball Fantasy Sundance TV zombie Chernobyl GLAAD streaming movies rt archives strong female leads binge Tarantino rotten Amazon Television Critics Association FX king kong Ovation Turner Classic Movies trailers Horror aapi period drama series Sundance Now zero dark thirty worst movies scene in color Oscars social media 79th Golden Globes Awards composers Sneak Peek 24 frames Syfy Election remakes Mindy Kaling canceled cops genre obituary ABC Disney Channel directors Brie Larson YouTube Red spy thriller spider-verse spider-man Lifetime Christmas movies Action TNT IMDb TV First Look asian-american CBS All Access 20th Century Fox Avengers anthology TruTV rt labs AMC jurassic park DC streaming service christmas movies movies ViacomCBS boxing stand-up comedy 72 Emmy Awards Funimation crime sopranos Captain marvel 73rd Emmy Awards FX on Hulu slashers TV renewals live action Box Office Toys halloween tv nbcuniversal BBC Drama interviews ESPN Columbia Pictures reviews Grammys Watching Series El Rey Sundance Classic Film fast and furious olympics hispanic festival scary movies PlayStation psychological thriller thriller See It Skip It jamie lee curtis 2018 Winners best Paramount Amazon Studios 99% vampires spanish Teen joker Emmy Nominations SundanceTV PaleyFest Turner Disney dceu DGA diversity Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Emmys Rock 2021 Baby Yoda History children's TV doctor who blaxploitation TCA 2017 japanese YouTube monster movies sequel NBA cats San Diego Comic-Con Kids & Family harry potter classics breaking bad Premiere Dates MTV Academy Awards WGN YouTube Premium X-Men archives cancelled television Family high school book adaptation SDCC sag awards comedies Opinion adenture Set visit universal monsters A24 Podcast The Purge crossover Photos dreamworks summer TV Warner Bros. IFC Disney+ Disney Plus MGM Superheroe Polls and Games comic book movie foreign 4/20 Biopics all-time adventure cinemax Rocky CW Seed news finale book Disney Plus Best Director VICE debate Marathons cancelled TV series hidden camera feel good TCA Winter 2020 Marvel Television USA Network action-comedy Comics on TV wonder woman stop motion films Sony Pictures Mary poppins stoner women crime drama Quiz American Society of Cinematographers Wes Anderson HBO unscripted razzies TCA Trivia TIFF new star wars movies Hallmark Fox Searchlight indie zombies free movies art house Reality golden globes Fargo Sci-Fi vs. chucky comic Comedy Central travel mockumentary Creative Arts Emmys sports prank aliens Paramount Pictures criterion Amazon Prime dark VH1 Crunchyroll Anna Paquin independent 2015 cults DC Universe YA Calendar Endgame transformers worst The Arrangement richard e. Grant mutant Tags: Comedy Writers Guild of America streamig Logo TCA Awards Spike twilight 2019 satire new york 2016 dramedy documentaries Mystery adaptation 1990s young adult football The Walt Disney Company E3 cancelled TV shows hispanic heritage month CMT HFPA 45 Super Bowl The CW telelvision Spectrum Originals golden globe awards reboot Heroines Lifetime emmy awards 21st Century Fox Country Character Guide Rocketman cartoon james bond TV movies kaiju E! game of thrones facebook Esquire BET Awards canceled TV shows LGBTQ elevated horror First Reviews hist comic book movies king arthur Instagram Live Showtime Mudbound President Prime Video Netflix Christmas movies Marvel Studios dragons Animation Holidays Neflix Infographic 93rd Oscars Freeform die hard politics BAFTA screen actors guild hollywood true crime spinoff 2020 RT21