Trophy Talk

Six Oscar Long Shots Who Could Surprise Us Come Nominations Morning

An Oscar for a scream queen, a "Walking Dead" star, and a first-time actress? It could happen.

by | January 15, 2019 | Comments

With Sunday’s Critic’s Choice Award ceremony done, all of the prominent critics groups have had their say on the best films of 2018. Each year, countless critics associations host year-end awards to recognize exceptional filmmaking, but the National Society of Film Critics, Los Angeles Film Critics Association, New York Film Critics Circle, and Broadcast Film Critics Association are carefully considered when making Oscars predictions. Each group will say they are independent to the academy in voting, tastes, and identity, but they help shape the race for the big one. And so we have our eyes on them.

Our Awards Leaderboard tracks major critics groups’ and guilds’ honors, and looking at the current leaders, we think Roma, If Beale Street Could Talk, and The Favourite should feel fairly confident of some Oscar love when the nominations are announced on Tuesday. (Regina King, Olivia Colman, and Richard E. Grant in particular would not be risking much to set an early alarm.) This year, though, there have been coordinated efforts to bring lesser-known films and performances into the conversation, so we’re also expecting a number of surprises among the noms. Where might those surprises come from? Below, we’re looking at Oscar long shots who might just have enough buzz – and which have a couple of awards already in the bag – to break through with some Oscar voters.

Toni Collette, Hereditary (2018) 89% – Best Actress
Already recognized by: Gotham Awards, Film Independent

Toni Collette in Hereditary

Do we need to say more about what Toni Collette did in Hereditary? It seems some may have forgotten the greatest full body performance of 2018. In the movie – which caught fire at Sundance and made an impact at the box office – Collette gifted all of us with a face-screwed-screech-filled-terrified performance that takes at least three viewings to fully deconstruct. The Aussie actress started strong this awards season with a Gotham win followed by a Film Independent nomination, but then things went quiet. Collette would be vying for the open fifth Best Actress nomination – assuming favorites Colman, Lady Gaga, Glenn Close, and Melissa McCarthy all come through as expected. She will need those horror lovers in the Academy to champion her incredible work.

Yalitza Aparicio, Roma (2018) 95% – Best Actress
Already Recognized by: BFCA, Gotham Awards


(Photo by © Netflix)

It’s worth noting the star of the most awarded film of the season has gone largely unrecognized. An unknown actress, in a black-and-white foreign language film, distributed on a platform many Academy voters herald as the end of cinema, is a hard sell. Director Alfonso Cuarón has repeatedly said Roma does not exist without the women who inspired and made it, but the accolades have not exactly come streaming in. In Cuarón’s semi-autobiographical love letter to Mexico and the woman who raised him, Aparicio gave depth and aching authenticity to a character rarely featured on screen. Cuarón painted a masterpiece, but Aparicio is the canvas, paint, and brush.

Steven Yeun, Burning (Beoning) (2018) 95% – Best Actor
Already Recognized by: LAFCA, NSFC

Steven Yeun in Burning

(Photo by @ Go Well USA)

Yeun’s performance as a South Korean playboy in Burning is ethereal, charismatic, and unnerving. Another foreign language entry, Lee Chang-dong’s noir-thriller slowly unravels and builds to a climactic twist you don’t see coming – and so much of it rests on the former Walking Dead star’s performance; our thoughts on Yuen’s character, Ben, mirror how we interpret the events of the film. Is he just a spoiled playboy formulating sinister plots for entertainment? Or is he a calculating psychopath? Or maybe just a guy who likes to burn greenhouses? It all rests on what we see in Yuen, in his gaze or sly smile. It’s a tightrope to pull off a likable Oscar-worthy villain, and Yeun makes it look effortless. The formula worked for Javier Bardem in No Country for Old Men, so fingers crossed.

Debra Granik, Leave No Trace (2018) 100% – Best Director
Already Recognized by: Film Independent, National Board of Review, LAFCA

Thomasin McKenzie and Debra Granik

(Photo by JA/Everett Collection)

In a year littered with exceptional work by female directors, it’s hard to justify their lack of inclusion come award time. The Rider, You Were Never Really Here, A Private Life, Can You Ever Forgive Me?, and Destroyer… all are worthy of recognition. But Debra Granik’s Leave No Trace distinguishes itself from even those stellar entries – and not just because it still sits at 100% on our Tomatometer after 200 reviews. Director Jane Campion may have said it best in her impassioned plea for Leave No Trace: “A film filled with compassion… it has had a powerful impact on audiences. Not because it is loud, but because the truth that Granik speaks quietly can be heard even in a noisy world.”

Elsie Fisher, Eighth Grade (2018) 99% – Best Actress
Already Recognized by: Film Independent, Gotham Awards, DGA, BFCA, NYFCC

Eighth Grade (A24)

(Photo by © A24)

Cringeworthy Cinema: that’s how Bo Burnham’s Eighth Grade and its star Elsie Fisher charmed their way into our hearts. Reliving the painfully awkward moments of adolescence with such unflinching honesty, Fisher gave the best performance of the year that we had to watch through fingers and stooping down in our seats. (OK, maybe tied with Collette – but for very different reasons.) Burnham’s script is the quintessential coming-of-age story for the YouTube generation and, as with Roma, his film lives or dies by its central performance. As Kayla, Fisher is relatable and endearing for tweens and their parents, finding a perfect blend of earnestness and mortification.

Ethan Hawke, First Reformed (2018) 93% – Best Actor
Already Recognized by: Film Independent, Gotham Awards, NYFCC, BFCA, LAFCA, NSFC

(Photo by © A24)

Ethan Hawke often remarks that he doesn’t want to be known just for the Dead Poets Society. But after the over 30 years, 80 credits, four Oscar nominations, and countless more beloved performances, Hawke still hears “Oh Captain, My Captain” on the regular. His turn as the conflicted and apathetic Reverend Toller is miles away from any previous role he has done. Many are taking notice: With a near clean sweep of the critics associations, Hawke’s performance in First Reformed is second only to Regina King’s in Beale Street in regards to acclaim this season. Why isn’t he a lock for an Oscar nom? Hawke’s lack of movement outside of the critics groups’ awards does not bode well. We’ll be watching this one keenly.

Oscar nominations are announced on Tuesday, January 22, 2019

Tag Cloud

ABC Musicals President miniseries psychological thriller renewed TV shows batman foreign SXSW mockumentary Paramount Plus kaiju prank game of thrones Oscars Endgame LGBTQ sequel comedies Pop Reality films festivals Set visit independent werewolf dragons documentaries X-Men Epix zombies Showtime YouTube halloween Masterpiece stand-up comedy Valentine's Day SundanceTV series romance obituary dogs The Witch 2019 Film Festival Lifetime Christmas movies WarnerMedia ratings Lionsgate adaptation telelvision Spectrum Originals crime justice league Crunchyroll fast and furious Emmys football best Quiz Broadway ViacomCBS Thanksgiving blockbusters video rom-coms Marvel women Box Office Academy Awards cancelled television cooking Drama Certified Fresh natural history VOD tv talk trailers Opinion Disney streaming service singing competition animated Captain marvel 99% disaster 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards cancelled TV series boxoffice First Look Women's History Month BBC One festival political drama Sony Pictures Biopics rotten movies we love Starz 4/20 Mary Tyler Moore Fox Searchlight medical drama blockbuster doctor who name the review joker Pop TV video on demand Pirates Marathons Teen remakes WGN Acorn TV Ovation Television Critics Association HBO Max Britbox Disney Plus Comic Book Hulu New York Comic Con Polls and Games supernatural ITV CBS Star Wars jamie lee curtis CNN binge indie Superheroes canceled TV shows crossover based on movie Peacock Pride Month Amazon 2015 child's play Ghostbusters 20th Century Fox Song of Ice and Fire Adult Swim Mary Poppins Returns Holidays concert 45 BAFTA Sci-Fi YouTube Premium Arrowverse breaking bad Cartoon Network TIFF Video Games elevated horror Spike superman Walt Disney Pictures spinoff Nat Geo composers screenings SDCC The CW cancelled TV shows spanish language YA Disney+ Disney Plus CBS All Access Anna Paquin OWN what to watch Election 72 Emmy Awards BET Awards Nickelodeon Dark Horse Comics cats harry potter casting Infographic revenge 2018 Amazon Prime psycho free movies Best and Worst game show scary movies 24 frames zombie Country finale Stephen King crime drama HBO Go Awards Universal stoner archives FXX Star Trek See It Skip It RT History Paramount Network popular sag awards Tarantino mission: impossible 2016 green book cartoon sports Pixar FX Discovery Channel The Arrangement TV renewals GoT television romantic comedy Apple TV Plus Funimation TCA Winter 2020 Mystery Schedule talk show reboot Reality Competition MTV movie criterion halloween tv pirates of the caribbean classics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt docudrama Pet Sematary The Walt Disney Company NYCC Rom-Com Year in Review social media politics TV TNT indiana jones Spring TV PBS Syfy space Marvel Television Disney Channel latino kong biography directors Sundance richard e. Grant American Society of Cinematographers serial killer A24 Heroines cinemax hollywood nature Winners Tumblr Nominations CMT historical drama christmas movies dc laika comic books italian PlayStation Apple scorecard Photos a nightmare on elm street BET Fox News spy thriller cancelled Martial Arts docuseries Trivia Sundance Now USA Network crime thriller aliens Alien french MCU Food Network Writers Guild of America 2021 sequels TV One Grammys USA Turner worst dceu TCA Awards LGBT hispanic quibi FOX blaxploitation Logo jurassic park National Geographic TruTV Legendary deadpool Warner Bros. razzies comics A&E adventure Animation Super Bowl Elton John Watching Series science fiction comiccon theme song Tomatazos Esquire Fall TV police drama Music Mary poppins BBC Amazon Prime Video Western The Purge Hear Us Out Christmas Black History Month AMC Columbia Pictures Hallmark Christmas movies period drama Tubi Interview nfl Netflix discovery spider-man worst movies australia Paramount fresh Podcast Action HBO ghosts Trailer strong female leads hist Binge Guide Creative Arts Emmys CW Seed Exclusive Video Family Freeform japanese Character Guide franchise The Walking Dead 2020 Travel Channel 71st Emmy Awards comic 21st Century Fox PaleyFest Shudder VICE robots unscripted die hard Superheroe Avengers asian-american VH1 Comedy streaming ABC Signature TCA 2017 rotten GIFs parents twilight DC streaming service thriller Cannes kids black IFC Films TCM TCA The Academy OneApp E3 war TLC news Sundance TV Cosplay canceled dark cults Countdown king kong BBC America book Rocketman Winter TV Vudu DirecTV movies Rock 2017 007 Disney IFC nbcuniversal cops ID superhero Trophy Talk Marvel Studios golden globes spain monster movies Holiday toronto Kids & Family golden globe awards NBC godzilla universal monsters zero dark thirty GLAAD Crackle all-time critics Mindy Kaling Film cars E! venice Emmy Nominations Chernobyl Amazon Studios Musical south america Bravo versus Lucasfilm DC Comics MSNBC anthology stop motion Ellie Kemper Awards Tour Apple TV+ Chilling Adventures of Sabrina hidden camera boxing witnail Mudbound true crime Black Mirror Baby Yoda First Reviews Television Academy San Diego Comic-Con ESPN Extras Netflix Christmas movies Premiere Dates documentary vampires travel chucky james bond RT21 reviews Rocky children's TV Hallmark Brie Larson Shondaland Calendar diversity Comics on TV El Rey FX on Hulu emmy awards award winner TBS DC Universe Horror dramedy Fantasy satire anime APB Classic Film spanish Comedy Central Sneak Peek transformers YouTube Red Turner Classic Movies TV Land Summer technology teaser facebook sitcom History mutant rt archives Lifetime screen actors guild DGA toy story Red Carpet Toys slashers ABC Family