Critics Consensus

Ford v Ferrari Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Charlie's Angels is fun but a little flat, The Good Liar is a bit too predictable, and Atlantics, Waves, and The Report are also all Certified Fresh.

by | November 14, 2019 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a racing rivalry (Ford v Ferrari, starring Matt Damon and Christian Bale), angelic agents (Charlie’s Angels, starring Kristen Stewart and Naomi Scott), and conniving conman (The Good Liar, starring Helen Mirren and Ian McKellen). What are the critics saying?


Ford v Ferrari (2019) 92%

Director James Mangold is no stranger to the Oscars, his most recent film Logan having earned him a Best Adapted Screenplay nomination, and he looks poised to make some noise again at the next ceremony with his latest film, Ford v Ferrari. The last time Mangold took on a story based on true events — the 2005 Johnny Cash biopic Walk the Line, specifically — the end result was five Academy Award nominations, and based on the reception to Ford v Ferrari so far, it’s not out of the question to assume more nominations are in the cards. Matt Damon and Christian Bale star as legendary car designer Carroll Shelby and British racecar driver and engineer Ken Miles, respectively, who were hired by the Ford Motor Company after its president, Henry Ford II, felt slighted by Ferrari owner Enzo Ferrari pulling out of a business deal between the two companies. Shelby and Miles’ mission? To develop and race a car that would defeat Scuderia Ferrari in the 24 Hours of Le Mans race in 1966. Critics say Ford v Ferrari not only delivers on the pulse-pounding action on the race track but also serves up outstanding performances from Damon, Bale, and their supporting cast, as well as a crowd-pleasing story infused with plenty of human intrigue. Even if you aren’t an auto enthusiast, this is likely to be a satisfying drama that maybe doesn’t take many risks but hits almost all the right notes.


Charlie's Angels (2019) 52%

Elizabeth Banks did a pretty respectable job when she made her feature directorial debut with Pitch Perfect 2 in 2015, so for her sophomore effort, she decided to help revive and reinvent a classic franchise with similar female bonding themes. Charlie’s Angels began as a television series back in the mid- to late-1970s and found new life in a pair of cheeky, early 2000s action flicks starring Cameron Diaz, Lucy Liu, and Drew Barrymore — both revolved around a trio of female agents who specialized in investigation and espionage and were commanded by a mysterious man named Charlie. In this modern update, the angels (or would-be angel, in one case) are played by Kristen Stewart, Ella Balinska, and Naomi Scott, and they comprise just one team of many around the world who all take orders from various “Bosleys” — their own is played by Banks herself. When one of the trio discovers the company she works for is developing a potentially dangerous technology, she unwittingly stumbles upon a conspiracy that the Angels must work to unravel. Critics say Charlie’s Angels is an earnest effort from all involved, with a particularly sprightly performance from Kristen Stewart, but it’s also a little disappointingly rote, as far as action fare goes, and it doesn’t make the greatest case for why it was revived. That said, it’s energetic, breezy, and appropriately cheeky, even if it is formulaic, and it may be just fun enough to pass the time for most.


The Good Liar (2019) 63%

Ian McKellen and Helen Mirren are two of modern cinema’s most celebrated and revered actors, so it may surprise some to learn that, between their extensive resumes, they have yet to share the screen together. That all changes this week with The Good Liar, a twisty, dramatic thriller that critics say doesn’t quite live up to the talents of its two esteemed stars. McKellen plays a veteran conman who sets his sights on a wealthy widower (Mirren) and inserts himself into her life. As he dodges her suspicious grandson, the elder pair grow closer, but his past threatens to catch up with him and bring the whole scheme crashing down. Critics say The Good Liar, directed by Bill Condon (Beauty and the BeastMr. Holmes), just misses the mark; though both McKellen and Mirren are magnetic on screen, the story twists itself into impossible knots in its efforts to squeeze intrigue out of what amounts to a fairly basic premise, and the end result may be a little difficult for some viewers to swallow. Though it sports all the trappings of a classic mystery, it only halfway meets its ambitious goals and ends up feeling like a pulpier take on better-executed films.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Mickey and the Bear (2019) , a drama about a young woman seeking independence from her Iraq War veteran father, is at 100%.
  • Recorder: The Marion Stokes Project (2019) , a documentary about the woman who recorded her television around the clock for over 30 years, is at 100%.
  • Everybody's Everything (2019) , a documentary about the life of rapper Lil Peep, who died at 21 years old from a drug overdose, is at 100%.
  • White Snake (2019) , an animated film about a young woman with amnesia who uncovers a supernatural conspiracy as she strives to recover her memory, is at 100%.
  • Atlantics (2019) , a romantic mystery about a young Senegalese woman’s relationship to a disgruntled construction worker who may be the only survivor of a boat crash, is at Certified Fresh at 96%.
  • Scandalous: The Untold Story of the National Enquirer (2019) , a documentary about the notorious tabloid and its questionable practices over the years, is at 93%.
  • I Lost My Body (2019) , an animated French film about a disembodied hand who journeys to reunite with its body, is at 92%.
  • Waves (2019) , starring Sterling K. Brown and Kelvin Harrison Jr. in Trey Edward Shults‘ drama about a Florida family’s trials and tribulations, is Certified Fresh at 89%.
  • The Hottest August (2019) , a documentary portrait of New York City over the course of an entire month, specifically August of 2017, is at 86%.
  • The Report (2019) , starring Adam Driver in Scott Z. Burns‘ dramatization of the release of the report detailing the U.S. government’s use of torture following 9/11, is Certified Fresh at 84%.
  • The Shed (2019) , a horror film about a teenager who discovers a vampire hiding out in his abusive grandfather’s tool shed, is at 71%.
  • The Warrior Queen of Jhansi (2019) , a historical action film about a female general in 19th century India who became a feminist icon, is at 10%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Polls and Games scary movies PaleyFest Arrowverse Pop TV fast and furious Apple CBS Fargo Turner Disney+ Disney Plus Pet Sematary batman Emmys marvel comics Film Festival 2021 2017 canceled dexter crime drama CNN jamie lee curtis Universal History technology streaming black Pixar Super Bowl boxing monster movies Disney streaming service Box Office toy story ViacomCBS Wes Anderson Fall TV japan disaster Travel Channel Sundance Now Amazon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spanish language Photos TBS GoT Discovery Channel medical drama Trivia MSNBC casting Sony Pictures crime Marvel independent documentary 1990s Christmas finale cancelled TV shows golden globe awards Hulu Comic Book nfl debate BBC America Ovation Crackle Broadway facebook a nightmare on elm street adventure ratings television superman San Diego Comic-Con festivals blockbusters TV Logo deadpool Character Guide godzilla psycho Marathons reboot telelvision Anna Paquin Biopics HBO Max X-Men Rock 79th Golden Globes Awards PBS Amazon Studios animated best Comic-Con@Home 2021 Esquire adenture nature 2016 IFC blaxploitation films sag awards boxoffice comic books Women's History Month 93rd Oscars Opinion TNT Lucasfilm dark cooking movies new star wars movies vs. art house elevated horror Spring TV President dragons Marvel Studios indiana jones LGBT fresh stand-up comedy rotten movies we love Spike Academy Awards black comedy Nat Geo classics MTV cancelled AMC Plus Tubi video Paramount Network sequel romance die hard police drama worst movies new zealand Paramount Plus Pride Month Sundance IFC Films Nominations live action dceu Amazon Prime Video AMC HBO Go scorecard hidden camera video on demand HBO crime thriller Rom-Com legend DC Comics Martial Arts DC Universe Disney Channel Hollywood Foreign Press Association scary movie cinemax VOD Calendar streaming movies scene in color Drama Song of Ice and Fire docudrama CMT olympics vampires Instagram Live Thanksgiving laika travel lord of the rings gangster Hallmark Christmas movies razzies BBC One TCM jurassic park cartoon Avengers 21st Century Fox Certified Fresh worst Holidays Funimation italian Epix Amazon Prime james bond genre Summer emmy awards kaiju cults cancelled television First Look E! canceled TV shows comics SundanceTV dramedy strong female leads Musical blockbuster WGN E3 zombie CW Seed chucky Starz Sneak Peek Image Comics Valentine's Day young adult theme song Stephen King Music Tarantino VH1 TLC mutant National Geographic Toys Film Bravo Adult Swim Reality Competition Mystery game of thrones NBA dreamworks Schedule Tags: Comedy directors spain comic book movie Marvel Television critics hispanic heritage month Black History Month ABC Signature See It Skip It YouTube The Witch Mary Tyler Moore TV movies rt labs YA Elton John Set visit Freeform ghosts new york trophy New York Comic Con ID biopic Fantasy The Purge historical drama basketball Pop Premiere Dates twilight werewolf Brie Larson psychological thriller serial killer 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Apple TV+ live event Year in Review Mary poppins Peacock science fiction YouTube Red romantic comedy marvel cinematic universe award winner DGA 71st Emmy Awards Video Games transformers OWN joker Vudu ABC Family Rocketman halloween TruTV rom-coms Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt FOX supernatural Awards 20th Century Fox Sundance TV spinoff binge Tumblr 99% crossover cats TCA Awards OneApp unscripted heist movie Pacific Islander news Acorn TV Shudder tv talk doctor who nbcuniversal hispanic biography Comics on TV Pirates all-time know your critic cops APB Trophy Talk teaser comic suspense Comedy Central TCA rotten leaderboard comiccon war zero dark thirty Crunchyroll Lifetime Christmas movies king arthur Emmy Nominations Heroines posters sitcom docuseries universal monsters politics American Society of Cinematographers The Academy richard e. Grant 007 anthology 2020 miniseries A&E mob australia Tomatazos parents Exclusive Video natural history comic book movies indie revenge FXX DirecTV reviews justice league political drama remakes The Walt Disney Company Syfy Netflix Christmas movies GLAAD Mindy Kaling social media PlayStation MCU halloween tv NYCC NBC discovery El Rey screen actors guild obituary Disney 4/20 First Reviews green book aliens 45 singing competition USA Network target Television Critics Association Classic Film Election Fox News true crime satire Legendary Winners Columbia Pictures slashers zombies 2019 golden globes comedies cancelled TV series christmas movies superhero WarnerMedia SXSW 24 frames Captain marvel Ghostbusters venice Nickelodeon Awards Tour Shondaland sopranos pirates of the caribbean Superheroes Warner Bros. spy thriller Food Network Endgame versus Walt Disney Pictures VICE saw adaptation Paramount The CW Best and Worst ESPN Kids & Family mission: impossible book adaptation Showtime CBS All Access Apple TV Plus quibi stoner Baby Yoda The Walking Dead spanish harry potter japanese based on movie Chernobyl Creative Arts Emmys Grammys Star Trek hist Interview FX on Hulu spider-man feel good action-comedy 73rd Emmy Awards Watching Series mockumentary Prime Video Dark Horse Comics rt archives RT21 children's TV TCA Winter 2020 2018 asian-american BAFTA The Arrangement Superheroe anime LGBTQ concert kong Masterpiece Mudbound what to watch IMDb TV breaking bad Cannes child's play Sci-Fi king kong high school Black Mirror TV Land TV renewals Extras TV One 90s hollywood free movies YouTube Premium football Cartoon Network criterion USA cars women diversity composers Rocky robots 2015 period drama south america Winter TV screenings Lionsgate Netflix Trailer Britbox kids A24 RT History TIFF Binge Guide festival Ellie Kemper dc Lifetime popular Family Turner Classic Movies international HFPA Hallmark Tokyo Olympics ABC series latino Cosplay royal family Musicals Action BET rt labs critics edition Mary Poppins Returns wonder woman Fox Searchlight critic resources ITV Universal Pictures book name the review mcc stop motion FX Reality Animation Writers Guild of America renewed TV shows Holiday Alien TCA 2017 Country space franchise aapi french Star Wars Horror Red Carpet trailers DC streaming service dogs Disney Plus BET Awards documentaries Teen slasher Spectrum Originals Neflix foreign talk show Comedy witnail 72 Emmy Awards GIFs sequels Countdown SDCC Podcast BBC sports game show Western Hear Us Out Oscars thriller prank Infographic Quiz archives toronto Television Academy spider-verse