News

Fresher Movies Make More Money at the Box Office: A Tomatometer Deep Dive

We crunched the numbers and found that the Fresher a movie is, the better its box office chances are on average... though there are always exceptions to the rule.

by | December 3, 2019 | Comments

Star Wars: The Force Awakens
(Photo by ©Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures/Lucasfilm Ltd./Courtesy Everett Collection)

What do the movies with the highest domestic box office totals for each year since 2010 have in common? None of them have Rotten Tomatometer scores – and they all made over $300 million. In fact, when averaged together, these 10 Fresh blockbusters – Toy Story 3, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 2, The Avengers, Iron Man 3, Guardians of the Galaxy, Jurassic World, Finding Dory, Star Wars: Episode VIII – The Last Jedi, Black Panther, and Avengers: Endgame – have a super-Fresh Tomatometer average of 90.3%.

Currently, the highest domestic (and worldwide) grossing film of 2019 is the 94% Tomatometer-rated Avengers: Endgame,  which has earned a mind-snapping total of $858 million domestically and over $2 billion worldwide. By crossing the $2 billion milestone, Avengers: Endgame has joined Titanic, Avatar, Star Wars: Episode VII – The Force Awakens, and Avengers: Infinity War in the exclusive “$2 Billion Club.” What do these movies have in common? Yep, you guessed it again: They’re all Fresh.

The success of these Fresh films got us thinking: Are these blockbuster movies Fresh anomalies, or do Fresh movies make more money at the box office generally? Is there a relationship between Tomatometer score and box office performance? (And we stress: a “relationship,” and not necessarily a causal one; so many factors contribute to box office performance.) To aid us in our data deep dive, we pulled the Tomatometer and domestic box office data for the 1,404 movies that received wide theatrical domestic releases (600-plus screens) since 2010. Here’s what we found…

*The box office results have been adjusted for inflation. All calculations accurate as of November 28, 2019.


MOVIES WITH FRESH TOMATOMETER SCORES MAKE MORE MONEY THAN ROTTEN MOVIES – ON AVERAGE

© Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, ©Marvel Studios
(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, © Marel Studios)
  • Fresh Movies since 2010: Inflated Domestic Average of $104 million
  • Rotten Movies since 2010: Inflated Domestic Average of $54 million

When it comes to Tomatometer and domestic box office results, Fresh movies, on average, make more money than Rotten movies. It may sound obvious – good films draw more people to the theater! – and you are probably thinking, “I could’ve told you that,” but the difference is quite startling. The $101 million average for the 636 Fresh movies in the sample is nearly double the $54 million average of the 799 Rotten films. Even if you removed Disney brands Marvel and Pixar, which produce some of the most critically beloved blockbusters, such as Black Panther, Toy Story 4, and Avengers: Endgame, the average for Fresh films since 2010 is still a respectable $91 million.


THE FRESHER THE MOVIE, THE BIGGER THE BOX OFFICE BOUNTY

It’s also worth noting that the more Fresh a movie is, the better it is likely to do at the box office, and the more Rotten it is, the worse it is likely to perform. Movies with a 0-20% Tomatometer score had an average domestic box office of $40 million; movies with 80-100% Tomatometer scores averaged $113 million.

However, not every Fresh movie makes money: 58 of the 187 (or 42%) wide-release movies that made under $10 million at the box office since 2010 are Fresh. A Fresh rating doesn’t guarantee massive success, and Fresh movies like Green Room and The Raid 2 don’t automatically collect $100 million dollars domestically.


MOVIES WITH HIGHER TOMATOMETER SCORES HAVE A BETTER CHANCE OF CLEARING $100 MILLION

Sanja Bucko/Warner Bros.
(Photo by © Warner Bros. Pictures)

Some 323 movies have made over $100 million at the domestic box office since 2010. Of those, 219 (68%) have Fresh Tomatometer scores, which means the odds of a movie making more than $100 million increase when it receives a Fresh Tomatometer score. Only 5% of movies with a 0-10% Tomatometer score (or 3 of the 62 movies) – namely Grown Ups 2, The Last Airbender, and Little Fockers – made over $100 million. On the other hand, 41% of the movies with a score above 90% (or 68 of the 164 movies) – such as Spy, Girl’s Trip, and Crazy Rich Asians – cleared the $100 million milestone. That 41% may not seem like a lot, but it’s a big jump over the movies in the 70-80% range, where 33% of the movies broke $100 million.

Below is a breakdown of Tomatometer ranges and the average amount of money the movies in them make.

  • 0-10% Movies: $33 million
  • 10-20% Movies: $43 million
  • 20-30% Movies: $50 million
  • 30-40% Movies: $49 million
  • 40-50% Movies: $61 million
  • 50-60% Movies: $76 million
  • 60-70% Movies: $78 million
  • 70-80% Movies: $110 million
  • 80-90% Movies: $95 million
  • 90-100% Movies: $132 million

THE $400 MILLION DOMESTIC CLUB IS ALMOST EXCLUSIVELY FRESH

(Photo by © Universal)

Only 25 movies have made over $400 million domestically since 2010; 23 of those movies are Fresh, and 13 have scores above 90%. The only Rotten films are Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom and The Lion King. Rotten movies can make killer money; it’s just rare, and they seem to need the word “king” somewhere in their name. (Also, in 2009, Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen made over $400 million domestic. Trend?) 

The Fresh Jurassic World was a Mosasaurus-sized blockbuster, whereas its Rotten sequel Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom made $260 million less ($678 million down to $418 million) – though that dropoff is not unusual for a sequel to a mega hit. The lowest-rated Avengers film, Avengers: Age of Ultron (75% on the Tomatometer) is the only Avengers film that didn’t clear the $500 million mark. The same can be said for the $214 million-grossing Solo: A Star Wars Story. At 70%, it has the lowest Tomatometer score of any of the latest Star Wars films — and they all made over $500 million.

The Hunger Games (84% on the Tomatometer) and The Hunger Games: Catching Fire (89%) cleared $400 million, whereas The Hunger Games: Mockingjay – Part 1 and Part 2 had lower Tomatometer scores (69%, 70%) and couldn’t pass the $400 million mark.

There are definitely other factors at play, such as franchise fatigue, time of release, competition, and more, but it’s interesting to note that the less critically appreciated films in a franchise tend to underperform those that score better on the Tomatometer.


ROTTEN SMASH HITS: THE EXCEPTIONS TO THE RULE

(Photo by © Warner Bros. Pictures)

Movies don’t need Fresh scores to make a lot of money. Just ask any Adam Sandler comedy – You Don’t Mess With the Zohan should have at least a 67% Tomatometer score according to some Rotten Tomatoes staffers – or inquire with the Twilight and Transformers franchises. Twelve Rotten movies have cleared $300 million domestically since 2010 and 10 have made over $1 billion worldwide since 2010. In 2018 alone, Venom, Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom, The Meg, The Nun, Rampage, The Equalizer 2, Fifty Shades Freed, and The Grinch pulled in at least $100 million domestically.

So, while there seems to be a correlation between Freshness and box office domination, it’s an imperfect one – and working out causation is an entirely different matter. Our data dive is not about finding out whether Tomatometer scores drive or dampen box office, merely whether there is any trend between the two sets of data. For now, we can simply say that better-reviewed movies tend to do better at the box office, with a few exceptions. And if Adam Sandler suddenly kicked off a Zack Snyder-directed Transformers franchise – and, please do – then this data could look very different in 10 years.

Assuming those films are Rotten, of course.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Thumbnail image courtesy Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, Marvel Studios

Tag Cloud

TCM golden globes vampires TCA 2017 crossover WarnerMedia YouTube Red foreign The CW Spike Comic Book Heroines Ovation Star Trek medical drama MTV Countdown Teen TV romance cancelled television HBO Max rotten movies we love Film movies APB series Music true crime Shudder Bravo El Rey green book SundanceTV Summer Acorn TV anime 71st Emmy Awards Showtime cartoon IFC Films TLC witnail Nominations GLAAD Marathons Holidays composers Watching Series werewolf stand-up comedy slashers revenge Disney streaming service Rocky Opinion Disney sports TCA zombie Syfy book VICE Lifetime Valentine's Day crime thriller Shondaland transformers Nat Geo ABC Family Sony Pictures television blaxploitation diversity 2015 2018 Creative Arts Emmys Trailer Polls and Games Quiz Hulu cancelled TV shows adaptation Oscars cults Pride Month YouTube Premium The Purge Biopics Mary Poppins Returns dceu festivals USA Network Calendar Chernobyl Hallmark Christmas movies dramedy miniseries Reality Competition Grammys Emmys Crackle christmas movies Freeform Cosplay Amazon 007 Adult Swim Spring TV Rocketman Fantasy quibi richard e. Grant San Diego Comic-Con spain mutant docudrama Mindy Kaling science fiction Superheroe Fall TV unscripted Elton John Amazon Prime Video PaleyFest Comics on TV game of thrones HBO CW Seed Peacock A&E adventure Stephen King spanish language 2020 Paramount batman MSNBC FXX social media Emmy Nominations talk show TruTV serial killer FX Pop mockumentary dc Star Wars dragons versus BBC America CMT Marvel Studios Lionsgate Turner Classic Movies Western TNT ghosts Best and Worst period drama Superheroes based on movie FOX Esquire sequel NBC natural history comics doctor who The Arrangement 21st Century Fox AMC Box Office politics Turner WGN ITV Country National Geographic Mudbound game show President Nickelodeon Holiday Tomatazos ratings CNN sitcom justice league Lucasfilm Video Games Premiere Dates Infographic romantic comedy crime drama LGBT The Walking Dead strong female leads Drama Women's History Month latino E! screenings tv talk Awards toy story discovery YA spy thriller travel Ellie Kemper Cartoon Network Christmas cinemax elevated horror USA Year in Review RT History YouTube Cannes Epix technology zero dark thirty Anna Paquin 45 what to watch crime theme song Warner Bros. Toys Masterpiece Song of Ice and Fire Captain marvel streaming south america facebook cooking casting The Witch supernatural DGA singing competition war GoT PBS Ghostbusters cancelled children's TV History Netflix Christmas movies Hallmark Brie Larson DC Universe BBC 2019 First Look kids 24 frames cats CBS political drama Television Academy Chilling Adventures of Sabrina teaser Apple TV+ Binge Guide boxoffice 2016 spinoff renewed TV shows First Reviews Disney+ Disney Plus Extras finale TV Land aliens DirecTV jamie lee curtis OWN IFC Trivia free movies Britbox Disney Channel Rock Writers Guild of America New York Comic Con E3 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Martial Arts NYCC BET Netflix hispanic DC streaming service thriller independent Set visit historical drama DC Comics Certified Fresh joker cars nature Apple TV Plus GIFs Podcast Walt Disney Pictures Crunchyroll See It Skip It Trophy Talk Musicals Schedule Red Carpet RT21 Sneak Peek video TBS Marvel Television X-Men robots MCU American Society of Cinematographers Universal Food Network harry potter Mary Tyler Moore Dark Horse Comics Amazon Prime police drama Super Bowl SDCC zombies Pixar VH1 Disney Plus Marvel 20th Century Fox breaking bad Tarantino psycho Winter TV Kids & Family Classic Film Musical Family Arrowverse Character Guide Mary poppins canceled TV shows Rom-Com SXSW halloween Film Festival Photos Horror animated comiccon canceled Lifetime Christmas movies Sundance LGBTQ 2017 Pet Sematary TIFF Election Tumblr Paramount Network Action Logo comic Comedy disaster blockbuster indie hist Columbia Pictures cops Comedy Central ABC Fox News Thanksgiving Black Mirror spider-man Sci-Fi Sundance Now Winners biography TV renewals Apple space Pirates CBS All Access Mystery ESPN Spectrum Originals anthology Vudu binge A24 cancelled TV series Reality Awards Tour Animation Starz Interview award winner psychological thriller