Showdowns

Halloween H20 Vs. Halloween (2018)

The two big "Return of Laurie Strode" movies are considered the best sequels in the franchise, but which is better? We're breaking it down by Tomatometer, Audience Score, box office, storyline, and more.

by | October 31, 2020 | Comments

In one movie, a boozed-up and torn-down Laurie Strode must face the white-masked demon from her past and save her family; in the other, a boozed-up and… well, you get the gist. These two reboot/sequels, one released 20 years after the original Halloween and one released 40 years after, share a lot of the same DNA. But DNA is also the key difference: in Halloween H20: 20 Years Later, Laurie is related to Michael Myers; in 2018’s Halloween, that element of the plot has been slashed away and Laurie is simply the obsession, but not the sibling, of the Shape. Which movie did the whole reboot thing better? That’s what we’re deciding in the latest episode of Vs. Host and Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis is pitting H20 and H40 against each other across four rounds – Box Office, Tomatometer and Audience Score, Storyline, and one wildcard round – to decide which sequel deserves the Halloween franchise silver medal. (Because gold, of course, goes to The Curse of Michael Myers, right?). As ever, if you don’t agree with our call, feel free to stalk us slowly and quietly in the comments.


Thumbnail image: © Dimension Films, © Universal Pictures


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

live action blockbusters batman ITV monster movies LGBT christmas movies Nickelodeon tv talk stand-up comedy rt labs critics edition debate Exclusive Video ViacomCBS rt labs summer preview news kids high school wonder woman biopic mcc TV movies docudrama Instagram Live OneApp Lionsgate Warner Bros. Hulu nfl Film Festival space TNT Lifetime Christmas movies romantic comedy 2021 venice fresh docuseries El Rey war prank Pirates IFC VH1 hidden camera hispanic comiccon mob 24 frames new zealand streaming movies FOX WGN E3 ABC Family Certified Fresh CBS All Access Pop TV police drama festival Animation kaiju Marvel Infographic Mary Poppins Returns Best Picture Emmys SundanceTV basketball Comedy Central Ghostbusters Pride Month movies dogs stoner die hard HFPA Heroines TV renewals Starz Anna Paquin Women's History Month A&E new york sports The Arrangement Bravo Apple TV+ CNN asian-american halloween tv book adaptation Oscars Discovery Channel medical drama Nominations transformers Best and Worst The Walking Dead CMT adaptation Star Wars 73rd Emmy Awards Disney+ Disney Plus what to watch Schedule Columbia Pictures zombies gangster Fall TV travel screenings kong 93rd Oscars latino know your critic 2018 Pop richard e. Grant Tumblr directors Apple TV Plus 20th Century Fox Crackle Marvel Studios CW Seed Endgame comic book movies football National Geographic Mary poppins Neflix Character Guide justice league thriller witnail Legendary spy thriller popular Calendar australia VICE Best Director The CW Watching Series slashers Polls and Games 45 spanish language Academy Awards Year in Review Rom-Com boxoffice Hallmark Christmas movies dragons Binge Guide cooking Mindy Kaling E! Travel Channel Set visit X-Men President south america TCA Winter 2020 godzilla cinemax Esquire Grammys politics SXSW 2022 RT History IFC Films parents OWN YouTube comic golden globes cars dceu trophy Brie Larson new star wars movies mission: impossible live event psychological thriller Apple Family period drama AMC MTV Reality GIFs NBC dc Prime Video Thanksgiving AMC Plus RT21 crime stop motion Chilling Adventures of Sabrina A24 Funimation Reality Competition Mystery HBO Go documentaries Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt lord of the rings summer TV preview comics 007 indie festivals Summer Ellie Kemper Amazon Studios marvel comics 2019 MGM Paramount cancelled scene in color Captain marvel teaser Focus Features nature deadpool critic resources robots Alien DC streaming service Disney streaming service Universal comic books Trophy Talk Podcast The Academy Sundance rotten movies we love Red Carpet 71st Emmy Awards spain a nightmare on elm street 1990s boxing BET Awards critics satire versus Elton John free movies facebook Awards Tour scary movies marvel cinematic universe Extras ABC Signature composers Musicals supernatural heist movie legend scorecard Pixar Adult Swim werewolf obi wan Election Tags: Comedy Photos child's play natural history broadcast FXX YouTube Red comedies Holiday Writers Guild of America toy story renewed TV shows adenture Acorn TV Chernobyl archives spanish game show disaster BBC One WarnerMedia Countdown APB superhero twilight American Society of Cinematographers obituary Sneak Peek streamig name the review Image Comics black 72 Emmy Awards cancelled TV shows mockumentary 90s strong female leads jamie lee curtis Drama Comedy GoT 2016 Sony Pictures Spike Syfy cancelled television Mary Tyler Moore Paramount Pictures Wes Anderson rom-coms BBC America TCM DGA worst Turner Classic Movies SDCC Comics on TV Television Academy First Reviews crime drama Ovation cops historical drama DirecTV canceled Hallmark halloween sequels royal family razzies Amazon Prime DC Universe Baby Yoda Tokyo Olympics Superheroes Kids & Family Sundance TV true crime series pirates of the caribbean singing competition concert GLAAD Valentine's Day sag awards Super Bowl suspense sopranos BAFTA Paramount Plus crime thriller posters Crunchyroll PaleyFest saw cartoon hispanic heritage month Country breaking bad Black History Month TV french summer TV Stephen King The Purge zero dark thirty technology toronto Interview LGBTQ remakes Shondaland vs. Disney Channel political drama art house game of thrones dreamworks Star Trek screen actors guild Cartoon Network Hear Us Out science fiction BBC NYCC fast and furious binge Broadway slasher black comedy Creative Arts Emmys VOD feel good elevated horror unscripted Food Network Premiere Dates Mudbound serial killer TCA Awards social media Martial Arts Winners anthology Peacock Superheroe TBS telelvision quibi canceled TV shows Film PBS First Look movie ratings ESPN theme song ghosts comic book movie Dark Horse Comics Horror San Diego Comic-Con Spring TV 2020 franchise emmy awards Masterpiece Netflix action-comedy talk show South by Southwest Film Festival 99% Rocketman Vudu ID romance New York Comic Con Lifetime 4/20 TCA Comic Book Showtime 79th Golden Globes Awards jurassic park TruTV women ABC sequel Classic Film vampires Paramount Network Fox Searchlight scary zombie superman Amazon Holidays video on demand Oscar revenge TV Land Christmas SXSW anime CBS DC Comics Disney Plus green book dexter Music USA Network TLC History NBA hollywood Trailer 2017 chucky sitcom Sci-Fi Pet Sematary FX 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Fox News 94th Oscars Universal Pictures The Walt Disney Company adventure Sundance Now Turner rotten young adult Nat Geo Fantasy discovery king kong The Witch Hollywood Foreign Press Association cancelled TV series Song of Ice and Fire independent MCU YA Teen 2015 cats joker Winter TV Netflix Christmas movies Television Critics Association TV One book doctor who universal monsters Opinion diversity finale video japan miniseries Action Freeform italian Musical reviews television See It Skip It Awards hist HBO Toys IMDb TV best Box Office criterion harry potter rt archives USA Quiz Rocky reboot Comic-Con@Home 2021 Emmy Nominations Tubi Best Actor Epix psycho olympics Western YouTube Premium Arrowverse crossover Video Games spinoff japanese genre james bond casting Disney TIFF documentary nbcuniversal Marathons cults TCA 2017 foreign Logo Best Actress HBO Max spider-man worst movies aapi target animated Pacific Islander 21st Century Fox MSNBC laika leaderboard films PlayStation children's TV Trivia spider-verse based on movie Lucasfilm blaxploitation Amazon Prime Video Shudder dark blockbuster Spectrum Originals Avengers biography trailers Tarantino classics golden globe awards Black Mirror Walt Disney Pictures Fargo streaming dramedy all-time Britbox award winner king arthur Cannes BET aliens international indiana jones FX on Hulu Marvel Television Rock Tomatazos mutant Cosplay Biopics