Michael vs. Freddy vs. Jason: Who Is the Ultimate Horror Baddie?

Who makes the most money? Whose movies are the best? Who has the most creative kills? We break it all down. You know, for science.

by | October 14, 2020 | Comments

It’s machete vs. butcher knife vs. razor-glove thingy. It’s hockey mask vs. Shatner mask vs. serious burns. It’s hulkish brute vs. silent-type vs. pun-loving babbler. That’s right, it’s Jason vs. Michael vs. Freddy in a special episode of Vs. where we answer once and for all: Who is the ultimate horror baddie? We don’t answer the question by throwing them in a sorority house and seeing who does the most damage (though we’re now going to copyright that film idea), but with math: we’re grading these bad boys on box office performance, as well Audience and Tomatometer Scores. Plus, host and Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis looks at their cultural relevance and carnage creativity to determine a victor. And if you don’t agree, as ever, let us know in the comments.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Thumbnail image: ©Dimension Films, ©New Line Cinema/courtesy Everett Collection, ©New Line Cinema

Tag Cloud

video on demand stop motion Pet Sematary Fantasy PBS Holiday HBO obituary WGN Comedy Central Polls and Games Pop TV Pirates boxing canceled TV shows classics Disney streaming service police drama Peacock biography Interview Brie Larson USA Network SXSW football The Witch black Tumblr spy thriller Trailer heist movie razzies video trailers golden globe awards rom-coms Comic Book Christmas universal monsters venice green book spinoff Starz Emmy Nominations 45 mutant Writers Guild of America Awards breaking bad werewolf space Superheroe 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Rock cooking documentary FOX latino Martial Arts ghosts ratings thriller The Walt Disney Company crime anthology nbcuniversal romantic comedy Photos VICE Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Broadway war miniseries Discovery Channel concert Winter TV witnail Academy Awards YA cars Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Hallmark Christmas movies Watching Series book adaptation TruTV ID cartoon Film Star Trek Funimation Columbia Pictures adventure Black Mirror godzilla Schedule Disney political drama Red Carpet australia DirecTV PaleyFest game of thrones TIFF DC streaming service Binge Guide a nightmare on elm street TCA 2017 History CBS BAFTA robots travel festival strong female leads cancelled television TLC BBC One quibi ViacomCBS Podcast documentaries CNN The Academy APB WarnerMedia rotten movies we love AMC 99% animated james bond Showtime fresh The Purge cancelled TV shows Walt Disney Pictures Elton John GLAAD RT History superhero HBO Go GIFs 4/20 hollywood Black History Month streaming Holidays sag awards Disney+ Disney Plus Paramount Plus Super Bowl Captain marvel series versus Valentine's Day zero dark thirty Emmys hispanic Chernobyl singing competition Alien Vudu vampires Sundance Now saw Trophy Talk 24 frames aliens Food Network Toys DGA Fox Searchlight Arrowverse facebook Legendary stoner TNT halloween tv Marvel comics Biopics richard e. Grant emmy awards book canceled OneApp indiana jones Masterpiece dramedy stand-up comedy what to watch A&E BBC Action Video Games sports The Arrangement El Rey Reality 2017 BBC America Travel Channel television LGBTQ disaster Drama reboot dceu doctor who spider-man Horror italian RT21 mission: impossible USA telelvision japanese elevated horror X-Men dogs nfl Countdown Amazon sequel laika YouTube Premium science fiction revenge Apple SundanceTV dc Grammys king kong Bravo ABC superman Year in Review serial killer 2019 NYCC spanish language CW Seed crime thriller Fox News pirates of the caribbean E! Endgame See It Skip It news reviews tv talk Sci-Fi festivals E3 Comedy 007 name the review historical drama Ovation natural history IFC Films IFC Apple TV Plus 2020 CBS All Access Cartoon Network nature FX on Hulu Oscars Rocky TCA Awards toy story Exclusive Video Freeform rt archives cats 20th Century Fox popular Awards Tour MTV Music critics Certified Fresh Baby Yoda DC Comics Premiere Dates spain Summer criterion DC Universe all-time 2016 blaxploitation Creative Arts Emmys Western Amazon Studios Mary Tyler Moore die hard movies Marvel Studios screenings dragons worst movies Star Wars Apple TV+ remakes Dark Horse Comics politics toronto mockumentary TBS Television Critics Association blockbuster chucky Musical anime christmas movies Nat Geo TCM composers TV films Britbox Women's History Month medical drama Tarantino Calendar joker children's TV asian-american Country zombie Quiz Infographic Ghostbusters cancelled TV series Epix Shudder crossover GoT sitcom Cannes Lucasfilm comic cults monster movies American Society of Cinematographers Trivia hidden camera Universal BET Awards TCA Winter 2020 Paramount Network Tubi Sony Pictures Election teaser twilight Set visit cancelled Rocketman directors hist Cosplay ABC Family sequels Amazon Prime boxoffice game show slashers PlayStation kaiju rotten Box Office VH1 parents dark YouTube Musicals Comics on TV kong based on movie Kids & Family Extras Acorn TV theme song blockbusters Disney Channel halloween TV Land Sundance TV Sneak Peek Spike Mindy Kaling San Diego Comic-Con Esquire TCA First Look Fall TV Spectrum Originals finale transformers ABC Signature Mary Poppins Returns free movies HBO Max Character Guide fast and furious cinemax President adaptation Lionsgate Hallmark Marvel Television New York Comic Con casting Hear Us Out Amazon Prime Video 71st Emmy Awards harry potter psychological thriller movie LGBT diversity A24 high school Television Academy zombies spanish Avengers scorecard The Walking Dead Netflix Christmas movies Logo Pride Month docudrama Ellie Kemper VOD Crackle 21st Century Fox golden globes FX 93rd Oscars south america 2021 Paramount MSNBC crime drama discovery foreign Netflix jurassic park 2018 Opinion french Rom-Com Turner Classic Movies Stephen King Film Festival MCU satire NBC Mystery comedies TV One BET Tomatazos batman ESPN romance social media justice league Nominations Nickelodeon talk show Mary poppins Pixar Sundance FXX Heroines Marathons worst Turner Reality Competition comic books Shondaland docuseries Thanksgiving award winner Classic Film women kids Best and Worst technology TV renewals franchise Anna Paquin scary movies Crunchyroll renewed TV shows Adult Swim Teen Spring TV Pop Animation SDCC screen actors guild prank National Geographic unscripted true crime Lifetime Christmas movies Lifetime independent deadpool 2015 psycho cops supernatural The CW comiccon new star wars movies ITV 72 Emmy Awards Winners period drama Superheroes binge First Reviews Warner Bros. YouTube Red Mudbound Family child's play CMT OWN Disney Plus Hulu archives jamie lee curtis best Syfy indie Song of Ice and Fire