POW! Read Comics & Graphic Novels vs. The Critics!

by | July 23, 2010 | Comments

To celebrate the 2010 Comic-Con, we present to you Comics & Graphic Novels vs. the Critics, an exhaustive countdown that includes movies based on everything from superheroes to graphic novels, from manga to strips from the funny pages — in order of critical approval.

We can see those thought bubbles above your heads — you’re wondering how we compiled this thing. Here’s the breakdown: every movie here originates from a comic book source of some kind, not another medium (we know about the Alien vs. Predator graphic novels, but the movies aren’t based on the comics). Only movies with 20 or more reviews are included (sorry, Fritz the Cat), and we use a weighted formula that takes release year and number of reviews into account (see How It Works for more). We also omitted all TV or straight-to-DVD flicks.

Now remove the protective plastic bag, flip to the first page, and dig into Comics & Graphic Novels vs. the Critics!

Tag Cloud

007 comic Cosplay mockumentary Avengers Cannes venice Mindy Kaling boxoffice Cartoon Network Sundance miniseries canceled Hallmark asian-american WarnerMedia Lionsgate Paramount comics Quiz Disney Channel HBO Go nfl The Arrangement El Rey Funimation comedies dceu Crackle spanish language LGBTQ true crime science fiction 72 Emmy Awards versus Pirates Disney Plus Academy Awards justice league crime drama Amazon Prime Video Premiere Dates Winter TV streaming Trophy Talk mutant Superheroe 2015 Brie Larson BBC TCA indie Marvel Television Chernobyl Netflix Christmas movies Travel Channel 2019 Calendar singing competition ABC television animated natural history Film Festival IFC Films Photos MTV cancelled ESPN cancelled television Mystery Starz sports 2020 free movies superhero book adventure Nominations latino sequels scorecard Biopics dragons jamie lee curtis Animation Tubi Walt Disney Pictures CMT Comics on TV Pop TV what to watch psycho TCM Film vampires VH1 GoT thriller Britbox dark nature BBC America NBC First Reviews Food Network CBS All Access FOX worst movies Ellie Kemper Elton John Marvel comiccon Watching Series Red Carpet based on movie twilight zombies stoner Vudu theme song cooking Awards Tour cancelled TV shows Best and Worst transformers Mary Poppins Returns MSNBC PlayStation Infographic Lifetime Christmas movies spain Holiday war 4/20 RT21 CW Seed dc Emmy Nominations 2017 cults Stephen King Pet Sematary Sci-Fi Chilling Adventures of Sabrina video on demand LGBT TruTV Video Games CBS TCA Awards space universal monsters 71st Emmy Awards cops FX unscripted criterion emmy awards indiana jones zombie worst diversity The Witch ratings VOD TIFF period drama Musical documentary Crunchyroll BAFTA facebook Sony Pictures hist DC streaming service renewed TV shows BBC One Dark Horse Comics zero dark thirty Pixar The Purge Apple TV Plus FXX franchise hispanic rotten movies we love Arrowverse Epix fast and furious Rock Reality Competition Amazon Prime Star Wars Paramount Network E! award winner police drama batman GLAAD Shondaland Toys 20th Century Fox TV Comic Book ITV GIFs crime thriller TCA 2017 kids Fox News Lifetime E3 Captain marvel FX on Hulu laika Hallmark Christmas movies Horror sequel mission: impossible ghosts Ovation romantic comedy reboot San Diego Comic-Con Countdown Marvel Studios Grammys Black History Month Bravo dramedy DGA TLC Super Bowl Disney streaming service parents Esquire werewolf technology APB spider-man Opinion stand-up comedy Set visit Netflix game show Television Critics Association BET Awards scary movies hollywood Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt stop motion Sneak Peek obituary Thanksgiving disaster witnail ABC Family anthology Martial Arts USA Disney+ Disney Plus Music festival WGN Television Academy Creative Arts Emmys Ghostbusters Rocketman Turner Classic Movies cinemax movie Spectrum Originals Valentine's Day Trivia Syfy directors Adult Swim films Christmas IFC A24 A&E politics YA DC Comics cancelled TV series romance harry potter teaser south america First Look Peacock screen actors guild series Classic Film 2016 Star Trek Family casting composers Apple Mary Tyler Moore Shudder Logo Pride Month Musicals X-Men aliens toy story Holidays spy thriller CNN Schedule HBO strong female leads Pop finale game of thrones The CW Year in Review NYCC docudrama canceled TV shows children's TV TNT spinoff best Lucasfilm travel 21st Century Fox Tomatazos Summer christmas movies child's play History sitcom National Geographic dogs green book critics rotten Kids & Family 45 video Reality DirecTV social media Polls and Games VICE SXSW Nickelodeon Nat Geo doctor who Mudbound a nightmare on elm street robots Fall TV HBO Max die hard SDCC Warner Bros. 2018 Hear Us Out Spike Rocky DC Universe Disney YouTube Red Comedy Western TV renewals cars USA Network Amazon Studios Women's History Month Fantasy Awards historical drama serial killer Sundance TV AMC Universal binge Teen football Podcast nbcuniversal New York Comic Con The Walking Dead Action screenings medical drama Election Drama cats TBS Trailer OneApp name the review crossover TV Land Freeform halloween YouTube foreign Spring TV discovery Interview chucky SundanceTV breaking bad BET quibi Country political drama elevated horror independent Black Mirror festivals Winners golden globes Rom-Com toronto PaleyFest concert President anime Emmys reviews Heroines RT History Tumblr adaptation Box Office Endgame Sundance Now Amazon movies news Tarantino Columbia Pictures blaxploitation cartoon tv talk supernatural PBS Oscars Character Guide TCA Winter 2020 revenge OWN sag awards crime Masterpiece MCU Anna Paquin satire richard e. Grant talk show YouTube Premium Certified Fresh joker blockbuster Baby Yoda Superheroes Turner Showtime Discovery Channel Apple TV+ psychological thriller Song of Ice and Fire Mary poppins Marathons Writers Guild of America Hulu all-time American Society of Cinematographers 24 frames Extras documentaries classics remakes See It Skip It Acorn TV biography Comedy Central Binge Guide slashers