Rotten Tomatoes' Early Oscar Predictions: Best Supporting Actor

Pesci, Pacino, Pitt: It's a battle of the megastars when it comes to Supporting Actors this year.

by | November 6, 2019 | Comments


(Photo by Courtesy of Netflix)

We’re at the stage in awards season where we can mostly peg who’s competing for Lead Actor and who is competing for Supporting. Though there has been no ‘official’ word yet on Christian Bale and Matt Damon for Ford vs. Ferrari, early whispers have both Oscar winners going lead. In truth, the supporting performances prove the hardest because the category on both sides is often stacked with leading performances that are being positioned for supporting to up their chances of winning.

For the supporting performances in 2020, we see a reversal of previous years. The men seem to have the hardest path to a nomination, while the female side is relatively more straightforward. As with our Best Actor predictions, the list of male supporting performances runs deep, with several marquee names and newcomers in contention. Post-TIFF-Telluride-Venice, a number of the films likely to be in the conversation have already screened and earned Tomatometer scores, plus the pundits are already singling out the major standout performances in them. We’re sifting through all that noise and breaking down our  early picks for 2020 Best Supporting Actor contenders.

Don’t agree with our picks? Have at us in the comments.

Sterling K. Brown Waves (2019) 84%

Who doesn’t love Sterling K. Brown? The This Is Us star has charmed his way into the hearts of America with his moving and hilarious portrayal of Randall on the hit NBC drama. Even more impressive, the actor managed that while filming his performance in the third effort for up-and-coming indie favorite Trey Edward Shults – that’s right, he shot a full feature film while the weekly drama was still in production. Waves is a film that is best enjoyed when you go in knowing as little as possible, so we don’t want to give too much away here, but the Emmy winner’s turn as the stern and demanding father to Kelvin Harrison Jr.’s model minority son is frightening, charismatic, and gut-wrenching. Perhaps the largest obstacle in the way of Brown making it to Oscar night will be how the Academy reacts to the film’s distinctive narrative style.

Tom Hanks, A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood (2019) 95%

It is fitting that the nicest and most beloved man in Hollywood would portray the nicest man to ever grace our television screens. Fred Rogers was an icon of children’s television and a relentless advocate for the value of carving out a safe space for children on our airways. Since the first trailer was released back in July – and sometime before that, if we’re being are honest – Tom Hanks has been on just about every prognosticator’s shortlist for Oscar glory. (Though the same was said of his performance in The Post back in 2018, and he failed to garner a nomination.) Marielle Heller, who directed Richard E. Grant and Melissa McCarthy to dual Oscar nominations last year in Can You Ever Forgive Me?, is poised to maybe do the same for Hanks and lead Matthew Rhys in 2020. Perhaps after a couple of nominations for Heller’s film, we can finally get over the fact the Mr. Rogers documentary Won’t You Be My Neighbor? failed to make it to Oscar night this year.

Joe Pesci and Al Pacino, The Irishman (2019) 95%


(Photo by Netflix)

Last year, during the Oscars ceremony, as Netflix was racking up multiple wins from its 15 nominations, the studio opted to play a teaser for Martin Scorsese’s upcoming and long-awaited film The Irishman. It was a signal to the Academy and anyone who was watching that regardless of what happened that night, they were just getting started. With the movie currently Certified Fresh at 97% on the Tomatometer, Scorsese and company are set to rack up multiple nominations, including likely dual nominations for Al Pacino and Joe Pesci. The latter came out of retirement to play quietly menacing mob figure Russell Bufalino in the film, while Pacino portrays the teamster boss Jimmy Hoffa. Both men are operating at the height of their powers for this new mob epic based on a script by Steven Zaillian. The only thing standing in the way of Pacino or Pesci taking home the top prize is Brad Pitt, but more on that later.

Jamie Foxx, Just Mercy (2019) 85%

Warner Bros. Pictures

(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures)

The Academy is particularly fond of films that pair riveting performances with a timely message (see BlacKkKlansman and Get Out for recent examples). Just Mercy is a true-life adaptation of Bryan Stevenson’s book chronicling the Harvard Lawyer’s founding of the Equal Justice Initiative and his attempts to navigate the perilous world of death row incarceration and bring exoneration to those wrongly convicted. Set in the heart of Alabama, the book and movie from director Destin Daniel Cretton both shine a light on the systematic racism of our criminal justice system, which so often unjustly incarcerates African-Americans. One of Stevenson’s first and most high-profile clients, Walter McMillian, is the focus of the narrative and is brought to life by Jamie Foxx. Foxx is powerful and tragic as the downhearted inmate just months away from execution, and he is getting his best reviews since his Oscar-winning role in Ray. Foxx’s history with the Academy and the film’s subject matter place him as a strong contender, though if there were any real justice in this world, his co-star Rob Morgan would be right there in contention with him for his brief but powerful depiction of another death row inmate.

Brad Pitt Once Upon a Time... In Hollywood (2019) 85%

With such a stacked field, star power could be the thing that tips the vote – and no one has more star power than Brad Pitt. Now that we are confident the A-lister is competing for the supporting category and not for lead, we are placing our money on his chances for a nomination and potentially winning it all. Pitt’s quiet confidence and cocksure smile as strong and silent stuntman Cliff Booth has charmed both critics and audiences alike. Though the star has come out saying that he doesn’t plan to campaign, the veteran actor and producer may not have much to say in the matter; it is the studio and friends of potential nominees that have more say in how the film is rolled out to critics and Academy members.

Also in contention: 

  • Timothée Chalamet (Little Women)
  • Anthony Hopkins (Two Popes)
  • Rob Morgan (Just Mercy)
  • Shia LaBeouf (Honey Boy)
  • Wesley Snipes (Dolemite Is My Name)
  • Jonathan Majors (The Last Black Man in San Francisco)
  • Jamie Bell (Rocketman)
  • Willem Dafoe (The Lighthouse)
  • Alan Alda (Marriage Story)

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

technology YouTube Red 71st Emmy Awards classics Crackle Apple TV+ CBS canceled blockbuster Marvel Studios trailers Summer LGBTQ The Walking Dead RT History Amazon Studios Rocky Extras king kong singing competition Avengers Writers Guild of America movies franchise dark feel good DC streaming service Tomatazos Ovation canceled TV shows mutant latino reviews australia toy story indiana jones SXSW dexter mockumentary halloween tv Rocketman Legendary casting MTV comic books Video Games Red Carpet saw tv talk Vudu Toys finale Cartoon Network TCA Awards Creative Arts Emmys popular Discovery Channel boxoffice WarnerMedia Star Wars book Mystery 20th Century Fox Cannes jamie lee curtis live event FOX Calendar toronto critic resources slashers Mary Poppins Returns 2019 FX Tags: Comedy Song of Ice and Fire Comedy hispanic heritage month Oscars kong Grammys royal family GLAAD Amazon cars ABC Family mcc Amazon Prime 2015 SundanceTV james bond Schedule DGA Action Film target Food Network Syfy Sundance screenings BAFTA Pixar japanese Epix revenge what to watch asian-american action-comedy The Academy gangster cops Premiere Dates National Geographic APB Masterpiece dc quibi The CW Emmys Mary Tyler Moore Country Pride Month dceu venice composers Peacock Paramount Network Rock japan marvel cinematic universe Fantasy Captain marvel biography OWN italian aliens Prime Video crime thriller spinoff Election Mary poppins Super Bowl SDCC aapi cancelled TV shows wonder woman 72 Emmy Awards sag awards 2018 RT21 Spike hispanic Black History Month films Shudder debate versus Mudbound Anna Paquin supernatural Pet Sematary children's TV BET Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dramedy Sundance TV CW Seed fresh Lucasfilm Netflix robots cartoon archives Lifetime spanish language HBO Go slasher harry potter rt archives stand-up comedy HFPA know your critic talk show comiccon Amazon Prime Video Chilling Adventures of Sabrina foreign Disney+ Disney Plus screen actors guild Martial Arts President sopranos Disney Plus serial killer X-Men television science fiction Interview Sony Pictures Comic-Con@Home 2021 TV movies Countdown psycho documentaries ABC E3 Pirates Pop TV 93rd Oscars high school Academy Awards black NBA Disney diversity comic witnail TV Fox News TCA BET hollywood Nickelodeon dreamworks Superheroe Travel Channel anthology romance Photos Comics on TV Trailer 24 frames Hollywood Foreign Press Association romantic comedy zombie The Walt Disney Company sequel worst AMC deadpool art house anime Nominations Comic Book The Purge historical drama south america 007 crime drama french doctor who Britbox scene in color Winter TV Tubi DC Universe political drama golden globe awards zombies emmy awards GIFs blockbusters Exclusive Video Universal Pictures name the review game of thrones TCA Winter 2020 Marvel Television FX on Hulu adenture Infographic spy thriller American Society of Cinematographers disaster criterion Certified Fresh Netflix Christmas movies TruTV Trophy Talk directors Acorn TV MCU elevated horror cats A24 animated Hear Us Out medical drama FXX ghosts IFC Films Holiday marvel comics sports halloween Disney Channel Turner Classic Movies TLC Kids & Family batman telelvision independent twilight HBO Max Cosplay Ghostbusters TV renewals period drama USA Spectrum Originals CMT kids new star wars movies war transformers Set visit video Alien travel TV One adventure book adaptation 2017 cinemax chucky superman Rom-Com Thanksgiving 2016 TCA 2017 game show cancelled television football Bravo Emmy Nominations Sci-Fi Western binge Drama stop motion Comedy Central discovery black comedy Teen ITV social media laika 90s stoner basketball 21st Century Fox E! Animation cancelled History Nat Geo Watching Series ratings VICE YA Horror Neflix hidden camera pirates of the caribbean VH1 biopic Reality Competition mob Ellie Kemper christmas movies Spring TV 79th Golden Globes Awards spider-verse Universal worst movies Biopics king arthur PaleyFest NYCC Tumblr Box Office docudrama Hulu rt labs critics edition Binge Guide DirecTV legend docuseries trophy TCM vs. indie cancelled TV series YouTube spanish Brie Larson free movies kaiju leaderboard movie women monster movies Best and Worst richard e. Grant comics renewed TV shows spain young adult news mission: impossible concert Pop olympics prank reboot blaxploitation Quiz critics Hallmark Christmas movies Opinion facebook 2020 dogs adaptation Columbia Pictures CNN lord of the rings festival nature Chernobyl satire police drama Mindy Kaling child's play sequels suspense international 73rd Emmy Awards DC Comics First Look obituary Starz WGN PlayStation nfl TV Land Fargo posters Winners ID Hallmark Awards The Witch Family rotten streaming movies new zealand Television Academy USA Network Apple space best First Reviews Holidays Logo golden globes streaming CBS All Access miniseries San Diego Comic-Con Arrowverse Instagram Live heist movie 4/20 a nightmare on elm street unscripted YouTube Premium Baby Yoda Wes Anderson true crime Tokyo Olympics Shondaland comic book movie Fox Searchlight thriller BBC Marvel Superheroes Dark Horse Comics series BBC America Image Comics Classic Film Funimation jurassic park festivals Musicals Polls and Games award winner cooking Turner Sneak Peek 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Paramount Plus vampires rom-coms hist Film Festival superhero NBC natural history die hard Musical PBS rotten movies we love new york GoT 45 crossover A&E Black Mirror Marathons IFC boxing Trivia Reality LGBT TBS zero dark thirty genre Crunchyroll Character Guide Warner Bros. documentary Walt Disney Pictures Year in Review ViacomCBS universal monsters Valentine's Day werewolf Women's History Month all-time Endgame BBC One Music scorecard Adult Swim IMDb TV dragons TNT scary movies based on movie breaking bad AMC Plus See It Skip It TIFF Elton John Lionsgate Sundance Now psychological thriller comic book movies rt labs fast and furious Podcast 1990s Broadway teaser Fall TV razzies joker strong female leads New York Comic Con Television Critics Association Apple TV Plus Paramount cults godzilla live action Heroines Stephen King remakes theme song OneApp 99% green book MSNBC parents scary Tarantino Star Trek VOD Christmas El Rey video on demand Pacific Islander HBO sitcom Awards Tour justice league crime politics 2021 Esquire Lifetime Christmas movies comedies The Arrangement nbcuniversal spider-man Showtime Disney streaming service ABC Signature ESPN Freeform