Scream Queen Showdown: Who Is the Ultimate Final Girl?

It's Sigourney Weaver vs. Jamie Lee Curtis vs. Neve Campbell vs. Sarah Michelle Gellar as we break down Tomatometer, box office, performance, iconic moments, and more.

by | October 31, 2020 | Comments

In our latest episode of Vs. we’re paying tribute to cinema’s greatest scream queens… by making them battle it out to the final reel! (To be fair, something each of them has some practice in.) It’s slasher icon Jamie Lee Curtis against sci-fi icon Sigourney Weaver against ghostface killer Neve Campbell against fisherman’s not-friend Sarah Michelle Gellar as we seek to crown horror’s ultimate portrayer of the “final girl.” How will the battle play out? Well, first we’re trapping them in a mansion with about 30 escaped-from-a-mental-hospital serial killers… Oh wait, no, not that, that would be illegal. We’re actually comparing their box office performance, Audience and Tomatometer Scores, and the quality of their enemies, and adding a bonus round for good measure. Will it be Ripley, Laurie, Buffy, or Sidney who lives to earn that sweet sequel paycheck? Watch along as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks it down, then have at us in the comments.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Showtime scorecard franchise Syfy Travel Channel Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pixar cars Extras child's play Nickelodeon Film universal monsters Arrowverse what to watch Lifetime blockbusters Holiday APB Esquire Valentine's Day Ellie Kemper Stephen King Vudu Acorn TV monster movies PBS Endgame Certified Fresh USA Network classics sitcom elevated horror Paramount Plus teaser Box Office BET GLAAD dc TV Apple TV Plus Pride Month 21st Century Fox diversity Ovation Paramount VICE period drama Reality Competition 24 frames Song of Ice and Fire FOX The Purge cancelled television Amazon The CW true crime reviews transformers Character Guide witnail aliens werewolf YouTube Premium Photos San Diego Comic-Con Shondaland Lionsgate nbcuniversal Warner Bros. Mystery telelvision IFC facebook screen actors guild Rock technology DC Universe supernatural cops biography best YouTube Red TCA Winter 2020 hollywood Binge Guide ID a nightmare on elm street Spring TV cancelled TV series 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Peacock ratings 4/20 Action award winner political drama crime thriller casting revenge Emmys streaming TBS cooking American Society of Cinematographers 45 Captain marvel NBC Cannes latino FX on Hulu theme song justice league canceled TV shows Countdown Logo TLC SDCC Elton John Spectrum Originals LGBT cinemax Red Carpet archives Crunchyroll italian black ABC Signature Trailer docudrama sports docuseries book HBO Go 2018 X-Men Fox News criterion Best and Worst canceled CBS cancelled thriller animated news Hulu stop motion 2020 slashers spy thriller Emmy Nominations TV Land women Reality MTV sag awards RT History Starz Tomatazos movie science fiction rotten USA History PaleyFest GoT singing competition romance worst natural history unscripted war Writers Guild of America BBC One space Winter TV indiana jones Cosplay documentary finale Rom-Com Martial Arts The Walt Disney Company jurassic park Amazon Studios Marathons french comiccon Disney Channel E3 Podcast laika spinoff rotten movies we love TIFF Polls and Games Film Festival Alien Biopics Christmas Sony Pictures obituary OWN Awards Classic Film Disney A&E crossover 2016 ITV zombies mission: impossible New York Comic Con Amazon Prime sequels pirates of the caribbean Funimation children's TV renewed TV shows Sci-Fi adventure CNN Broadway Western japanese HBO Mary poppins CBS All Access cults CW Seed Lifetime Christmas movies Infographic king kong Watching Series Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt hist social media ABC Family Avengers Netflix Christmas movies vampires TV renewals Turner comics anthology SXSW Pop TV all-time dark HBO Max Superheroes Heroines The Walking Dead 20th Century Fox cartoon Music prank Quiz Netflix razzies Black Mirror Opinion cats Discovery Channel asian-american boxoffice dogs NYCC Women's History Month superman video on demand AMC spanish Comedy Amazon Prime Video OneApp Shudder 2021 Schedule strong female leads travel Television Academy sequel Drama DGA nfl kong blaxploitation TCA police drama TV One BBC America dceu Exclusive Video WGN 2017 RT21 Hear Us Out quibi Tumblr doctor who YA The Academy game of thrones MCU spanish language Columbia Pictures See It Skip It 2019 mutant Universal 72 Emmy Awards toronto Sundance Now Mudbound psychological thriller Disney streaming service 007 LGBTQ Marvel Ghostbusters 2015 joker Fantasy Winners Nat Geo screenings name the review ViacomCBS Hallmark Christmas movies anime Horror National Geographic Dark Horse Comics toy story Epix green book hispanic BAFTA talk show films nature halloween tv twilight Creative Arts Emmys El Rey die hard E! Musical MSNBC disaster medical drama Paramount Network binge based on movie game show FX video Pop richard e. Grant chucky emmy awards Election Marvel Studios Grammys discovery composers indie VOD zero dark thirty TCM Tubi kaiju 71st Emmy Awards scary movies Comic Book ABC dragons Television Critics Association foreign batman venice jamie lee curtis romantic comedy tv talk Mindy Kaling CMT Masterpiece Trophy Talk Year in Review Bravo Nominations Trivia critics crime historical drama versus Summer Marvel Television crime drama boxing Star Wars Disney Plus independent Super Bowl Legendary fast and furious christmas movies Fox Searchlight FXX hidden camera television dramedy rt archives BET Awards comedies DirecTV DC Comics free movies Disney+ Disney Plus stoner Mary Tyler Moore adaptation First Look parents YouTube WarnerMedia Sundance Video Games blockbuster Animation Apple series Britbox Baby Yoda Freeform Teen serial killer south america GIFs halloween 99% robots golden globes zombie golden globe awards ghosts Holidays Interview deadpool TCA 2017 harry potter cancelled TV shows BBC Pet Sematary football Turner Classic Movies comic Comics on TV festival TNT Toys Awards Tour SundanceTV Premiere Dates TCA Awards worst movies Calendar spider-man australia rom-coms Apple TV+ Kids & Family satire godzilla popular comic books Food Network Hallmark Sneak Peek Set visit festivals Lucasfilm Mary Poppins Returns kids The Arrangement Tarantino First Reviews President IFC Films A24 Brie Larson Oscars PlayStation directors Chernobyl DC streaming service Academy Awards james bond Family Rocketman Spike breaking bad miniseries Black History Month documentaries TruTV Rocky ESPN Star Trek Cartoon Network politics reboot Anna Paquin mockumentary movies fresh Fall TV Thanksgiving Walt Disney Pictures stand-up comedy superhero Pirates trailers concert Crackle psycho Adult Swim The Witch VH1 Sundance TV Country Musicals Superheroe spain remakes Comedy Central