Ghostbusters: Afterlife First Reviews: McKenna Grace Shines in a Worthy Sequel Fans Will Love

Early reviews for Jason Reitman's addition to the franchise say it's heartfelt, packed with nostalgic Easter eggs, and led by a star-making performance from its young lead.

by | October 9, 2021 | Comments

Fans of the Ghostbusters franchise have been waiting for decades for another true sequel to the 1984 paranormal comedy and its 1989 follow-up. Regardless of whether you enjoyed the 2016 reboot, Ghostbusters: Afterlife has a lot to live up to. Fortunately, the first reviews of the new movie agree that the devoted fanbase will be pleased, and they’ll find a young new star to follow into more installments. There are some disagreements on just how much Afterlife works as both a sequel and as a movie overall, but it seems you don’t need to be afraid of this effort.

Here’s what critics are saying about Ghostbusters: Afterlife:

Is this the Ghostbusters sequel fans have been waiting for?

Ghostbusters: Afterlife emerges as a wildly successful next installment… An utter joy to take in.” – Joey Magidson, Awards Radar

“This new spin gets it soooooo right… A warm, funny, exciting, nostalgic, emotional, and altogether winning return to the pure joy of that 1984 classic.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline

“In terms of being a Ghostbusters movie, what Jason Reitman and Gil Kenan achieved with this film is incredible. This is the Ghostbusters sequel that I have been waiting my entire life to see.” – Scott Menzel, We Live Entertainment

“Make no mistake, this is a Ghostbusters movie through and through.” – Rosie Knight, IGN Movies

“It’s not quite the same as the Ghostbusters we know, but it entirely feels like Ghostbusters.” – Olly Richards, Empire Magazine

“The good news for Ghostbusters fans is that Afterlife does nothing to tarnish what has come before.” – Peter Debruge, Variety

“When it’s good, it’s very good.” – Germain Lussier,

“One of the best sequels in recent memory.” – Marya E. Gates, Nerdist

“One of the best movies of the year.” – Kaitlyn Booth, Bleeding Cool

Paul Rudd in Ghostbusters: Afterlife

(Photo by Colulmbia Pictures)

Is there a lot of fan service?

“There are enough Easter eggs to make a grown man cry.” – Rosie Knight, IGN Movies

“Yes, there are fan service moments in the movie, but how these moments are handled makes them stand out even more.” – Scott Menzel, We Live Entertainment

“Reitman’s biggest swings are sure to create divisive and heated conversations amongst fans of all generations.” – Sean O’Connell, CinemaBlend

“The weakest parts of the film really are when it leans a little too hard into fan service, with too heavy a knowing wink.” – Marya E. Gates, Nerdist

“You go from caring about these characters to being distracted by all of the references, and that’s a real shame.” – Germain Lussier,

Does it bring anything new to the franchise?

“Very new in all the right ways.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline

Ghostbusters: Afterlife is a more grandiloquent approach than the original flick… It mostly works because of how winning the new elements are.” – David Crow, Den of Geek

“It’s rich with affection for its source but excited about new ways to play with it.’” – Olly Richards, Empire Magazine

“Plenty here is shiny and new… It shines brightest when Reitman finds new ways to spin these callbacks, rather than just repeat them.’” – Marya E. Gates, Nerdist

“It’s endearing to see [all the] props back in play, and refreshing to see how Reitman uses them in drastically different fashion than his father did.’” – Sean O’Connell, CinemaBlend

Afterlife succeeds precisely by not messing with the formula… This is a movie that feels like a product of the ’80s in a good way.’” – Jane Crowther, Total Film

“The story these characters are sucked into is so directly tied to the original… Ghostbusters: Afterlife feels like a film scared to be its own thing.’” – Germain Lussier,

Ghostbusters: Afterlife poster

(Photo by Columbia Pictures)

What if you’ve never seen Ghostbusters?

“You can go into this movie without seeing any of the previous movies, and you’ll like it just as much as a fan will.” – Kaitlyn Booth, Bleeding Cool

“It manages to balance that fine — and financially lucrative — line between pleasing fans of the original and creating something accessible for new audiences.” – Rosie Knight, IGN Movies

“This film will open the doors to those who may not have seen the original. I can see this film becoming a massive hit and generating a fan base.” – Scott Menzel, We Live Entertainment

“It’s hard to imagine Ghostbusters: Afterlife minting a new generation of fans.” – Christian Holub, Entertainment Weekly

Does it have broad appeal?

“There is plenty here for everyone to like. This is a movie that is going to be enjoyed by the kids in the theaters just as much as the adults.” – Kaitlyn Booth, Bleeding Cool

“More akin to bygone family-focused adventure films like Honey I Shrunk The Kids than the first two films, there’s plenty here for viewers of all ages.” – Marya E. Gates, Nerdist

“One of those rare movies that’s a genuine four-quadrant treat… A film that will entertain adults as much as kids, fans and much as newbies.” – Jane Crowther, Total Film

Is it funny?

“The jokes are very funny.” – Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post

“[It] retains the other key aspect of the original formula: the deadpan drollery and sharp timing… Afterlife’s engaging cast has the comic beats down.” – Sheri Linden, Hollywood Reporter

“[It’s] sometimes amusing.” – Sean O’Connell, CinemaBlend

Logan Kim and McKenna Grace in Ghostbusters: Afterlife

(Photo by Columbia Pictures)

Does it have heart?

“Bring the tissues because you are going to need them.” – Scott Menzel, We Live Entertainment

“Jason Reitman, son of the original film’s director Ivan Reitman, injects a large helping of heart into the franchise.” – Marya E. Gates, Nerdist

“Certain moments, which I wouldn’t dare spoil, literally filled my heart to the brim…It’s the emotion of it all that works best, making a good flick great.” – Joey Magidson, Awards Radar

“The younger Reitman’s film resorts to extreme, and frankly questionable, measures to tug at the pre-existing fanbase’s heartstrings.” – William Bibbiani, The Wrap

“In its climactic sequence, the movie gives in to a more than a bit of self-congratulatory schmaltz — catnip for fans.” – Sheri Linden, Hollywood Reporter

How is the screenplay?

“Reitman and co-writer Gil Kenan have crafted a cheeky, witty, well-paced, and heartfelt script that constantly delights.” – Rosie Knight, IGN Movies

“The script as a whole doesn’t just respect the source material, but it also respects the characters and the audience.” – Kaitlyn Booth, Bleeding Cool

“There’s so much plot, character, and backstory stuffed in, a few crucial connections get frustratingly pushed to the side or left way too vague.” – Germain Lussier,

“It takes nearly an hour (51 minutes, to be exact) for any ghosts to appear.” – Peter Debruge, Variety

What about the special effects?

“The special effects are again dynamite here.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline

“Special effects have advanced light-years since 1984, and yet Reitman (the younger) makes the respectable decision to stick to the look of the original film.” – Peter Debruge, Variety

“Those effects are certainly smoother this time around, even while keeping within the visual vernacular of the 1984 film.” – Sheri Linden, Hollywood Reporter

“The practical effects make the visuals in Ghostbusters: Afterlife far more like the films earlier in the franchise than most of today’s effects-heavy films.” – Marya E. Gates, Nerdist

McKenna Grace and Finn Wolfhard in Ghostbusters: Afterlife

(Photo by Columbia Pictures)

Are there any standouts in the cast?

“McKenna Grace as Phoebe walks away with pretty much the entire movie, which is really impressive considering the caliber of talent that we have here.” – Kaitlyn Booth, Bleeding Cool

“McKenna Grace is the kind of talent that only comes around once in a generation.” – Rosie Knight, IGN Movies

“Phoebe is by far the best thing about Ghostbusters: Afterlife. McKenna Grace… gives a truly revelatory, star-making performance here.” – Germain Lussier,

“Grace is just aces here…This is Grace’s show, and she really makes it a main event.” – Joey Magidson, Awards Radar

“You simply cannot look away from Grace when she is on screen. She’s funny and smart, but in a way that feels authentic and true.” – Marya E. Gates, Nerdist

“McKenna Grace gives the standout performance..if the franchise wanted to move forward with her in a leading role, I’d say we were in good hands.” – Sean O’Connell, CinemaBlend

What about the rest of the cast?

“Logan Kim as Podcast, Phoebe’s motormouth classmate who documents everything, is like a fun-size John Candy.” – Olly Richards, Empire Magazine

“Kim proves himself as a new comedic talent. His scenes with Grace are some of the best in the movie and deliver a few of its biggest laughs.” – Rosie Knight, IGN Movies

“[Paul Rudd] continues to prove himself a comedy MVP, earning half the movie’s big laughs.” – Peter Debruge, Variety

“[Carrie] Coon is wonderful as always.” – Marya E. Gates, Nerdist

“The excellent Carrie Coon is completely underused here.” – Germain Lussier,

Ghostbusters: Afterlife

(Photo by Columbia Pictures)

Does director Jason Reitman do his father proud?

“The real star here is Jason Reitman who, like Phoebe, rediscovers and reinvents his own family cinematic legacy.” – Pete Hammond, Deadline

“You can feel Reitman’s thrill in it, the enthusiasm of a man who has known Ghostbusters since he was six.” – Olly Richards, Empire Magazine

“Jason Reitman was literally born to make this movie… with all the love and affection of a fan, but with the moviemaking chops that have nearly won him an Academy Award.” – Joey Magidson, Awards Radar

“Reitman’s direction may be sharp and professional, but that’s only in the service of familiar material, so it falls to an excellent cast to make the most of a very repetitive situation.” – William Bibbiani, The Wrap

Will we want another Ghostbusters movie?

“When Ghostbusters: Afterlife ends, it leaves you wanting more.” – David Crow, Den of Geek

“The film does enough world-building that you leave hoping to see more from these characters in the future.” – Germain Lussier,

“If this serves as a launchpad for a new phase in the franchise, with such a dynamic lead as Phoebe at the helm, I’m willing to follow her anywhere.” – Marya E. Gates, Nerdist

“[Phoebe is] character I want to see busting ghosts in future installments.” – Joey Magidson, Awards Radar

“By the time the lights go up, one gets the distinct impression that all that really mattered was clearing the slate and setting this franchise up for future exploitation.” – William Bibbiani, The Wrap

Ghostbusters: Afterlife is in theaters on November 19, 2021.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

crossover 21st Century Fox Pride Month Epix Star Trek TV renewals Disney Plus scary Pet Sematary First Reviews live event ABC Signature movies Superheroes Showtime Watching Series LGBTQ rt labs MSNBC LGBT YA 73rd Emmy Awards quibi Freeform christmas movies lord of the rings Musical emmy awards Year in Review streaming classics Disney+ Disney Plus Comedy Central nfl Neflix Superheroe Turner king kong political drama Television Academy genre Red Carpet Fall TV romance joker facebook news Crackle independent Super Bowl Biopics Baby Yoda IFC USA Paramount Network james bond El Rey YouTube new star wars movies CBS free movies 93rd Oscars 24 frames AMC toy story nature DC Universe USA Network Pacific Islander Toys television Black Mirror Starz latino Disney streaming service Ghostbusters Amazon Prime theme song women CMT cartoon ratings Discovery Channel TCA politics The Walking Dead NYCC natural history TIFF Awards cars 20th Century Fox mission: impossible best Holiday cults superhero Stephen King sequels Family boxing diversity Marvel halloween dceu BAFTA Disney Channel CW Seed golden globes HBO werewolf San Diego Comic-Con critics Kids & Family Trophy Talk blockbusters DC Comics medical drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Legendary TCA Winter 2020 Brie Larson cancelled romantic comedy biography gangster jurassic park Academy Awards slasher sopranos RT21 DirecTV Amazon Studios teaser young adult foreign Warner Bros. live action satire Reality Nat Geo archives aapi canceled TV shows remakes Photos indiana jones American Society of Cinematographers true crime TV tv talk films fresh leaderboard Marvel Studios boxoffice dreamworks Certified Fresh marvel comics space Marathons Christmas The Academy Set visit trophy green book crime festivals documentary Comic-Con@Home 2021 Mary Tyler Moore deadpool OWN Valentine's Day Vudu BBC America monster movies Comic Book Sundance TV 2018 Netflix Christmas movies Calendar 72 Emmy Awards doctor who Podcast cinemax miniseries cancelled TV series AMC Plus technology The CW APB Box Office historical drama GoT YouTube Red TruTV Pixar kaiju TLC mcc Tarantino screenings Countdown black Logo Lucasfilm New York Comic Con A24 Fox News Schedule rom-coms target Animation Spectrum Originals Elton John Adult Swim festival zero dark thirty war The Arrangement E3 vs. popular unscripted Apple TV Plus Martial Arts Rocketman spy thriller Winners mockumentary cancelled television Ellie Kemper obituary venice south america Funimation Opinion Amazon Prime Video Music witnail justice league Sony Pictures Creative Arts Emmys renewed TV shows FXX Mary Poppins Returns GIFs award winner Instagram Live robots The Witch finale WGN universal monsters indie scary movies Video Games Paramount nbcuniversal parents rotten movies we love The Purge book adaptation reboot scorecard Character Guide Cartoon Network Sci-Fi WarnerMedia Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Tokyo Olympics new zealand Emmy Nominations heist movie Election Chernobyl Pop Netflix Trivia ABC sports HBO Max hispanic heritage month OneApp Ovation Black History Month Heroines DC streaming service VOD sag awards The Walt Disney Company BBC dc MCU zombie Reality Competition supernatural comic book movies stand-up comedy criterion YouTube Premium A&E Lionsgate wonder woman Television Critics Association dogs FX on Hulu SDCC anime sitcom crime thriller cops CNN X-Men Marvel Television Rocky Summer aliens Star Wars Shondaland NBC Broadway mob Acorn TV video docuseries GLAAD Apple President Hallmark ABC Family science fiction 1990s 99% canceled comic books 71st Emmy Awards 90s TV Land TV One Dark Horse Comics comic book movie rt archives Turner Classic Movies comics streaming movies international Action Universal spinoff french mutant 2020 Bravo Pirates Polls and Games strong female leads Fantasy Food Network posters ID cooking spider-verse transformers psycho Wes Anderson cancelled TV shows spanish language Cosplay Mystery TNT Paramount Plus DGA ITV CBS All Access Teen saw high school child's play batman disaster TCA Awards Columbia Pictures superman Hallmark Christmas movies directors IFC Films marvel cinematic universe Lifetime casting children's TV TCM chucky Mudbound talk show king arthur stop motion Best and Worst First Look Arrowverse PBS name the review Fox Searchlight Amazon police drama PlayStation what to watch MTV zombies Western Travel Channel HBO Go action-comedy die hard period drama Masterpiece kong new york toronto Grammys Universal Pictures 2021 blockbuster FOX adventure Drama royal family hidden camera dramedy Musicals rt labs critics edition serial killer art house all-time social media spanish Crunchyroll Spring TV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Nickelodeon animated Exclusive Video adenture olympics australia movie Trailer VH1 worst Comics on TV Anna Paquin NBA Writers Guild of America 2017 Hear Us Out Mary poppins asian-american TV movies screen actors guild golden globe awards video on demand Rock series Classic Film comic concert SundanceTV japan legend Sundance Now Premiere Dates vampires Alien TCA 2017 richard e. Grant BET Awards 2019 basketball worst movies crime drama Rom-Com Disney Cannes laika telelvision Binge Guide Tumblr TBS VICE BBC One singing competition prank History Country Hulu Esquire Thanksgiving SXSW Spike See It Skip It Avengers football comiccon Britbox hispanic Oscars razzies Quiz composers documentaries game of thrones Film Festival Tomatazos italian Infographic kids japanese Holidays biopic book 45 hollywood 4/20 Lifetime Christmas movies fast and furious Nominations Sundance slashers 2016 IMDb TV FX Syfy Fargo binge Women's History Month discovery Horror Film twilight Shudder stoner debate docudrama sequel godzilla Pop TV spain Image Comics Captain marvel Walt Disney Pictures revenge BET pirates of the caribbean elevated horror E! travel Interview Emmys Mindy Kaling comedies feel good spider-man Winter TV Awards Tour blaxploitation 007 Song of Ice and Fire Endgame jamie lee curtis Apple TV+ ViacomCBS ghosts Tubi suspense adaptation RT History rotten Peacock hist harry potter thriller franchise cats National Geographic ESPN know your critic a nightmare on elm street critic resources game show 2015 Comedy psychological thriller dexter Extras black comedy anthology trailers Sneak Peek dragons scene in color dark breaking bad versus halloween tv based on movie reviews PaleyFest