Further Reading: Celebrating the Brilliance of The King of Kong

Kim Newman reassesses the much-loved videogaming doc.

by | August 7, 2008 | Comments

Further Reading by Kim Newman

One documentary from the US last year spoke to avid videogamers more than any other, and in the process told a brilliantly human story about good, evil and Donkey Kong. In this week’s Further Reading, Kim Newman celebrates The King of Kong.

This is the most exciting, audience-involving film of any kind I’ve seen this year. At none of the previews of the summer’s blockbusters was I part of such a vocal, enthusiastic and wholly-gripped crowd as I was at a relatively small screening of a picture which has made its UK debut as a DVD retail item.

The King of Kong is an aptly ragged-looking documentary which takes a completely uninviting subject — a controversy in the world of retro-computer gaming about whether longtime Donkey Kong champion Billy Mitchell should cede his title to contender Steve Weibe — and makes it the stuff of legends. Donkey Kong, for those who don’t remember, is (or, rather, was) an early, fiendishly difficult game from the Super Mario Bros stable, in which the plumber tries to ascend various ladders to rescue a princess, while avoiding missiles tossed by a malign ape. From the DVD extras, I learned that the game was originally supposed to feature Popeye, Olive Oyl and Bluto, but the Japanese designers couldn’t get the rights to the characters and came up with their own.

The King of Kong

Billy Mitchell, hailed as ‘the gamer of the century’, is a reptilian, faux-cool smarm-bucket who invokes fanatical loyalty from longtime rivals and associates, including Brian Kuh (the third-highest DK scorer), who scuttles around with Renfield-like devotion to his master, and Walter Day, the bizarre Roberts Blossom lookalike who has taken on the mantle of definitive judge for the field (an accolade confirmed when he strikes an alliance with the Guinness Book of Records).

Though a patriot, a family man, a successful hot sauce tycoon and rated as ultra-cool by his circle, the goateed and distinctively coiffed Mitchell comes across onscreen as a classic villain. Even his closest friends call him devious, but he is also tragically puffed up in his idea of celebrity, flirting with the interviewer and referring to himself in the third person as if he were a world leader planning a counter-coup rather than a probable saddo whose highest achievement (a perfect Pac-Man score) means less and less with every passing minute.

The King of Kong

Wiebe, by contrast, is a classic underdog: following a run of near-miss careers in baseball and music, he took up the game after being laid off, then reinvented himself as a science teacher loved by his students. Crucially, in this showing at least, he doesn’t even seem to think that much of his knack for DK, though he is clearly as obsessively devoted to chasing the record as Mitchell is to keeping it.

Director Seth Gordon intended a more general inside-retro-gaming documentary but lucked into an astonishingly potent storyline and must have sorted through acres of footage to get stuff this good. So good, in fact, a dramatised remake is reportedly in the works. It has vivid supporting characters, including Roy Schild (aka ‘Mr Awesome’), a secondary ‘evil mastermind’ in Wiebe’s camp and Wiebe’s amazing children (a young son who shouts ‘stop playing Donkey Kong‘ as Dad is on his first record-breaking attempt, a tweenage daughter who wryly observes that a lot of people ruin their lives trying to get into the Guinness Book of Records).

Further Reading by Kim Newman

You also get as many ups and downs as a sports fiction film, with the added plus that since it’s a true story the outcome isn’t decreed by cliché — though there are triumphs and disasters near the end, the story goes on and you can’t stop yourself looking up on the internet to find out who reigns as the current King of Kong. Everyone, including the near-saintly but not sanctimonious Wiebe, reveals more about themselves than the average reality TV contestant would, with many jaw-dropping statements about epochal achievements and grand calamities that took place in a world of game-playing marginalised by the end of the 1980s.

The King of Kong

Mitchell and cohorts act in such a way that, even if it turned out Gordon manipulated and edited the hell out of the footage, it would be impossible for your conclusions about these people not to be — to some extent – horribly true. When Wiebe sends in a tape of his first record-breaking score, Day has agents talk their way into his house to assess his personal DK machine to see if it’s been tampered with, Mitchell claims only scores achieved in public count and the record doesn’t go into the books. When Wiebe does it again at a games convention, Mitchell has protégé Doris Self (an 80-year-old Q*Bert whizz) hand over a blurry, splicey tape in which he purportedly sets a higher record which Day and company accept within ten minutes.

I don’t see how this incident could be spun in a way which doesn’t suggest the tiny sub-culture was stacked against the outsider, though there’s a subtle thread later in the film, which I suspect comes from a dawning awareness of what they look like on the record, as Day and his crowd (except the loyal Kuh) begin to feel the long-time champion has been less than honest with them and respond to Wiebe’s essential decency even as they consistently mispronounce his name.

The King of Kong

There’s a stunning moment when the antagonists almost meet, for the only time in the film, as Wiebe is openly friendly to Mitchell, who cruises by ignoring him at a games machine while making a snide remark to his wife; it may be that when the cameras weren’t on them, these men have played each other or treated each other courteously, but the audience I saw it with hissed a pantomime villain and cheered for the decent contender. Even Mitchell’s obviously genuine decency towards Doris, a little old lady whose gaming career he enabled and championed, doesn’t take the sting out of his Dick Dastardly act elsewhere.

It makes good use of 1980s inspirational pop music, and — like the best of these ‘American weirdo’ documentaries (American Movie, Spellbound) — works up a vein of melancholy sympathy for folks who fanatically and unselfconsciously pursue goals that seem absurd. The middle-aged guy dressed like a teenager who wistfully remembers thinking that the guys who racked up big arcade scores would have hot babes clustering about them perfectly encapsulates the delusional, funny-sad heroism of the world of Kong.

Good documentaries can be made about significant subjects, like the recent Iraq/torture-themed Standard Operating Procedure and Taxi to the Dark Side, but sometimes outstanding true life films spin gold out of ostensibly ridiculous, trivial material.

Tag Cloud

Year in Review posters biography Image Comics nfl Mudbound MSNBC Britbox TNT USA romantic comedy festivals TCM Red Carpet blockbuster fast and furious Pride Month book CNN dceu jurassic park BBC One movies Comics on TV australia fresh PaleyFest Character Guide Trophy Talk Prime Video Superheroes video cancelled Captain marvel razzies scorecard series animated ESPN IFC Best Actor Disney streaming service Fox Searchlight Holidays Country ITV Hear Us Out 2016 20th Century Fox king arthur young adult Elton John Sci-Fi olympics Quiz CBS All Access scary movies hidden camera Sundance TV NBC Thanksgiving Infographic slasher mutant PBS Baby Yoda chucky satire based on movie streaming Reality South by Southwest Film Festival FX on Hulu trophy Video Games japan criterion summer TV preview Ellie Kemper Broadway Endgame YouTube Red 007 mockumentary Shudder pirates of the caribbean 73rd Emmy Awards crime thriller diversity documentary TBS 99% BBC America Action thriller live event DGA adenture Anna Paquin Mystery Tumblr trailers cops sports stand-up comedy remakes 4/20 2017 GIFs YouTube Hallmark Nickelodeon revenge Bravo Crunchyroll Mindy Kaling Heroines El Rey RT History Best and Worst A24 science fiction cars rotten movies we love The CW debate GoT Teen NBA TV One james bond TLC hispanic heritage month Winter TV legend Pop TV werewolf Trivia YA popular sitcom Election TV Land spanish language basketball japanese award winner Holiday singing competition television Focus Features golden globe awards New York Comic Con live action SXSW 2022 children's TV wonder woman Tubi kids black comedy FXX Peacock Star Trek cooking Schedule biopic PlayStation OWN Martial Arts comic books NYCC documentaries Musical ABC rt archives Pop 94th Oscars Best Director zombies kaiju Summer Hallmark Christmas movies aliens Super Bowl HFPA summer preview adaptation Columbia Pictures Wes Anderson broadcast X-Men Oscars DC streaming service DC Comics foreign AMC Plus hispanic scene in color comics scene in color film series latino anime 2015 The Arrangement elevated horror hist royal family serial killer boxing facebook obituary Acorn TV ratings APB OneApp Lifetime psychological thriller Awards blockbusters what to watch Emmy Nominations cancelled TV series dragons Turner Classic Movies HBO Max period drama Binge Guide TCA 2017 E3 blaxploitation marvel comics Lionsgate BET Awards YouTube Premium Native true crime vs. video on demand cancelled TV shows critic resources Western miniseries witnail canceled Showtime robots Avengers Dark Horse Comics Comic Book dramedy composers 79th Golden Globes Awards docudrama critics prank AMC FX 45 Star Wars HBO Go 2019 Film Festival slashers sopranos high school Song of Ice and Fire scene in color series Shondaland telelvision The Walking Dead feel good reboot Horror Lucasfilm A&E deadpool Black Mirror Disney Channel twilight 24 frames Tokyo Olympics Biopics Amazon Prime a nightmare on elm street lord of the rings crossover binge See It Skip It Amazon war 93rd Oscars Arrowverse theme song halloween tv LGBT godzilla Certified Fresh parents zero dark thirty comic book movie WGN Family Paramount Network comic italian Animation Comic-Con@Home 2021 Alien adventure dogs Apple Paramount Plus Christmas National Geographic VH1 child's play mob Pet Sematary obi wan new york Rom-Com toy story international TCA Awards unscripted MCU Disney+ Disney Plus medical drama WarnerMedia Comedy Central summer TV Esquire zombie Syfy DC Universe Legendary anthology movie Sony Pictures VOD Apple TV+ Countdown mission: impossible dreamworks Travel Channel Podcast The Witch tv talk Toys Exclusive Video SDCC doctor who Women's History Month cats reviews saw spider-verse harry potter E! Warner Bros. Universal Kids & Family Awards Tour renewed TV shows Tarantino Pirates Set visit game of thrones Spectrum Originals talk show suspense comedies MTV jamie lee curtis Adult Swim police drama VICE emmy awards social media toronto natural history directors festival boxoffice First Look strong female leads concert 1990s green book nbcuniversal heist movie cults spinoff spider-man target scene in color Interview discovery women Music Sundance Now The Purge SundanceTV stoner archives Indigenous transformers king kong crime 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Academy Awards ABC Signature stop motion aapi justice league all-time new star wars movies sequels disaster book adaptation Oscar Nominations rom-coms cinemax historical drama Reality Competition worst docuseries psycho franchise interviews Trailer casting 21st Century Fox Writers Guild of America HBO Television Academy football know your critic new zealand TCA Winter 2020 BAFTA Rocky Marvel Geeked Week SXSW TIFF Comedy GLAAD target USA Network Chilling Adventures of Sabrina teaser kong universal monsters Neflix comic book movies Hulu canceled TV shows versus Pacific Islander finale news Paramount Pictures The Academy Marvel Studios screenings Netflix Christmas movies Starz cancelled television Paramount christmas movies San Diego Comic-Con Lifetime Christmas movies genre marvel cinematic universe rt labs critics edition Classic Film Film free movies President 72 Emmy Awards nature technology asian-american dark 2018 Mary Poppins Returns Ghostbusters supernatural independent films Epix die hard rotten batman Extras 2021 name the review Superheroe Mary poppins Freeform rt labs Vudu mcc richard e. Grant CBS game show Premiere Dates space Fargo Hollywood Foreign Press Association Sneak Peek Amazon Prime Video dexter Brie Larson TV movies Box Office spanish comiccon Marvel Television History Funimation Nat Geo vampires french politics black Universal Pictures Amazon Studios Cannes Fox News TV Logo Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt halloween streaming movies Winners 71st Emmy Awards Photos MGM Stephen King venice streamig Ovation LGBTQ hollywood Chernobyl Polls and Games IMDb TV political drama Discovery Channel Mary Tyler Moore ghosts breaking bad quibi 2020 Watching Series Grammys 90s Calendar The Walt Disney Company golden globes action-comedy ID Best Picture Musicals Cartoon Network Fall TV Spring TV sag awards Turner art house ABC Family scary Pixar Emmys Best Actress Masterpiece ViacomCBS Star Wars Celebration laika Creative Arts Emmys American Society of Cinematographers travel joker Food Network superman gangster BET Instagram Live CMT sequel IFC Films superhero worst movies Disney leaderboard spy thriller Crackle Walt Disney Pictures DirecTV indie Valentine's Day monster movies Opinion Cosplay Black History Month Apple TV Plus Television Critics Association Spike south america FOX Tomatazos Tags: Comedy dc TCA screen actors guild romance Rocketman RT21 TruTV Sundance cartoon TV renewals BBC First Reviews classics Marathons Sony Disney Plus Fantasy indiana jones best Netflix Rock crime drama spain CW Seed Drama