Hear Us Out

Hear Us Out: Underworld Is the Most Underrated Action-Horror Franchise

On the 15th anniversary of Underworld: Evolution, we break down why the franchise's campy atmosphere, nu-metal aesthetic, and earnest self-seriousness actually work in its favor.

by | January 20, 2021 | Comments

The huge success of The Matrix spawned a number of films with similar aesthetics: shiny, black leather wardrobes, lots of slow-motion, and action scenes that mixed martial arts with gunfighting. Take all of that and combine it with Blade, and you’ll see a path leading to one of the best action-horror franchises we’ve got — Underworld.

This original franchise chronicles the centuries-long secret war between vampires and werewolves, and while none of its five entries impressed critics — the highest-rated film is the first, at just 31% on the Tomatometer — there is more to it than meets the eye. Sure, it’s full of campy B-movie silliness, but it’s so devoted to its concept and its complex mythology that you can’t help but be enthralled by it. Plus, it gave us Kate Beckinsale as one of the most badass heroines of the 2000s. For the 15th anniversary of the franchise’s second entry, Underworld: Evolution, we’re throwing on our best black leather jacket and cranking up the nu-metal as we revisit why Underworld is the most underrated action-horror franchise.


It Takes Its Surprisingly Complex Mythology Seriously

Kate Beckinsale in Underworld: Evolution

(Photo by (c)Screen Gems courtesy Everett Collection)

A franchise about vampires fighting werewolves — otherwise known as “Lycans” — admittedly sounds silly, and it could have remained nothing more than that. But the Underworld franchise’s biggest strength is that it builds a big and complex mythology that it treats absolutely seriously. Because this is not a franchise about a single vampire or werewolf, but whole communities of them, we see how their weaknesses inform their way of life. The vampire covens’ castles have automatic sealing gates outside every window to prevent sunlight from entering. Rise of the Lycans, the third film in the series and a sequel, depicts captured Lycans who are forced to wear collars adorned with silver spikes to prevent them from transforming. We also see a fantastic escalation and evolution of weaponry being used by both sides, from more traditional artifacts like silver swords to UV bullets and grenades filled with liquid silver.

Though not necessarily groundbreaking, the Underworld franchise also introduces new concepts into both the vampire and werewolf mythos. In Evolution, we learn that the first generation of werewolves was not able to return to human form, making them generally more feral. On the vampire side, gone is the need for human blood (any blood is sufficient — even that of other vampires), but we learn that blood carries memory; one can see a another’s entire life flash before their eyes by ingesting some of their blood.

Each film doubles down on the mythology of the previous one while adding a new layer, and one could easily imagine a cinematic Underworld universe with spin-off material recounting the creation of the other covens or the first and second immortal purges of Awakening.


Its Supporting Cast Elevates the Silliness

If the franchise itself taking its mythology seriously helps bring you into its world, then hiring classy stage actors to elevate the sillier aspects of the story makes it feel like you’re watching a Shakespearean horror epic. This starts with Kate Beckinsale herself. Before she was the leather-clad Death Dealer Selene, the Oxford-trained actress played Hero in Much Ado About Nothing and had appeared in several West End productions.

Then there’s the villains. The moment Bill Nighy shows up in heavy makeup as the evil vampire overlord Viktor, curls his lip, and starts talking about the Lycans, you’re fully committed to this franchise. Nighy’s serious yet over-the-top performance is like watching him play Titus Andronicus one minute and Macbeth the next. His rapport with Michael Sheen’s slave-turned-freedom fighter-turned-villain Lucian was so great to watch that they made an entire prequel just to give Sheen a Spartacus speech to deliver to an army of Lycans.

Evolution brings in former member of the Royal Shakespeare Company (Sir!) Derek Jacobi to play the first immortal man, Alexander Corvinus, and he similarly plays his role as if he were in a tragic stage play rather than a action-horror movie. Just listen to the somber way he speaks about how much it pains him that the war his two sons have begun has lasted for centuries, and that he can’t bring himself to kill one of them to end it all. The latter two movies of the franchise also introduce two Game of Thrones veterans: Charles Dance (Tywin Lannister) plays a vampire noble who loves his son and gets to do some badass sword-fighting, while Tobias Menzies (Edmure Tully) plays Lucian’s successor as the leader of the Lycans, boasting a commanding presence and a rather enviable hairstyle. It’s a simple yet very effective way to make the villains memorable and the conflict more compelling.


It Features Great Use Of Practical Effects

One of the biggest cinematic crimes in history is the decline of practical makeup and costume design in werewolf movies — something that extends to many other genres across the industry. But Underworld knows that there’s no beating a practical werewolf suit.

The design of the eight-foot-tall beasts that walk on two legs with grey skin, massive necks, and elongated heads are some of the most impressive werewolves in decades, and they are unique enough to be recognized among the crowd of movie werewolves. These Lycans have less fur compared to most other interpretations, with rather Mohawk-like manes that accentuate the beasts’ imposing musculature. Though they are meant to be doglike, the Lycans also possess some feline characteristics, which was the intention from the beginning, to give the Lycans a sense of agility.

The use of practical suits with yak fur and animatronic legs and faces, as well as the extensive wirework, make the action scenes hit harder and the gore feel more real. Sure, there is still a lot of CGI in the franchise, especially in the latter films, but it’s always a thrill to see a huge, practical Lycan chase Selene before she puts them down.


It Feels Like A Nu-Metal Music Video

Though it initially drew comparisons to The Matrix, the Underworld franchise quickly carved out its own gothic look that made the franchise instantly recognizable.

Its use of moonlight and shadow in the cinematography, its excess of black leather, and its use of elaborate sets and European castles make Underworld feel like you’re stepping into an early-200os Hot Topic store or a late-1990s nu-metal concert. Central to this aesthetic is Kate Beckinsale herself, who first pops on screen in a trench coat, perched in the rain like a gargoyle surveying the streets of Budapest with enough gothic glamour to create an iconic look for the franchise at large. We’re not saying the style is for everyone, but it’s difficult to deny the role it’s played as the signature look for the series; not every franchise can say the same.


It Knows How To Reinvent Itself

Every long-lasting franchise, at some point, has to evolve or die. The recent Fast & Furious movies have little in common with the very first film in the franchise, for example. Though Underworld hasn’t exactly turned into a Mission: Impossible-style spy thriller, it has still managed to change and adapt over time, providing different and exciting experiences for the audience with every entry.

After the first film ends with a change in the status quo for Selene and the worlds of both vampires and Lycans, the second entry dives deeper into the mythology by introducing us to the first of both species. Their look is unlike anything in the first movie, offering a proper winged nosferatu and a feral werewolf straight from a classic Universal monster movie. The third film goes full Romeo and Juliet by returning to the past, making tragic heroes of the Lycans, and trading UV bullets for swords.

Even the more maligned Awakening still offers something new, as it jumps forward in time to a dystopian future in which the Lycans are even bigger and more terrifying. Lastly, Blood Wars feels like a response to the rise in popularity of Game of Thrones, as it explores even more political intrigue and features an epic fantasy-heavy third act that’s basically an Arthurian myth mixed with the triumphant climax of The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers. Seriously, there’s an army of pale, silver-haired vampires brandishing swords in the middle of a gunfight, and it rules.


Underworld: Evolution was released in theaters on December 17, 2010.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

romantic comedy cartoon Quiz critics high school worst movies obituary Song of Ice and Fire ViacomCBS LGBT SDCC Horror wonder woman Black Mirror historical drama boxoffice slashers TLC foreign Rom-Com GLAAD animated golden globe awards Nominations Warner Bros. 90s cults remakes Western legend dark Lifetime Black History Month Discovery Channel Spring TV Opinion news Elton John Lifetime Christmas movies Fantasy 24 frames action-comedy based on movie singing competition Certified Fresh posters book The Purge rotten Mudbound spanish language revenge children's TV DC Comics Amazon Prime Biopics spanish superman Grammys TCM target MTV japan RT History Disney Channel police drama Legendary know your critic The Walking Dead Amazon Prime Video Apple TV+ binge theme song Emmy Nominations independent NBA Trailer strong female leads Awards Tour dceu comedies Sundance Image Comics justice league Teen Star Trek franchise festival Lucasfilm Acorn TV Oscars Disney streaming service christmas movies classics movies Turner best festivals rt archives robots medical drama BET Trophy Talk politics hidden camera criterion Character Guide 1990s fresh Vudu Britbox venice prank Heroines series Sci-Fi CNN Academy Awards Creative Arts Emmys Pixar TCA 2017 Holiday A&E zombie directors TV movies quibi GIFs Endgame Sony Pictures Election cooking adenture mockumentary GoT mcc child's play unscripted VOD rt labs stop motion sequels cancelled television boxing 2016 DirecTV documentary worst Tokyo Olympics Pet Sematary dexter Photos FX on Hulu Walt Disney Pictures women asian-american rt labs critics edition godzilla black 71st Emmy Awards OneApp spain CBS japanese archives ESPN aapi Nickelodeon TNT vampires BBC One Extras south america Best and Worst stoner twilight BET Awards Sneak Peek thriller docuseries Country A24 political drama BBC America Box Office Red Carpet Marvel Television screen actors guild First Reviews Baby Yoda crime 2015 nature Hulu dogs Logo Martial Arts royal family natural history a nightmare on elm street golden globes IFC Films talk show Disney Music TCA Winter 2020 Holidays Pacific Islander cancelled Pride Month toy story Disney Plus Pop TV Universal space TBS Ovation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comic CBS All Access king kong Disney+ Disney Plus elevated horror Avengers hispanic romance Tomatazos debate TIFF cancelled TV series toronto serial killer Reality Infographic discovery Hallmark Television Academy Awards Starz Comic-Con@Home 2021 Valentine's Day streaming movies Calendar Interview anthology Turner Classic Movies Marvel Studios new star wars movies WGN Shudder Family kaiju Food Network Tubi Paramount Network TV Masterpiece slasher universal monsters popular name the review scorecard fast and furious Fox Searchlight Syfy Year in Review 4/20 45 Mary poppins 73rd Emmy Awards E! Ghostbusters renewed TV shows sequel Apple witnail rotten movies we love Summer Mindy Kaling spider-man canceled TV shows blaxploitation New York Comic Con Arrowverse jamie lee curtis YA Apple TV Plus Premiere Dates concert LGBTQ supernatural Amazon stand-up comedy deadpool finale Netflix Christmas movies History VICE scene in color video on demand Comedy Drama die hard chucky Sundance TV emmy awards Film USA razzies YouTube Premium Ellie Kemper docudrama ABC Family Bravo The Witch green book feel good adaptation comic book movie Reality Competition El Rey CMT 72 Emmy Awards mutant football crime drama live action italian FOX Kids & Family transformers Toys satire sag awards comic books Mary Poppins Returns breaking bad sitcom Rocketman casting Anna Paquin joker what to watch Fall TV Action award winner miniseries DGA batman book adaptation 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards disaster laika hist nbcuniversal WarnerMedia Emmys Thanksgiving BAFTA jurassic park OWN ABC Signature Winter TV Superheroes hollywood aliens james bond psychological thriller NYCC facebook 2021 2019 lord of the rings new zealand SundanceTV See It Skip It YouTube french Tarantino Rocky Cosplay FXX halloween tv indiana jones Broadway telelvision Brie Larson australia Musical TCA Awards Video Games parents scary movies halloween HBO Max 20th Century Fox Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Watching Series travel indie king arthur zero dark thirty Winners reboot suspense anime screenings Captain marvel Epix all-time kids comics comic book movies 93rd Oscars biopic Paramount Plus NBC Musicals critic resources 99% Super Bowl Spike DC Universe Trivia blockbuster ITV Travel Channel TV Land Film Festival pirates of the caribbean period drama CW Seed new york Nat Geo documentaries Christmas Stephen King Marvel rom-coms psycho harry potter President Tumblr 007 Peacock werewolf Adult Swim Netflix DC streaming service teaser technology TV One The Walt Disney Company marvel cinematic universe latino Marathons TruTV zombies Women's History Month Classic Film PlayStation ghosts crime thriller X-Men superhero Lionsgate war true crime biography Wes Anderson HBO Go USA Network composers Alien Columbia Pictures Cartoon Network 2017 2018 Hear Us Out mission: impossible PBS PaleyFest heist movie richard e. Grant Superheroe Fox News VH1 Schedule movie Hallmark Christmas movies gangster 2020 spinoff RT21 E3 MSNBC streaming dragons game show nfl canceled TV renewals Binge Guide marvel comics video Amazon Studios kong Paramount YouTube Red young adult cancelled TV shows San Diego Comic-Con international Pop monster movies Cannes Spectrum Originals SXSW comiccon Comedy Central The CW Comics on TV social media diversity Television Critics Association AMC Dark Horse Comics cops ID IFC HBO Showtime Polls and Games Chernobyl Rock Animation Esquire basketball doctor who cinemax Pirates The Academy Writers Guild of America dramedy saw Mary Tyler Moore adventure reviews trailers TCA MCU Star Wars versus science fiction sports Freeform game of thrones 21st Century Fox hispanic heritage month Exclusive Video cats dc cars Podcast FX APB BBC The Arrangement National Geographic Crackle Mystery American Society of Cinematographers Funimation television First Look blockbusters Countdown films spy thriller olympics crossover ABC ratings Set visit Comic Book free movies Sundance Now tv talk Shondaland Crunchyroll