Ridley Scott vs. James Cameron: Which Director Rules Sci-Fi Action?

The two influential directors who separately gave us Blade Runner, Gladiator, The Terminator, Alien and Aliens go head-to-head according to Tomatometer, box office, and more!

by | June 3, 2020 | Comments

It’s the first ever director face-off in our Vs. series, and it’s an epic battle between two of the most influential filmmakers of our time – especially when it comes to action and sci-fi cinema. In the one corner you have Sir Ridley Scott, the man who gave us Alien, Blade Runner, Gladiator, and… The Counselor. (Mean, we know.) In the other corner is James Cameron, the man who gave us Aliens, The Terminator, Titanic, and… Piranha II: The Spawning. (Really.) Which director comes out on top when it comes to box office, Tomatometer and Audience Score, influence, and more? Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis is crunching the numbers and making the big calls and, as ever, if you don’t agree with the verdict, let us know in the comments.

Thumbnail images by Everett Collection and ©Fox 2000 courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Brie Larson best target Acorn TV SXSW President video History Ovation batman breaking bad rotten crime movies psychological thriller superman disaster Marvel Studios black comedy hollywood king kong Britbox TIFF Hallmark Christmas movies french NBA indie monster movies chucky Exclusive Video miniseries sports spider-verse Nominations Arrowverse 71st Emmy Awards TV anthology BET Awards Drama free movies SundanceTV name the review animated doctor who travel Cannes Apple TV Plus zero dark thirty nfl Comedy Pride Month fast and furious Fox Searchlight Captain marvel Sundance book posters Music pirates of the caribbean jurassic park Disney Channel TruTV Family SDCC werewolf king arthur nature toy story rt labs critics edition 2017 sag awards legend Kids & Family 2019 The Arrangement Television Academy The Witch football boxoffice spy thriller OneApp cancelled television true crime medical drama biopic DC Universe psycho screen actors guild harry potter Universal HBO Best and Worst Fantasy Year in Review films stand-up comedy Fargo TCA Awards Schedule RT History Lionsgate Horror The Walking Dead live event TV renewals crossover Avengers venice Syfy spanish robots YouTube Red ViacomCBS directors scene in color slasher satire quibi finale Sundance Now PlayStation dark Certified Fresh Classic Film Nat Geo blockbusters Tokyo Olympics Cartoon Network japanese south america vampires Ghostbusters Awards Tour TCA Rock OWN facebook Martial Arts criterion Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Bravo VICE AMC MSNBC FOX festivals Reality Competition 90s parents NBC halloween debate Countdown cinemax lord of the rings Fox News Sundance TV new zealand Character Guide movie Film HBO Go singing competition TLC saw Shudder Disney Plus The Academy police drama indiana jones Oscars superhero hidden camera Superheroe YA critics Grammys FXX based on movie basketball Lucasfilm discovery PaleyFest binge IMDb TV Cosplay PBS CNN Paramount Plus golden globes nbcuniversal mockumentary Mary Tyler Moore spanish language AMC Plus GoT LGBT TBS christmas movies 21st Century Fox young adult Tumblr Apple cancelled TV shows ID Television Critics Association romance Musicals australia Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Summer CBS DC Comics Animation composers green book WarnerMedia Stephen King justice league USA E3 archives Baby Yoda science fiction Mary poppins Infographic Disney streaming service book adaptation First Reviews ABC Lifetime Adult Swim WGN dc Calendar comic know your critic mutant hispanic heritage month comiccon Paramount Network comic book movies TV movies Turner Classic Movies CMT Country Black History Month FX on Hulu comedies MCU Academy Awards Netflix Christmas movies suspense 73rd Emmy Awards telelvision comic books heist movie series kong Walt Disney Pictures Trophy Talk Marathons Winners latino romantic comedy die hard 2018 fresh LGBTQ blockbuster Epix CW Seed sequel Spike cancelled TV series concert Rom-Com strong female leads Endgame Logo women ABC Signature Tomatazos Pixar teaser National Geographic wonder woman Heroines GIFs award winner stop motion Showtime DirecTV 2020 Tarantino space japan Holiday Columbia Pictures deadpool rt labs ITV Mindy Kaling The Purge Star Wars Tubi San Diego Comic-Con Premiere Dates trailers emmy awards Box Office anime zombie Holidays Rocky Anna Paquin cancelled technology Esquire IFC twilight 45 festival aliens streaming cops worst movies Photos child's play DC streaming service all-time Black Mirror diversity Set visit asian-american 20th Century Fox mcc TNT A&E cartoon international Thanksgiving Neflix Comedy Central Trivia Mystery italian witnail feel good Apple TV+ casting mob 2016 television olympics Podcast 72 Emmy Awards 2015 screenings ESPN Pop TV talk show HBO Max james bond Wes Anderson hist aapi dexter Spectrum Originals scorecard Christmas prank First Look Disney+ Disney Plus Reality See It Skip It stoner obituary Lifetime Christmas movies classics 24 frames TV One adaptation Sneak Peek 2021 Crunchyroll TCA Winter 2020 high school Writers Guild of America Discovery Channel jamie lee curtis game of thrones Crackle what to watch VH1 streaming movies sopranos game show Broadway ghosts BBC One canceled TV shows Shondaland dogs USA Network reviews independent live action DGA Toys critic resources CBS All Access docudrama Winter TV Super Bowl Vudu cooking revenge Hulu Extras sitcom Netflix Paramount action-comedy toronto Marvel Television Amazon Prime biography Western spain BAFTA Food Network black Women's History Month Disney political drama dramedy foreign El Rey Alien Creative Arts Emmys Mary Poppins Returns Polls and Games IFC Films The CW Instagram Live new star wars movies Emmys scary 007 art house war documentaries Opinion Superheroes Spring TV kaiju docuseries Comic-Con@Home 2021 rt archives vs. Pet Sematary Rocketman canceled Peacock Action laika ratings Election hispanic unscripted A24 Comic Book comics halloween tv Ellie Kemper marvel cinematic universe Song of Ice and Fire news 99% TCM dreamworks FX adenture X-Men crime thriller children's TV Watching Series Teen Hallmark genre royal family politics elevated horror 93rd Oscars documentary BET Valentine's Day thriller rotten movies we love Freeform zombies New York Comic Con Musical popular transformers VOD The Walt Disney Company NYCC Image Comics Chernobyl Fall TV cats richard e. Grant Sony Pictures Funimation tv talk YouTube Premium new york Red Carpet comic book movie Awards supernatural MTV Amazon Studios marvel comics BBC America reboot renewed TV shows cults Pop Emmy Nominations E! godzilla blaxploitation historical drama Marvel Starz a nightmare on elm street spider-man golden globe awards Video Games universal monsters Biopics Travel Channel Universal Pictures Masterpiece TCA 2017 Mudbound Warner Bros. Legendary Sci-Fi 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Turner American Society of Cinematographers rom-coms APB mission: impossible natural history dragons slashers worst gangster Trailer serial killer 1990s sequels franchise Film Festival GLAAD Dark Horse Comics YouTube social media Pacific Islander adventure Binge Guide Pirates Comics on TV cars Amazon crime drama joker scary movies razzies dceu RT21 kids video on demand Amazon Prime Video theme song Interview Nickelodeon versus Elton John Star Trek Quiz TV Land Hear Us Out 4/20 boxing period drama spinoff ABC Family remakes BBC