Onward First Reviews: A Funny, Soulful Adventure That Feels a Little Familiar

Critics say Pixar's latest doesn't break any new narrative or visual ground, but it's a solid, deeply personal film that should resonate with families.

by | February 21, 2020 | Comments

After a decade of mostly producing sequels, Pixar begins a new era of original animated features with the release of Onward. Featuring the voices of Chris Pratt and Tom Holland, the fantasy adventure is co-written and directed by studio vet Dan Scanlon, who previously helmed Monsters University. While still technically garnering Fresh marks from critics, Onward is being labeled a somewhat lesser Pixar effort in the first crop of reviews. Whether it’s too sub-par for recommendation depends on the writer and may depend on your appreciation for its sentiments as well.

Here’s what critics are saying about Pixar’s Onward:

How does it measure against other Pixar movies?

Onward may have taken my number one Pixar spot, and I’m not ashamed to say it.
– Rachel Leishman, The Mary Sue

Onward isn’t Pixar’s best film, but it’s one of its most personal.
– Kristen Acuna, Insider

Pixar’s latest film, Onward, lives up to its predecessors… albeit slightly underwhelming.
– Germain Lussier, io9

The majority of Pixar’s films are special for one reason or another. Which makes the generic bro humor and familiar Dungeons & Dragons role-play vibe of Onward a let-down.
– David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

This is what a disappointing Pixar film is: a perfectly fine one.
– Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

This may not be Pixar’s worst movie… but it sure feels like the weakest.
– Roger Moore, Movie Nation

Lesser Pixar is still pretty goood, though, right?

Pixar, in its very bravura, has more than earned the right to put out a movie like this one — an unabashed piece of product, a kind of Pixar place-holder made with a tiny dash of soul.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety

While Onward may not be the strongest Pixar movie, it still delivers on everything fans have come to expect from an animated film produced by the studio.
Molly Freeman, ScreenRant

Ian, Barley, and their dad’s legs’ story is a worthy addition to the studio’s impeccable catalogue. I went in with doubt. Now, I can’t wait to see it again.
Alison Foreman, Mashable

While its emotion and structure are certainly uneven, there’s not anything truly bad to say about it.
Germain Lussier, io9

(Photo by Disney/Pixar)

Is it original enough?

Some may find that Pixar is retracing its steps a bit… [but] Onward rarely feels formulaic because its characters and setting are so specific.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

This particular once-upon-a-time scene setter feels curiously, even knowingly derivative.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

The emotion in Onward is earned, and the situational setup seems unique. It’s all… fine, but also overly familiar.
Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

How is the story?

Scanlon, Jason Headley and Keith Bunin’s screenplay functions at its best when it’s leaning into sincerity over silliness.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Save for a few by-the-book action sequences and corny gags, Onward maintains its clever balance of formula all the way through an emotional climax.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

While Onward is a distinctly colorful animated film, its story feels like a variant on a low-key dramedy you might find at Sundance.
Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

This is a movie about two kids resurrecting their dead dad’s crotch and it’s just the WEIRDEST thing.
Mike Ryan, Uproxx

(Photo by Disney/Pixar)

Are there memorable characters?

In addition to the filmmakers’ forward-thinking approach to dealing with grief, they approach traditional character archetypes with just as much innovation.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

There’s a lesbian character in Onward… but the most revolutionary thing that Pixar has done in advance of the movie’s release is not tell anyone about it.
Sam Adams, Slate

This is a pretty uninspired bunch… characters that often feel like plot padding.
David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

How are the performances?

Holland and Pratt, both MCU stalwarts, show great vocal chemistry as two brothers bonded together through family and tragedy.
Robert Daniels, 812filmreviews

Holland and Pratt have a winning rapport, in part because they could be starring in a parallel-universe Avengers spinoff with Spider-Man and Star-Lord.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

[Pratt’s] vocal performance is the film’s highlight, as he returns to his Andy Dwyer days.
Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

Pratt and Holland make for a loving vocal duo, oozing with audible affection, but voice acting veteran Mel Rodriguez steals the show as Laurel’s cop boyfriend Colt Bronco.
Alison Foreman, Mashable

Is Onward funny?

Combining stellar visual comedy with memorable dialogue, Onward makes the most of every joke and bit on its path.
Alison Foreman, Mashable

Onward is 100 percent Weekend at Bernie’s for kids… that the filmmakers did this is funnier than most of the actual jokes in the movie.
Joshua Rivera, The Verge

Onward wisely leans more on humor than drama to get its message across.
David Sims, The Atlantic

Onward may be hilarious, but it is so much more than that.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

The situational humor in Onward is fleeting.
Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

There isn’t a laugh in it.
Roger Moore, Movie Nation

Pixar being Pixar, will have you laughing constantly until the climax reduces you to a puddle of tears.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

(Photo by Disney/Pixar)

So it’s another Pixar tearjerker?

Onward isn’t Pixar’s biggest tearjerker, but expect to find yourself tearing up a bit throughout.
Kristen Acuna, Insider

Get ready to ugly cry – especially those who’ve lost someone near and dear.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

What makes this one pretty good, and sometimes inspired, is that… all those emotions seem to spring naturally from the story’s intricate roots.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

As I’m getting ready to write about the heart of this movie, I’m crying again.
Rachel Leishman, The Mary Sue

How does it look?

Onward is a visual treat throughout. It almost goes without saying now with Pixar that everything looks gorgeous, but the fantastical world they’ve built is vibrant and packed with detail.
Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

The animation’s good, lovely but not dazzling.
Roger Moore, Movie Nation

From a visual standpoint, the movie offers few surprises… but script and character generally overwhelm the need for technological innovation.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

The backgrounds around Barley and Ian are so meticulously designed, with even photorealistic dust particles floating around the house, that it jars with the more traditionally cartoonish design of its fanciful characters.
David Crow, Den of Geek

Mostly, the look is disappointingly pedestrian.
David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

(Photo by Disney/Pixar)

Who is Onward best suited for?

Far more a film for adults than Pixar’s ever done.
Robert Daniels, 812filmreviews

If you like classic, high fantasy settings inspired by stuff like Dungeons & Dragons and Magic: The Gathering, you’ll love what Scanlon and his team have done here with Onward.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

The best thing that Scanlon’s film does is that it gives audiences of all ages (but especially young kids) the tools to work through sorrow in a safe space.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Onward is in theaters on March 6.


Onward (2020)

Adjusted Score: 101.173%
Critics Consensus: It may suffer in comparison to Pixar's classics, but Onward makes effective use of the studio's formula -- and stands on its own merits as a funny, heartwarming, dazzlingly animated adventure.
Synopsis: Set in a suburban fantasy world, Disney-Pixar's "Onward" introduces two teenage elf brothers who embark on an extraordinary quest to... [More]
Directed By: Dan Scanlon

Tag Cloud

Grammys Comics on TV comic MSNBC Netflix YouTube Red vampires Lifetime Christmas movies spinoff Valentine's Day Marathons CMT See It Skip It cooking Vudu Star Trek sag awards TBS TV true crime crime drama facebook blockbuster binge festivals Sundance SundanceTV Awards Tour Creative Arts Emmys TLC LGBTQ Trophy Talk Disney streaming service SDCC Election streaming Holiday game show 24 frames thriller reviews RT21 Masterpiece Set visit free movies dragons Watching Series YA DC Comics cancelled HBO Max halloween spider-man Netflix Christmas movies zombie spanish language batman cinemax FX on Hulu elevated horror Family Teen dogs Premiere Dates war Pet Sematary Tumblr Lucasfilm Interview Sundance TV scary movies Nominations GIFs Pirates cancelled TV shows Stephen King Holidays DirecTV Trivia Paramount Paramount Network YouTube sequel Musicals based on movie A24 supernatural Spectrum Originals Drama justice league Bravo name the review crossover finale TV renewals ABC OneApp CW Seed Summer Pride Month Opinion Marvel Television Pop Ovation IFC Spike 2017 Marvel tv talk The Witch Shudder Dark Horse Comics Chernobyl Rock adventure movies canceled versus screen actors guild mutant MTV technology discovery Adult Swim Red Carpet indie serial killer Acorn TV latino Television Academy Hallmark Christmas movies ITV Ellie Kemper Polls and Games anthology Mary Poppins Returns slashers CNN toy story FOX Cosplay Anna Paquin theme song Columbia Pictures Apple TV Plus Kids & Family richard e. Grant WGN Fall TV animated Music jamie lee curtis Amazon science fiction 007 south america Logo movie Mary Tyler Moore GoT TCA Winter 2020 unscripted RT History Epix Mystery BBC Reality rotten movies we love Winners Marvel Studios Sony Pictures Captain marvel Ghostbusters Podcast independent SXSW politics Horror Funimation Hulu Hallmark Winter TV medical drama Comic Book crime natural history USA Apple Action Superheroes Trailer foreign San Diego Comic-Con Infographic social media Schedule First Look reboot DC streaming service Certified Fresh Lifetime TruTV Emmys Apple TV+ Disney Plus canceled TV shows casting Tubi LGBT Reality Competition Baby Yoda Academy Awards Video Games Film The Walking Dead E3 Superheroe documentary Freeform 21st Century Fox FX romance Crackle Avengers APB American Society of Cinematographers Disney+ Disney Plus Peacock Fantasy 71st Emmy Awards Nat Geo Lionsgate Walt Disney Pictures Emmy Nominations ABC Family Pop TV USA Network TCA 2017 revenge Sundance Now cancelled television TCM National Geographic Mindy Kaling Esquire Warner Bros. Elton John Box Office Syfy IFC Films aliens Extras cartoon Fox News cops Rocketman E! Sci-Fi Mary poppins franchise cancelled TV series blaxploitation Amazon Studios ratings ghosts Shondaland comiccon robots NYCC christmas movies Tomatazos Black History Month what to watch Showtime Mudbound OWN renewed TV shows DGA cats Classic Film joker Turner Comedy Tarantino screenings historical drama VICE Travel Channel Country First Reviews 2016 video El Rey Photos 20th Century Fox Song of Ice and Fire television adaptation sports Biopics Comedy Central stand-up comedy singing competition Heroines 2018 game of thrones teaser Western travel The CW Calendar Character Guide Sneak Peek Arrowverse X-Men zero dark thirty GLAAD Disney docudrama werewolf zombies AMC New York Comic Con Quiz Writers Guild of America CBS 2020 Countdown TIFF Film Festival Best and Worst The Purge disaster witnail Musical space golden globes Super Bowl Spring TV DC Universe CBS All Access composers VH1 President talk show dc hispanic strong female leads ESPN psycho Martial Arts Pixar Year in Review spain political drama universal monsters police drama harry potter nature dceu History BET quibi award winner PBS Women's History Month 2015 Cartoon Network comics crime thriller The Arrangement miniseries A&E Star Wars Black Mirror Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Universal transformers book spy thriller Rocky Britbox Rom-Com Amazon Prime Video diversity series Food Network YouTube Premium Toys cars Cannes Binge Guide TV Land MCU BBC America Turner Classic Movies Awards Thanksgiving Discovery Channel mockumentary period drama dramedy biography Christmas directors romantic comedy Disney Channel HBO kids breaking bad Animation doctor who Endgame children's TV 45 PaleyFest Oscars cults Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Brie Larson TNT Nickelodeon anime Crunchyroll TCA Amazon Prime boxoffice NBC hist 2019 sitcom psychological thriller Starz FXX green book WarnerMedia