Showdowns

Halloween H20 Vs. Halloween (2018)

The two big "Return of Laurie Strode" movies are considered the best sequels in the franchise, but which is better? We're breaking it down by Tomatometer, Audience Score, box office, storyline, and more.

by | October 31, 2020 | Comments

In one movie, a boozed-up and torn-down Laurie Strode must face the white-masked demon from her past and save her family; in the other, a boozed-up and… well, you get the gist. These two reboot/sequels, one released 20 years after the original Halloween and one released 40 years after, share a lot of the same DNA. But DNA is also the key difference: in Halloween H20: 20 Years Later, Laurie is related to Michael Myers; in 2018’s Halloween, that element of the plot has been slashed away and Laurie is simply the obsession, but not the sibling, of the Shape. Which movie did the whole reboot thing better? That’s what we’re deciding in the latest episode of Vs. Host and Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis is pitting H20 and H40 against each other across four rounds – Box Office, Tomatometer and Audience Score, Storyline, and one wildcard round – to decide which sequel deserves the Halloween franchise silver medal. (Because gold, of course, goes to The Curse of Michael Myers, right?). As ever, if you don’t agree with our call, feel free to stalk us slowly and quietly in the comments.


Thumbnail image: © Dimension Films, © Universal Pictures


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

films 24 frames APB Watching Series 007 Bravo Country GoT Box Office hispanic Black History Month obituary dark cancelled Writers Guild of America HBO Max streaming renewed TV shows Classic Film singing competition Funimation cults teaser PaleyFest Winners Cosplay Mystery dogs canceled TV shows 20th Century Fox Ovation franchise Travel Channel SundanceTV CBS All Access Turner Classic Movies a nightmare on elm street emmy awards Avengers crime thriller Lifetime toronto The Academy game of thrones Music IFC 21st Century Fox Hulu tv talk Winter TV President 2019 El Rey The Purge Red Carpet golden globes breaking bad TCA Winter 2020 VOD Cannes YouTube Red diversity X-Men kids sitcom Musicals festival Hallmark green book Shudder Teen Pet Sematary casting CBS First Look documentaries Hear Us Out Pride Month Film james bond Martial Arts spanish Fall TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt sequel disaster romantic comedy comics E! Election documentary Chilling Adventures of Sabrina natural history National Geographic supernatural transformers Mary poppins animated comiccon Fantasy Year in Review The Arrangement dragons Spring TV 71st Emmy Awards stand-up comedy independent TLC Cartoon Network 2015 psychological thriller cars Kids & Family DC streaming service Premiere Dates spinoff Schedule science fiction Pirates Nominations based on movie CNN Discovery Channel WGN stop motion sequels Disney Channel joker Character Guide SXSW DGA child's play FXX 2020 Trivia cancelled TV series biography Toys reviews New York Comic Con 4/20 talk show GIFs BBC America nbcuniversal Disney Plus E3 Epix Marathons Sony Pictures die hard quibi Reality boxoffice Summer 45 dc Superheroes Academy Awards Polls and Games politics romance Western Baby Yoda YouTube Certified Fresh Amazon Interview Disney+ Disney Plus black parents DC Comics adventure Black Mirror Trailer space YouTube Premium 2018 zero dark thirty rotten movies we love latino USA Network MTV Universal Mindy Kaling movie First Reviews robots ID dramedy Sundance Starz revenge canceled cancelled TV shows Television Academy Ellie Kemper criterion ESPN Infographic spain Columbia Pictures remakes BET Awards indiana jones Spectrum Originals miniseries Christmas IFC Films crime Sneak Peek comedies australia Apple Mary Tyler Moore Sci-Fi Super Bowl Pop TV OWN TNT ABC Family halloween scary movies ITV SDCC Tarantino Comedy Central jamie lee curtis LGBT Tomatazos serial killer composers RT21 psycho Oscars Star Trek The CW TCA screenings name the review Anna Paquin Opinion Comic Book crossover Film Festival spanish language Paramount Network BET fast and furious Nat Geo Dark Horse Comics anthology Britbox DirecTV rotten Tumblr VH1 scorecard 2016 toy story chucky foreign worst movies PlayStation Tubi christmas movies Extras festivals Endgame ABC Family mutant TCA Awards American Society of Cinematographers YA rt archives adaptation richard e. Grant versus Musical movies strong female leads VICE Sundance TV Mudbound Elton John Pixar worst NBC Valentine's Day finale Comics on TV San Diego Comic-Con facebook mockumentary true crime Mary Poppins Returns Warner Bros. WarnerMedia MSNBC children's TV social media Video Games sports zombie Arrowverse hist screen actors guild CW Seed Lionsgate superhero docudrama war french video Binge Guide award winner ghosts cartoon Women's History Month Shondaland Lucasfilm Drama Crunchyroll AMC 72 Emmy Awards See It Skip It HBO TruTV Apple TV Plus anime south america Holiday indie deadpool Television Critics Association TCA 2017 Logo TV Disney critics Star Wars Syfy Rocketman blockbuster all-time Captain marvel Acorn TV Best and Worst mission: impossible Fox News twilight Grammys LGBTQ FOX Turner theme song Stephen King Brie Larson zombies DC Universe Comedy Emmys BBC The Walking Dead cops unscripted werewolf Apple TV+ TV renewals Photos stoner Paramount Pop aliens BBC One cats 2017 television PBS vampires halloween tv Food Network Esquire Marvel Studios Netflix Christmas movies ratings Amazon Studios historical drama elevated horror Amazon Prime Video comic books A&E Trophy Talk Rock FX TCM venice political drama TBS Masterpiece NYCC book football Biopics best doctor who A24 GLAAD Superheroe period drama Rocky Netflix Countdown Showtime directors technology dceu TV Land CMT History Heroines video on demand Holidays medical drama nature Peacock spider-man Calendar Action comic blaxploitation Awards Tour FX on Hulu cancelled television Chernobyl Awards Podcast witnail satire police drama game show Spike Disney streaming service Marvel Fox Searchlight binge Lifetime Christmas movies USA Vudu universal monsters concert Crackle Reality Competition asian-american crime drama Rom-Com laika spy thriller Emmy Nominations Creative Arts Emmys Quiz MCU Walt Disney Pictures Nickelodeon archives Hallmark Christmas movies Amazon Prime nfl slashers OneApp what to watch BAFTA justice league Freeform harry potter The Witch HBO Go hollywood thriller classics series Horror Animation cooking free movies Song of Ice and Fire japanese Adult Swim Ghostbusters Sundance Now reboot discovery Marvel Television travel TIFF italian cinemax Thanksgiving batman sag awards news Set visit RT History