Ordinary Joe Star James Wolk Specializes in Characters Leading Double Lives — This Time There Are 3

The upcoming drama series follows a man offered different life paths — and what happens when he takes each of them.

by | July 23, 2021 | Comments

What would your life be like now if you made one different decision 10 years ago? It’s a question that could keep someone up at night, but it’s also the premise behind upcoming NBC drama Ordinary Joe. Premiering September 20, the series stars Mad Men and Watchmen’s James Wolk as three different versions of one man — all because he was late to his college graduation 10 years ago and was then presented with three different options that would result in different career paths and relationships.

In one, Joe Kimbreau becomes a successful and famous musician and is married to Natalie Martinez’s Amy. In another, he’s a nurse and partnered with Elizabeth Lail’s Jenny. In the third, he’s single and joins the family business as a NYPD officer. In all of these scenarios, Joe’s life results in different issues and conflicts — not just for him, Amy, and Jenny, but also for his best friend Eric (Charlie Barnett) and his family.

With the release of the trailer, we spoke with Wolk about the series and thoughts of lives less traveled.

James Wolk

(Photo by Chris Delmas/AFP via Getty Images)

Whitney Friedlander for Rotten Tomatoes: You’re playing three versions of the same person. Does that make it harder than just playing three different characters?

James Wolk: In some ways, it is more challenging because you can’t just go and create three different characters. You have to really think about, in a nuanced way, how someone’s life can change in 10 years. So it’s basically creating the same backstory from birth until 21. And then everyone takes a divergent road.

Obviously, costumes and makeup play a part in this. But does that also affect your posture, your cadence, etc.?

Yeah, absolutely. All three versions of this guy are so different, right? You have the rock star, who is super confident versus the nurse, who’s down on his luck. I think that’s a posture thing, for sure — just the way we hold ourselves when we’re feeling really confident versus when we’re feeling down on our luck. And then the cop, who’s to me is kind of like a big kid. So he’s just kind of like a big Labrador. Wardrobe help big time. There’s wigs. there’s a beard expert that came in and hand-laid that beard for each for each time I was rock star …

Ordinary Joe key art

(Photo by NBC Entertainment)

The musician character, naturally, performs a lot and the police officer sings in the pilot. You can sing. But do you play the guitar and the piano?

I sing, but I sing to my kids: my four-year-old and my two-year-old. So what you hear is my voice. I do play guitar. But they did bring in a guitar aficionado to really play it. That is me singing. That is me playing guitar. And when you hear it in the mix, you’re hearing the guitars, but you’re getting my voice because my guitar skills are like that of a camp counselor. I can play, like, Cats in the Cradle and a couple of songs around the fire. I don’t have rock-star technique.

And there was a great vocal coach in Chicago. I haven’t sung seriously since high school when I used to do high school musicals. And they brought in this guy and he was amazing. He added two notes to the top of my register that I never thought I could hit.

In all versions of this, Joe is successful. He’s a really good nurse. He’s an extremely successful musician. He’s a really good cop. Was that interesting? Were there conversations about having a Joe who wasn’t doing well in his career?

It’s interesting. Nurse Joe is down on his luck, but it’s with his marriage. They all have their thing [that’s not going well] like, in their show, his marriage isn’t going well. Music Joe: he’s always wanted to be a dad. It appears in the pilot that his dad passed away on 9/11 and there’s a whole backstory that will come out as the series goes on. I think, he has always wanted to replicate that father-son relationship. For him, he and his wife deal with infertility. With Cop Joe, he never moved on with his life. He froze in time; he has Peter Pan syndrome. So they all have something that’s eating at all of them.

You keep calling them Music Joe or Cop Joe. Is that what you call them on set or are there nicknames for them?

We should get nicknames for them.

MAD MEN, James Wolk

(Photo by Jaimie Trueblood / © AMC / Courtesy: Everett Collection)

This isn’t the first time you’ve played characters with a sort-of double life. You did the short-lived series Lone Star. And even your character on Mad Men, Bob Benson (pictured), had a sort of double life because he was a gay man living in the closet. Is there something that draws you to these characters?

Subconsciously, I’m attracted to that duality. I think that I’m someone who went on this path to become an actor. But prior to this, I had so many different interests. I was attracted to that script because I felt like I had a lot of ways I wanted to go at 21 — like vastly different ways. Like grad school. Or did I want to pursue acting? Or did I want to stay in my hometown of Michigan? Or did I want to go to New York?

Each one of those choices would have led me to completely different paths. I’m married with two kids now. And I’m in love with my wife, and I have these two amazing kids. Had I made a different choice, the probability is that I would have a totally different family. So that concept is really interesting to me.

And then along those lines, Lone Star and Bob Benson: just the idea of the faces we show versus who we really are inside? It also interests me.

Ordinary Joe premieres at 10 p.m. September 20 on NBC.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Character Guide classics 73rd Emmy Awards versus jamie lee curtis toy story crime thriller Nominations comedies Kids & Family posters CW Seed 2020 Apple TV+ Polls and Games Lionsgate theme song video on demand reboot Teen Action Turner travel Fox News USA adenture YouTube Premium Comics on TV TV renewals Super Bowl Holiday TruTV adventure Britbox hispanic Cannes vampires Valentine's Day Nickelodeon facebook crime japan DirecTV BET space dc Marvel composers Musicals diversity Cartoon Network The Purge spinoff canceled TV shows Hulu scorecard politics RT21 Music VICE dceu PBS YouTube New York Comic Con Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt critics what to watch justice league discovery Holidays kaiju Masterpiece sequels Sony Pictures transformers free movies joker VH1 rom-coms talk show rotten movies we love italian Election American Society of Cinematographers Pacific Islander foreign quibi stoner Fall TV 45 festival witnail ABC Family BAFTA Grammys Pop TV Martial Arts halloween ABC Signature Mudbound Writers Guild of America movies ratings blockbuster PaleyFest cancelled TV series Image Comics news wonder woman 2017 series Sci-Fi DC streaming service TLC GLAAD Ghostbusters Food Network festivals Binge Guide President 2018 NBC 71st Emmy Awards Calendar debate science fiction Lifetime Christmas movies best comic book movie Mary poppins Tokyo Olympics cancelled television Anna Paquin mission: impossible robots DC Universe football cooking sports hollywood comic venice anthology Television Critics Association gangster Sneak Peek History Watching Series ABC sequel Hallmark Christmas movies The Arrangement 2015 Christmas Film biopic First Look The Academy black Tubi crime drama Logo anime boxing TV One Winners south america Pixar obituary Box Office Emmy Nominations psychological thriller CMT teaser emmy awards boxoffice Marvel Television films Pop blaxploitation remakes asian-american tv talk singing competition technology royal family book Rom-Com Exclusive Video cartoon Hallmark romantic comedy fast and furious TNT Lifetime Podcast Captain marvel DC Comics true crime documentaries Broadway game show Heroines werewolf critic resources Netflix child's play zombie streaming movies kong Sundance Now USA Network TV scary movies Shondaland Ovation Best and Worst Oscars Mindy Kaling Adult Swim Disney streaming service new york parents TCA Winter 2020 zombies video scene in color Emmys Drama Esquire CNN cats VOD Reality Chilling Adventures of Sabrina OneApp animated Toys psycho Comedy breaking bad 007 Western Paramount Network 99% docudrama TV Land Comic-Con@Home 2021 GoT superman serial killer Marathons laika strong female leads war Creative Arts Emmys FXX feel good MCU renewed TV shows Film Festival dexter 4/20 children's TV Star Wars FX on Hulu DGA OWN hidden camera Universal 2019 ID Classic Film new star wars movies adaptation basketball a nightmare on elm street casting spider-man Alien harry potter cancelled TV shows king kong natural history spain indiana jones NBA supernatural Summer razzies Netflix Christmas movies Baby Yoda Crunchyroll Spectrum Originals Star Trek directors prank Disney Channel sag awards 24 frames TV movies Animation cars dark Trailer Countdown Musical rt labs Paramount book adaptation AMC Set visit Comedy Central olympics BBC One Epix Premiere Dates Sundance Warner Bros. doctor who Black Mirror LGBT 93rd Oscars international docuseries Television Academy new zealand Fantasy ITV BBC marvel cinematic universe Sundance TV comic book movies elevated horror Trophy Talk Arrowverse deadpool award winner game of thrones El Rey X-Men Amazon chucky Tomatazos Pet Sematary social media cults Bravo young adult action-comedy Cosplay worst Elton John IFC National Geographic finale Peacock screen actors guild criterion The Walking Dead SDCC know your critic Fox Searchlight Winter TV suspense First Reviews sitcom Interview Family Academy Awards blockbusters hispanic heritage month stop motion 1990s Schedule 21st Century Fox ghosts TCM Awards golden globes Extras TIFF PlayStation disaster Vudu Horror IFC Films LGBTQ Infographic cops Tarantino indie Columbia Pictures MSNBC WarnerMedia YouTube Red richard e. Grant cinemax aliens Certified Fresh spanish language Legendary Superheroes trailers Ellie Kemper jurassic park crossover archives historical drama Avengers mockumentary french spy thriller period drama mutant A24 Superheroe WGN SXSW worst movies telelvision james bond Hear Us Out Mary Tyler Moore BET Awards HBO Go hist dogs godzilla Discovery Channel HBO marvel comics TCA Opinion Starz Country Amazon Prime Walt Disney Pictures Lucasfilm zero dark thirty Freeform nature Trivia saw BBC America Photos Quiz all-time Crackle ViacomCBS mcc legend Syfy streaming spanish Nat Geo heist movie YA Chernobyl toronto batman The Walt Disney Company Year in Review RT History christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns canceled Rocky television fresh Black History Month Spring TV Paramount Plus die hard 2021 72 Emmy Awards Rock Spike police drama NYCC green book Song of Ice and Fire 2016 universal monsters Comic Book superhero Rocketman TBS CBS APB The CW dramedy FX Travel Channel latino medical drama halloween tv king arthur SundanceTV unscripted slashers ESPN Stephen King Showtime comics romance TCA Awards Turner Classic Movies stand-up comedy twilight Shudder Amazon Studios Funimation Disney E! aapi Disney Plus Pride Month Video Games Pirates TCA 2017 MTV japanese reviews Endgame screenings independent comic books rt archives political drama nfl documentary The Witch Amazon Prime Video A&E comiccon miniseries live action 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards monster movies lord of the rings biography Red Carpet thriller Thanksgiving Apple name the review satire CBS All Access revenge Acorn TV Apple TV Plus kids Brie Larson Marvel Studios concert slasher franchise Wes Anderson binge San Diego Comic-Con Reality Competition Awards Tour Disney+ Disney Plus rotten HBO Max pirates of the caribbean rt labs critics edition Biopics dragons based on movie cancelled nbcuniversal See It Skip It golden globe awards Women's History Month australia E3 FOX popular Dark Horse Comics 90s movie women Mystery 20th Century Fox GIFs target Tumblr high school