Showdowns

RT Users Crown Toy Story the Best Pixar Film Ever

The film that started it all overcame challenges from The Incredibles, Up, and Finding Nemo to emerge as the fan favorite in our polls.

by | June 17, 2022 | Comments

The community has spoken! The winner of the Pixar Showdown is none other than the film that started it all, 1995’s Toy Story! Perhaps this was always going to be the case, but there was no guarantee it would turn out this way. For many fans, choosing between Toy Story and Toy Story 2 is akin to picking a favorite between the first and second Godfather films… and then Toy Story 3 came along to jerk even more tears from all of us. But even 2 was ousted by Up, while 3 made the earliest exit of any of the Toy Story films, losing to Ratatouille in the second round.

All in all, we can’t say we were disappointed that the Final Four turned out to be Toy Story, UpRatatouille, and Finding Nemo — classics, all of them — but we did think Nemo would offer Woody and Buzz more of a challenge for the title in the championship round. In the end, it’s perhaps only appropriate that Toy Story won, considering Lightyear is officially out today, but let’s give Pixar another few years, and we’ll see if anything changes after they’ve released another dozen or so films. As always, big thanks to everyone who participated in the showdown, and congratulations to the original Toy Story for being voted the Best Pixar Movie Ever.


Final Round Result

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 Next

Tag Cloud

boxing social media TV renewals series obituary sag awards Teen 21st Century Fox Sci-Fi DGA Paramount Pictures Rocketman 2015 Binge Guide zombies Amazon Studios Drama remakes Focus Features Shondaland 4/20 Tags: Comedy ViacomCBS The Purge Year in Review Disney Plus deadpool Countdown teaser romance TNT crime thriller emmy awards spinoff 2021 posters Comic Book tv talk Cosplay book Television Academy historical drama See It Skip It 2016 interviews psycho TCA Winners kids Native video blockbuster movies Masterpiece comics Fargo NBA elevated horror crossover spider-verse travel kong WGN comic books comedies feel good slashers mockumentary Hear Us Out Crunchyroll rt archives romantic comedy scary new york Set visit comiccon Comics on TV Video Games films cancelled HBO Go strong female leads casting Walt Disney Pictures spider-man 72 Emmy Awards MCU Best Actress Pride Month live action Amazon Comic-Con@Home 2021 Mudbound Hallmark Christmas movies summer TV preview dc new star wars movies Cartoon Network Writers Guild of America Trivia adventure renewed TV shows mission: impossible LGBTQ twilight 24 frames American Society of Cinematographers based on movie die hard Spectrum Originals Image Comics boxoffice El Rey Peacock Quiz Esquire History game show halloween tv festival Discovery Channel Epix Vudu Disney+ Disney Plus all-time APB children's TV Marvel Studios target OneApp Infographic Oscar Nominations Black Mirror CNN Apple TV+ japanese sitcom AMC Plus BBC America true crime Emmys The Witch hidden camera Legendary 20th Century Fox MSNBC Christmas 94th Oscars Mary Poppins Returns saw Spike directors WarnerMedia genre natural history SXSW chucky canceled Marvel Television doctor who parents criterion Netflix Christmas movies Super Bowl Action biography 93rd Oscars Music Musicals cars Toys Lionsgate cults Columbia Pictures IFC Films Paramount Network richard e. Grant hispanic TLC psychological thriller witnail BBC CBS biopic Dark Horse Comics HBO art house dark concert king arthur toy story classics indiana jones french Starz Fox News political drama FX cats Classic Film blockbusters popular screenings YouTube Red ID VH1 diversity free movies Amazon Prime Video vampires prank USA documentaries New York Comic Con broadcast legend YouTube Premium Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt scene in color Paramount Plus A&E Neflix streaming movies fresh golden globe awards reviews Country vs. Awards Tour critics hispanic heritage month TCA Winter 2020 asian-american Universal Pictures king kong telelvision Comedy Exclusive Video stand-up comedy spanish Hollywood Foreign Press Association justice league Film aapi Geeked Week 99% CMT GoT TBS science fiction razzies Marvel black superman Ellie Kemper scary movies worst Pet Sematary Musical PBS Heroines TV Photos spain Spring TV Chernobyl The Arrangement San Diego Comic-Con The Walking Dead gangster medical drama sopranos Superheroe Pop TV Valentine's Day movie debate 73rd Emmy Awards Emmy Nominations festivals Bravo documentary TV movies Nickelodeon Ghostbusters Mindy Kaling batman docudrama scene in color series Red Carpet robots summer preview cancelled TV series Holidays canceled TV shows Thanksgiving 45 Pacific Islander revenge Acorn TV TIFF dragons Lucasfilm rotten sports Television Critics Association YA foreign obi wan kaiju finale VOD italian live event target scene in color zero dark thirty best Horror action-comedy OWN trailers PaleyFest Tomatazos wonder woman Amazon Prime 90s BET Awards thriller anime critic resources adenture green book basketball independent YouTube space Tubi TV One Grammys rt labs critics edition Film Festival 79th Golden Globes Awards Academy Awards Winter TV MGM sequel ABC Family Sundance TV women Sundance Now 2019 Tarantino royal family AMC Reality Competition IMDb TV Certified Fresh Fantasy BAFTA theme song Creative Arts Emmys First Look Best Director TCA 2017 Baby Yoda marvel cinematic universe cops Lifetime Christmas movies LGBT Oscars comic book movie rom-coms stop motion franchise Box Office Rock ratings Netflix satire Rocky cinemax 71st Emmy Awards Apple TV Plus lord of the rings Chilling Adventures of Sabrina trophy Ovation mcc TCM 2017 Western serial killer Podcast Apple 2018 Best Picture Interview Black History Month Election 1990s Superheroes First Reviews SXSW 2022 animated GIFs E3 Turner Classic Movies Sundance cancelled television Premiere Dates screen actors guild Extras Star Wars Reality a nightmare on elm street hollywood werewolf adaptation dogs heist movie Schedule ESPN The Walt Disney Company Family Showtime Sony Pictures leaderboard talk show A24 IFC comic hist discovery Hulu mob Cannes Indigenous Wes Anderson Biopics VICE Women's History Month dexter suspense binge Crackle fast and furious stoner know your critic DC Universe transformers streaming FOX scorecard dceu crime drama game of thrones Mystery dramedy jurassic park worst movies Character Guide politics breaking bad james bond Nat Geo toronto mutant nfl unscripted anthology Britbox television National Geographic 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Trailer Pixar Prime Video 2020 book adaptation BET Disney streaming service Sneak Peek 007 ABC Signature south america Disney Channel Anna Paquin jamie lee curtis scene in color film series Stephen King ITV Fall TV Animation Brie Larson Freeform cartoon aliens Mary Tyler Moore CW Seed crime quibi young adult Paramount Song of Ice and Fire christmas movies singing competition SDCC football indie streamig video on demand summer TV disaster pirates of the caribbean Pop supernatural Rom-Com FXX Lifetime zombie rt labs Best Actor CBS All Access Awards X-Men Logo child's play Pirates Elton John period drama Marathons reboot Tumblr cancelled TV shows Summer composers Captain marvel RT History FX on Hulu harry potter NBC Star Trek new zealand Alien Comedy Central ghosts USA Network President TV Land venice BBC One NYCC TruTV archives spy thriller Best and Worst dreamworks award winner Calendar Funimation miniseries sequels technology GLAAD Trophy Talk name the review comic book movies international Arrowverse halloween Food Network SundanceTV Polls and Games Tokyo Olympics Syfy The Academy Universal war cooking japan joker DirecTV nbcuniversal Endgame Disney black comedy golden globes Opinion DC Comics Mary poppins godzilla Holiday universal monsters HFPA laika monster movies nature MTV marvel comics RT21 Hallmark ABC Adult Swim news blaxploitation Kids & Family Sony Instagram Live australia docuseries HBO Max latino The CW Fox Searchlight Warner Bros. high school police drama DC streaming service Travel Channel Turner E! spanish language South by Southwest Film Festival rotten movies we love Broadway facebook Avengers olympics slasher what to watch Shudder Star Wars Celebration Martial Arts superhero PlayStation TCA Awards Watching Series versus