Critics Consensus

Dear Evan Hansen Misses the High Note

Plus, The Guilty is a solid thriller, and Netflix's Midnight Mass and Disney+'s Star Wars: Visions are both Certified Fresh.

by | September 23, 2021 | Comments

This weekend, we’ve got a musical misfire (Dear Evan Hansen, starring Ben Platt and Kaitlyn Dever), and an emergency call gone awry (The Guilty, starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Ethan Hawke), as well as a couple of hotly anticipated new streaming series. What are the critics saying?

Dear Evan Hansen (2021)


In a year chock full of musical adaptations, you’d think that one based on a multiple Tony Award-winner would be a sure thing… and you’d be wrong. Stephen Chbosky’s (The Perks of Being a WallflowerDear Evan Hansen, based on the 2016 Broadway musical of the same name, stars Ben Platt as the titular high school senior suffering from anxiety who’s been tasked by his therapist to write encouraging letters to himself. When a troubled classmate named Connor (Colton Ryan) nabs one of those letters, then later commits suicide, Connor’s parents believe Evan is the best friend they never knew their son had, and the misunderstanding quickly spirals out of Evan’s control. Critics say that the central premise of the story, which was already problematic on stage, is even more egregiously toxic now, and instead of embracing its inherent darkness, Chbosky and Co. insist upon wringing inspirational platitudes from it, much to the film’s detriment. The impressive cast also includes Kaitlyn Dever, Amy Adams, and Julianne Moore, and the musical numbers translate fairly well onto celluloid, but reviews say the whole enterprise feels a little tone deaf, which robs it of some of its power. It’s still probably worth a watch for fans of the original, but be prepared for a different experience here.

The Guilty (2021)


It’s usually a pretty risky proposition to center a film on a single actor in a single location, but fantastic results are possible (see: 2010’s Buried or 2013’s Locke). The latest to make the attempt is The Guilty — which is itself a direct remake of the 2018 Danish film of the same name. The new film, releasing in theaters this week and streaming on Netflix next week, is directed by Antoine Fuqua and stars Jake Gyllenhaal in the central role, Joe Baylor, an L.A. cop relegated to 9-1-1 dispatch duty who takes a call from a woman in the midst of a kidnapping. As Joe attempts to ascertain the woman’s whereabouts and get to the bottom of her story, he gradually learns that not everything is as it seems. Critics say The Guilty isn’t quite as gripping as its predecessor, but Antoine Fuqua knows his way around a tense, gritty thriller, and Jake Gyllenhaal brings his A-game to the table in a riveting performance that holds the film together.

What’s New on TV

An ambitious meditation on grief and faith that is as gorgeous as it is unsettling, Midnight Mass’s slow boil is a triumph of terror that will leave viewers shaking – and thinking – long after the credits roll.

Gorgeously animated and wildly creative, Visions is an eclectic, but wholly enjoyable collection of Star Wars stories that breathe new life into the galaxy.

Thumbnail image by Universal Pictures

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

marvel comics Comedy Central spider-man ITV Crunchyroll superman Year in Review psychological thriller Trailer Tumblr anthology book Action Black History Month technology A&E tv talk CNN Discovery Channel Alien nature Apple art house child's play women Nat Geo mission: impossible Biopics singing competition Spectrum Originals supernatural critic resources Star Wars Sundance Now Certified Fresh archives CW Seed comic book movie south america renewed TV shows football Pacific Islander Grammys laika E3 twilight mob independent Turner streaming concert obituary First Reviews TruTV animated crossover Freeform psycho USA Network TV renewals news action-comedy Mystery dexter superhero Masterpiece HBO Food Network Lifetime Trophy Talk Paramount Plus Music wonder woman war all-time discovery Cosplay Women's History Month Warner Bros. dreamworks Black Mirror WarnerMedia dceu legend Shondaland Dark Horse Comics Reality fresh target Lucasfilm Stephen King Creative Arts Emmys crime drama Valentine's Day cartoon YouTube Red adventure Amazon spy thriller President black TLC Vudu Film Festival royal family canceled cars Rocky pirates of the caribbean Showtime thriller golden globe awards rotten movies we love children's TV marvel cinematic universe Broadway NBC cancelled television Sci-Fi based on movie versus dragons deadpool Hallmark DC Universe Pixar 2015 kids comic books Wes Anderson Emmys 2019 Film documentaries Holidays boxoffice Amazon Prime Video Summer BBC America Fantasy 93rd Oscars TCA Awards directors Musical indiana jones Spring TV vampires Horror The Academy SundanceTV japanese adaptation cooking Thanksgiving Winners Heroines IMDb TV Bravo theme song new york Anna Paquin Awards Tour RT History BET Pop DirecTV politics YouTube Premium green book video on demand rt labs critics edition Universal Tokyo Olympics Winter TV 20th Century Fox YouTube Esquire Podcast Comedy VICE Emmy Nominations Travel Channel heist movie jurassic park sopranos robots vs. asian-american zombies TCA 2017 Elton John HBO Max ratings television feel good TV movies Writers Guild of America Image Comics Classic Film Brie Larson slasher remakes scary movies lord of the rings Neflix james bond unscripted Lifetime Christmas movies book adaptation italian japan Star Trek miniseries genre Western 2016 IFC game show high school satire crime mutant stoner TCA Winter 2020 Ellie Kemper game of thrones Country Television Critics Association MSNBC parents USA Paramount Network aapi nfl space Shudder new zealand Election Netflix Superheroe Arrowverse travel Avengers criterion monster movies First Look Disney+ Disney Plus biography LGBTQ Acorn TV movie Marvel Turner Classic Movies reviews halloween tv finale BBC One comedies 24 frames cancelled TV series video The Walt Disney Company australia best golden globes hidden camera Super Bowl YA festival harry potter 90s Premiere Dates Watching Series Pop TV social media biopic Comic-Con@Home 2021 Calendar GIFs Mary Poppins Returns Rom-Com Musicals films medical drama strong female leads spain ghosts ABC Signature Marathons Mary poppins Amazon Studios Starz live event Nickelodeon foreign BAFTA kaiju disaster die hard sequel halloween CBS All Access San Diego Comic-Con 4/20 PaleyFest Ghostbusters 2021 blaxploitation Syfy scary basketball zombie documentary police drama Hear Us Out kong screenings Hulu TCM 72 Emmy Awards spinoff Comic Book Exclusive Video Ovation casting cancelled TV shows sag awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The Arrangement comiccon trailers nbcuniversal History facebook Chernobyl comic dc Best and Worst Christmas know your critic docuseries popular crime thriller GLAAD classics debate Animation Captain marvel science fiction cancelled E! breaking bad natural history Superheroes National Geographic stop motion VH1 revenge SXSW witnail Epix Song of Ice and Fire international The CW FX Pirates New York Comic Con Sundance TV serial killer Britbox sports BET Awards VOD TV Land Set visit romance mcc doctor who Disney Plus PlayStation Sneak Peek historical drama Disney streaming service franchise hispanic binge gangster scorecard ABC Columbia Pictures CMT Comics on TV Toys award winner composers joker transformers Tomatazos DGA Academy Awards Mudbound Baby Yoda slashers RT21 Marvel Studios Amazon Prime TBS Family Hallmark Christmas movies Character Guide Awards American Society of Cinematographers comic book movies Mary Tyler Moore 007 prank docudrama Countdown fast and furious cults The Purge Cartoon Network new star wars movies aliens stand-up comedy quibi name the review LGBT Rocketman young adult spider-verse hispanic heritage month christmas movies Legendary Fall TV Spike blockbuster Kids & Family live action El Rey IFC Films black comedy comics Cannes canceled TV shows cops NYCC rt labs Marvel Television WGN Universal Pictures MCU Crackle series Television Academy Opinion mockumentary spanish language universal monsters NBA saw SDCC screen actors guild Netflix Christmas movies hist boxing A24 diversity Lionsgate elevated horror Nominations Disney Channel TV One a nightmare on elm street reboot 73rd Emmy Awards Extras scene in color Reality Competition Endgame Fox Searchlight worst OWN Pride Month Paramount Pet Sematary Photos Polls and Games Trivia Video Games telelvision Adult Swim anime festivals Box Office TV dark period drama posters Interview blockbusters Fox News talk show spanish Drama Teen Binge Guide AMC chucky political drama FXX Apple TV Plus CBS sequels jamie lee curtis batman werewolf razzies teaser 21st Century Fox toronto ESPN Walt Disney Pictures king kong Martial Arts AMC Plus PBS Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ViacomCBS FX on Hulu venice king arthur The Walking Dead romantic comedy Peacock suspense 2020 71st Emmy Awards justice league TIFF dogs hollywood GoT Logo indie Schedule french DC Comics zero dark thirty latino DC streaming service X-Men emmy awards sitcom critics true crime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Funimation BBC TCA See It Skip It MTV 1990s Quiz godzilla rotten Apple TV+ Rock 45 dramedy movies toy story Oscars Red Carpet APB OneApp Sundance 2017 Infographic free movies HBO Go TNT adenture cats rt archives 2018 FOX Instagram Live what to watch cinemax ABC Family 99% Mindy Kaling The Witch streaming movies rom-coms worst movies olympics Holiday Tarantino Sony Pictures ID Disney Tubi richard e. Grant