Lord of the Rings Vs. Harry Potter: The Ultimate Fantasy Franchise Face-Off

Does the Boy Who Lived out-magic the hobbits, orcs, elves, and dwarves of Middle-earth? Find out as we break both series down by Tomatometer, box office, character quality, and more!

by | May 21, 2020 | Comments

It’s the Super Bowl of fantasy series showdowns in the latest edition of Vs., in which we’re pitting the Lord of the Rings movies against the Harry Potter films – including, for both franchises, the prequels. (And no, this does not help either side on the scoreboard.) Do Peter Jackson’s big-screen takes on J.R.R. Tolkien’s novels walk all over the movie adaptations of J.K. Rowling’s books like so many Ents stampeding through a forest? Or does the Boy Who Lived snatch up victory as if it were some quick-darting Golden Snitch? Find out as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks down each franchise by Tomatometer and Audience Score, box office, heroes and villains, and one special wild card category.

The Lord of the Rings films are available to rent or buy on FandangoNOW, Vudu, iTunes, and AmazonThe Harry Potter films are available to rent or buy on FandangoNOW, Vudu, iTunes, and Amazon

Thumbnail images by Universal courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Disney+ Disney Plus festivals game show MTV El Rey superhero Musicals stop motion Extras dark DC Comics Sundance TV NYCC Arrowverse Lionsgate 45 VICE Pirates slashers anime Netflix Christmas movies PaleyFest Columbia Pictures President GoT fast and furious PlayStation science fiction Song of Ice and Fire free movies mission: impossible SXSW Photos Chernobyl VOD Grammys Valentine's Day Brie Larson sequels Teen Britbox facebook Tumblr Animation Tarantino Certified Fresh zombies sag awards TCA Winter 2020 MCU DC Universe name the review FOX The Purge docudrama nbcuniversal aliens crossover green book Fox Searchlight A24 Opinion jamie lee curtis sports 99% PBS Infographic children's TV Comics on TV canceled TV shows LGBTQ dramedy stand-up comedy comiccon supernatural Superheroe CMT Lucasfilm Summer vampires Nat Geo latino Sci-Fi rotten deadpool Year in Review Sneak Peek documentary Apple TV Plus transformers boxing romance singing competition YA travel christmas movies Adult Swim game of thrones Acorn TV mutant Showtime biography Mary Tyler Moore richard e. Grant Trophy Talk Spike GIFs serial killer Star Wars Bravo Musical cancelled TV shows psycho based on movie nature TruTV 4/20 Pet Sematary adventure football Reality Interview Disney streaming service Baby Yoda cults Family adaptation Food Network Biopics Christmas mockumentary natural history Disney werewolf San Diego Comic-Con Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dogs Turner dragons Sundance Now BAFTA Pop TV Horror Amazon Prime documentaries Elton John 2017 The Witch Best and Worst zero dark thirty screenings television History all-time FXX blaxploitation Kids & Family CW Seed ABC Family 007 Crunchyroll Disney Plus Lifetime Christmas movies OneApp diversity Sundance Pixar 21st Century Fox Western halloween tv composers Marvel Studios Film Festival Avengers spy thriller sequel Holidays Holiday series Television Academy award winner tv talk HBO Go spanish Freeform Masterpiece Box Office TIFF Hallmark Christmas movies elevated horror parents Dark Horse Comics Schedule Spectrum Originals revenge italian spinoff DirecTV crime HBO Max Tomatazos FX 2018 Mindy Kaling Writers Guild of America Cannes Comedy Central scary movies anthology justice league Crackle versus indie 2015 black Mary poppins robots Pride Month thriller DC streaming service zombie finale scorecard cancelled LGBT ABC hist comic books 72 Emmy Awards breaking bad Set visit technology 71st Emmy Awards theme song screen actors guild south america halloween cinemax BBC One golden globes Trailer Discovery Channel FX on Hulu strong female leads Apple films remakes Mary Poppins Returns cartoon fresh canceled 2016 Black History Month Comic Book IFC Films ghosts Syfy festival DGA Awards Tour spider-man dceu Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Reality Competition franchise casting toronto police drama Paramount streaming best reboot french TCM Amazon political drama war Marvel Television Fantasy hispanic TV Vudu Warner Bros. Rock New York Comic Con Thanksgiving Trivia universal monsters rt archives Nickelodeon Apple TV+ twilight disaster romantic comedy YouTube Premium X-Men Cartoon Network talk show period drama Logo animated comedies miniseries Rocketman Video Games USA Awards ESPN Ellie Kemper Music binge cats die hard cancelled television Mystery obituary venice Tubi asian-american teaser australia independent true crime Disney Channel crime drama foreign Hulu indiana jones politics Endgame First Reviews Mudbound BBC kids Calendar Classic Film Walt Disney Pictures E3 BET Awards Ovation Election blockbuster Esquire satire Martial Arts The Walking Dead dc movie cancelled TV series APB Nominations 2020 quibi NBC nfl Pop Superheroes TLC A&E Turner Classic Movies toy story Winners BBC America Starz Star Trek Rocky See It Skip It discovery concert stoner Binge Guide American Society of Cinematographers Hear Us Out directors Character Guide Oscars doctor who Watching Series child's play Country video on demand AMC Fox News laika Funimation TV renewals Comedy CBS All Access joker Epix unscripted Travel Channel MSNBC Podcast historical drama Alien TCA 2017 space The CW worst Sony Pictures 20th Century Fox worst movies 24 frames Quiz crime thriller renewed TV shows Winter TV Women's History Month Polls and Games Anna Paquin what to watch Drama Black Mirror TNT The Academy WGN RT21 Spring TV cops news YouTube Red video reviews criterion BET Heroines Emmys Marvel Universal james bond RT History Television Critics Association Shudder Premiere Dates WarnerMedia The Arrangement medical drama YouTube Countdown TBS Action USA Network Amazon Prime Video Super Bowl SundanceTV boxoffice emmy awards Toys TCA Awards social media ITV book HBO 2019 harry potter TV Land archives Hallmark hollywood cars cooking VH1 Peacock Ghostbusters rotten movies we love National Geographic CNN SDCC Fall TV CBS comic Cosplay GLAAD critics OWN a nightmare on elm street japanese Academy Awards Creative Arts Emmys spain IFC ID Emmy Nominations spanish language Film chucky Red Carpet movies First Look TCA batman Paramount Network Amazon Studios ratings E! sitcom comics classics Stephen King psychological thriller Lifetime Shondaland Marathons Netflix Captain marvel witnail Rom-Com