11 Divisive Horror Movies That Critics Loved But Audiences Slayed

Too weird? Too slow? Too scary? For some reason, these horror greats left some audiences cold.

by | June 18, 2018 | Comments

It’s always nice when (mostly) everyone is unanimous about a movie’s quality, and it’s also sort of fun when (just about) everyone dislikes the same movie – but there’s something really fascinating about that middle ground. Hereditary defied box office expectations its opening weekend, riding on a wave of critical adulation that had started at Sundance. But when audiences finally caught up with Ari Aster’s much-hyped film, not everyone was loving it quite as much as the critics – the film has a Tomatometer score of 91% but an Audience Score of 56%, with an average audience rating of 3.2 out of 5.

Hereditary is not the first horror movie to polarize in this way, and it won’t be the last. With the industry wondering what exactly it was that divided critics and audiences about the film, we pulled data on other horror flicks with high Tomatometer ratings and low Audience Scores to see if there are any commonalities. So, let’s take a look at some of the most divisive horror films to ever grace the vines of the tomato patch. And if it turns out you agree more with the Audience Score, check out our companion list of horror movies audiences loved but critics savaged.

The Witch (2016) 91%

Audience Score: 57%
Divide: 34 percentage points

Ah, the double-edged sword of early festival reviews. On one hand you definitely want that positive buzz. On the other hand those early reviews sometimes generate “overhype,” which is nothing any filmmaker wants to deal with. This was the case for The Witch, which premiered to acclaim at Sundance in January 2015; much like Hereditary, its slow-paced terror split audiences when it finally bowed at the multiplexes.

We Are What We Are (2013) 86%

Audience Score: 49%
Divide: 37 points

This stark and disturbing remake of a Mexican horror film of the same name comes from Jim Mickle, who’d go on to deliver fantastic productions like Cold in July and the Hap and Leonard TV series – but it doesn’t seem like audiences enjoyed this effort as much as critics did. Movies about cannibalism are frequently very divisive, for obvious reasons.

The Innkeepers (2012) 80%

Audience Score: 42%
Divide: 37 points

Indie veteran Ti West is no stranger to splitting audiences down the middle. (His second feature, Trigger Man, scored a 90% Tomatometer but an Audience Score of just 45%, and even his awesome The House of the Devil has a ratio of 86 to 63!). But it’s a little strange to notice the wide disparity in scores on this fine, freaky, dryly funny horror flick. Perhaps it’s something about that “slow burn” that sometimes irritates general audiences.

We Are Still Here (2015) 95%

Audience Score: 48%
Divide: 47 points

Critics and festivalgoers had a ball with this old-fashioned throwback to campfire tales, monster movies, and Lucio Fulci splatter, but the charms of this horror cocktail seem to have been lost on a chunk of the viewing audience. Suffice to say that this movie works best for those who appreciate obscure TV movies from the 1970s.

It Comes At Night (2017) 87%

Audience Score: 44%
Divide: 44 points

Most would blame the misleading title (and marketing campaign) for this artsy thriller that’s more a dark suspense film than a conventional horror flick. When people hear that “it” comes at night, they expect “it” to be some sort of monster. Not a metaphor. (Wait, is that a spoiler!?)

Splice (2010) 75%

Audience Score: 37%
Divide: 38 points

This odd concoction of Frankenstein tropes and frankly sexual science fiction themes earned a lot of fans when it played the festival circuit, but it seems to have left general viewers cold. It’s an eerie, icy genre film that may be tough to love, but it’s also an audacious, fascinating experiment.

Teeth (2007) 79%

Audience Score: 45%
Divide: 35 points

What? You’re telling me audiences are staunchly divided on a darkly comedic horror film about a young woman who has teeth in her… nether-regions? Obviously this is a willfully weird genre film with an offbeat sense of humor – but maybe it’s just the premise itself that turns some audiences off.

The Last Exorcism (2010) 71%

Audience Score: 34%
Divide: 38 points

Perhaps this one got slightly better reviews than average because, let’s face it, most found-footage horror films are not very good. But that doesn’t explain the inordinately low Audience Score. Perhaps viewers expected something more like The Exorcist – or maybe they didn’t take to the film’s long set-up to a short, sharp shock of an ending.

The Blair Witch Project (1999) 87%

Audience Score: 56%
Divide: 31 points

The movie that kick-started the aforementioned found-footage craze was a marketing sensation and a bona fide box office smash – it made $248 million off a production budget of under $75,000! These days, it doesn’t seem to have all that many fans, though 56% is not a terrible Audience Score for a horror film; the genre’s fans can be tough. My own theory is that some horror fans resent the movie for “tricking” them into believing the story was real. And horror fans are known to hold a grudge.

Willow Creek (2014) 87%

Audience Score: 33%
Divide: 53 points

Yet another found-footage indie that found fans among film writers, but not quite as many among general film watchers. Like most movies of this sort, it’s fairly basic and it does take a little while to warm up – but it also has a solid handful of scary moments that stand up quite well. But I guess when people hear “Bigfoot movie,” they want a whole lot of Bigfoot.

Open Water (2004) 71%

Audience Score: 32%
Divide: 40 points

I was at Sundance when this movie hit and everyone kinda went overboard praising it. And perhaps I was one of them. On one hand it’s a creative way to tell a shark attack story. On the other hand, a very large chunk of the film consists of two people bobbing up and down in the ocean, arguing at each other. So maybe the audience got this one right.

Tag Cloud

Epix Sundance Now Apple Mystery DGA VH1 based on movie Nickelodeon unscripted Music Winners Country Premiere Dates miniseries ABC Family Freeform 2016 Holidays Rocky MTV serial killer comic science fiction ratings Grammys crime dc 2015 TV Land Box Office Walt Disney Pictures cops YA Britbox festivals biography Sundance Calendar travel Countdown streaming Action jamie lee curtis Sci-Fi DC Comics Warner Bros. Tumblr golden globes Kids & Family Superheroe YouTube Red Disney NYCC Trailer Marathons Quiz El Rey NBC historical drama doctor who TCA Drama Tomatazos singing competition Toys CBS All Access Lifetime mutant Crackle what to watch technology crime drama diversity Nat Geo Showtime Nominations Reality Competition OWN 21st Century Fox Podcast History Election Comedy Watching Series Interview spy thriller Star Trek robots blaxploitation PaleyFest Comics on TV discovery crime thriller IFC Films AMC comiccon Anna Paquin Acorn TV VICE Valentine's Day Photos transformers TruTV Horror Food Network docudrama Emmys Lucasfilm Musical Rock TLC TCA 2017 vampires TV Black Mirror The Arrangement Awards Marvel 45 Animation 2019 007 adventure Trophy Talk Mary Tyler Moore crossover facebook A&E FOX Musicals Spike anime psycho Mary poppins X-Men Logo Paramount Network Adult Swim Amazon Brie Larson binge Thanksgiving CBS green book Cosplay First Look Martial Arts Esquire DC streaming service Character Guide Amazon Prime LGBTQ social media Summer CNN Western Oscars Sneak Peek Extras DC Universe Captain marvel Paramount Comic Book Best and Worst Fall TV Columbia Pictures TIFF Writers Guild of America CW Seed Super Bowl Teen sitcom sports Universal television USA Syfy TCM Trivia dramedy supernatural Christmas RT History ITV E! 24 frames BET 20th Century Fox HBO GLAAD Winter TV San Diego Comic-Con Mary Poppins Returns casting Cartoon Network Fantasy SXSW talk show cinemax Shondaland Dark Horse Comics Mindy Kaling FXX period drama Superheroes spider-man E3 composers cooking SundanceTV MSNBC Infographic finale politics Shudder Pirates Lionsgate FX President GoT BBC America Comedy Central Schedule DirecTV Masterpiece Star Wars aliens YouTube Premium zombie 2018 BBC Bravo zombies cults thriller Biopics Rom-Com Pixar Pop GIFs The CW Video Games Certified Fresh CMT SDCC political drama American Society of Cinematographers medical drama award winner TBS Red Carpet war ESPN 2017 romance justice league Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Set visit Chilling Adventures of Sabrina See It Skip It Starz boxoffice Ovation Song of Ice and Fire Opinion hist Spring TV National Geographic dceu ABC MCU Polls and Games Ellie Kemper Creative Arts Emmys New York Comic Con Ghostbusters APB police drama Fox News WGN harry potter cats Netflix Sony Pictures Reality USA Network Year in Review IFC PBS Awards Tour Disney Channel TNT Hulu