Critics Consensus

Fantasy Island, Underwater, and The Rhythm Section Hit Digital Release This Week

As more people self-quarantine at home, we run down the most notable films hitting VOD and early digital release.

by | April 16, 2020 | Comments

As more and more people are compelled to practice social distancing and encouraged to stay home, as movie theaters temporarily shutter their doors, and as studios continue to pull their scheduled 2020 films off the release calendar, we’ve decided to reformat this weekly Critics Consensus column to focus on titles that are newly available on the home entertainment market. With that in mind, our list of digital new releases this week includes a trio of thrillers – one about an insidious vacation destination, one about deep-sea terror, and one about a fledgling vigilante on the warpath. See below for the full list.


Blumhouse's Fantasy Island (2020) 8%

The late 1970s/early 1980s TV series Fantasy Island always had something of a Twilight Zone-esque feel to it, what with people living out their deepest, wildest fantasies “for a price,” so it didn’t seem entirely unreasonable for the good people over at Blumhouse to take that premise and mine it for horror thrills. In this big screen adaptation, Michael Peña plays Mr. Roarke, the titular island’s mysterious proprietor and host, who welcomes a group of young visitors and sets about introducing them to the wish-fulfillment scenarios that will inevitably go sideways and force them to fight for their lives. Unfortunately, despite a premise with some potential, Fantasy Island was savaged by critics, who called it thinly plotted, populated by generic characters, and overly reliant on the most predictable horror movie cliches, en route to a 7% on the Tomatometer. That said, it did make a decent chunk of change at the box office, so don’t be surprised if Blumhouse decides it’s worth another visit.

Available now on: FandangoNOWAmazonGoogle PlayiTunesVudu


Underwater (2020) 47%

If something about Underwater feels familiar, that may be because it wears its influences on its very wet sleeve. Taking its cues from isolation-based horror classics like Alien and The Thing, this thriller centers on the crew of a deep-sea research and drilling vessel that is hit hard by an earthquake, forcing them to flee for the refuge of another underwater station a mile away. At the same time, the crew become aware that they are being hunted by creatures of unknown origin. Critics were split on Underwater, with some calling it stylish and well-acted enough to serve as a satisfactory diversion, while others called it too blatantly and blandly derivative to leave a lasting impression. This one made just below what Fantasy Island did at the box office, but it also cost a lot more to make, so even if Underwater got better reviews, don’t expect it to be the beginning of a new franchise.

Available now on: FandangoNOW, AmazonGoogle PlayiTunesVudu


The Rhythm Section (2020) 29%

You might be thinking to yourself, “Gee, the new movies available on digital this week aren’t particularly good,” and you’d be right, at least judging from the Tomatometer scores. But it’s also understandable, considering these are all January and February releases – i.e. historically not the most optimal time to find quality cinema playing at your local theaters. With that in mind, it shouldn’t be surprising that yet another female vigilante/super-spy action-thriller failed to generate much excitement for critics, even if it was based on a novel, produced by the people behind the James Bond movies, and starred a committed Blake Lively. The story follows an Oxford-educated woman whose life has crumbled after her family was killed in a plane crash. When she’s approached with information that the crash wasn’t an accident, she embarks on a journey that finds her training to become an assassin and plotting her revenge. It’s a familiar template that’s been utilized, in one way or another, several times before, both in much better movies and in much worse ones. It’s not likely this will go down as one of the more memorable efforts, unfortunately.

Available now on: FandangoNOWAmazonGoogle PlayiTunesVudu


Thumbnail image by Columbia Pictures

Tag Cloud

cancelled TV shows free movies diversity Sundance Rock remakes TBS Hallmark Comic Book Star Wars monster movies name the review Comic-Con@Home 2021 LGBT indie italian spinoff Lionsgate Hallmark Christmas movies unscripted stoner asian-american Spring TV blockbusters ESPN Chernobyl Holiday casting worst movies Writers Guild of America kids dogs Emmy Nominations Black Mirror book festivals PBS wonder woman marvel comics 2015 CBS All Access series Starz nature 2018 Television Academy zero dark thirty Television Critics Association Food Network Tarantino debate richard e. Grant Schedule cars RT History nfl news Women's History Month dc Pop Photos TV renewals Cartoon Network jurassic park Disney Plus new york Paramount Network dexter biopic Classic Film Image Comics war Avengers a nightmare on elm street Family what to watch Turner BAFTA all-time tv talk USA Network composers Fantasy parents Spectrum Originals witnail theme song mutant scene in color versus CBS emmy awards Red Carpet rt labs Trailer GoT rotten dragons child's play New York Comic Con Pride Month Tumblr 24 frames ghosts Mary Tyler Moore black mob Discovery Channel Crunchyroll spider-man Apple TV+ Horror zombies Comedy vampires psychological thriller young adult BBC One black comedy Reality Competition Binge Guide heist movie anthology 90s Watching Series canceled Hear Us Out rom-coms Netflix Christmas movies 45 Apple TV Plus Tubi Marathons justice league medical drama Superheroes Heroines Netflix deadpool independent hispanic heritage month Pacific Islander 2017 stop motion Apple blockbuster laika historical drama Broadway A&E ABC Family DC Universe comic book movies Marvel Studios Warner Bros. Set visit The CW Syfy TCA 2017 TCA Winter 2020 Baby Yoda Funimation high school superman Quiz based on movie popular olympics movie BBC cancelled biography CW Seed SXSW Black History Month Disney women Pixar Sneak Peek VICE Cosplay cancelled television AMC Plus Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Awards Tour Shondaland festival MCU documentaries doctor who Emmys slashers Columbia Pictures renewed TV shows slasher Animation VH1 1990s critic resources animated nbcuniversal godzilla DC streaming service foreign documentary zombie Comics on TV lord of the rings psycho Nat Geo streaming movies hispanic golden globes pirates of the caribbean Anna Paquin MTV aapi Martial Arts movies venice History HBO Max hidden camera HBO Go TV movies Musicals crime drama discovery trailers Opinion romance Tokyo Olympics Trophy Talk TCM Disney Channel cults Epix The Purge directors Sci-Fi concert Film joker Rocketman award winner superhero The Walking Dead Comedy Central target Winners NBA Lifetime ratings Summer Pop TV king arthur elevated horror gangster comedies Fox News book adaptation FX on Hulu period drama PlayStation 2021 adaptation ViacomCBS video rt labs critics edition new zealand TV One cooking Hulu south america boxing NBC comic Paramount Exclusive Video 2016 Stephen King Trivia Extras Crackle new star wars movies LGBTQ Logo Disney+ Disney Plus cartoon batman Sony Pictures toy story scorecard USA Box Office latino docudrama Fox Searchlight twilight Certified Fresh comic book movie breaking bad The Academy President 73rd Emmy Awards Sundance Now miniseries boxoffice Holidays Ellie Kemper Bravo japan children's TV Alien transformers Arrowverse 4/20 Best and Worst Countdown Grammys RT21 Neflix CNN rotten movies we love space Action archives green book 20th Century Fox The Walt Disney Company Pirates Mary poppins football Legendary screen actors guild spanish hist dramedy french El Rey sequel Cannes mockumentary anime streaming Country halloween tv live action OWN sitcom YouTube Nominations prank Elton John Infographic TV Travel Channel Election MSNBC Fall TV live event Interview christmas movies See It Skip It spain australia royal family Lifetime Christmas movies ID universal monsters blaxploitation hollywood Creative Arts Emmys Amazon Prime Video Christmas Endgame GIFs DGA The Witch Reality San Diego Comic-Con TIFF 007 travel comics NYCC politics DC Comics Brie Larson sequels obituary kaiju basketball legend technology rt archives Podcast werewolf IFC crime Showtime classics 2019 SundanceTV teaser binge Ovation genre sopranos Disney streaming service criterion true crime quibi posters police drama facebook comic books game show docuseries vs. razzies strong female leads APB natural history Paramount Plus Pet Sematary political drama Awards Music finale TLC Dark Horse Comics Video Games OneApp TCA Awards cats YouTube Premium Character Guide Premiere Dates AMC Polls and Games Calendar cinemax jamie lee curtis Academy Awards halloween international adenture Nickelodeon A24 japanese screenings franchise Spike BET Awards films know your critic Super Bowl Tomatazos sag awards fast and furious 99% Britbox Shudder First Look X-Men Esquire kong serial killer james bond Amazon Masterpiece IFC Films GLAAD spanish language Instagram Live romantic comedy Captain marvel television revenge Ghostbusters Marvel Biopics comiccon critics PaleyFest Valentine's Day Superheroe Peacock 21st Century Fox 93rd Oscars mission: impossible 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards chucky social media Year in Review BBC America satire mcc game of thrones Amazon Prime feel good crime thriller First Reviews Adult Swim suspense fresh Mary Poppins Returns HBO Sundance TV E! 2020 National Geographic crossover dreamworks Fargo Winter TV TCA Film Festival Acorn TV Teen IMDb TV YA YouTube Red marvel cinematic universe dceu toronto Drama Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Universal Pictures supernatural ABC Signature robots Toys 72 Emmy Awards talk show SDCC Turner Classic Movies ABC scary WarnerMedia spider-verse ITV video on demand TruTV cops adventure FOX saw singing competition reboot thriller Oscars cancelled TV series The Arrangement BET FX reviews VOD WGN aliens action-comedy spy thriller scary movies Mudbound science fiction golden globe awards Song of Ice and Fire American Society of Cinematographers Freeform Walt Disney Pictures canceled TV shows harry potter Vudu TV Land indiana jones telelvision Wes Anderson die hard dark Marvel Television Western Universal DirecTV FXX stand-up comedy Rom-Com Thanksgiving CMT sports E3 71st Emmy Awards art house Rocky Amazon Studios worst best Lucasfilm disaster Musical Kids & Family king kong Mindy Kaling Mystery Star Trek TNT