RT Podcast

"Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong" About... Deep Blue Sea (with Special Guest Saffron Burrows)

The star of Netflix's You dives deep to tell us why her 1999 smart-shark creature feature is more than just "Jaws Lite."

by | December 2, 2021 | Comments

Saffron Burrows in Deep Blue Sea (1999)

(Photo by Warner Bros.)

In the canon of notable shark movies, 1999’s Deep Blue Sea resides somewhere between Jaws and Sharknado, scary enough to provide some good jolts and campy enough to inspire a few genuine laughs. In some cases – see: the now-infamous sudden demise of Samuel L. Jackson’s Russell Franklin – you got both in the same scene. Opening just two weeks after The Blair Witch Project and one week ahead of The Sixth SenseDeep Blue Sea nevertheless managed to attract a sizable audience and carve out a space for itself during a summer that included Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom MenaceThe Mummy, and American Pie.


Listen Now: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher TuneIn | Google Podcasts | Radio Public | Deezer | iHeart | Art19


Despite its healthy box office take (it grossed over $165 million worldwide), the film just barely missed the Fresh threshold at 59% on the Tomatometer, and though it spawned a pair of sequels and sparked a retrospective reassessment as one of the greatest shark movies of all time, it maintains a surprisingly low Audience Score of 39%. It also marked the beginning of director Renny Harlin’s descent into shlocky, poorly reviewed clunkers after he showed promise with action fare like Die Hard 2 and Cliffhanger.

While fans of the film acknowledge its goofier B-movie trappings, they’re keen to point out its focus on its characters – LL Cool J’s resident chef Preacher is a highlight – and its effective slow build to the carnage that unfolds in the latter half of the film. There’s clearly a divide between those who feel it isn’t nearly frightening or funny enough and those who feel it accomplishes both with surprising efficiency, and that ultimately may come down to an “agree to disagree” stalemate. But for those who enjoy the gory, campy thrills of Deep Blue Sea, there is no redemption to be found in the Tomatometer or Audience Score.

One person who finds this a particularly egregious injustice admittedly has a dog – or a shark – in the fight: Saffron Burrows, who stars in Deep Blue Sea as the ill-fated Dr. Susan McCallister. Burrows can currently be seen in the hit Netflix series You, whose third season premiered a little over a month ago, and she’s also preparing to make her directorial debut on a film called Everything I Ever Wanted to Tell My Daughter About Men. But this week, she dives deep with co-hosts Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley talk about favorite scenes and reminisce about her experience making the film.

Aside from breaking down what, in her opinion, makes Deep Blue Sea such an effective thriller, Burrows has a wealth of fun stories from the set to share. She explains how dangerous the mechanical sharks used in the film actually were and describes how her seasick co-stars Jackson and Thomas Jane fell asleep during a scene on a lifeboat. Burrows also explains how her character was originally supposed to survive but rewritten to perish after test-screening audiences called out for her death (ouch!), and recounts the time Jackson essentially saved her from drowning when Harlin thought she was just turning in a killer performance.

Check in every Thursday for a new episode of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast From Rotten Tomatoes). Each week, hosts Jacqueline and Mark and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”


Check out some more episodes of Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong:


If you have a suggestion for a movie or show you think we should do an episode on, let us know in the comments, or email us at rtiswrong@rottentomatoes.com.


Meet the hosts

Jacqueline Coley is an editor at Rotten Tomatoes, with a focus on awards and indie coverage but with a passion for everything, from the MCU to musicals and period pieces. Coley is a regular moderator at conventions and other events, can be seen on Access Hollywood and other shows, and will not stand Constantine slander of any kind. Follow Jacqueline on Twitter: @THATjacqueline.

Mark Ellis is a comedian and contributing editor for Rotten Tomatoes. He currently hosts the Rotten Tomatoes series Versus, among others, and can be seen co-hosting the sports entertainment phenomenon Movie Trivia Schmoedown. His favorite Star Wars movie is Jedi (guess which one!), his favorite person is actually a dog (his beloved stepdaughter Mollie), and – thanks to this podcast – he’s about to watch Burlesque for the first time in his life. Follow Mark on Twitter: @markellislive.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.


Tag Cloud

79th Golden Globes Awards japan singing competition rom-coms Masterpiece Countdown Reality Competition dexter Christmas criterion Crunchyroll Tomatazos biography james bond Watching Series discovery mission: impossible venice Pet Sematary hist Best Actor Calendar Comedy Native summer preview twilight golden globe awards zombie Best Picture binge Amazon Prime Video Anna Paquin Set visit anthology sopranos Chernobyl award winner black Sundance TCA Awards hollywood interviews spy thriller Binge Guide Amazon universal monsters critic resources Superheroe sequels WarnerMedia VH1 TCA Winter 2020 vampires Ghostbusters TV One stoner obi wan Winter TV Shudder TV Land Reality Turner historical drama cats MTV jurassic park adaptation doctor who black comedy Apple Cosplay news a nightmare on elm street adenture DGA PlayStation worst Trailer Dark Horse Comics debate all-time renewed TV shows VICE South by Southwest Film Festival Certified Fresh action-comedy popular E3 canceled TV shows Focus Features BET Awards Fox News Mary poppins sequel Western Travel Channel TNT young adult Peacock History aapi spanish mob classics FX marvel comics spider-man The Walking Dead Quiz TV Hear Us Out The Academy Country Film Festival nfl BBC America justice league Mudbound supernatural Tubi Chilling Adventures of Sabrina crime thriller documentaries comic The Purge stand-up comedy 90s The Arrangement feel good SDCC latino international diversity talk show Ovation cartoon new zealand Toys Extras American Society of Cinematographers directors deadpool crossover President 24 frames Pride Month comic books Super Bowl 72 Emmy Awards Lifetime Christmas movies disaster Captain marvel series rotten Animation sports Sony Pictures IFC Films biopic Video Games Photos Hallmark Christmas movies Mystery Kids & Family New York Comic Con USA witnail japanese based on movie best CNN WGN Stephen King Legendary indiana jones women Podcast 2017 concert Comic-Con@Home 2021 Tarantino boxing theme song Mary Tyler Moore elevated horror tv talk vs. Black Mirror football Brie Larson Sony PBS stop motion zero dark thirty Showtime Fall TV Shondaland south america travel emmy awards sitcom Action new star wars movies archives DirecTV 20th Century Fox 21st Century Fox DC streaming service documentary See It Skip It Tokyo Olympics RT21 ViacomCBS harry potter free movies true crime Film USA Network composers First Look Adult Swim kids Holiday Television Academy SundanceTV Endgame Martial Arts Pop Fox Searchlight italian Marvel Television Pixar 2021 FXX green book satire child's play cults serial killer 94th Oscars SXSW 2022 spain FX on Hulu cancelled television crime Instagram Live marvel cinematic universe thriller king kong ID Trivia Britbox Marathons posters CBS Hulu Neflix Tags: Comedy TCA 2017 cancelled TV shows comiccon christmas movies TLC toronto 2020 legend A&E Broadway cooking Red Carpet hispanic boxoffice psychological thriller FOX Spring TV Warner Bros. king arthur book Awards Tour versus breaking bad kaiju Star Wars hidden camera Star Trek Schedule Rom-Com romance The Witch comic book movies game show Indigenous slashers razzies cancelled Vudu target scene in color ESPN Winners pirates of the caribbean scary movies Oscar Best Director Nominations target TCM AMC Plus batman 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 2015 Black History Month Musical Prime Video Classic Film docuseries Ellie Kemper psycho 2019 war 2016 monster movies cinemax Music Biopics Comic Book festival Lifetime political drama YA Sundance Now golden globes jamie lee curtis video trailers aliens Crackle suspense screen actors guild adventure Disney Plus broadcast Alien DC Universe films Cannes screenings royal family nature Wes Anderson Summer 73rd Emmy Awards quibi BBC what to watch Pirates Esquire Academy Awards olympics zombies Image Comics slasher halloween Hallmark fast and furious new york Nat Geo TBS werewolf indie Epix miniseries cancelled TV series Marvel mockumentary Best and Worst Awards Creative Arts Emmys CBS All Access prank Grammys asian-american Universal summer TV preview name the review Disney Family Lucasfilm ABC Signature Turner Classic Movies Exclusive Video animated 1990s NBA Emmy Nominations Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt die hard HBO Max strong female leads NYCC El Rey parents casting 45 revenge Starz Comics on TV Nickelodeon Horror telelvision wonder woman Heroines comic book movie leaderboard halloween tv Lionsgate SXSW medical drama Acorn TV scene in color film series Interview scene in color series Thanksgiving Premiere Dates TIFF transformers Trophy Talk LGBTQ blaxploitation Fantasy Amazon Studios know your critic Disney streaming service laika superman First Reviews BAFTA unscripted remakes Geeked Week live event Spike Universal Pictures summer TV MSNBC OWN Mary Poppins Returns Opinion TV movies Character Guide rotten movies we love foreign Star Wars Celebration Sundance TV cops Fargo teaser Netflix Christmas movies Women's History Month comics reboot Cartoon Network Spectrum Originals BBC One ITV worst movies Apple TV Plus fresh richard e. Grant finale Columbia Pictures art house french rt labs HBO TruTV television scorecard Sci-Fi Mindy Kaling cars lord of the rings Walt Disney Pictures independent A24 joker MCU spinoff CMT Bravo X-Men Syfy APB Year in Review Pacific Islander Arrowverse police drama dramedy Valentine's Day Emmys Election ratings Oscars GLAAD rt archives IMDb TV Song of Ice and Fire basketball Discovery Channel gangster docudrama Hollywood Foreign Press Association dc San Diego Comic-Con HBO Go streamig Disney Channel toy story VOD Paramount Pictures godzilla festivals streaming movies romantic comedy National Geographic YouTube Red social media Baby Yoda Marvel Studios AMC critics Television Critics Association LGBT 007 chucky scary OneApp mcc anime 2018 Comedy Central game of thrones science fiction superhero movie ghosts Polls and Games HFPA franchise Funimation Rock GoT Superheroes Box Office movies dogs genre children's TV scene in color obituary nbcuniversal video on demand blockbusters Rocketman technology PaleyFest dreamworks period drama Tumblr TV renewals Paramount spanish language GIFs Freeform blockbuster Avengers DC Comics 71st Emmy Awards Writers Guild of America book adaptation hispanic heritage month streaming ABC robots crime drama canceled TCA RT History sag awards facebook natural history high school rt labs critics edition E! Sneak Peek dark IFC CW Seed live action space 93rd Oscars Paramount Plus spider-verse Logo Musicals heist movie 4/20 mutant saw Elton John Drama BET comedies MGM NBC Infographic The Walt Disney Company Disney+ Disney Plus politics trophy dragons Teen Holidays Rocky kong australia YouTube Premium Amazon Prime Netflix Pop TV dceu Apple TV+ The CW Paramount Network reviews Food Network 99% Best Actress ABC Family YouTube