Hear Us Out

Hear Us Out: Josie and the Pussycats Is the Most Underrated Music Film of the Past 20 Years

Two decades after its release, the film's distinctly early-2000s aesthetic sensibilities, over-the-top industry satire, and killer soundtrack have made it a cult favorite.

by | April 11, 2021 | Comments

Josie and the Pussycats

(Photo by Everett Collection)

Music movies are having a moment right now. In 2018, Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga lit radio waves and theaters ablaze with the third remake of A Star is Born; that same year, Bohemian Rhapsody earned four Academy Awards; and last year, Renée Zellweger took home the Best Actress Oscar for playing Judy Garland in a biopic. Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom is a strong contender for a few Oscars in a couple of weeks, we’re getting a film about Aretha Franklin later this year, and dramas about Elvis Presley, Bob Marley, and Peggy Lee — among others — are all in the works.

But 20 years ago today, before the world was clamoring for biopics, musicals, and films about musicians, a wild satire based on a comic book from the ’60s and cartoon series from the ’70s was released in theaters, and it failed, both critically and commercially.

That film was Josie and the Pussycats, and despite its 53% Tomatometer score and its box office failures, it’s one that deserves to be celebrated.

So put on your cat ear headphones and stick a DuJour CD in your Discman, because in honor of the 20th anniversary of Josie and the Pussycats, we’re breaking down the reasons why it should be recognized as one of the most iconic music films of the 21st century.

It’s a Time Capsule That Gets Better with Age

Remember a time before digital music and streaming services? A time when you had to watch MTV to see your favorite artists? A time when AOL was one of the biggest brands in the world? That’s the time of Josie and the Pussycats.

If ever there was a movie that screamed early-2000s, it’s this one. Boy bands, rampant consumerism, TRL, Breckin Meyer — you really get everything you could want out of a Y2K-era satire of pop culture, and despite being so quintessentially of its time, the film only gets better with age.

For one thing, Josie and the Pussycats is aggressively overt with its product placement — even Mac and Me is tame by comparison — but unlike most other films, its corporate promotion is more world building than brand endorsement. A few years ago, writer-director Deborah Kaplan stated, “We didn’t take a dime from any of those people… They had to be in on the joke and let us use their logos.” Which, looking back, is hilarious, especially when you now spy an ad for Nokia cellphones, a reference to MovieFone, or a wall of AOL logos.

The same goes for seeing the computer screen of a live-streamed Pussycats concert, a line of fans waiting to buy the hottest CD, or Total Request Live and its host Carson Daly, who at the time was the real-life boyfriend of Tara Reid, who plays Melody in the film (isn’t that just the most late-’90s thing ever?).

As more and more of these companies, characters, and cultural touchstones fall by the wayside, the satire of Josie and the Pussycats only gets sharper.

The Record Industry Satire Is Spot On

We all know how most music films work; there’s an artist or a band who does a small gig/has a hit song/sings Edith Piaf in a bar, they get noticed by someone important, and soon enough, due to their incredible talent, they’re at the top of the charts playing sold-out shows. But one major aspect of the music industry that rarely gets any play is the antagonistic record labels who exploit artists’ talents.

In Josie and the Pussycats, MegaRecords executive Wyatt Frame (played by Alan Cumming) first stumbles across the struggling band when he nearly hits them with his car. When he notices that Josie (Rachael Leigh Cook) and the Pussycats (Rosario Dawson’s Valerie and Tara Reid’s Melody) have the look and sound of a hit band, he makes them an irresistible offer, flies them from Riverdale to the big city, nurtures them, and introduces them to the harmless world of music superstardom, leading to a long and lucrative partnership that benefits everyone.

Except that’s not what happens at all, because Josie and the Pussycats isn’t just a simple, inspirational tale about overcoming obstacles with talent and perseverance, it’s a critique of the way the musical industrial complex manufactures stars, uses them to promote fashion/toys/products/the military/etc., and then spits them back out when they’ve found the next band du jour.

MegaRecords CEO Fiona, played by Parker Posey, aims to accomplish this by brainwashing the band’s fans through subliminal messages hidden in their recordings. What better way to manipulate listeners into loving Matt Damon and wearing orange sweaters? Of course, it’s also pretty helpful in making Josie and the Pussycats an overnight sensation or, you know, attempting to break them up so Josie can fly solo and become a pop idol whose music will, in turn, be used to create a generation of mindless consumers.

We all know how vile “the industry” can be, and while Josie and the Pussycats is admittedly a little silly and over-the-top, there’s a lot of truth hidden behind the excess, and the record execs played by Cumming and Posey aren’t so many shades darker than their real-life counterparts.

The Music Is Outstanding

The one thing a music movie has to have is killer music, and Josie and the Pussycats has that in spades.

With tracks written by 12-time Grammy winner Babyface, the late, great, EGOT-nominated cinematic earworm maestro Adam Schlesinger, Jane Wiedlin of the Go-Go’s, and Adam Duritz of Counting Crows, just to name a few, and produced by Babyface and Schlesinger with vocals performed by Kay Hanley of Letters to Cleo, this film and its soundtrack album are filled with bangers.

Distinctly early-2000s bangers, sure, but bangers nonetheless.

From the first power chords and hits of the hi-hat on the soundtrack album’s opening song, “3 Small Words,” the music bursts with a professionalism far beyond what you might expect. But the subsequent lyrics “I’m a punk rock prom queen” shock you back into remembering that this is actually a song from Josie and the Pussycats. This song and “You’re a Star” evoke pop punk princess Avril Lavigne a full year before her first album and subsequent stardom, and the power chord-laden “Shapeshifter” would fit great on any Good Charlotte album.

At the same time, this film is perfectly situated in the zenith of the Backstreet Boys/NSYNC era, and the film’s ill-fated boy band, DuJour, hits all those same notes just as hard in “DuJour Around the World” and “Backdoor Lover,” with the latter being deployed in the film with an over-the-top but also completely spot-on music video.

Despite being a send-up of the music industry, the songs are so incredibly earnest and the musicianship is so well done that the music stands on it own.

People noticed, too. Despite the film’s disappointing box office run, the soundtrack album went certified Gold and hit the Top 20 on the U.S. Billboard chart. In the subsequent years, there have been multiple vinyl re-releases of the soundtrack, including one that dropped behind a 2017 show that had more fans than were at the film’s climactic concert, proving people are still clamoring for Pussycats songs 20 years later.

If you ask me, “Pretend to be Nice” ranks right up there with the best movie songs from the past 20 years, and that includes “Lose Yourself,” “Let It Go,” and “Shallow.”

It Paved the Way for the “Archie-Verse”

Riverdale Cast

(Photo by Art Streiber/The CW)

In 2001, nobody really cared what drama was happening in Riverdale or which witches were living in Greendale, but now the Archie Comics extended universe, as it were, is a cultural phenomenon. And it became one because these shows follow a template set by Josie and the Pussycats.

With its PG-13 content and tongue-in-cheek approach to the original content, this film is a stark departure from the family-friendly Melissa Joan Hart-led Sabrina the Teenage Witch sitcom and the Scooby-Doo knockoff cartoon series. Josie and the Pussycats instead lives in a world of its own, a hyper-realized pastiche of pop culture, comic book visuals, satire, throwback allusions, and darker-than-expected drama that somehow works.

Though it draws inspiration from the old comic book series of the same name, it has been dragged into the 21st century and thrust into a dramatic new contemporary world complete with all the problems that tweens, teens, and young people face these days.

Now, you’ll find a similar sensibility in current hit Archie Comics shows like Riverdale and Chilling Adventures of Sabrina that serve as spiritual and narrative successors to Josie and the Pussycats. With Riverdale renewed for at least two more seasons and another spin-off in development, Archie Comics won’t be going anyway any time soon, and Josie and the Pussycats was the catalyst for it all.

Josie and the Pussycats was released in theaters on April 11, 2001.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Best and Worst CNN festivals Amazon Studios Spring TV Martial Arts Mudbound Universal Action WGN stand-up comedy Musical strong female leads FX casting blaxploitation LGBTQ breaking bad Shondaland theme song reviews Biopics dogs critics BBC America Lifetime vampires Quiz OneApp all-time dc asian-american Rom-Com jurassic park high school new star wars movies TCA Awards movies discovery Election criterion DC Comics 2021 Bravo space Super Bowl based on movie BET Awards SundanceTV DGA indie Amazon Prime cancelled cults Western doctor who IFC Films Legendary ghosts revenge docudrama First Look USA transformers Superheroe The Walt Disney Company diversity Winners Masterpiece finale VICE south america 4/20 child's play green book james bond stop motion Calendar NYCC parents Writers Guild of America TV Cannes teaser Turner hidden camera zero dark thirty composers pirates of the caribbean 2015 Reality Competition psychological thriller travel Heroines TV Land HBO Go sitcom screenings Arrowverse series social media Schedule werewolf binge renewed TV shows VH1 streaming Vudu directors cartoon spy thriller Extras award winner X-Men Black Mirror Turner Classic Movies Mindy Kaling Superheroes biography VOD Box Office Endgame movie dark Marathons serial killer dragons ABC Family reboot nbcuniversal die hard Amazon YA rt archives ITV talk show Musicals El Rey anthology crossover Trivia indiana jones sports Paramount Plus Walt Disney Pictures DC Universe Apple TV Plus docuseries Pet Sematary TIFF CW Seed superman Academy Awards Rocky hispanic Starz Acorn TV Discovery Channel Tumblr ratings HBO Winter TV Watching Series technology natural history Emmy Nominations Britbox WarnerMedia stoner romance television Dark Horse Comics kaiju emmy awards kong Netflix satire Marvel Television mutant canceled Comedy toronto San Diego Comic-Con Freeform Interview Lucasfilm dceu New York Comic Con telelvision Funimation Drama Spike halloween tv archives Podcast TBS 2020 latino Logo Sundance Now rotten movies we love Hear Us Out tv talk Exclusive Video witnail game show screen actors guild football Nominations Nat Geo Travel Channel BBC One Anna Paquin chucky Toys classics concert Apple TV+ The Purge DirecTV zombie news remakes Columbia Pictures comics cars YouTube MCU Adult Swim Comics on TV crime drama fast and furious boxoffice History TLC batman foreign justice league Syfy free movies japanese Awards Creative Arts Emmys MSNBC comic books halloween rom-coms Cartoon Network italian Disney Plus cancelled television Shudder kids Photos 45 Rocketman elevated horror Infographic cats YouTube Red TCA Certified Fresh Pride Month adventure period drama USA Network comiccon Christmas hollywood Star Wars Warner Bros. Pop blockbusters FXX Black History Month Polls and Games Apple 71st Emmy Awards Mystery spanish language golden globes cancelled TV series scary movies IFC romantic comedy Hallmark Esquire ABC Signature blockbuster Sundance TV festival king kong true crime Nickelodeon Elton John cancelled TV shows Pirates MTV video cinemax australia Set visit crime thriller Rock National Geographic obituary politics name the review spain Oscars Fox News Ghostbusters AMC Hulu 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards worst Horror Opinion richard e. Grant Fantasy Emmys Marvel Studios canceled TV shows Brie Larson medical drama christmas movies NBC Valentine's Day TCA Winter 2020 facebook BET Lifetime Christmas movies Television Critics Association slashers Holidays RT History Pop TV Tomatazos heist movie First Reviews 99% laika Disney+ Disney Plus sequel Mary Tyler Moore 2019 Ovation 93rd Oscars quibi Classic Film OWN Thanksgiving independent Epix 2018 what to watch CBS All Access Paramount Network Country President nature Marvel comedies Alien Spectrum Originals fresh nfl APB robots hist Music jamie lee curtis cooking animated superhero a nightmare on elm street documentary DC streaming service children's TV Red Carpet PlayStation Ellie Kemper GLAAD Disney science fiction Sundance joker sag awards mockumentary Grammys TV renewals Chernobyl Character Guide psycho Crunchyroll The Academy TNT GIFs Teen Holiday sequels ABC SDCC disaster aliens TCM Stephen King supernatural Paramount 21st Century Fox anime Trophy Talk Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt FX on Hulu Star Trek miniseries golden globe awards black Netflix Christmas movies The Witch The CW prank HBO Max Broadway dramedy Cosplay Comedy Central Women's History Month spanish versus zombies Video Games Family Tarantino TV One GoT comic twilight The Arrangement SXSW See It Skip It video on demand adaptation LGBT saw Film Festival Captain marvel E3 Baby Yoda PaleyFest TCA 2017 toy story Fall TV best venice Year in Review A&E mission: impossible thriller Amazon Prime Video CBS Kids & Family Mary Poppins Returns Chilling Adventures of Sabrina unscripted 20th Century Fox A24 BBC Trailer universal monsters 2016 Reality crime Summer godzilla french spider-man films 007 BAFTA spinoff Animation 24 frames franchise YouTube Premium Comic Book historical drama 2017 documentaries cops E! PBS RT21 Crackle 72 Emmy Awards Premiere Dates monster movies worst movies Pixar Fox Searchlight Binge Guide ViacomCBS Mary poppins TruTV Song of Ice and Fire Disney streaming service deadpool Avengers rotten Awards Tour American Society of Cinematographers popular Television Academy Film war Peacock Countdown police drama Tubi women ID game of thrones political drama Lionsgate scorecard Sony Pictures Sci-Fi Sneak Peek CMT Disney Channel FOX boxing Showtime ESPN book singing competition The Walking Dead Food Network razzies trailers harry potter book adaptation Hallmark Christmas movies