Five Reasons Why Election Is Still a Perfect Comedy, 20 Years Later

Alexander Payne’s razor-sharp, high school-set satire, which opened on April 23, 1999, is still as fresh and as relevant as ever.

by | April 23, 2019 | Comments

Released halfway through what many argue is the best year in film history, Election didn’t exactly set the box-office ablaze after it debuted on April 23, 1999 — the $25 million-budgeted movie made a mere $17.2 during its run. And while critics for the most part went gaga for it — Election is Certified Fresh at 92% — compared to other class-of-’99 highlights, it’s almost easy to understand the general public’s collective confusion about it: It’s not a technological game-changer like The Matrix (88%), not a Best Picture conversation piece like American Beauty (88%), not an ambitiously sprawling drama like Magnolia, not a dorm-room philosophical manifesto like Fight Club (79%), and, even with its high-school setting, not quite what first pops into mind when we talk about ’90s teen movies (despite being co-produced by MTV).

Director Alexander Payne and writing partner Jim Taylor’s follow-up to their abortion satire Citizen Ruth (80%) is not a tidy sell. The comedy, which follows an idealistic teacher (Matthew Broderick) hell bent on making sure one particularly ambitious student (Reese Witherspoon) loses the school’s presidential election, is decidedly dark yet laugh-out-loud funny and paced at a fun, confident clip. So how good is it, with the benefit of two decades’ worth of hindsight? Let us count the ways.

Its Script Is Better Than the Book It Was Based on (and That’s Saying Something)

Before his novels were adapted into big-deal film and TV projects (Little Children, The Leftovers), a then-unemployed Tom Perrotta, obsessed with the one-two punch of the Anita Hill hearings and the 1992 U.S. Presidential election, cooked up a brisk, very funny page turner in response. Election’s narrative setup, in which each chapter is told from the perspective of a different character, couldn’t have been easy to sell on the big screen. Yet Payne and Taylor stick to it, economically and tidily introducing each main player (Broderck’s Mr. M., Witherspoon’s Flick, Chris Klein’s smiley jock Paul Metzler, Jessica Campbell’s nihilistic Tammy Metzler), usually doing something embarrassing. (See: the freeze frame of Witherspoon’s unbecoming expression.)

Speaking of embarrassing, Payne and Taylor’s script consistently strips away any empathy for these characters that the book had, pointing out that most of the people onscreen are essentially trash. (Just count the number of shots of refuse, or when it’s used as a major plot point). Similarly, the duo cook up new scenes, like Mr. M. being stung in the eye by a bee (humiliating) or the re-shot ending, in which — spoiler alert! — the now-disgraced teacher doesn’t have a sort of heart-to-heart with Flick as he does in the novel, but instead chucks a soda (trash again) at her limo when he spots her in D.C.

The Casting Is Ace, with Breakthroughs, Debuts, and One Indelible Character

Paramount courtesy Everett Collection

(Photo by Paramount courtesy Everett Collection)

After her turns in Fear and Cruel Intentions, Witherspoon was keen to go full-comedy, initially hoping to play Tammy Metzler, the screw-it-all sister of popular football star Paul Metzler who makes waves as a last-minute candidate in her school’s student council election, running against her brother. But she was convinced to take on the role of Tracy Flick instead — and thank god for that. Beyond critical hosannas from the likes of Roger Ebert and a much-deserved Best Actress nom at the Golden Globes, the young actor displays a deft comedic sensibility and range (not to mention a killer, energetic midwestern accent) that raises Tracy Flick to icon status. In the following decade, that performance would influence Tina Fey’s impersonation of Sarah Palin, and Dan Harmon said Flick was the inspiration for Annie Edison on Community.

Then there’s Flick’s nemesis, Mr. M., the most popular and beloved teacher at school. At first, Perrotta didn’t think Broderick would work for the role. But, like he proved three years earlier in The Cable Guy, the actor’s sensitive, soft-spoken demeanor is the perfect comedic foil, and as his life starts spiraling out of control (an extramarital affair here, an election sabotage there), his aww-shucks, nice-guy shell makes the whole mess he creates that much funnier.

Although his role wasn’t as demanding as Witherspoon’s or Broderick’s, Chris Klein also shouldn’t get short shrift. Payne discovered the high school senior when he was scouting locals in Omaha, and in his onscreen debut as the sidelined quarterback-cum-student body hopeful Paul Metzler, Klein amps up the dumbness, walking around the halls with a smile plastered on his face like a clueless kid. That summer, Klein would go on to co-star in American Pie, which did 14 times the box-office business of Election and made him something of a teen-movie celeb.

It Somehow Tackles Taboos and Maintains Its Comic Levity

“Her p—y gets so wet.”

“F–k me, Mr. M.”

Both of those lines are in reference to Tracy. (We know. Yikes.) The first one comes from Tracy’s math teacher, Mr. Novotny (Mark Harelik), who drops the description while admitting his affair to Mr. M. The second is from “Tracy,” during a fantasy Mr. M. has while having sex with his wife. (Garbage, remember?) Payne impressively keeps the film lively and buoyant, even when delving into these dark depths, not letting anyone off the hook morally or taking a tonal left turn.

The nastiness doesn’t stop there. Later, in a delightful bit of verbal sparring, Mr. M. brings up the affair, to which Tracy spits back, “I don’t know what you’re referring to, but maybe if certain older, wiser people hadn’t acted like such little babies and gotten so mushy, then everything would be OK… and I think certain older people, like you and your colleague, shouldn’t be leching after their students, especially when some of them can’t even get their own wives pregnant.” Broderick’s stunned, I’ve-been-bested-by-a-pupil face that follows is priceless.

It Nails the Hell of High School (and A Certain Slice of the Midwest)

Paramount courtesy Everett Collection

(Photo by Paramount courtesy Everett Collection)

No matter what side of the desk you’re on, high school can be incredibly… boring. Payne captures that monotony throughout Election, with shots of students spacing out until the bell rings and giving half-assed answers when pushed by their teachers.  As he nears rock bottom, the once-idealistic Mr. M., record-holder for teacher-of-the-year at his school, gets fed up with the routine, too. “‘Mr.McAllister. Mr.McAllister,’” he says, in a voice mocking a whiny student. “‘Can I get an A? Can I get a recommendation? Can I? Can I?’ F–k them.”

The midwest — or, more accurately, Payne’s hometown of Omaha, where the film takes place — isn’t spared, either. Chain restaurants playing depressing pop, cheap cars with dirt-smudged windshields, hyperbolically polite parents, and frosty, grey-skied mornings paint a picture of a very specific mediocrity. (The director also explores his native state, and similar dark-comedic waters, in Citizen Ruth, About Schmidt, Downsizing and, yes, Nebraska.)

It’s Still Politically Relevant

We don’t want to get political here (this is a safe space, people), but can you talk about Election without bringing up, you know, elections? Beyond the aforementioned inspiration for Perrotta’s book, Witherspoon’s turn as Tracy Flick has drawn comparisons to too many real-world politicians to mention over the years. (Hillary Clinton, hands down, is the most referenced, and Payne claims Barack Obama told him Election was his favorite political film.) But it does say something about the film’s longevity (or maybe mankind’s predictability) that critics saw plenty of Election in the most recent U.S. Presidential face-off. Same as it ever was.

Election opened in limited release April 23, 1999

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.


Election (1999)

Adjusted Score: 96.887%
Critics Consensus: Election successfully combines dark humor and intelligent writing in this very witty and enjoyable film.
Synopsis: In this satiric comedy, Jim McAllister is a popular and well-respected instructor at George Washington Carver High School in Omaha,... [More]
Directed By: Alexander Payne

Tag Cloud

tv talk E! cancelled TV shows Pixar critics Lifetime Christmas movies Paramount 99% 1990s Television Critics Association mockumentary best political drama FX war universal monsters Captain marvel 93rd Oscars RT History japanese godzilla Rocky Lucasfilm Pop TV criterion Ovation Box Office prank doctor who Fantasy disaster YouTube concert Black Mirror sports Comic Book slashers boxoffice mission: impossible green book Premiere Dates video Pride Month WarnerMedia First Reviews Super Bowl aliens king kong dark RT21 Marvel Studios justice league adaptation Winter TV Pacific Islander indiana jones TCA Awards strong female leads romantic comedy Tomatazos OWN Crackle Podcast satire transformers lord of the rings joker Epix foreign Video Games robots comics 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Best and Worst adenture movies Creative Arts Emmys psycho CBS Summer live action new star wars movies The Purge parents Pop 72 Emmy Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dramedy Paramount Network Amazon Lifetime See It Skip It Character Guide target spinoff sitcom Sneak Peek finale TV movies Cannes Nominations football Classic Film natural history deadpool serial killer nbcuniversal italian VICE SundanceTV FX on Hulu scene in color MCU DirecTV ABC New York Comic Con what to watch spy thriller cops Spectrum Originals ID crime drama ratings SXSW 21st Century Fox Comic-Con@Home 2021 Election kaiju USA Trophy Talk ITV Spike blaxploitation breaking bad jurassic park A24 television laika Freeform anime quibi History zero dark thirty know your critic X-Men Year in Review Crunchyroll spider-man monster movies saw documentaries fast and furious DC streaming service basketball french BBC toronto BBC One movie women Disney Cosplay diversity Tokyo Olympics Nat Geo Song of Ice and Fire popular indie Writers Guild of America emmy awards Apple TV+ Hallmark Christmas movies Set visit Exclusive Video Awards worst movies elevated horror supernatural Musical Sci-Fi Dark Horse Comics Anna Paquin Binge Guide animated Fox Searchlight Trivia canceled BET Marvel docuseries Showtime Mindy Kaling streaming movies Emmys Marvel Television ESPN a nightmare on elm street Mary poppins PaleyFest Mudbound Avengers stop motion werewolf international Sundance TV Trailer Tubi Vudu superman Shondaland binge Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mystery Chernobyl Heroines Photos award winner MTV 24 frames witnail TCA Infographic social media 2019 4/20 south america book Disney+ Disney Plus suspense Superheroes Peacock politics asian-american Arrowverse First Look heist movie 007 singing competition Comedy Central Academy Awards crime thriller Tumblr thriller Certified Fresh stand-up comedy Shudder zombies zombie PBS Schedule Kids & Family YouTube Red revenge SDCC Amazon Studios YouTube Premium science fiction historical drama canceled TV shows technology FXX Red Carpet Travel Channel renewed TV shows Emmy Nominations 71st Emmy Awards olympics worst Awards Tour halloween tv Film Calendar Fall TV ABC Signature versus superhero VH1 Grammys Sundance Walt Disney Pictures hidden camera TCM spain facebook American Society of Cinematographers 2017 Broadway Food Network Columbia Pictures Toys sequels spanish franchise book adaptation rotten movies we love Paramount Plus The Academy composers golden globe awards theme song kong nfl reboot Hallmark HBO Nickelodeon cartoon sequel batman Funimation CMT A&E OneApp police drama romance Television Academy Netflix Action Syfy Western IFC Films cancelled TV series LGBT discovery Rocketman cooking anthology Countdown blockbusters golden globes comic books APB child's play 45 Drama NBA Turner aapi Musicals comic trailers legend ghosts festival black dogs Rom-Com Family 2020 AMC films boxing Horror kids Star Trek HBO Go Disney Channel BET Awards E3 Thanksgiving TV Land stoner Pirates spanish language GoT Country Women's History Month japan latino cinemax Legendary Amazon Prime Video Hulu CNN El Rey Opinion series Martial Arts Holidays Endgame mutant miniseries die hard marvel cinematic universe Quiz classics TruTV australia Image Comics YA Christmas The Arrangement Teen Starz telelvision crime children's TV adventure all-time independent teaser PlayStation medical drama toy story dceu TV Warner Bros. President Reality Competition hispanic Film Festival fresh 20th Century Fox razzies Pet Sematary Polls and Games Apple Biopics game show Esquire Netflix Christmas movies TBS NYCC Logo chucky jamie lee curtis nature harry potter Animation San Diego Comic-Con Holiday travel dc Fox News Disney Plus The Witch archives Sony Pictures high school psychological thriller Marathons Bravo hist Universal BBC America Comics on TV video on demand The Walking Dead Mary Poppins Returns Amazon Prime james bond MSNBC Winners unscripted period drama Acorn TV scorecard Spring TV Alien documentary Disney streaming service remakes cults BAFTA Oscars casting dragons crossover CW Seed Britbox space sag awards screenings rom-coms Lionsgate vampires WGN TV renewals Superheroe Cartoon Network FOX Sundance Now directors National Geographic venice Mary Tyler Moore Wes Anderson scary movies HBO Max cancelled name the review obituary GIFs Extras Interview DC Universe richard e. Grant screen actors guild Reality game of thrones comiccon ViacomCBS TV One Comedy 2018 VOD new york NBC Ghostbusters GLAAD cancelled television rotten twilight Rock christmas movies TIFF free movies Music 90s The Walt Disney Company Brie Larson based on movie ABC Family pirates of the caribbean docudrama Black History Month 2021 DC Comics reviews Stephen King comedies festivals Discovery Channel Adult Swim CBS All Access biography streaming hollywood blockbuster Star Wars halloween Watching Series Valentine's Day 2015 Ellie Kemper Apple TV Plus rt archives Elton John Masterpiece cars Turner Classic Movies The CW true crime TNT TLC Hear Us Out Tarantino talk show TCA 2017 USA Network cats TCA Winter 2020 news new zealand IFC 2016 LGBTQ Baby Yoda DGA