News

Sonic the Hedgehog First Reviews: Jim Carrey Steals the Show in a Solid Family Adventure

Early reviews say the SEGA video game adaptation is a pleasantly surprising children's film with enough to entertain the adults and a Jim Carrey performance worthy of his '90s heyday.

by | February 13, 2020 | Comments

Sonic the Hedgehog had a lot of hurdles to overcome, from the fan backlash to its character design (and the subsequent production delay in response) to the general low expectations that come with video game movies. Fortunately, based on the relatively positive reception of the Sega adaptation, many fans and families will find this to be a pleasant surprise. Mostly harmless fun with a scene-stealing throwback performance from Jim Carrey, Sonic is nothing revolutionary but is hardly a prickly affair either.

Here’s what critics are saying about Sonic the Hedgehog:


Is it better than expected?

I admit I had my reserves about Sonic the Hedgehog, but it completely blew my mind.
– Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Raise your expectations. Sonic the Hedgehog is the first cinema surprise of the year.
– Julian Roman, MovieWeb

A movie miracle or at the very least an unexpected surprise, this adaptation… largely presses all the right buttons — and even does so in the right order.
– Oliver Jones, Observer


Are the updated visuals worth the wait?

The effects, while maintaining fidelity to the popular video game, turned out stellar.
Yolanda Machado, The Wrap

You know what, it works. It’s a really effective rendering of the classic character many of us grew up playing.
Wenlei Ma, News.com.au

Not only did the animators go above and beyond in fixing Sonic to look more like his video game origins, but they might’ve saved the movie.
Dami Lee, The Verge

The filmmakers were able to get what amounts to a stuffed toy to emote more successfully than, say, the filmmakers behind last summer’s The Lion King.
Oliver Jones, Observer

In the finished film this new, cartoony Sonic might be more aesthetically pleasing, but he’s a bizarre outlier in an otherwise photorealistic world.
Huw Fullerton, Radio Times


Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

How does it rate as a video game movie?

Sonic the Hedgehog succeeds where so many other video game adaptations fail because it captures the spirit of the games and the character.
Spencer Perry, ComicBook.com

Sonic the Hedgehog is a fairly middling family-friendly adventure movie, but a comparably good video game adaptation.
A.A. Dowd, AV Club

You might have to go all the way back to 1993’s Super Mario Bros. to find such a striking disconnect between the experience of playing something at home and watching it in a theater.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

It’s not quite Detective Pikachu, but it’s fun enough.
Huw Fullerton, Radio Times


How is Jim Carrey?

Sonic offers Jim Carrey in a performance almost as full-tilt as those of his mid-’90s heyday. .
John DeFore, Hollywood Reporter

Carrey’s physicality and comedic timing evoke memories of his Ace Ventura and Liar Liar heyday, proving the gifted comedian hasn’t lost his touch.
Akeem Lawanson, IGN

This is peak Carrey, a delightfully unhinged, physical performance reminiscent of his work in Ace Ventura or The Mask.
Wenlei Ma, News.com.au

Carrey is the film’s most prized weapon…his vitality makes an otherwise routine endeavor worthwhile. The movie is fine, but the villain’s a delight.
Bilge Ebiri, Vulture

He’s far more animated than Sonic. And far too good for this.
Steve Rose, Guardian


Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

And James Marsden?

Marsden manages to mine the heartwarming moments with Sonic even if it’s ultimately not a standout turn in his career.
Akeem Lawanson, IGN

To Marsden’s credit, there’s a natural camaraderie… which is impressive given that the critter was likely represented on set by a tennis ball on a stick.
Jake Cole, Slant


Is the movie funny?

I found myself laughing out loud several times, and yes, I even shed a few tears.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

One of the strengths of the film is that it’s always throwing new gags and jokes at the audience, so even if one doesn’t work, there’s another right around the corner that arrives as quickly as Sonic himself.
Spencer Perry, ComicBook.com

Gets away with [one fart joke], otherwise bypassing the all-too-common cheap laughs for a story that’s loaded with smart humor [and] snappy dialogue.
Kristen Page-Kirby, Washington Post

The jokes are almost all uniformly awful, following a formula of some zany thing happening and a character merely describing aloud what just happened in an incredulous voice.
Jake Cole, Slant


Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

How is the script?

The script itself is very light-hearted, even with undercurrents about being an outsider and the loneliness that comes with it.
Yolanda Machado, The Wrap

Even when grappling with potentially heavy themes like government-sponsored drone warfare and situational depression, Sonic the Hedgehog never loses its buoyant sense of storytelling.
Oliver Jones, Observer

Sonic the Hedgehog has a terrific script. Screenwriters Patrick Casey and Josh Miller infuse a lot of creativity into the Japanese source material.
Julian Roman, MovieWeb

Sonic the Hedgehog is frustratingly old-school in its condescension, as the filmmakers constantly hold the audience’s hand.
Jake Cole, Slant

Writers Patrick Casey and Josh Miller spend too much time trying to modernize Sonic… but they sacrifice so much of his character in the process.
Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews


Is it strictly for fans of the game?

First and foremost for Sonic fans. If you’ve been there for the little blue fella these past 29 years… then Sonic the Hedgehog is the love letter you’re probably looking for. If you’ve never really cared for the Blue Blur, you’ll probably want to avoid this flick like one of Dr. Robotnik’s badniks.
Akeem Lawanson, IGN

If you spent your afternoons collecting rings and battling Dr. Robotnik as a kid like I did, you will LOVE this movie.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Fans of the video games will find a host of allusions, but there’s plenty to please any moviegoer who can’t tell a Sega from a Switch.
Kristen Page-Kirby, Washington Post


Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

Is it really family-friendly?

Make no mistake, Sonic The Hedgehog is a kids’ movie, but there’s enough here for their parents so that it’s not a total slog.
Wenlei Ma, News.com.au

Sonic is a children’s movie that recognizes it may be kids’ first introduction to the hedgehog, so it makes minimal references to the video game world he comes from.
Dami Lee, The Verge

Sonic the Hedgehog is what a family movie should be – entertaining, delightful, a good story, fun for all ages, and packed with life lessons.
Tania Lamb, Lola Lambchops

Few but diehard fans and young children will be charmed by this predictable, derivative caper.
Steve Rose, Guardian


Any major complaints?

It’s not a great sign of creative storytelling when a kids film plugs Amazon, Zillow, and Olive Garden in the span of a single scene, without a trace of irony.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

I can put up with product placement that is tastefully done but if we pay $15 for a ticket to a movie we don’t expect to constantly see advertisements especially in movies for children.
Rachel Wagner, Rachel’s Reviews

Sonic could’ve used more of the attitude that made him Sega’s antithesis to Nintendo’s Mario during the video game console wars.
Travis Hopson, Punch Drunk Critics

To add insult to injury, they added a sassy Black woman stereotype. Why…is this present in 2020 and in a Sonic movie?
Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews


Will audiences want more?

It has me beyond hyped for a sequel.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Hopefully Sonic the Hedgehog will get the chance to explore its world and take more risks in a followup.
Molly Freeman, ScreenRant


Sonic the Hedgehog is in theaters on February 14.

#1
#1
Adjusted Score: 72.545%
Critics Consensus: Fittingly fleet and frequently fun, Sonic the Hedgehog is a video game-inspired adventure the whole family can enjoy -- and a fine excuse for Jim Carrey to tap into the manic energy that launched his career.
Synopsis: SONIC THE HEDGEHOG is a live-action adventure comedy based on the global blockbuster video game franchise from Sega that centers... [More]
Directed By: Jeff Fowler

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

hist ratings transformers Vudu Sony Pictures vampires critics Amazon Studios asian-american Comics on TV dragons politics stand-up comedy OneApp Marvel Television LGBT south america sag awards Animation canceled Warner Bros. unscripted series TV TIFF game show Tumblr children's TV child's play Epix Certified Fresh cancelled TV series Musical sports biography comics Spike Pirates cops Ghostbusters twilight rotten chucky blockbuster Toys medical drama Tubi Super Bowl news dramedy Classic Film VICE Showtime romance Awards Tour 2018 robots Mary Poppins Returns AMC documentary golden globes renewed TV shows Emmy Nominations Black Mirror PBS VH1 Apple TV Plus stoner Funimation streaming National Geographic canceled TV shows CMT APB stop motion The Purge aliens Sundance Now Western slashers Trailer Comic Book Thanksgiving joker Lionsgate Cartoon Network Brie Larson Holiday TBS strong female leads PlayStation FXX Hulu Universal Discovery Channel Acorn TV RT21 based on movie Set visit GLAAD Mudbound a nightmare on elm street Masterpiece criterion binge discovery Lucasfilm boxoffice Turner composers hispanic cooking latino 71st Emmy Awards FOX Mystery satire American Society of Cinematographers San Diego Comic-Con Starz Disney streaming service justice league Film Festival teaser Calendar cults NBC foreign 2019 Amazon Prime Video Television Academy E3 thriller Syfy Superheroe Action mission: impossible First Reviews Pride Month 2015 period drama Disney Plus docudrama Women's History Month Sundance TV 4/20 book Podcast Tarantino Rock Music Cannes animated YouTube Nominations comic Walt Disney Pictures political drama christmas movies rotten movies we love TCA Winter 2020 Columbia Pictures cancelled television Country comedies Freeform TruTV richard e. Grant crime thriller talk show revenge Holidays fast and furious Summer LGBTQ scary movies Pixar Premiere Dates Drama TV renewals GIFs sequel Character Guide The Walking Dead HBO Election indie cats 72 Emmy Awards ABC Family elevated horror Shondaland Hear Us Out Horror CBS All Access Musicals travel Fall TV kids Adult Swim Heroines HBO Go BBC Rocky Arrowverse space harry potter SDCC directors VOD jamie lee curtis nature Fox News Bravo 24 frames name the review The CW free movies A24 Netflix Anna Paquin DirecTV Tomatazos Trophy Talk Creative Arts Emmys MSNBC Logo Mary Tyler Moore parents independent adventure DC streaming service witnail spy thriller movie serial killer TNT DC Comics TCA Awards Amazon Cosplay Winter TV Video Games Chilling Adventures of Sabrina FX on Hulu spanish language Avengers die hard adaptation superhero theme song Family DC Universe technology HBO Max festivals tv talk A&E Turner Classic Movies 20th Century Fox movies Biopics blaxploitation Disney classics Film Countdown breaking bad cancelled cinemax award winner IFC Films El Rey Rom-Com FX 21st Century Fox Quiz BAFTA Star Trek mutant spider-man Lifetime Teen YouTube Red USA emmy awards Infographic dc Pop Pop TV cancelled TV shows spain OWN Captain marvel First Look Chernobyl BBC America Song of Ice and Fire The Arrangement miniseries cars Hallmark Christmas movies YA Marvel Studios what to watch true crime dceu diversity Sneak Peek 2017 DGA reviews Food Network Grammys RT History zero dark thirty Travel Channel BBC One TCA 2017 supernatural social media sitcom Schedule Lifetime Christmas movies Baby Yoda batman ESPN Peacock casting Comedy Central MTV zombie reboot films WGN quibi psychological thriller Interview video on demand screen actors guild Oscars police drama Emmys concert laika Nickelodeon CBS Comedy ITV Pet Sematary Esquire crime mockumentary ghosts Year in Review Netflix Christmas movies Writers Guild of America Apple History Red Carpet Christmas war Television Critics Association crime drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Star Wars MCU disaster Sci-Fi dogs natural history green book Paramount crossover TCA X-Men sequels Trivia Black History Month psycho PaleyFest The Witch Paramount Network Apple TV+ TCM Binge Guide Crackle facebook President best game of thrones Reality Competition Shudder Photos ABC all-time television Kids & Family Academy Awards Polls and Games USA Network Box Office anthology 007 Superheroes Disney Channel halloween zombies Best and Worst BET Awards Endgame Disney+ Disney Plus Dark Horse Comics 2016 dark Crunchyroll Ovation See It Skip It Mary poppins worst Amazon Prime Stephen King comiccon Marathons 2020 New York Comic Con nbcuniversal Ellie Kemper indiana jones E! TV Land Elton John Fantasy SundanceTV CW Seed SXSW romantic comedy cartoon Extras CNN werewolf franchise NYCC Winners hollywood GoT spinoff Valentine's Day anime Opinion obituary WarnerMedia BET doctor who Hallmark Awards YouTube Premium Rocketman Spring TV Watching Series IFC Sundance Martial Arts versus documentaries screenings singing competition finale science fiction universal monsters Marvel Mindy Kaling 45 historical drama Reality Britbox toy story Nat Geo video TLC Spectrum Originals