Hear Us Out

Hear Us Out: 30 Years Later, Misery Is Still the Most Terrifying Treatise on Toxic Fandom

Kathy Bates' Annie Wilkes represented the worst-case outcome of problematic entitlement years before the internet gave it unprecedented power.

by | November 30, 2020 | Comments

Compared to other genres, comedies and horror films are at greater risk of losing their efficacy as they age. No matter how The Exorcist may have terrified audiences upon its release, there’s a good chance someone watching it for the first time in 2020 won’t be fazed by it, either because they’ve become desensitized or because the subject matter is effectively passé at this point.

One film that has avoided that fate is Rob Reiner’s adaptation of Stephen King’s Misery, precisely because it has only become more relevant since it debuted in theaters on November 30, 1990. The harrowing tale of a deranged superfan who kidnaps her favorite author not only anticipates the rise of toxic fandom, but also hints at the kind of dangerous direct access that contemporary social media affords the general public. It’s also just a damn good movie. To celebrate its 30th anniversary, we explore how the Hitchcockian thriller predicted the fraught relationship between the content creators of today and their sometimes problematic fans. Keep those cockadoodie sledgehammers handy.

“When you first came here, I only loved the writer part of Paul Sheldon.”

When we first meet Annie Wilkes (played b Kathy Bates, who won an Oscar for her performance), she’s polite, sweet, and, dare we say it, likable. Sure, she has difficulty with boundaries, but she seems harmless enough and genuine in her love for the work of writer Paul Sheldon (James Caan). Having rescued Paul from a bad car accident during a snowstorm, she’s initially surprised to discover he’s different from what she expected, based on how his book covers described him, but she makes the most of her private audience with him to air her grievances.

This disconnect between a celebrity’s public persona and private self is an all-too-common discovery in the age of social media. These days, every public entity, from pop stars and athletes to fast food companies and, ahem, movie review websites, maintains such a meticulously curated presence online – their “brand” – that breaches of protocol, even deeply human ones, risk massive controversy. Even still, it’s never been easier to contact your favorite actor, comedian, or, yes, writer; all it takes now is a Tweet, and if you’re lucky, you might get a response. This unprecedented access can lead to fun, insightful interactions, but it can just as easily breed unfettered hostility – there may not be anyone strapped to a bed, but this is about as direct as hate mail can get, and it can be pretty nasty.

“I’m your number one fan. There is nothing to worry about.”

The thing that differentiates Annie Wilkes from most other movie stalkers is that her violence and sense of entitlement are born of artistic admiration, rather than sexual attraction or murderous intent. She is dangerously unwell, of course, but her sickness manifests in a twisted devotion to Paul’s popular, Harlequin-esque series romance novels starring a character named Misery Chastain.

Our first indication that she’s more than just an obsessive fan comes when she convinces Paul to let her read a draft of his latest book, an attempt to branch out from romance. To say Annie disapproves of the profanity is a gross understatement; as Paul calmly explains that it’s based on his own experiences, she lashes out in a bizarre tirade before she catches herself, but by then it’s clear something is amiss.

Later, when Annie picks up a copy of the latest Misery book and discovers the character dies, she snaps and calls Paul a murderer. The dynamic changes as she ceases to be a caretaker and instead becomes Paul’s captor. She grows more violent, but she rationalizes her behavior as a byproduct of her love for Paul and the books. She kisses his cheek, apologizes, and asks him to forget anything bad has happened. When she finally admits that she’s kidnapped him, she blames Paul for everything; clearly he brought it all upon himself.

Three decades later, we’ve seen a rise in fan culture taken to dangerous extremes, with cries of ruined childhoods and death threats forcing some to leave social media altogether. Like Annie, the gaslighting comes from a place of distorted love, the kind that compels her to “hobble” Paul with a sledgehammer when he dares to seek escape from his captivity. He has committed a grievous crime in the eyes of his “number one fan,” and he is obligated to fix it at any cost.

“You’re gonna write a new novel… Now you’ll make it right.”

In Annie’s mind, there is only one way for Paul to atone for killing Misery Chastain: Bring her back to life in a new book, and do it in a fashion that satisfies Annie. She knows exactly what story she wants to read, but she needs Paul to write it. Naturally, the first pages he delivers aren’t to her liking, because she remembers the novels better than anyone – possibly even better than Paul himself – and according to her, the new direction flies in the face of continuity, and she won’t stand for it. Her expectations are more important than the right story being told, so she throws another hysterical tantrum, and an exasperated Paul is back to square one.

In real life, this admittedly isn’t a new phenomenon. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, for example, was compelled by publishers and fans to revive Sherlock Holmes over a decade after he wrote the character’s death. Nowadays, though, it’s exceedingly common to see people feel so entitled to a piece of media that they would presume to dictate how it should be done.

It’s natural for fans to feel a connection to their favorite characters, and it’s frequently said that a creator’s work no longer belongs to them once it’s presented to the public. But it’s another thing to send death threats to Rian Johnson for his handling of Star Wars: The Last Jedi – whatever one’s opinions on the film are – and even campaign to remake the film. Just a year later, Game of Thrones viewers were so incensed at the series’ final season that they petitioned HBO to spend millions of dollars to remake it as well. After a massive fan outcry, Paramount Pictures literally went back to the drawing board and redesigned the title character in Sonic the Hedgehog, effectively delaying the release of the film by four months. Next September, HBO Max will premiere Zack Snyder’s Justice League, a recut, partially reshot, serialized version of the 2017 DC superhero film closer to the director’s vision, thanks in large part to another fan petition after the original production suffered multiple setbacks and a poor reception. This is, in other words, not a trend on the downswing.

“I put two bullets in my gun. One for you and one for me.”

Stephen King originally intended to call the book “The Annie Wilkes Edition,” which gets to the heart of the story and helps explain why it’s still relevant. Annie clearly adores Misery Chastain – she even named her pet pig after her – and she just wants to do right by the character, but it’s telling that she has no plans to publish Paul’s corrective novel after he finishes it. When she realizes that the police are onto her, she plans to shoot Paul and then herself as soon as the book is ready. Paul isn’t the object of her affection; he’s merely the delivery mechanism for her personal fan fiction. Misery belongs to Annie and no one else, and Paul only matters as long as he gives Annie exactly what she wants.

This doesn’t feel too dissimilar from some of the outrage over 2016’s Ghostbusters for going with a female cast (“This isn’t my Ghostbusters“) or the backlash over the diversification of the Star Wars sequel trilogy’s cast. Behind the bigotry seems to lie a fear that these franchises will somehow actively work to exclude the people complaining about it. They are the original fans, they might say, and they won’t stand to have their memories desecrated. There are certainly other legitimate criticisms to be leveled at those films (and the final season of Game of Thrones, and Justice League), but the folks making those criticisms aren’t the ones we’re talking about. Imagine all the Misery Chastain fans in Paul Sheldon’s world who were upset with the character’s death but, you know, didn’t kidnap him, torture him, and force him to write another book.

Misery not only became a commercial and critical success, but also the only film in the prolific world of Stephen King adaptations to win an Academy Award. But beneath the fake smiles and that horrifying sledgehammer scene lies a deeper, more prescient indication of how terrifying it would be if an Annie Wilkes – much an army of Annie Wilkses – were to rise up every time a Misery Chastain meets her end.

Misery was released in theaters on November 30, 1990.

Thumbnail image by (c)Columbia Pictures

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Food Network based on movie teaser thriller E3 kaiju heist movie stoner Awards rom-coms TNT adaptation 4/20 Year in Review richard e. Grant Tubi dceu Premiere Dates new star wars movies Exclusive Video MTV E! hist Rocky parents Infographic Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Marvel BBC period drama cancelled television Showtime RT History romance YouTube Super Bowl MCU mutant classics free movies Classic Film what to watch sequels Star Wars WarnerMedia talk show ABC Family Podcast Lifetime Mary poppins hispanic TIFF ABC Signature toronto child's play Video Games CBS All Access Captain marvel TCA Awards DC Universe black Apple TV+ suspense Mary Poppins Returns know your critic NBC supernatural TCA south america screenings dramedy Comedy Amazon Prime Video king kong worst movies BBC One historical drama 2021 ViacomCBS YouTube Premium sports adventure Fantasy worst PBS Elton John Polls and Games Schedule 21st Century Fox Apple TV Plus YouTube Red werewolf GLAAD basketball lord of the rings new york Reality TLC golden globes psycho Warner Bros. GIFs vampires Vudu miniseries name the review Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Election theme song The CW Paramount anime italian movie finale 2016 Rocketman Acorn TV cults The Witch 20th Century Fox TCA 2017 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards japan Universal Pride Month streaming binge The Academy comic book movies robots BET dark chucky Trivia technology social media Television Academy Holidays New York Comic Con cars stop motion posters remakes dexter hollywood Mudbound 99% canceled Masterpiece Summer green book TBS Pop dc adenture renewed TV shows Chernobyl Grammys live action Musical Opinion National Geographic Sneak Peek Reality Competition spain Bravo Thanksgiving 73rd Emmy Awards Set visit Superheroes FOX CMT Cannes cartoon Certified Fresh christmas movies ESPN Shudder BBC America sitcom Funimation series mockumentary Apple game of thrones Starz Biopics Women's History Month 71st Emmy Awards golden globe awards NYCC space international Avengers The Walt Disney Company Awards Tour politics Family slashers streaming movies Amazon Prime asian-american Crackle psychological thriller HBO Go cats TV renewals royal family boxing Hallmark Christmas movies breaking bad travel Ellie Kemper rt labs critics edition PlayStation rotten rt labs Mary Tyler Moore spanish language justice league comics GoT popular Rock indie football History crime thriller Turner Classic Movies AMC Arrowverse documentaries comedies ID films Cartoon Network gangster spy thriller Music new zealand superhero book zombie venice OneApp screen actors guild DirecTV Kids & Family Paramount Plus USA nfl Musicals science fiction Tarantino directors australia Superheroe HBO Max Film Festival marvel cinematic universe latino DGA indiana jones discovery war Comedy Central pirates of the caribbean laika Binge Guide Esquire Syfy Nat Geo Emmy Nominations Black History Month Tumblr cancelled Image Comics SundanceTV Winners boxoffice The Walking Dead A24 X-Men Logo Amazon Studios game show Disney+ Disney Plus diversity CBS See It Skip It Stephen King olympics batman TV One japanese Amazon superman Black Mirror elevated horror emmy awards 007 disaster Fall TV tv talk deadpool dogs VH1 romantic comedy blockbusters CW Seed Columbia Pictures 72 Emmy Awards 93rd Oscars SDCC rotten movies we love Legendary franchise Holiday stand-up comedy VICE mcc Box Office television Pixar fast and furious Pet Sematary LGBT fresh reviews 2017 debate 90s Adult Swim NBA monster movies Nickelodeon Discovery Channel cinemax cancelled TV series Cosplay Fox News FXX Endgame jamie lee curtis Comic Book DC Comics crime zero dark thirty Interview Emmys composers women El Rey telelvision 45 Song of Ice and Fire Shondaland 2019 TV movies true crime ghosts Extras ratings jurassic park Teen TCA Winter 2020 serial killer MSNBC Ghostbusters VOD reboot Writers Guild of America Ovation Sundance Now Hear Us Out blaxploitation police drama Television Critics Association spider-man aliens Netflix Christmas movies Animation witnail obituary Pirates scene in color canceled TV shows video on demand Countdown Disney 1990s crime drama ABC Crunchyroll SXSW Creative Arts Emmys Comics on TV Wes Anderson twilight young adult Marvel Studios USA Network Character Guide Watching Series anthology Spring TV Paramount Network sequel legend Country high school marvel comics award winner action-comedy children's TV Disney streaming service Winter TV The Arrangement Drama Freeform Photos all-time Rom-Com Toys slasher festivals joker San Diego Comic-Con documentary transformers Film Comic-Con@Home 2021 quibi halloween PaleyFest Western Lucasfilm Nominations Marathons hispanic heritage month Tokyo Olympics casting Fox Searchlight Martial Arts Sony Pictures dragons zombies die hard Mindy Kaling docuseries french YA universal monsters Best and Worst The Purge Christmas RT21 comic independent harry potter Red Carpet Britbox animated CNN TCM APB Walt Disney Pictures Turner comic books Mystery feel good godzilla kong Netflix Disney Plus Pacific Islander Spectrum Originals medical drama cooking facebook toy story Alien Spike singing competition OWN trailers hidden camera sag awards wonder woman nature WGN TruTV Sci-Fi biography foreign king arthur 2015 cancelled TV shows halloween tv Pop TV IFC Films Brie Larson a nightmare on elm street scorecard FX comic book movie First Look Lionsgate Tomatazos criterion saw Marvel Television archives Action BET Awards ITV cops blockbuster Sundance DC streaming service spinoff Dark Horse Comics Oscars Peacock news Quiz prank Sundance TV BAFTA Trophy Talk strong female leads revenge American Society of Cinematographers Hulu Disney Channel Hallmark razzies james bond 2020 Baby Yoda HBO satire crossover book adaptation critic resources A&E TV Land Broadway doctor who video Heroines target Lifetime Christmas movies critics LGBTQ rt archives aapi mission: impossible scary movies spanish 24 frames FX on Hulu unscripted First Reviews best festival Travel Channel Star Trek docudrama IFC 2018 comiccon versus concert Valentine's Day Trailer nbcuniversal movies President Calendar biopic TV Epix Academy Awards political drama kids Horror Anna Paquin natural history