Writer-Artist P. Craig Russell on Adapting Neil Gaiman's American Gods as a Comic Book — Plus, Issue 2 Sneak Peek

Ahead of the TV series, Russell reveals why he's not planning to watch the show — yet. And Dark Horse provides a preview of book 2 that introduces "leprechaun" Mad Sweeney.

by | March 17, 2017 | Comments

American Gods #2 variant cover by David Mack (Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

When new TV series American Gods debuts on Starz on April 30, it will be the second time that Neil Gaiman’s classic 2001 fantasy novel — about “the clash between the old gods of mythology and the new gods of technology” — will be adapted to a visual medium, but only by six weeks.

Thanks to writer and layout artist P. Craig Russell (who previously adapted Gaiman’s Coraline), artist Scott Hampton (Black Widow: Breakdown), and, of course, Gaiman himself, American Gods is also being adapted into a comic book, the first issue of which was released on March 15.

With the second of 27 issues out April 12th, we spoke to Russell about how this adaptation compares to the original novel, and how it’s intentionally not influenced by the TV show.

American Gods #2 variant cover by Bill Sienkiewicz (Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

Paul Semel for Rotten Tomatoes: What was it about American Gods that not only made you want to adapt it into a comic, but also made you think that you were the right person to do this adaptation?

Russell: The simple answer is that it’s a well-written book, it’s a compelling story, and there’s a lot of fun to it amidst all the darkness. I’ve been working with Neil for 25 years, adapting his short stories and novels, so from experience alone, I’m the right person to do this.

RT: My understanding is that this is a fairly faithful adaptation. It’s not abridged or a reimagining.

Russell: Well, it can be abridged and still be faithful. Gone with the Wind could’ve been a 40-hour-long movie if they’d done the whole book. So there’s a great deal of editing that goes on, as I’m sure there will be with the TV series. Neil can pack a lot into a page, so I’ve learned the art of reducing conversations down to a half-dozen lines down from 10 or 20. It’s a matter of getting to the essence of the narrative. It’s like taking a Duesenberg apart and reassembling it as a small sports car.

Author Neil Gaiman at the start of production on Starz series American Gods (Starz)

RT: How involved was Neil in this adaptation?

Russell: He pretty much just gives me the book and lets me run with it. Though I will text him if I have any questions. I’ve read the novel three times, but I don’t have a photographic memory. That said, Neil, Scott, and the editor did go through several revisions when it came to the design of Shadow [the main character]. But, again, Scott was also faithful to the way characters were described by Neil in the book.

RT: American Gods came out in 2001. Did Neil ever say anything like, “This part seems dated, let’s fix it”?

Russell: Well, when the 10th anniversary edition of the book came out, Neil restored things that had been edited out of the first version. When I started working on this, I asked Neil which edition to use, and he said the second one.

But in terms of things being dated, there were a couple little things. Like there’s a part where Shadow is watching TV, and Lucy Ricardo [from I Love Lucy] starts talking to him, she’s one of the new gods, a celebrity, and she mentions shopping malls. But she also mentions online shopping, which were just starting at the time, so I emphasized that since shopping malls are dying and people do more online shopping.

Ian McShane, Ricky Whittle in American Gods (Starz)

RT: Now, along with your adaptation, there’s also the American Gods TV show. Given that you were working on this at the same time they were putting the show together, did anyone, presumably Neil, show you images from the show?

Russell: No, not a bit. In fact, my editor sent me a link to the first trailer that came out, and I won’t look at it. I don’t want there to be any kind of cross contamination. It’s like when I was doing the comic adaptation of Coraline and they were doing the animated movie at the same time, I wouldn’t look at any of their stuff. Though once I finish my version, I will binge-watch the show. I want to see how they’re doing it. I’m looking forward to seeing how they handle the editing of the book and how they stitch it back together. I’m really interested in seeing how they deal with the same challenges that I’ve been facing.

RT: Neil has said he is going to write a sequel to American Gods. Have you talked to him doing it as comic book with you at the helm, or doing a comic book adaptation at some point?

Russell: No, we haven’t talked about it because it’s in such a preliminary stage; though I wouldn’t be surprised if, at some point, I was asked to do an adaptation of it.

RT: What about convincing him to call it American Gods II: Electric Boogaloo?

Russell: Ha! No, but I will now.

American Gods: Shadows #1 is out now. American Gods #2 will be out April 12. New issues will be released every month. The first collected edition will be released in early 2018.

American Gods: Shadows #2 Sneak Peek

Description: Fresh out of jail, Shadow Moon finds himself recruited as a bodyguard for the enigmatic Mr. Wednesday, only to be interrupted and kidnapped by the dangerous Technical Boy, who wants answers as to Wednesday’s plans.

The following sequence introduces hard-drinking brawler Mad Sweeney, who calls himself a leprechaun, but is taller and more dangerous.

Variant cover by David Mack: 

American Gods #2 variant cover by David Mack (Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

Variant cover by Bill Sienkiewicz: 

American Gods #2 variant cover by Bill Sienkiewicz (Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

Cover by Glenn Fabry:
American Gods #2 cover by Glenn Fabry (Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)
American Gods No. 2 page 1 (Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

(Photo by Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)


American Gods No. 2 page 2 (Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

(Photo by Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

American Gods No. 2 page 3 (Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

(Photo by Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)


American Gods No. 2 page 3 (Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

(Photo by Dark Horse Comics, Inc.)

Tag Cloud

festivals rotten comedies zombie Comedy Photos Pride Month discovery Turner police drama ghosts DGA Disney+ Disney Plus mutant docudrama golden globes Ovation comic romance television Black Mirror films child's play Election boxing Pirates Toys italian adaptation thriller asian-american facebook Hear Us Out BBC GLAAD crime Extras sitcom stand-up comedy witnail Ellie Kemper Marvel Studios teaser black 2019 TCA 2017 political drama Lifetime Christmas movies Fox Searchlight Emmy Nominations Reality Competition Watching Series WarnerMedia SundanceTV Crackle BBC One Spring TV superhero canceled Comic Book Shudder screenings Trivia ABC Family concert criterion indiana jones Arrowverse E3 Star Wars talk show PBS indie Showtime Christmas GoT NBC Turner Classic Movies cancelled TV series LGBTQ Creative Arts Emmys aliens universal monsters Syfy Podcast mission: impossible IFC Films Cartoon Network Funimation San Diego Comic-Con SXSW Paramount Network kids RT21 Chernobyl VOD Pop TV batman Epix Apple TV+ TNT Sundance Tomatazos Schedule YouTube Premium Drama adventure finale Women's History Month christmas movies Shondaland Film Festival USA FXX fresh Masterpiece Netflix Christmas movies PaleyFest obituary Comics on TV Adult Swim RT History HBO award winner satire rotten movies we love First Look Sundance TV Premiere Dates Television Critics Association DC Universe blaxploitation foreign Food Network Holidays twilight directors Rocketman Awards Tour 99% Polls and Games Best and Worst binge name the review Fantasy Baby Yoda ITV YA Reality Starz 007 japanese CBS Musical historical drama Disney Plus OneApp YouTube SDCC based on movie tv talk DC Comics MSNBC richard e. Grant OWN PlayStation documentary Mary poppins zero dark thirty Year in Review Grammys X-Men Marvel National Geographic psycho video news USA Network crime drama Super Bowl 4/20 Rock Apple TV Plus space sequel reviews james bond anime Sundance Now The Witch Mindy Kaling streaming CNN versus Bravo slashers A24 sports Lifetime parents dragons disaster revenge elevated horror cartoon independent australia technology Television Academy TIFF Star Trek AMC medical drama Mary Poppins Returns game of thrones animated Crunchyroll Quiz Tubi screen actors guild YouTube Red Horror movie vampires Spectrum Originals Universal TCM Teen natural history APB nature remakes Rom-Com Anna Paquin scary movies stop motion hollywood New York Comic Con festival reboot FOX Red Carpet Mystery Thanksgiving Winter TV WGN Classic Film football 2018 DC streaming service a nightmare on elm street Superheroe fast and furious Nat Geo The Arrangement social media Oscars mockumentary Animation cinemax Amazon Prime Video Travel Channel Academy Awards Emmys TV renewals Discovery Channel ID crime thriller scorecard Elton John Kids & Family spanish language archives Sony Pictures children's TV Rocky The Purge travel MTV Acorn TV worst comic books First Reviews 72 Emmy Awards war Western cults Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Paramount BBC America BET Fox News cooking Character Guide dogs TV Land Warner Bros. diversity toy story 2017 Lionsgate free movies dceu robots cancelled critics Superheroes LGBT Marathons TLC Hulu Disney Amazon Prime TV HBO Go Lucasfilm TBS Britbox Certified Fresh jamie lee curtis Cosplay breaking bad History hispanic Video Games Interview best Film Captain marvel quibi nfl IFC Columbia Pictures CW Seed Black History Month The Academy deadpool hist spy thriller Infographic Binge Guide Sci-Fi Valentine's Day casting joker Apple spinoff sag awards period drama Winners comiccon documentaries Amazon Studios theme song chucky doctor who Family VH1 TCA Winter 2020 Calendar cats Pet Sematary Cannes Esquire GIFs Nominations dramedy dark MCU cars 2015 Country BAFTA 71st Emmy Awards transformers venice Nickelodeon boxoffice halloween tv laika Tarantino El Rey Walt Disney Pictures ESPN classics toronto singing competition werewolf Countdown Netflix Ghostbusters 2020 renewed TV shows blockbuster Freeform strong female leads composers harry potter Opinion 24 frames science fiction canceled TV shows comics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 2016 stoner true crime Summer E! CBS All Access Mudbound Marvel Television latino Spike dc nbcuniversal Action miniseries movies romantic comedy Heroines Peacock President Pixar See It Skip It The Walking Dead FX video on demand Disney Channel serial killer psychological thriller anthology biography TruTV franchise worst movies Holiday series Comedy Central 21st Century Fox Martial Arts halloween Biopics The CW CMT unscripted Dark Horse Comics Sneak Peek FX on Hulu cancelled television 20th Century Fox Trophy Talk NYCC spain Music Song of Ice and Fire Disney streaming service Stephen King Box Office Vudu Awards zombies Mary Tyler Moore TCA Awards ratings politics cancelled TV shows Fall TV Trailer all-time ABC book cops American Society of Cinematographers what to watch french supernatural spanish Set visit Hallmark TCA BET Awards Avengers sequels Writers Guild of America die hard Brie Larson Hallmark Christmas movies Tumblr crossover 45 Pop DirecTV emmy awards HBO Max Alien green book game show Amazon VICE A&E Musicals south america justice league rt archives spider-man Logo Endgame