RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... The Amazing Spider-Man 2

We revisit Sony's only Rotten Spider-Man movie to consider whether Andrew Garfield's second outing as Peter Parker is actually better than we thought.

by | January 13, 2022 | Comments

Jamie Foxx as Electro in The Amazing Spider-Man 2

(Photo by ©Columbia Pictures)

Film buffs — and particularly superhero movie fans — have long been aware of the complicated relationship between Marvel and Sony Pictures/Columbia Pictures over the rights to one of the comic book company’s flagship heroes, Spider-Man. The latter has held the film rights to the character since 1999 and shepherded three different franchises (four, if you count the animated Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse) featuring Spidey to the big screen. All of them have been successes, both critically and commercially… with one exception.

Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19

After Sam Raimi’s inaugural Spider-Man franchise fizzled out sometime around 2010, Sony’s second go-round with Peter Parker began in 2012 with The Amazing Spider-Man, which rebooted the character’s story with Andrew Garfield in the role and Emma Stone as love interest Gwen Stacy. Because the film earned a respectable 72% on the Tomatometer (against a 77% Audience Score) and made over $750 million globally, a sequel was as inevitable as Uncle Ben’s death. And so it came to be.

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is the only Rotten Spider-Man movie ever made.

Maybe that shouldn’t have been such a surprise. Andrew Garfield is a phenomenal actor, but he was a 30-year-old playing a high school senior, and the facade cracked just a bit at times. Oscar-winner Jamie Foxx raised expectations for the film as its primary villain, Electro, but the character was so mishandled that when Spider-Man: No Way Home brought him back, he was given a complete makeover. And we won’t even get into that Rhino business.

But — and be warned: major spoilers for Spider-Man: No Way Home follow here — there has been something of a reassessment of TASM2 in the wake of No Way Home, not only because of Foxx’s revamped Electro, but also because of Garfield’s scene-stealing, heartbreaking performance as an alternate-universe Peter Parker. And, as our guest this week would argue, that’s because the heart of The Amazing Spider-Man 2 lies in the romance between Peter and Gwen. This is what sets the film apart from the others, and this is the reason why Garfield’s presence in No Way Home helped elevate the film even further beyond its myriad other pleasures.

Joining regular co-hosts Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley this week is a guest who has been our go-to for Spider-Man-related episodes, the actress, podcast host, and pop culture commentator Roxy Striar, who also joined our discussions on Spider-Man 3 and Venom. Roxy is, unsurprisingly, a huge fan of The Amazing Spider-Man 2 and points to the passionate chemistry between Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone as one of the main reasons the film deserves a Tomatometer score much, much higher than its current 52%. Jacqueline, on the other hand, thinks “this movie is trash” — yikes — and Mark is stuck playing referee somewhere in the middle. Good luck, Mark!

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:

If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.

Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

TV Land Spectrum Originals monster movies Red Carpet Women's History Month IFC Films prank Writers Guild of America AMC Plus halloween tv streaming movies Rock travel Character Guide twilight comics Cannes archives war pirates of the caribbean Pet Sematary indie Tomatazos nature Syfy Arrowverse Thanksgiving Tags: Comedy cults new star wars movies new york ID suspense blockbusters blaxploitation TV renewals DC Universe foreign Set visit Exclusive Video news HBO Disney Channel Elton John sports Valentine's Day rotten movies we love wonder woman Comic Book Tarantino 4/20 films FXX ViacomCBS BBC America Pirates FX on Hulu A24 high school dramedy Nickelodeon 45 telelvision concert Apple TV Plus art house movies PaleyFest action-comedy doctor who based on movie Hulu vs. Disney+ Disney Plus Hollywood Foreign Press Association 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Winners series adenture Vudu stand-up comedy Wes Anderson DC Comics The Walking Dead laika quibi APB Video Games nbcuniversal legend Universal Pictures Comics on TV fast and furious Amazon Prime The Academy crime Columbia Pictures 72 Emmy Awards Showtime 2018 DC streaming service Disney tv talk Photos BAFTA BBC One Song of Ice and Fire sopranos dreamworks Reality Marvel Studios Musical aapi anime MCU Mindy Kaling YA Paramount Plus transformers Pride Month Esquire adaptation casting comic book movies spain Walt Disney Pictures asian-american Academy Awards TV One Cartoon Network Trailer facebook remakes dragons Trivia DirecTV Tumblr DGA Spike rom-coms Adult Swim teaser japanese spanish Awards Tour Prime Video docuseries YouTube Premium fresh NYCC heist movie 2021 technology Tubi 24 frames Infographic live event IMDb TV zombie cancelled TV series batman slasher USA Network Western Superheroe supernatural breaking bad Premiere Dates lord of the rings Sundance dark Pixar debate scene in color Podcast Image Comics 2019 San Diego Comic-Con award winner Lifetime Christmas movies Hallmark know your critic Discovery Channel The Witch CBS a nightmare on elm street YouTube Red FOX Anna Paquin name the review Rom-Com 73rd Emmy Awards WarnerMedia spy thriller Mary poppins genre ABC RT21 Marvel aliens HBO Max rt labs Cosplay Brie Larson VOD GIFs Turner Classic Movies Drama kaiju TNT Travel Channel Nominations Broadway comic emmy awards marvel cinematic universe kong classics all-time science fiction President joker Fox Searchlight National Geographic live action toronto Ghostbusters obituary USA LGBT cooking Horror OWN king kong CNN Watching Series Comedy strong female leads Fargo SundanceTV revenge royal family vampires versus The Purge Holidays Christmas olympics VH1 Universal Netflix canceled TV shows binge Box Office comiccon spider-verse Dark Horse Comics 71st Emmy Awards AMC zero dark thirty trophy Black Mirror rt labs critics edition festival cops Pop black comedy toy story leaderboard VICE south america Paramount Network Crackle Film Festival historical drama Baby Yoda die hard theme song french period drama Countdown stop motion documentary king arthur Reality Competition Mary Tyler Moore rt archives Tokyo Olympics book crime thriller dc werewolf comic books Creative Arts Emmys Sundance Now target hispanic finale saw Pop TV Fall TV History child's play Comic-Con@Home 2021 romance Musicals OneApp festivals richard e. Grant Amazon scary biography ghosts Binge Guide psychological thriller CMT directors PlayStation witnail The Walt Disney Company franchise Fox News CBS All Access canceled Television Academy FX TCA Awards TCA Stephen King Election 99% Funimation Martial Arts 93rd Oscars golden globe awards new zealand New York Comic Con justice league Awards medical drama reviews Lifetime Disney Plus The Arrangement spider-man mob Paramount composers Logo GLAAD Music venice rotten women ESPN Best and Worst cars dogs 2016 talk show MTV Calendar E3 screenings Rocketman what to watch cinemax cartoon space blockbuster Rocky 90s CW Seed Polls and Games robots hollywood Disney streaming service feel good documentaries anthology satire 2017 Trophy Talk NBA miniseries Britbox worst movies Teen Food Network independent BBC james bond Lionsgate See It Skip It Endgame Mudbound Quiz TLC worst Animation Starz dceu 20th Century Fox Sci-Fi singing competition discovery critic resources TV movies Acorn TV Year in Review Certified Fresh biopic christmas movies Marvel Television Fantasy boxing nfl Schedule streaming Peacock golden globes sag awards international animated trailers Warner Bros. Crunchyroll Spring TV basketball LGBTQ ITV cats gangster Ellie Kemper posters Television Critics Association Masterpiece natural history chucky superman spanish language dexter 79th Golden Globes Awards BET TCM universal monsters children's TV latino mission: impossible television spinoff critics TCA Winter 2020 Sony Pictures mcc zombies Oscars game of thrones sequels kids movie reboot BET Awards TIFF razzies Shondaland indiana jones halloween Epix E! HBO Go 21st Century Fox Hallmark Christmas movies YouTube thriller diversity australia Neflix Shudder crossover Instagram Live Turner japan Apple TV+ politics TCA 2017 hidden camera Freeform ABC Signature green book Comedy Central game show comedies video on demand Amazon Studios HFPA Netflix Christmas movies SXSW disaster godzilla Nat Geo screen actors guild Country Star Trek IFC Sundance TV First Look best marvel comics renewed TV shows Heroines Grammys GoT hist crime drama Family A&E El Rey Emmys romantic comedy The CW Ovation black social media cancelled television Lucasfilm MSNBC Star Wars Holiday Superheroes political drama jamie lee curtis Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Hear Us Out stoner scary movies First Reviews italian Bravo 1990s PBS 007 deadpool mutant Mystery RT History WGN free movies NBC TBS Mary Poppins Returns sitcom cancelled TV shows superhero ratings sequel Opinion docudrama Sneak Peek Kids & Family Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Black History Month Biopics hispanic heritage month Alien Captain marvel police drama book adaptation Winter TV Extras Amazon Prime Video Summer young adult elevated horror American Society of Cinematographers football parents Toys comic book movie ABC Family Legendary Action X-Men adventure harry potter Super Bowl TV popular scorecard cancelled 2015 Apple 2020 criterion unscripted Avengers Pacific Islander jurassic park Film mockumentary psycho Chernobyl Classic Film true crime boxoffice Interview slashers serial killer TruTV video Emmy Nominations SDCC Marathons