Critics Consensus

Eternals Is Underpowered

Plus, Spencer and The Harder They Fall are Certified Fresh, and Red Notice isn't as fun as it should be.

by | November 4, 2021 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got immortal heroes (Eternals, starring Gemma Chan and Richard Madden), a portrait of a princess (Spencer, starring Kristen Stewart and Jack Farthing), a stylish shoot-’em-up (The Harder The Fall, starring Jonathan Majors and Idris Elba), and a cheeky crime caper (Red Notice, starring Dwane JohnsonRyan Renolds, and Gal Gadot). What are the critics saying?

Eternals (2021)


After 25 films (and a handful of TV series), Marvel finally decided to hand the reins over to a Best Picture and Best Director winner to see what she might do with an entry in the MCU, and the results so far are surprising, to say the least. Nomadland director Chloé Zhao takes the helm for Eternals, which introduces nearly a dozen immortal heroes who have lived alongside humans on Earth for millennia with one explicit mission: protect the planet from being overrun by a race of monsters known as Deviants, and nothing else. When the Deviants resurface in the present day, the estranged Eternals must rally to suppress the attack. Bolstered by an all-star cast that includes Angelina Jolie, Salma Hayek, Kumail Nanjiani, Gemma Chan, Richard Madden, and more, the film benefits from some strong performances and Zhao’s typically stellar cinematic eye, but critics feel that her instincts are hampered by the Marvel formula, resulting in a tonally inconsistent narrative with a few too many distractions on the side. Eternals is ambitious, but everyone seems to be split on whether those ambitions are satisfactorily met.

Spencer (2021)


Director Pablo Larrain is nothing if not consistent — his last four films have all been Certified Fresh — and he’s proven in the past that he knows his way around a biopic (see: Neruda and Jackie). So far, it looks like he’s done it again with Spencer, a look at a brief period in the life of Diana, Princess of Wales. Set in 1991 during the holiday season, Spencer follows its titular royal (played by Kristen Stewart) as she navigates the Christmas festivities at Queen Elizabeth’s Sandringham Estate amid rumors of a potential divorce from Prince Charles (Jack Farthing). While most critics agree that Larrain has crafted a solid drama out of what easily could have felt like an exploitative story, the lion’s share of praise has gone to Stewart, who carries the film on the strength of her magnetic performance. There are certainly other impressive elements about the film, but Stewart is the reason to see it, if you can find it at a theater near you.

Red Notice (2021)


Dwayne Johnson has worked with director Rawson Marshall Thurber twice before, on Central Intelligence and Skyscraper, but for their latest collaboration, they decided to bring a couple more famous friends along. In Red Notice, Johnson plays an FBI agent who strikes a deal with a notorious art thief in order to bring down a mutual enemy, an even more notorious art thief. The two thieves in question? Ryan Reynolds and Gal Gadot (or their characters, anyway). Based on the synopsis and the talent involved, you pretty much know what you’re in for here, and you’re either all for it or not interested whatsoever. Unsurprisingly, critics as a whole haven’t been particularly impressed by the film so far; they say it’s so insistent upon its own charm and cleverness that it nearly backfires. In other words, it essentially delivers what it promises, even if it only promises a fairly boilerplate caper. Red Notice opens in limited release this week before streaming on Netflix next week.

Westerns populated by majority Black actors are few and far between, so if you’re going to film one, it makes sense to gather the most stunning cast imaginable. That’s what Jeymes Samuel managed to do for The Harder They Fall, his debut feature, which stars — deep breath — Idris Elba, Regina King, Jonathan Majors, LaKeith Stanfield, Zazie Beetz, and Delroy Lindo, among others. Based on actual historical figures from the Old West, the story centers on outlaw Nat Love (Majors), who rounds up a posse to hunt down Rufus Buck (Elba), the man who killed his parents and carved a cross in his forehead. The story is pure fiction but peppered with other real-life cowboys and outlaws, and critics say the cast is all aces, helping to elevate what might otherwise be a familiar tale of betrayal and revenge. It’s got action and swagger to spare, but it’s also grounded in a way that helps keep viewers invested, and most reviews say it’s a lot of fun. Though it had a limited release in late October, it’s available to stream on Netflix this week.

Thumbnail image by ©Marvel Studios

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

doctor who Instagram Live Women's History Month Comics on TV french Starz BBC Star Wars psychological thriller foreign nbcuniversal new york Travel Channel Vudu 1990s Winter TV Mindy Kaling trophy independent sag awards stand-up comedy zombies Writers Guild of America Comedy Central NBA sitcom Awards Tour politics japan Disney Toys hist ITV Trivia Comic Book SDCC FXX new star wars movies Thanksgiving fresh Funimation American Society of Cinematographers Election Bravo wonder woman OneApp PlayStation Fox News 45 emmy awards richard e. Grant natural history witnail criterion anime 2017 TCA Winter 2020 Awards docudrama young adult El Rey black canceled live event franchise TV renewals social media Cosplay harry potter marvel comics Musicals canceled TV shows medical drama italian crime drama free movies USA Network DGA Mystery Creative Arts Emmys reboot Black History Month leaderboard christmas movies Anna Paquin streaming movies teaser 93rd Oscars Best and Worst HBO Max NBC sopranos 90s kong toy story PaleyFest Premiere Dates Britbox breaking bad spinoff TruTV VOD Mary Tyler Moore RT History popular comic books singing competition vampires ABC Elton John Black Mirror venice superhero die hard Pride Month Tubi Mary Poppins Returns Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Crackle Lifetime dexter mutant Netflix prank YouTube Red The Witch Western Holiday Red Carpet comic book movies Freeform new zealand Shudder 2019 Lifetime Christmas movies GLAAD Columbia Pictures deadpool 72 Emmy Awards LGBT National Geographic boxing international strong female leads spanish king kong Set visit CMT BBC One aapi genre Sundance TV name the review Baby Yoda travel 24 frames miniseries Pop blaxploitation universal monsters revenge scary movies Reality Competition Food Network Epix Chernobyl TV concert Countdown Rock Paramount Plus BET Awards rotten japanese WarnerMedia 2016 hollywood Kids & Family Fox Searchlight political drama Grammys Marvel Studios mission: impossible know your critic golden globe awards black comedy SXSW First Look festivals Amazon Prime Video 2018 animated dc romantic comedy BET 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Lionsgate TNT Adult Swim CBS VICE Disney+ Disney Plus TLC Paramount Turner Marathons Television Critics Association ghosts Sneak Peek First Reviews jurassic park worst movies Binge Guide rt archives X-Men TCA Awards sports biopic Neflix high school spider-man pirates of the caribbean AMC Exclusive Video series Ovation ratings superman saw spy thriller Oscars dark History Walt Disney Pictures comiccon 2020 suspense Hallmark Christmas movies Polls and Games Endgame Wes Anderson award winner Fantasy Showtime razzies scene in color YouTube blockbusters SundanceTV ID australia stoner war all-time Rocky crossover crime basketball Christmas The Walking Dead Disney Plus Mary poppins satire disaster Winners Horror cancelled TV series dreamworks dogs unscripted Sundance Now cops romance comic Nickelodeon slasher obituary comics Spike 4/20 Character Guide Avengers President Pixar Video Games latino marvel cinematic universe sequel serial killer monster movies Marvel HBO Go comic book movie Spectrum Originals IFC 71st Emmy Awards cats Sci-Fi debate Tumblr Apple 73rd Emmy Awards Teen indiana jones anthology Lucasfilm Comedy Paramount Network mob binge royal family TCM cults cancelled television FOX Logo Mudbound NYCC Disney streaming service Shondaland child's play Star Trek Martial Arts batman TCA 2017 Comic-Con@Home 2021 Reality Film Festival technology nfl spider-verse Interview directors halloween Academy Awards Superheroe south america Arrowverse worst golden globes cinemax posters documentary Heroines Ghostbusters Quiz Netflix Christmas movies Dark Horse Comics Cartoon Network ABC Family Emmy Nominations green book ViacomCBS 21st Century Fox Biopics Extras Podcast historical drama Musical critic resources Superheroes 2015 Spring TV Music video on demand hidden camera based on movie period drama adaptation screen actors guild Marvel Television best hispanic heritage month spain facebook critics Rocketman FX on Hulu The Walt Disney Company justice league jamie lee curtis nature Stephen King Country Super Bowl rt labs Sundance television twilight Brie Larson TV movies Tomatazos New York Comic Con quibi Warner Bros. versus Classic Film Apple TV Plus diversity Discovery Channel IMDb TV Year in Review Song of Ice and Fire indie comedies Image Comics E3 parents Alien GIFs scorecard See It Skip It spanish language elevated horror space Masterpiece ABC Signature Captain marvel MSNBC adenture slashers feel good king arthur Trophy Talk chucky aliens children's TV mockumentary cars kids Nat Geo Calendar VH1 gangster TV One biography MTV stop motion sequels hispanic FX DC Universe Pacific Islander Box Office WGN Infographic reviews TBS DC Comics lord of the rings Cannes true crime Universal Pictures Summer DirecTV Holidays asian-american DC streaming service Broadway blockbuster Valentine's Day Fargo Pop TV 99% Acorn TV Hear Us Out transformers casting action-comedy rom-coms Drama 007 Nominations A&E theme song finale Turner Classic Movies Amazon YA Legendary game show Amazon Prime dramedy ESPN Photos BAFTA Pet Sematary TV Land Action zombie game of thrones video classics rotten movies we love Trailer cartoon BBC America boxoffice GoT scary PBS godzilla heist movie Schedule IFC Films trailers The Arrangement E! Esquire CBS All Access Chilling Adventures of Sabrina book Ellie Kemper Rom-Com USA MCU Certified Fresh Opinion thriller dragons target The Purge The Academy Television Academy remakes Peacock CNN legend Animation book adaptation news women composers Pirates docuseries Watching Series a nightmare on elm street cooking police drama kaiju tv talk Hallmark The CW 20th Century Fox Fall TV HBO APB talk show Syfy TIFF documentaries A24 Emmys dceu laika Universal Film Crunchyroll screenings science fiction movie robots OWN halloween tv RT21 YouTube Premium live action telelvision joker CW Seed Amazon Studios Hulu festival archives films werewolf Tokyo Olympics crime thriller toronto streaming rt labs critics edition what to watch movies adventure Sony Pictures football mcc Disney Channel San Diego Comic-Con Apple TV+ cancelled fast and furious Family Tarantino zero dark thirty supernatural 2021 LGBTQ TCA james bond olympics discovery psycho cancelled TV shows art house renewed TV shows AMC Plus vs.