Game of Thrones Season 8, Episode 3 Reviews: Critics Shrug as Battle of Winterfell Underwhelms

A few "holy sh--" moments punctuated "The Long Night," but what did critics make of the episode overall?

by | April 29, 2019 | Comments

Given the immense anticipation leading up to episode 3 of HBO fantasy juggernaut Game of Thrones 89%, the assumption was that the battle against the Night King’s army at Winterfell in “The Long Night” would be unequivocally epic. But you know what they say about assumptions.

Critics and fans hung on for two relatively mellow first weeks of the final season. It was fine that the premiere, “Winterfell,” was mostly filled with character reunions and episode 2, “A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms,” favored sentimentality over conflict, because everything was building to the #BattleofWinterfell (though that hashtag had been seen before).

Alas, not everyone was blown away by the latest battle at the Stark ancestral home, as demonstrated by the episode’s unusually low (for the series, that is) Tomatometer score: 75% with 92 reviews so far (at 1:20 p.m. PT on April 30).

Game of Thrones season 8, episode 3 (HBO)
(Photo by HBO)

Some critics were pleasantly surprised by the episode’s unexpected twists, others were utterly disappointed and lamented the return to the pursuit of the Iron Throne. Many critics found the battle “brutal and emotionally exhausting” — but in a good way! But more than a mere few — 23% if you do the math — as well as some vocal fans on Twitter, found it less-than-thrilling at best, and a “betrayal” at worst.

“The Long Night” is the lowest-scoring of the season’s three episodes so far, and if it stays that low, it would be the second lowest-scoring Game of Thrones episode ever (it recently dropped below season 3’s “The Bear and the Maiden Fair“). To put that score into context, however, that’s still higher than popular recent box office superhero fare like Aquaman (2018) 66%.

Read on to find out what critics had to say about Season 8 Episode 3: "The Long Night" 73%.

Did “The Long Night” live up to your expectations? Tell us in the poll below.

How Did Everyone Fare in Battle?

Game of Thrones season 8, episode 3 (HBO)
(Photo by HBO)

Fighting an army of the dead is never easy, but Daenerys and Jon’s output was so pitiful here that I worry their alliance might not make it to the final conflict with Cersei. — David Sims, The Atlantic

After bridging the trenches, the wights started climbing the walls. So it was up to Gendry, Jaime, and the gang to fight them all off one by one — a project that was manifestly futile from the start. Still, it gave Brienne a chance to save Jaime’s life, so that was nice. — Michael Hogan, Vanity Fair

What was most striking to me was that while the men were busy having existential crises in the middle of a bloody battle (I’m looking at you Clegane), women were getting shit done. — Anne Cohen, Refinery29

Cersei is a winner because she knows, every time, that she can just hang back and let other people do her dirty work, then sip her wine and chuckle to herself about how everybody else did the dirty work for her. — Todd VanDerWerff, Vox

Read more: The 11 Biggest Moments from “The Long Night.”

Did the Action Live Up to Expectations?

Game of Thrones season 8, episode 3 (HBO)
(Photo by HBO)

The episode stands in as the ultimate representative of one of the ways “Game of Thrones” has seen itself, as the staging-ground for ultra-violent action whose stakes are the fate of the world. — Daniel D’Addario, Variety

Perhaps the hour’s been built up too much, or maybe events were too foreshadowed; we knew that mankind would prevail, if only because it’s got to fight amongst itself a bit more before Thrones’ six-episode season is through. — Clint Worthington, The Spool

It’s hardly a roller coaster ride, but that’s actually why this might be one of the better battle-focused episodes of “Game of Thrones” to date; it makes every moment of dread feel truly lived-in, lets each character beat scattered between the battles sink in. — Liz Shannon Miller, indieWire

“The Long Night” was unique in that it’s the one Game of Thrones episode I will never watch again, under any circumstance. I do not need to relive that. If television could give you PTSD, this would have done the job. — Shane Ryan, Paste Magazine

I’m satisfied, but my eyes need a rest. — Spencer Kornhaber, The Atlantic

What’s Everyone Complaining About?

Game of Thrones season 8, episode 3 (HBO)
(Photo by HBO)

I know the night is dark and full of terrors, but does that mean the episode has to be so literally dark? — Clint Worthington, The Spool

The long-gestating Battle for Winterfell is difficult to follow, occasionally even impossible to discern, and ends the most existential threat the series has built up over the course of its run with a “one good hit kills them all” solution that feels more than a little cheap. — Andrew Bloom, Consequence of Sound

The scenes were often so dark that it was impossible to see the action unless it happened to include fire (thanks a bunch, Drogon and Melisandre). The editing was sloppy at times, and it was hard to tell who was where and how they got there. And despite the high death count, most of our major characters still made it out alive, an illogical outcome considering the enemy. — Kelly Lawler, USA Today

 Arya’s Ascendance to Hero-Dom has Everyone Saying #NotToday.

Game of Thrones season 8, episode 3 (HBO)

What spectacle! The deus ex machina of Arya’s attack satisfied in both its culmination of a seasons-long build (her development into a master killer) and its tension-exploding suddenness. — Daniel D’Addario, Variety

At nearly the last possible moment of the longest Game of Thrones episode ever, she saved Bran and all humanity from the Night King in one of those moves that would certainly land her a slot in The Avengers if they were making any more Avengers movies. — Ellen Gray, Philadelphia Daily News

Read more: All Game of Thrones Episodes, Ranked by Tomatometer

Final Verdict?

Game of Thrones season 8, episode 3 (HBO)
(Photo by HBO)

So, in summation, the Battle of Winterfell dead include: Dolorous Edd, Lyanna Mormont, Jorah Mormont, Beric Dondarrion, Theon Grejoy, Melisandre, and the Night King. — Kimberly Roots, TV Line

Everything in “Game of Thrones” these past seven seasons led us to these cataclysmic 80 minutes, the sum total of all our fears and theories. A shrug wouldn’t do at all, but only a physical, convulsive reflex — our own yawp into the night, as if to say that TV at its wild, most ambitious best really can make dreams come true. Or nightmares. This one certainly did. — Verne Gay, Newsday

With three episodes remaining in its eighth and final season, “Game of Thrones” has defeated its most powerful and threatening villain, the Night King… It was as grand and almost as fatal as we all predicted, sure, but it also ended the White Walker threat forever with one tidy blow. — Kelly Lawler, USA Today

If you asked me whether “Game of Thrones” is a genuinely great show, after “The Long Night,” I’d have to answer: not today. — Alyssa Rosenberg, Washington Post

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

First Reviews Lifetime Christmas movies cancelled television DC streaming service golden globes Kids & Family finale disaster cartoon E3 screen actors guild blaxploitation renewed TV shows Syfy 007 dramedy travel Trophy Talk 2018 canceled TV shows Action hispanic Super Bowl 2020 Netflix Christmas movies cancelled TV shows Pet Sematary CW Seed mockumentary SDCC medical drama Quiz adaptation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Musical sequel Emmys cancelled comics Certified Fresh werewolf versus richard e. Grant cops Pop Calendar boxoffice game of thrones 71st Emmy Awards Comedy Central strong female leads TCA 2017 TNT NYCC hist Apple TV+ Emmy Nominations TV OWN Christmas true crime Freeform Lionsgate Disney Plus Baby Yoda A24 canceled RT History Crunchyroll Toys reboot ITV ESPN talk show Holidays Biopics Hallmark indie Mary Tyler Moore MTV Cosplay Drama Comics on TV HBO USA Network Women's History Month ghosts Shondaland Best and Worst cancelled TV series discovery Creative Arts Emmys FXX ABC Family supernatural TruTV Britbox NBC serial killer political drama crime thriller CBS All Access Rocketman Epix period drama 24 frames based on movie Spike The CW technology Paramount Network kids foreign Horror cars Photos Tumblr Superheroe Star Trek Character Guide Superheroes screenings quibi theme song GLAAD BET Sneak Peek Pride Month Avengers Oscars Amazon Prime Video FX Bravo revenge thriller Apple TV Plus batman Amazon Prime Musicals Music Crackle 2016 series San Diego Comic-Con nature animated Columbia Pictures zombie Rock anime Comic Book zombies biography spider-man Premiere Dates Star Wars Awards Year in Review Marvel Television Showtime El Rey Netflix Marathons Infographic Schedule PBS war President green book Mudbound New York Comic Con Disney Amazon Studios AMC Cannes Mary poppins LGBTQ YouTube Premium cinemax Television Academy television Film Teen Interview The Witch dc IFC Films TCM adventure YouTube RT21 2019 21st Century Fox Nominations transformers Film Festival E! Paramount BBC American Society of Cinematographers joker DirecTV movies Video Games unscripted Watching Series See It Skip It SXSW Dark Horse Comics singing competition sag awards Family ABC cults dogs Mindy Kaling spy thriller Nickelodeon psycho Marvel Studios USA Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The Purge composers VICE anthology TV renewals Arrowverse YouTube Red TLC diversity Black Mirror Spectrum Originals docudrama GoT WGN Song of Ice and Fire game show festivals spinoff Nat Geo CNN MSNBC miniseries 2015 toy story crime 20th Century Fox christmas movies The Arrangement Animation Reality Competition Turner Adult Swim Acorn TV police drama Elton John Mystery LGBT Disney streaming service Stephen King TV Land Sundance Now Set visit movie historical drama PaleyFest award winner tv talk teaser Holiday casting rotten movies we love Universal National Geographic Lucasfilm Discovery Channel Logo romantic comedy Sci-Fi Rocky independent documentary Ellie Kemper The Walking Dead Polls and Games OneApp spain Trailer Classic Film Grammys TBS Pirates free movies Pixar Warner Bros. science fiction Valentine's Day Binge Guide video BBC America FOX blockbuster First Look mutant Brie Larson Amazon robots zero dark thirty Sony Pictures GIFs IFC A&E Winter TV dragons elevated horror History streaming Ovation Chernobyl natural history Extras Tomatazos Box Office 2017 Writers Guild of America Heroines MCU facebook CMT Cartoon Network Food Network WarnerMedia latino vampires aliens Red Carpet Sundance Mary Poppins Returns psychological thriller Opinion what to watch space Election south america romance Turner Classic Movies spanish language Hulu Tubi Endgame Captain marvel X-Men directors Spring TV children's TV Western Marvel Sundance TV slashers crossover Tarantino Fantasy APB Martial Arts HBO Max ratings dceu Disney+ Disney Plus politics DC Universe name the review Countdown Academy Awards jamie lee curtis Ghostbusters sports Comedy TCA Winter 2020 crime drama Vudu cooking Apple comiccon TCA TIFF DC Comics CBS book DGA Peacock stand-up comedy Rom-Com Esquire Winners comic Shudder Disney Channel YA Starz Walt Disney Pictures Country 45 Fox News cats justice league halloween Lifetime binge SundanceTV Trivia sitcom witnail Podcast Reality Fall TV VH1 breaking bad harry potter Awards Tour Hallmark Christmas movies Anna Paquin Thanksgiving Summer Masterpiece doctor who social media