POW! Read Comics & Graphic Novels vs. The Critics!

by | July 23, 2010 | Comments

To celebrate the 2010 Comic-Con, we present to you Comics & Graphic Novels vs. the Critics, an exhaustive countdown that includes movies based on everything from superheroes to graphic novels, from manga to strips from the funny pages — in order of critical approval.

We can see those thought bubbles above your heads — you’re wondering how we compiled this thing. Here’s the breakdown: every movie here originates from a comic book source of some kind, not another medium (we know about the Alien vs. Predator graphic novels, but the movies aren’t based on the comics). Only movies with 20 or more reviews are included (sorry, Fritz the Cat), and we use a weighted formula that takes release year and number of reviews into account (see How It Works for more). We also omitted all TV or straight-to-DVD flicks.

Now remove the protective plastic bag, flip to the first page, and dig into Comics & Graphic Novels vs. the Critics!

Tag Cloud

YouTube Premium joker President Spectrum Originals crime Mindy Kaling ghosts Peacock science fiction YouTube Red Rocky Sneak Peek BET spanish language Opinion A&E YouTube spy thriller renewed TV shows Emmy Nominations Certified Fresh television Horror Ovation Nominations The CW Showtime Classic Film canceled TV shows CMT cooking jamie lee curtis Sundance vampires what to watch Hallmark talk show 2017 versus Grammys casting Bravo doctor who cancelled TV shows HBO TCM psychological thriller Emmys Universal Binge Guide spain serial killer Freeform spider-man Shudder war cancelled television rotten movies we love Endgame Lionsgate First Look Pixar Song of Ice and Fire NBC SundanceTV cinemax Captain marvel based on movie Paramount book Podcast BBC independent TLC Amazon Prime Pirates Super Bowl Nat Geo Tarantino Infographic Summer 21st Century Fox Crunchyroll dramedy The Walking Dead Premiere Dates Columbia Pictures streaming Kids & Family Women's History Month Trailer true crime Comedy Superheroes Marvel Television FX Sundance TV 20th Century Fox Crackle Black Mirror CBS Heroines hist hispanic Stephen King 2019 FOX Musical Winners TV renewals DC Comics Family ESPN Character Guide Comedy Central Star Trek National Geographic miniseries Fox News Writers Guild of America Biopics YA Rom-Com game of thrones sequel Reality Competition Apple TV Plus Valentine's Day PaleyFest Comic Book TV Land docudrama period drama game show Netflix Christmas movies romance children's TV Sony Pictures CW Seed Dark Horse Comics Oscars Interview USA Network green book robots technology Esquire X-Men Rock WGN unscripted Paramount Network Spike Disney Channel dceu politics spinoff Creative Arts Emmys CBS All Access blaxploitation cults comiccon Avengers video Logo AMC Baby Yoda binge DirecTV slashers ABC Family romantic comedy Awards Tour tv talk RT History Polls and Games IFC Films Sundance Now anthology APB travel Disney streaming service Pride Month MCU ITV police drama 007 witnail Thanksgiving The Purge Marvel Watching Series Hallmark Christmas movies foreign Disney cancelled cats Teen El Rey 45 Cosplay 2015 Anna Paquin theme song mutant Trophy Talk christmas movies FXX First Reviews VH1 Shondaland IFC crime drama Marvel Studios facebook TCA 2017 halloween Christmas TCA Winter 2020 zombies Star Wars werewolf Fall TV medical drama Quiz E! diversity Mary poppins Cannes harry potter cancelled TV series ABC composers biography Masterpiece strong female leads Disney Plus Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt justice league elevated horror Action Awards Apple TV+ SXSW Television Academy RT21 Hulu The Arrangement Warner Bros. Red Carpet Lifetime Pet Sematary kids 71st Emmy Awards quibi singing competition OWN Amazon 2018 disaster Brie Larson Film Festival mockumentary Music movies Western Marathons adaptation Spring TV dragons LGBT teaser New York Comic Con Rocketman GoT WarnerMedia cars cops TV Academy Awards directors Martial Arts Sci-Fi Election Cartoon Network DGA name the review Food Network comics zombie animated Calendar Tumblr Elton John Animation Musicals Nickelodeon toy story Toys Trivia Discovery Channel Syfy USA screen actors guild adventure SDCC Disney+ Disney Plus GLAAD sag awards crime thriller political drama indie Set visit zero dark thirty LGBTQ Turner Classic Movies series San Diego Comic-Con thriller batman breaking bad Netflix TIFF PBS E3 Holidays Ghostbusters Holiday discovery crossover CNN NYCC MSNBC social media finale stand-up comedy See It Skip It historical drama Mary Tyler Moore 2016 revenge Schedule 24 frames Acorn TV Pop free movies dc TCA Country golden globes HBO Max Lucasfilm BBC America dogs latino Walt Disney Pictures Lifetime Christmas movies OneApp natural history anime A24 Box Office Vudu DC streaming service Chernobyl Year in Review Adult Swim transformers Fantasy aliens screenings blockbuster cartoon Film Mystery History Superheroe nature reboot supernatural Winter TV Starz Amazon Prime Video Tubi festivals 2020 TBS MTV movie Turner Amazon Studios DC Universe comic TNT Extras sitcom TruTV award winner The Witch Arrowverse documentary Britbox Comics on TV American Society of Cinematographers sports Apple Video Games space Ellie Kemper south america Drama Reality GIFs boxoffice Mary Poppins Returns Best and Worst psycho Countdown Epix Photos Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ratings VICE Tomatazos canceled Mudbound richard e. Grant