Comics On TV

7 Indie Comics Characters Who Deserve Their Own Shows

Remember that Scott Pilgrim movie with Michael Cera? Maybe it should've been a TV series. Plus, 6 more characters who would probably kill it on the small screen.

by | November 16, 2017 | Comments

Scott Pilgrim’s Precious Little Life, Fatale, Madman comics (Oni Press; Image Comics; Dark Horse Comics)

(Photo by Oni Press; Image Comics; Dark Horse Comics)

You might think television is home to all of the comic books now — between DC Entertainment’s domination of broadcast (six shows with more on the way!); Fox using the X-Men library to fuel two separate shows about mutants (The Gifted and Legion); Marvel’s Netflix family (Daredevil, Jessica Jones, new release The Punisher, etc.); ABC’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. also from Marvel; and Riverdale from Archie Comics on The CW. But those shows derive from comic books published by the major publishers. Meanwhile, there’s an exciting world of indie comics just waiting to enter the TV continuum. The following seven examples are just a handful of the characters who deserve their own television shows.


(Photo by Dark Horse Comics)

From the pages of: Madman by Mike and Laura Allred

Story: Frank Einstein was a government agent, but his life before he died is a vague mystery to him. Now a reanimated corpse, he aids his friend Dr. Flem in investigating the odd. He’s also sweet on Joe Lombard, a local secretary. Every so often aliens, mutant beatniks and G-Men from Hell interrupt Frank’s rather swell life. Occasionally, he yearns to remember who he was in his previous life, but why question a good thing when you can just have a picnic?

Why Frank: Despite a shady past and messed-up origin, Frank is the model of optimism. Sure, he can fight and has a few enhanced abilities thanks to his reanimation, but he’d rather make friends with his adversaries. As a show, Madman might be more of a quirky character comedy on Hulu or FX than a full-bore action series, but it could set a new standard for costumed quasi-superheroes on television.

Development status: The film rights have been in the hands of Robert Rodriguez since the 1990s, but no dice on a TV project.

Hunter Rose

(Photo by Dark Horse Comics)

From the pages of: Grendel by Matt Wagner and a number of other collaborators.

Story: Hunter Rose leads a double life. By day, he’s a successful author. By night, he’s the debonair assassin known as Grendel. Because things come easy to him, he eventually parlays his success as a hitman into running the New York mob syndicates. His constant adversary is Argent, a Native American werewolf hoping to end his curse by revealing the true identity of Grendel. Making things difficult for both, Argent’s friend Stacy is Hunter Rose’s adopted daughter.

Why Hunter Rose? While Grendel spans centuries, the Hunter Rose story is particularly evocative and visually compelling. The character himself is an interesting inversion of the superhero myth and as both Wagner and other writers filled in the broad strokes of his original short story, he only becomes a more compelling and intriguing villain. Imagine an HBO gangland series with a central character who moonlights as a costumed assassin.

Development Status: Not in development as a film or television project.

Goldie Vance

(Photo by BOOM!)

From the pages of: Goldie Vance by Hope Larson and Brittney Williams

Story: Hailing from a 1960s Florida in which same-sex relationships are apparently tolerated and segregation was dealt with long ago, Goldie works as a valet at the hotel her father manages, but longs to become the establishment’s in-house detective. She also solves seemingly petty crimes on the side. Sometimes a simple hotel robbery can have international implications and Goldie’s extracurricular activities get her noticed by the FBI despite being only 16.

Why Goldie? Goldie is a bright beam of sunshine in a world of would-be spies and astronauts. Full of resourcefulness and zippy catchphrases, Goldie manages to make the lives of those around her markedly better. Consider a Goldie Vance television show a successor of sorts to Veronica Mars with less death and more rockets, hot rods and pep. A worthy addition to The CW’s roster.

Development Status: Not in development (yet).

Scott Pilgrim

(Photo by Oni Press)

From the Pages of: Scott Pilgrim’s Precious Little Life (and subsequent volumes) by Bryan Lee O’Malley.

Story: Bumbling Toronto lay-about/guitarist Scott Pilgrim begins a relationship with American transplant Ramona Flowers. While his rock group Sex Bob-omb gets ready for a prolonged Battle of the Bands, Scott faces the wrath of Ramona’s seven evil exes. In order to date her, he must defeat them all.

Why Scott? A question all his friends ask constantly. Despite already appearing in a feature film, Edgar Wright’s Scott Pilgrim vs. The World, much of the journey O’Malley put Scott on solidified well after Wright and co-writer Michael Bacall began developing their version of events. Scott matures (somewhat unwillingly) and comes to see how much damage he caused his group of friends. Unlike the film, it is only through that deeper maturity that he ultimately “defeats” the last of the evil ex-boyfriends and saves a life in the process. The mixture of emotional growth and pop culture references would look right at home on Netflix.

Development Status: None, though Adult Swim did air Scott Pilgrim vs. The Animation as a tie-in to the film in 2010.


(Photo by Image Comics)

From the pages of: Fatale by Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips

Story: Josephine is an apparent immortal with the ability to hypnotize men. It would seem like a sweet power, but it is more of a curse, as Jo cannot turn it off. She is also pursued by a vicious cult with designs on her power. But as the decades tick by, she survives — even if she leaves a path of destruction in her wake.

Why Josephine? Thanks to her complicated morality, she makes for a compelling anti-hero. In subverting film noir tropes, she is both victim and perpetrator; making it difficult to trust anything she does. With the amount of sex, witchcraft and violence in her story, Fatale could only be a premium cable show.

Development Status: Not currently in development.

Jimmy Corrigan

(Photo by Pantheon Graphic Novels)

From the Pages of: Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth by Chris Ware

Story: Jimmy Corrigan is a lonely middle-aged man on the way to meet his father for the first time in his life. Finding it difficult to talk to anyone except his mother, Jimmy manages to work up the strength to make the parental reunion over a Thanksgiving weekend. Sadly, the man turns out to be vaguely racist and difficult, crushing what remaining hope Jimmy has in this life.

Why Jimmy? Despite consistently failing, Jimmy Corrigan is endlessly compelling in his life of quiet desperation. Between nostalgic dreams of being Superman and working at a dead-end job, Jimmy just keeps moving despite the crushing weight of a meager existence. He might be the only character on this list that needs to be animated, but imagine a Bojack Horseman like emphasis on emotional pain.

Development Status: Not in development, and considering Jimmy’s remarkable resemblance to Stewie Griffin – despite appearing years before Family Guy – it’s unlikely he’ll even become a TV star.


(Photo by HarperCollins)

From the pages of: Nimona by Noelle Stevenson.

Story: Nimona, a young shapeshifter in world where sci-fi tropes and fantasy settings coexist, becomes the sidekick of noted villain Lord Ballister Blackheart (whether he wants one or not). As she insinuates herself into his home and business, she begins to sense a mistake in the way “good” and “evil” are calculated; suspecting the Institution of Law Enforcement and Heroics as the source of the problem.

Why Nimona? Defying stereotypes of gender and power dynamics, Nimona smacks her world’s culture with a cheerful disposition, wit, and almost childlike curiosity into the nature of villainy. Like Blackheart, she’s not really evil, but charmed by its counterculture significance within the kingdom. She’s also delightfully complicated as a woman running for her past and using her powers to do it.

Development Status: Being developed as an animated movie by 20th Century Fox Animation and director Patrick Osborne.

Tag Cloud

Neflix Britbox Peacock Nat Geo TV One Mindy Kaling Holiday political drama rotten movies we love Mary poppins 93rd Oscars stand-up comedy witnail emmy awards scary universal monsters Avengers Reality trailers Paramount Network Infographic Marathons dexter Horror children's TV E! harry potter BET Awards GIFs mob streaming movies Animation period drama vs. FX heist movie lord of the rings President A&E young adult renewed TV shows richard e. Grant ID revenge First Reviews Baby Yoda talk show south america scene in color hispanic heritage month teaser WGN Disney Channel scorecard reviews blockbuster cars Writers Guild of America suspense mcc Video Games BET award winner adventure Lionsgate rotten DC Comics live action Freeform psychological thriller Discovery Channel Lucasfilm discovery Winter TV DGA worst movies Comedy Lifetime international Television Academy Marvel Logo PBS cancelled A24 Brie Larson DirecTV NBA sequel dc FXX action-comedy spinoff superman travel golden globes MCU razzies Apple TV+ versus Tomatazos BAFTA SundanceTV Spring TV twilight USA Endgame 4/20 Musical Mary Tyler Moore rt archives Biopics romantic comedy child's play BBC America RT History aapi reboot Apple independent Creative Arts Emmys National Geographic 2018 VH1 The CW news Academy Awards anime ratings movies TV movies rt labs critics edition zombies Amazon Prime NYCC Epix 24 frames dark 72 Emmy Awards kaiju Comic Book MTV rt labs sopranos Paramount Bravo Crunchyroll popular die hard legend Character Guide Christmas Disney TV renewals Country The Walt Disney Company festivals Cartoon Network superhero werewolf Action Kids & Family rom-coms Starz foreign breaking bad Crackle Chernobyl The Witch black prank Disney Plus The Walking Dead Premiere Dates Podcast Pop name the review toronto james bond adaptation video on demand Superheroe all-time 99% Sundance indiana jones docuseries zero dark thirty 73rd Emmy Awards Pop TV comiccon Extras Pride Month Awards Tour concert Thanksgiving justice league spy thriller Certified Fresh dceu cooking cops Reality Competition Sundance TV remakes boxoffice The Purge kong Turner Classic Movies Columbia Pictures TCA Awards E3 jamie lee curtis tv talk 1990s OWN game show blockbusters golden globe awards Set visit medical drama marvel cinematic universe YouTube Red Mystery Fall TV TLC comics halloween tv Valentine's Day Broadway natural history Amazon YouTube Nominations Oscars BBC screenings blaxploitation cancelled television New York Comic Con art house Universal Pictures Spectrum Originals YA Ellie Kemper 90s Black History Month politics Elton John Mary Poppins Returns DC streaming service spain MSNBC Superheroes Photos supernatural Grammys strong female leads Sony Pictures biography basketball Family 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Warner Bros. hidden camera stoner comic book movies batman cats toy story TNT El Rey criterion Arrowverse classics sequels french venice gangster live event new york Instagram Live deadpool comedies Star Wars what to watch posters animated franchise Classic Film Teen Paramount Plus Stephen King Spike Anna Paquin telelvision Year in Review japanese binge Super Bowl indie Holidays serial killer American Society of Cinematographers TBS Drama CNN singing competition TCA Box Office Best and Worst 21st Century Fox composers Tubi Apple TV Plus 2020 OneApp wonder woman Trophy Talk Polls and Games olympics Opinion HBO Max AMC Plus saw AMC Sci-Fi Fox News Emmys dramedy Pixar Wes Anderson aliens Ghostbusters VICE Toys unscripted Netflix Christmas movies Marvel Television Music latino dragons Turner Image Comics TruTV technology science fiction NBC TCA 2017 Acorn TV Walt Disney Pictures australia debate book adaptation IMDb TV monster movies chucky CBS 007 war television Black Mirror Food Network canceled TV shows screen actors guild diversity satire mission: impossible dreamworks HBO Go miniseries historical drama hist Musicals police drama archives VOD Trailer ESPN Red Carpet YouTube Premium ITV First Look Shondaland free movies Hulu japan Summer Fantasy Binge Guide parents facebook hollywood fast and furious Star Trek Adult Swim sag awards Martial Arts CMT Mudbound Election kids 45 critic resources disaster know your critic PlayStation halloween GLAAD jurassic park true crime spanish language theme song hispanic game of thrones Quiz mockumentary genre Film Festival Nickelodeon Schedule sitcom comic books Hear Us Out pirates of the caribbean ABC black comedy slashers Chilling Adventures of Sabrina documentary ViacomCBS Comic-Con@Home 2021 20th Century Fox comic book movie video vampires Amazon Prime Video Comics on TV PaleyFest TV Alien king arthur italian streaming adenture TIFF green book Cosplay space IFC Films mutant spider-man Amazon Studios Comedy Central Emmy Nominations Sundance Now 2016 Awards ghosts nfl nature cancelled TV shows based on movie crossover WarnerMedia quibi marvel comics spanish GoT high school Tokyo Olympics a nightmare on elm street new zealand cancelled TV series critics HBO Shudder joker APB Universal godzilla Fox Searchlight Television Critics Association The Arrangement Pet Sematary Pirates Western romance elevated horror ABC Signature documentaries 2015 cinemax Song of Ice and Fire nbcuniversal Hallmark Showtime CW Seed sports Tarantino robots Funimation LGBT biopic Countdown book See It Skip It crime drama CBS All Access Masterpiece slasher SXSW boxing directors movie Travel Channel Marvel Studios feel good Dark Horse Comics fresh Rocky Heroines 2019 stop motion football BBC One casting cartoon transformers San Diego Comic-Con IFC psycho Trivia 71st Emmy Awards canceled Disney+ Disney Plus Vudu X-Men spider-verse Ovation worst films Lifetime Christmas movies thriller crime Disney streaming service Winners FX on Hulu History Watching Series comic 2017 women Syfy TCA Winter 2020 Calendar LGBTQ Exclusive Video scary movies festival obituary anthology Rom-Com Rock finale TV Land ABC Family crime thriller doctor who Hallmark Christmas movies Captain marvel best Sneak Peek Cannes FOX Interview cults docudrama zombie social media The Academy Netflix laika christmas movies Esquire target Rocketman new star wars movies Tumblr RT21 USA Network DC Universe 2021 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Film TCM royal family dogs asian-american series Legendary king kong SDCC Pacific Islander Women's History Month